Monday, May 27, 2013

Vision for the Lost or Lost Vision - PART THREE


PART THREE

Let’s not beat ourselves up. This was a perfectly normal and natural thing to happen. Renewal movements initiated by charismatic leadership, always institutionalise and decline. Sometimes they break out again in renewed vigour. This has happened within the Christian church many times since the original “Jesus movement” which shook the institutionalised religion of first century Judaea. The Montanists, the Monastics, the Mendicant Friars and late medieval movements, the radical Reformers, the Methodists and the Pentecostals all illustrate the seemingly inexorable progression of the seasons of divine inspiration and human endeavour. Radical religious movements tend to arise in eras of rapid change and transition, of cultural liminality, of chaos, to which they are in part a response. Because such periods often involve social and economic dislocation, these movements are also often marked by concern for the poor, or are identified with them. As Johan Metz put it,

[Religious orders/congregations] are a kind of shock therapy… for the Church as a whole. Against the dangerous accommodations and questionable compromises that the Church… can always incline to, they press for the uncompromising nature of the Gospel and the imitation of Christ...[1]

We fit the template. The Salvation Army emerged in the late 19th century as the latest body of Enthusiasts, those Max Weber called the virtuosi,[2] the dazzlingly skilled, the spiritual athletes. The Army was widely recognised as a de facto new religious order within the church. The poet Francis Thompson in an essay on “Catholics In Darkest England” wrote, “Consider what the Salvation Army is. It is not merely a sect, it is virtually a Religious Order…”[3]

But, as Gerald Arbuckle writes of Catholic Orders:

Historically, once these movements cease to be prophetic, though in Church law they may remain religious congregations, they are no longer authentically religious. By sinking to the level of purely human institutions they have lost their reason for being.[4]

The Army fitted this template also. Booth knew it was changing even in his day. Here he is in 1902:

[M]any … officers are trying to do the Salvation Army without salvation – at any rate, with very little; trying to exemplify the principles of the most wonderful religious organisation that the world has ever seen with very little religion. They get into a formal or legal way of doing things and go on doing them without any results or with very little results because the life and heat, and fire and passion are burned out or almost out.[5]

So in 1904 he described another vision, for a new order of officers. He wrote (again, I abbreviate):

I thought … I saw a new body of Officers suddenly start into existence…
… they appeared to manifest extraordinary signs of earnestness, self-denial, and singleness of purpose; indeed … a reckless, daredevil set. …  to welcome privations… to revel in hardships … facing opposition and difficulties with meekness, patience, and love.

…  they had voluntarily embraced the old-fashioned vows of celibacy, poverty, and obedience… vows … only binding upon them for a term of years, with the option of renewal for a further term at the expiration of that period, or of being able at that time to honourably return to the ordinary ranks of Officership.
… they wore a novel kind of uniform … evidently proud of their colours.
… refused to accept any money or gifts … were pledged not to own any goods of any kind… except the clothes they wore.
… great wanderers… on foot, … and speaking to the people in the streets… wherever they had opportunity, about death, judgment, eternity, repentance, Christ, and salvation…
… I saw their number… very, very small at first, gradually increase until they reached quite a multitude. And the educated and well-to-do, charmed with this simple Christ like life, swelled its numbers, coming from the universities and the money­making institutions and other high places.[6]

Booth was describing officers as he had expected them to be twenty five years earlier – and clearly recognised that they were no longer. He didn’t admit that his troops were now too burdened with canvassing for funds, reporting statistics and managing the already-saved, all concomitant with the institutionalising of his vision, but he knew he now needed a new Order. Had he been 50 years younger, he would have founded it himself.

But he didn’t, and his “old” order is now 100 years older. It will be obvious that in this I’m speaking of the Army in the West – of which Australasia is a part.

The present surge of growth the Army enjoys in the “Developing World” may appear to parallel that of the Army’s early days, but that’s another study. It’s the decline of the West with which I’m concerned here.

So how did it happen? Quite naturally and humanly. The reasons are as much sociological as spiritual.

So what now? Can the vision be re-found?

Can the Army of the West be re-founded? Gerald Arbuckle would say not only can but must! Arbuckle is a New Zealand Marist priest who works out of Sydney consulting with Catholic religious congregations (Orders) internationally. He draws a distinction between “renewal”, which is really just tinkering with the existing responses to a situation, and “refounding”, which is about in-depth, radical change in the face of change.  He defines refounding as “a process of returning to the founding experience of an organisation or group in order to rediscover and re-own the vision and driving energy of the pioneers.”[7]

There is a need for such a rediscovery when society enters a renewed period of change and chaos. The mission which responded so aptly to the challenges of an earlier period may now be stuck in the form created to address conditions which no longer obtain. Of course society is always in transition but sometimes change becomes exponential. As a time of rapid change and transition, of cultural liminality and chaos, the last half of the twentieth century has been equal to the era of the Army’s founding.

Arbuckle says that “when people own their powerlessness, they return to the sacred time of the founding of the group. There they can ask fundamental questions about their origins, about what is essential to the founding vision and what is to be kept, and what is accidental and to be allowed to go.”[8]

Major Harold Hill
New Zealan, Fiji and Tonga Territory

The paper was given in response to an invitation to speak at a tri-territorial theological conference (NZ, AUE and AUS) in Sydney last year – the topic was set for the conference, not my choice… For the past 10 or so years the papers given at these have been published by the three territories jointly. This one isn’t out yet – there’s usually about a 12 months process and they’re available by the time of the following conference. Sydney Booth College website usually has the details of publications.

End Part Three




[1] J. Metz, Followers of Christ: The Religious Life and the Church (London: Burns and Oates, 1978) 12. Quoted by Gerald Arbuckle, From Chaos to Mission (Collegeville MN: The Liturgical Press, 1996) 11.
[2]  Max Weber, The Sociology of Religion (Boston: Beacon, 1964) 162-5.
[3] Francis Thompson (Ed. Wilfred Maynell), Prose Works (London: Burns and Oates, 1913) 3, 57. (Kessinger Publishing 2003).
[4] Arbuckle, From Chaos to Mission, 12.
[5] P.W. Wilson, General Evangeline Booth of the Salvation Army (New York: Salvation Army) [1935] 1948, 132-3.
[6] William Booth, International Staff Council Addresses (London: The Salvation Army, 1904) 144-147.
[7] Arbuckle, From Chaos to Mission, 3.
[8] Arbuckle, From Chaos to Mission, 87.

15 comments:

John Sullivan said...

Harold,

A superb conclusion: the Army can rediscover itself, it must, but the question remains will it? I don't know whether a "former" has the right to even ask the question, but I shall try to do it in general terms and await the responses of those who are more subjectively involved.

What I see is the apathetic acceptance of the Church, that decline in the West is inevitable, and at the same time solacing itself with the calm reassurance that it is growing in the third world. I hear statements like "Yes, but in terms of numbers we are larger than ever". But as you are quick to point out, the phenomenon taking place in Africa, India and Pakistan is another item altogether.

Particularly intriguing is the point you make that the resurgence of the Church always begins with a concern for the poor and the oppressed. That was what St. Francis, Wesley and Booth were about. The three were incarnations of that concern.

It appears that the new Pope has got the message. He personally puts into practice the liberation theology that evolved in South America, minus its previous communist connotations. What Catholicism lost with past Popes squelching the movement, the new Pope has embodied. He is aware that in the interval it was picked up by Pentecostalism, and the poor have been deserting the traditional church for a charismatic one. It makes sense.

Phyllis Tickle in her book the Emergent Church makes the case that every five hundred years the Church goes through another transition and that we are on the hinge of another. The past four have been the Great Transformation, which was the Incarnation; the second, the time of Gregory the Great; the third the Great Schism, the fourth the Great Reformation. She combines history, science, psychology and the causes of social upheaval and events to illustrate her position. Once again the quick rise of Pentecostalism in Latin America is noted as it responds to the needs of the poor and the oppressed.

Harvey Cox, the author the Secular City takes a different, though related path. He speaks of three shifts beginning with the early church's concern about "following" the teachings of Jesus, rather than enforcing "what to believe about Jesus", when the church focused on orthodoxy and right beliefs; and the last being the age of the Spirit, and turns his attention to orthopraxy and Pentecostalism's concern for the poor in South America, seeing this as the way ahead for the universal Church.

Can the Army make a turn around, or is it so bound up in its institutional protocol that it may be impossible? As an outsider looking in, it would appear that with its hierarchical and authoritative structure like Catholicism it will only happen if there is a visionary at the helm. The more democratic churches can change, if they choose, from the grass roots up, but it would seem to me that if the Army is going to have a resurgence it will have to come from the top down. It will depend on the leadership.

We have moved quite a way from Booth's vision of Hell!

Joseph Smith (Major) said...

Major Harold, thank you for your analysis and the massive effort you have put into it. Are you aware of any attempts to utilise your findings, and the results?

I love the SA and owe it more than I can say, so I deeply regret the consequence of the Army's decline.

God chose Wesley to demonstrate his love for the poor and the fallen. When Wesley followers preferred to look inwards, he chose Booth to make known his love for the poor and the fallen. If Booths follows also prefer to look inwards, God will raise up others to make his love known to the poor and fallen. Indeed he has already done this by causing numerous churches in the UK to look outwards respond accordingly.

Because of my bias towards the poor and fallen I would prefer that the SA chooses to identify itself as a lifeboat that risks all to rescue the perishing' from their sin and the corrupting self, power, and money obsessed world in which we live. But it is understandable that despite our conscious or unconscious rejection of our birthright, we may prefer to be a helpful fellowship for Christians who want an Ark to keep them, and their children safe during their journey through the world. Correspondingly I think we will look back in about twenty years and conclude that our charity based status and activities, determined by secular authorities, will disguise our declining usefulness for the poor and fallen for a few years, but in the end the internal conflicts will be too great for us to manage.

The relevant fact may be that the SA is just too big, too complex, and too diverse, to keep our frontline ministry as the controlling criteria.

Those of us privileged to take Booths vision to Russia after the collapse of the Soviet Union can testify that resistance or lack of faith of Russian seekers did not cause the most profound problems. It was disrespect for the existing churches and the competing cultural. political, colonialist and power based perspectives of a minority of Christians, from the developed world which caused the biggest problems, this included including misguided Salvationists.

With respect and regards. Joseph.

FORMER SALVATION ARMY OFFICERS FELLOWSHIP said...

"Our frustration with TSA could only be dealt with by leaving, as we realized it would never change.

We finally accepted the fact that maybe it shouldn't - who were we to change things we didn't like? The SA has a way of making you think you have a contribution to make, either as an officer (preferably), or soldier - and our egos lap it up. But if you try to change the status quo...forget it. The mindset of the institution has always been "if you don't like it...leave". We finally got it."

Anonymous - Name on file

FORMER SALVATION ARMY OFFICERS FELLOWSHIP said...

A powerful and compelling article Major Hill. Thank you for making it available to our readership

Your contribution (I've read the entire paper- others haven't) reclaims the intellectual high ground necessary for the rational Christian believer in the 21st century to move forward.

I've shared in a number of FB and other sites today that, 'If your SA news and dictates are the result of what you hear from your local SA social circles, or pulpit, your view is probably antiquated and parochial. You'll find a much more compelling read in the FSAOF' blog.’ The many recent blog articles are, in my view, prophetic!

John Shelby Spong shared in his blog today, quoting from his "Re-Claiming the Bible for a Non-Religious World" that, “Christianity is, I believe, about expanded life, heightened consciousness and achieving a new humanity.” He’s now retired and if he lives in New Jersey; why not invite him in and compare notes.

Sounds like we’re on the same page!

Cheryl Hagedorn said...

Sven, you need to block the person leaving links to vacation spots and dentists :-)
Excellent post - I love the idea of re-founding. When do we start?
former, USA Central

FORMER SALVATION ARMY OFFICERS FELLOWSHIP said...

Cheryl, the only option is that each person wishing to post sou;d have enter a code and that dissuades many from commenting... My teeth are perfect, but a nice little cottage on a palm fringed azure tinted lagoon works for me- keep the ads coming...

Joseph Smith (Major) said...

Brother Sven,

Please be careful. On reflection, you will surely wish you had not rated your blog above the men and women of God who preach and teach in His name each week.

To take a risk and leave, or to enthrone loyalty and stay is a question we all must face when we accept that we only have one life to live, and only one life to give to the Lord.

Booth faced the same dilemma as a Methodist minister. He loved Wesley and owed almost everything he was and had to the Methodists. But he had to accept that his first loyalty must be to God who had called him to a ministry that was unacceptable to his Methodist leaders. He and Catherine chose to take a risk and to trust God, they left their home, salary, security, and high status position. Then with their young children in tow, they left the Methodists forever. The Salvation Army is the product of that decision...

Respect and regards, Joseph.

FORMER SALVATION ARMY OFFICERS FELLOWSHIP said...

Joseph, you are a recent, and I gather regular visitor to this blog site. We have posted almost 1,500 articles with a number from the pen of several SA Generals, theologians, teachers and preachers, In addition a look back will reveal our fondness for challenging Godly messages from church leaders of many faiths. We don't hold our ministry above others. But we also don't bow to anyone believing our Christian message is any less authentic or effective.

Many who write for this blog preach weekly or periodically, as I do, in and outside the SA. And I believe that we share the Truth with integrity, faithfully seeking the Spirit’s presence as we do so. And I pray earnestly that the Truth as we know it today is not the truth we proclaimed 10, 20, or 30 years ago, no matter how earnestly. If so, as we can all witness to, people will seek to learn and grow in their faith elsewhere.

Many who no longer, by choice or otherwise, lead a congregation have found blogging to be the modern equivalent of the printing press but better and more effective. The Internet allows everyone, SA officers and ‘formers’ to be a ‘publisher’, and to have his or her voice heard, and it provides an important and effective tool in stimulating people around the world to consider and commit to a closer relationship with our God. The absence of a weekly pulpit doesn't release those called to preach by God to do so. We stand in front of a virtual pulpit; same message, same expectations!

Some decades ago one could enter most any SA hall and have the Christian message shared in the language and theological intellectual level of the preacher, and it was effective! And with little difference in the message or its effectiveness, one corps from another.

Today many people are seeking to experience Christianity in a new, vibrant and more intellectually invigorating and responsive way. The FSAOF blog is offering one such alternative, and God has blessed us, albeit using different tools than those in B&M structures with the SA crest above the front entrance.

In the six years we’ve been blogging thousands of Salvationist have looked in with many becoming regular readers. Some even call ‘us’ their corps. And others yet have requested that we become a virtual corps with weekly Sunday services. I don’t know where God will lead our ministry, but for now we will continue offering fresh spiritual content to challenge and equip believers, new and not so new as we celebrate our faith in union.

The tools are forged and in disciplined hands, and our message is one that demands telling. Our intent is to post compelling articles that expand the mind, feed the soul and connect one and all with God, through faith in Jesus Christ.

Kind regards, Sven

Anonymous said...

Thank you Sven! With the many gifted Christian writers and speakers in your fellowship why not consider a weekly pod or web cast? There are many who'd add your worship service to their present one.

Baptist in Peterborough
former Sallie

Joseph Smith (Major) said...

Sven,

Thoughtful readers will notice that you have avoided my concern altogether.

You wrote in your first paragraph above that you "don't hold our ministry above others". But the reason I wrote is that you expressed the opposite point of view in you Tuesday 28th May post (see below).

'I've shared in a number of FB and other sites today that, 'If your SA news and dictates are the result of what you hear from your local SA social circles, or pulpit, your view is probably antiquated and parochial. You'll find a much more compelling read in the FSAOF' blog.’

I care about you Sven and I fear that the way you promote your blog is not helpful for you. I suggest that that you take the following actions to avoid potential dangers in the future:

1. Remove yourself from any role in promoting this site, if your cannot do this, form a accountability group of mature Christians for the Blog.

2. Do not allow people unwilling to reveal their identity to post blogs. If contributors are serious about what they write, they should be willing to stand behind what they write.

I believe that steps will help protect you personally and the blog without restricting the aim of the blog to "to post compelling articles that expand the mind, feed the soul and connect one and all with God, through faith in Jesus Christ.

Wishing our Gods richest blessings. Joseph.

John Sullivan said...

Dear Friend Joseph,

By now you and I have gone from your being "outraged" that I dared to use a quote which was a caricature of what many contemporary Christians believe, to our becoming "friends".

I have come to believe that you are absolutely sincere in every word you write, and you would be surprised I am sure to hear that in this case you come across as a "Delphic oracle".

If you don't mind my saying so, your suggestion that Sven remove himself from the Blog would be like asking William Booth to exempt himself from The Salvation Army. And the suggestion that the blog be controlled by some authorized group sound like shades of Bramwell.

Sven has given his heart, mind and soul to this Blog, and my guess is every waking hour. I can't imagine anyone, certainly no Committee caring as much as he. Very seldom I have found does one find commitment or tears in the eyes of a Committee.

Let's remember that this Blog has been designed for Formers. Surely if one of us is unhappy with its Administration, we should be the first to raise any suggestions or objections.

I also want to register my disagreement with you about the use of the Anonymous designation. People who are presently officers and others who have been hurt may not feel free to be openly honest if they have to submit their names. In fact my experience has been that the use of silence in the Army and the fear of reprisal has been one of the factors that has allowed it to be resistant to change.

I love you, and as you sometimes say, "If I have offended you, please forgive me". I am also aware that the "friendly helper", (both of us in this case), can end up becoming the "victim". I pray that this will not be the result.

Your friend John <)))><

Joseph Smith (Major) said...

Thank you John, your response to my message to Sven is appreciated. But why do you feel the need to defend Sven? Sven and I go back many years, we have served side by side in some unique and very demanding situations, and we are capable of speaking the truth in love to each other.

I have not and would not suggest for a moment that Sven ceases to run this blog. I do not underestimate the importance of his input in its development. For good reasons I suggested that he ceases to promote the blog, and have explained why. It is my concern for Sven that motivates my message.

You will not be surprised that I still hold that contributors should include their name with their blog. The Lord will give courage if this is needed, and I am baffled to imagine why 'former' officers fear a bad response from the leadership within the SA. If serving officers fear this, it is just one more reason why the people causing this fear are unmasked (not on this blog but to the relevant authorities). But I have not noticed any 'anonymous' posts which should cause any fear of this kind.

Including our name also provides motivation to ensure that the contributions to this blog are carefully considered.

With respect and regards. Joseph.

FORMER SALVATION ARMY OFFICERS FELLOWSHIP said...

Joseph, thoughtful readers will know that I've breeched blogging etiquette.

'Make every attempt to have visitors focus all comments on blog content, not on issues with which the casual reader would have no knowledge. And, be certain that comments reference the correct article.'

I'm going to break the above rule and will willingly sit in a corner for an hour and repent provided I have stimulating reading in hand.

I believe I've deleted at most 5 or 6 comments since the creation of our blog which works out at one per year (minus those pesty adverts).

There isn't a blog administrator out there worthy of their title, who doesn't deem their content worthy of a visit and who would welcome comments (blogs unlike words can't be uttered in silence). Ours no less so.

I ask that comments be restricted to and focus with respect on the messages being shared. The persons taking precious time to open up to us deserve as much, and more.

Finally, addressing a common factor and blogging etiquette: 'If your readers are coming all the way to your site, reading your posts and then thinking of commenting, DON’T make it difficult for them to do so. Get rid of your capchas, trick questions and excessive authentication forms. Keep it simple Simon, and don't insist on knowing every Tom, Dick and Sallie'

Thus concludes today's lesson- in the future ONLY ONE non-relevant comment will be allowed per calendar week.

I've extended the offer before; why not submit something that your heart tells you our visitors ought to know or learn more about. Perhaps last week's sermon or meditation, or similar?

Blessings

Anonymous said...

Major Joseph,
I choose to write anonymously because I fear people like you will condemn me even me for being a former if you meet me in person than is already done. And it is done, we formers are too often considered lower than mud.
But others still within the ranks, either as officers or soldiers may also choose not to face condemnation in a more personal direct way by having to disclose their name, for experimenting with their views. Often we need to walk in another's shoes to fully appreciate their views and feelings.
You may be dismayed to know Major you have reinforced my desire to remain anonymous, by what I perceive initially, but accept it may be unintentional, a condemnatory attitude by not following the way you believe is correct (i.e. identification).

Joseph Smith (Major) said...

Anonymous (Saturday 01 June 2013),

I simply think there is real danger in a blog depending so much on anonymous contributors. It certainly brings into question the value of the blog as a vehicle of open debate.

The blog can provide a valued outlet for 'formers' not yet ready to risk exposing themselves to further trauma because they have withdrawn from officership. I just doubt it will thrive as a vehicle of open discussion. There are simply too many other blogs and FB pages available which are not limited in this way.

If you are interested in confidential conversations you can contact me through Face Book (Joseph Smith).

Respect and regards. Joseph.