We believe that continuance in a
state of salvation depends upon continued obedient faith in Christ.
I used to call this the clobber doctrine, because it was
used most Sundays to clobber people who were already doing it hard.
First let’s talk about what it does not mean. It does not
mean your salvation is in peril because of what you do or don’t do. Remember
doctrines 6, 7 and 8? You can’t
save yourself and you cannot “unsave” yourself. We also set ourselves apart from
our Calvinist brethren in doctrine 6 by saying Jesus died for everyone and not
just the elect. So it is not the case that God will make it impossible for you
to be saved (“in an eternal relationship with him” ) in the first place.
No, this means you and I will work at doing Jesus’ work in
response to our faith in the work he has done for us as we are turned towards
God. That is the outward sign of what is happening on the inside. It also
assures us that god makes that possible because of all that has gone before.
There are two ways to deal with the phrase “depends upon”.
Some people see it in terms of sequence. Continued obedient
faith is the precursor to salvation. No continued obedience, no salvation. In
this thinking, sinning counts you out until you have confessed it and been
forgiven again. It is like making your understanding of your marriage dependent
on the daily actions of your spouse. Are they doing what they promised? Great-
still married. Are they falling down? Bummer- not married anymore. God has a
covenant relationship with us, just like a marriage it cannot be dissolved
except with the consent and participation of the parties. It is an eternal
relationship not a moment-by-moment evaluation.
This is also to see obedient faith as a checklist of “sin
and not sin” activity. But the doctrine does not refer to sin at all. It is
about faith, the substance of things hoped for. Faith is hard stuff. It does
not mean being confident. It does not even mean being sure. It means I keep
acting as if what I believe is true even when I am not sure, not certain, and
frankly terrified. It is to put all your eggs in one basket.
This brings us to the second understanding of “depends upon”
that is that the “continuance in a state of salvation” only exists in its entirety if continued obedient
faith is present. Faith in what?- in as doctrine 8 suggests, the fact that
Jesus has already done it all. Stop believing in God’s ability to save you and
you no longer see yourself as in relationship with God. This is about our
response to God’s gift, not whether we sin 10 times or 70 times. It is not, I emphasize
about knowing it is true, it is about deciding to act as if it is true until
the contrary is proved.
God likes you, he really does, and he wants you to have a
great life. Jesus was into joy, and celebration and justice and hope and
forgiveness and inclusion. Continuance in state of salvation is about
continuing to believe and trust in all that Jesus is and enjoying the benefits
that come from that. Should you endeavor to stop sinning? Of course, but if you
sin, you will still be forgiven. God hungers after relationship with you, trust
him to ensure your spiritual safety.
Simply trusting every day,
Trusting through a stormy way;
Even when my faith is small,
Trusting Jesus, that is all.
Trusting as the moments fly,
Trusting as the days go
by;
Trusting Him whate’er befall,
Trusting Jesus, that is all.
Brightly
doth His Spirit shine
Into
this poor heart of mine;
While
He leads I cannot fall;
Trusting
Jesus, that is all.
Singing
if my way is clear,
Praying
if the path be drear;
If
in danger for Him call;
Trusting
Jesus, that is all.
Trusting
Him while life shall last,
Trusting
Him till earth be past;
Till
within the jasper wall,
Trusting
Jesus, that is all.
Edgar Page Stites SASB 754
Former SA Officer
Australia

6 comments:
LUV IT! Very well put former Australian officer. Why didn't we have "preaching" like this years ago in the small corps I grew up in on the southwest side of Chicago.
I can still remember as a corps cadet getting the impression somewhere that "prevenient grace" gave me a leeway of about two to three weeks between my sinning and repentance before the celestial axe came down and banished me to Hell forever. Since I could never quite live up to what was being expounded as "Christian Perfection" by some pretty dumb officers I was always in constant inner turmoil over my salvation being a month long deal at the most! Ah, Good Times--and I wouldn't want to go back to them if you paid me.
Today's officers (at least in the U.S. as I don't know how it was in other countries years ago) are for the most part a much better lot and better theologically educated bunch then half a century ago, no matter what the nostalgia buffs say about their supposed dedication levels, etc. which was probably more connected to being in a survival mode than it was to actual pure dedication!
I know I'm going against the grain for writing this but some of those jokers from the past were actually dangerous with the things they said and did. God only knows how the Army even survived in a lot of places!
Daryl Lach
USA Central
P.S. As you can see I'm having a "bad" day so I'm generalizing in my anger. The Army did arm its cadets with the basics and in the process gave a lot of people a chance who wouldn't have had a chance anywhere else. Some were able to rise to the occasion and do a lot of good in the world. Ultimately only God can judge what is going on in any one individual's heart so I probably shouldn't have made the judgment I made above. Fortunately with prevenient grace I've got two to three weeks to repent so maybe I will when the sun is shining and I'm feeling better tomorrow morning. Yet, unfortunately it is true that the system also created some monsters who were downright dangerous!
"You Must Go home By the Way of the Cross, To Stand with Jesus in the Morning!"
Thank you for writing this with such clarity. It gives substance to the way I always felt about my relationship with God although I could not quite reconcile it with the doctrinal teaching I knew was the SA years ago. The struggle to be perfect and never sin was not possible for the human that I was, tho I so wanted to be perfect like the christian I was expected to be and worked so hard to become.
More of the same...
Blame the leaders of the day, but what precisely did you do to improve our lot?
Neither the doctrines nor scripture suggest one can be perfect this side of heaven. What we're promised is that the leading and power of the Holy Spirit will guide us to the indwelling experience of He who is perfect.
Former Officer, Methodist Minister, Ct, USA
Dear Former Officer, Methodist Minister, CT, USA
If your question was directed at my comment (and apparently the second commenter also had similar experiences to mine while growing up) my gripe is not with either Doctrine #s 9 or 10 but rather with the way some leaders who were suppose to be trained and should've known better wrongly interpreted and expounded on the doctrines.
First of all I was speaking about my experiences as a corps cadet. At the time I was learning from and picking up on the attitudes, poorly thought out beliefs and misinterpretations of the doctrines held by some officers (and soldier-leaders). What was I or anyone else in the same boat suppose to do when we were just absorbing what we were being told?
Secondly, when I was older, better theologically educated and more grounded in the faith what I was able to do to help change things was this: Whenever someone would unburden to me (and it happened several times) that a particular officer sent them on a guilt trip over what turned out to be nothing, I'd usually discover that the officer was attempting to promote the 9th and 10th doctrines while subscribing to a Calvinist definition of sin which is "to fall short of the Glory God."
I'd explain that in Arminian theology though falling short of the Glory of God is sin, the only sin we're responsible for is when we "transgress the known law of God". I'd then sympathize with them and let them know that the officer in question was probably "out to lunch" that day in Doctrine Class when he/she was a cadet. That usually helped.
Anyway, that's the short of it in a nutshell though I could go on if I had the time or thought it would do any good. I do however want to reiterate that Australia former communicated excellently what the 9th doctrine is all about.
And lastly on a positive note, the sun has broken out through the clouds this afternoon, the barometric pressure has risen, my outlook is much brighter today and I have repented of my cranky, snap judgment on officers yesterday. Many are and were wonderful people (though I still contend that some were real doozies) and thanks to prevenient grace I doubt that in the interim I had lost my salvation over any of this!
Daryl Lach
USA Central
"You Must Go Home By the Way of the Cross, to Stand With Jesus in the Morning!"
Oops! Make that "when we willfully transgress the known law of God." There now, that's much better-----
Daryl Lach
USA Central
Former officers interested in the way TSA now officially explains its doctrines may be interested to read the latest Handbook of Doctrine (2000. ISBN 978-0-85412-822-8.
Post a Comment