Once upon a time human beings were head-hunters,
and once they hunted witches. Once they hunted game for food: now they hunt big
game for sport. One hunt that has changed little is the heresy hunt. It's much
less expensive, and much less uncomfortable. One doesn't have to ride on the
top of an elephant or camel. One can stay right in front of one's computer in
the comfort of one's home.
A heretic is anyone who doesn't follow what
others consider the accepted line. He or she chooses one's own line; it may be
the wrong line. If it is, he or she not only goes wrong oneself, but may also
influence others depending on the persuasiveness of one's personality and the
cogency of one's cause. It is therefore the duty of the orthodox to hunt for
heretics, before they have a chance to do any serious damage. There are various
ways of stopping them. One can bully them, ostracize them and muzzle them.
So long as there are human beings this kind of
hunt will always take place. For one thing, there will always be people who
need the safety of absolute authority. For example, it was not enough for the
cardinal doctrine to say what it says about inspiration, or for the Handbook to
point out that the Bible does not claim to be infallible or inerrant. For some
reason, since the Handbook's recent publication, the new General has declared:
that "the Bible is the authoritative Word of God".
It appears there will always be people who need
the safety of absolute authority. I am writing of the kind of authority which
says: "This is what the Bible says; this is what the Creeds say, this is
what the eleven cardinal doctrines say, this is what the Handbook of Doctrine
says, this is what the Church universal says." There will always be people
who need that, and there will always be churches that say that.
As a matter of fact, the churches that seem to
be growing are the churches who say exactly that. They speak with dogmatic
authority. There is no place for doubt, or difference of opinion. And it's no
wonder. This is a time of confusion. Many people do not want to be told: use
your imagination; use your intelligence; think about these things. They want to
be told this is it; do it; obey it.
Also, there will always be people who sincerely
believe that it is their God-given duty, to protect the pattern of belief and
behaviour from anyone who threatens it. Most of them, I think, will fulfill
that duty by living within that pattern and letting the example of their life
be seen by people and speak for itself. But there will always be some, who will
go beyond their line of duty and hunt for those whom they consider are too far
off-base to be safe.
They are afraid of them, and also I wonder if
they are not a little insecure. The people who are secure aren't likely to be
out looking for those who differ from them, or be afraid of what they might do
that they want to brand them as heretics.
Speaking now only for myself I can say that in
spite of the appeal of orthodoxy without freedom, I've never been drawn more to
the position of freedom than in this time and space - the freedom of
imagination and intelligence. Of all the major heretics in Christian history,
as far as I can see, every one of them made some contribution to the truth.
There is, to be sure, a real reason to be
fearful of heresy. What I fear even more is that the armour of orthodoxy might
become so heavy that the wings of the spirit are clipped. If I had to choose my
company, I can almost say that I would rather be among heretics who have
insights that lead to a greater understanding of the truth, than among the
good, orthodox people, who always choose to trod along the safe line.
There was a heresy hunt going on in Jerusalem,
not long after Jesus was raised from the dead. Peter and his colleagues were
trying to tell the people about Jesus and the officials shut them up in prison.
There rose up at that time a man for whom I have the greatest respect. He was a
Jew; he was a Pharisee; he was a lawyer; he was a member of the Sanhedrin; his
name was Gamaliel. He said to the people, "Take care what you do with
these men. If this plan is human, it will fail; but if it is of God, you will
not be able to overthrow them. You might even be found to be opposing
God!"
I am thankful for the wisdom of that wise Jewish
lawyer; he wasn't a Christian and as far as we know he never became one, but he
had the sense to stand firm for the things he believed to be right and to leave
to God the judgment and criticism of others. Evidently he spoke with power, for
the story ends: "So they took his advice and let them go". The
doctrine series has begun, so I see have the heresy hunters, I can only hope
and pray that the most of us may heed the wisdom of Gamaliel, and go and do
likewise.
Blessings- Dr. John Sullivan <)))><
Former Officer Canada
Former Officer Canada

9 comments:
Joseph: you present an interesting perspective that fascinatingly illustrates how two people, ostensibly, looking at the same thing each see something markedly different.
My experience is, primarily, through soldiering at larger provincial city centre corps; places that were staunchly traditional in their programme framework and expression. Sadly, with the exception of one corps who had a significant ‘community programme’ attached to it, I have not been part of a set-up that was anything, in terms of its attempt to connect and serve with either the poor or the distressed or the needy, that met the wider general publically-held idea of what the Army might be. Given that SA PR continues battles in changing the perception that we are actually a ‘church’ as well as a social agency, I have been part of too many places that were all ‘church’ and not ‘social’. To my mind, and it probably needs writing skill and space that neither I nor this forum can adequately present, it is the dislocation that creates the elitism and the exclusivity.
When barriers, real or imagined, are placed in the way of full participation we create, of itself, exclusivity: when those barriers are demanding standards of proficiency or availability, whether it be time, talents or treasure, that are beyond a significant majority to attain or deliver then we create elitism. I believe that such thinking and practice, all too prevalent in too many places, is beyond the raising or maintaining of standards. An informal audition to join a corps music section is, in my experience, used to keep people out though it is, of course, not couched in such language. If we are truly inclusive, using this example, there would be no auditions at all. I was fortunate: my Army upbringing and organisational music education has served me incredibly well. My sister, without the same level of interest and/or ability was cut-adrift at sixteen years of age. Her experience is not unique.
It is, often, so subtle and I would suggest not always intentional. However, a corps event with a ticket price that puts attendance beyond the wallet of an individual/family creates exclusivity. Show-case events with shop-window sections/individuals push the notions of elitism: they are, in the main, PR exercises with fund-raising and recruitment dynamics – part of the organisational marketing of itself. The sociological imparts and impacts of some practices and preferences is to not, to my mind, always considered or understood as fully as they should be.
Redefinition of class is probably a spurious argument even though there is an historical understanding of the term that resonates in the minds of those who do not study the developed and nuanced arguments of such definitions. Relatively recently, UK sociologists came up with a defined class-system that still included middle-class albeit with, perhaps, a changed categorisation of what it means to be middle-class. I would still contend, if it is regarded essential to the discussion, that the majority of SA corps’ are ‘middle-class’ and that such dynamics presents some barriers, when we are organisation based on the gospel imperatives of inclusivity – the whosoever- that can, in turn, factor the reach of the gospel and filter the efficacy of grace.
I have no axe-to-grind with the Army and I certainly do not wish to be regarded as uber-critical but I have long thought that that an organisational inability (when compared to historical beginnings) to more effectively connect with the ‘unsaved’ is not entirely wrapped in changed ideas about organised religion and rampant secularisation. The ‘identity’ and ‘belonging’ dynamic was key to early-day success and that, to my mind and experience, is not as understood as it should be when addressing ideas of decline along with countering strategies for growth and development.
DW
DW
Wow as always, you never cease to disappoint; talk about an accurate description of many Canadian Corps in the cities, you have succeeded.
Certainly that would describe the Army in the city where I live.
Your point about inclusivity vs. exclusivity is particularly relevant, and from my perspective there is a great divide between the 614 Corps and the ones that are located in suburbia.
That not only includes high levels of music performance, but posh buildings, which create curiosity in the public as to where the money comes from. Those of us in the know are aware that it comes from legacies, which in all likelihood were not intended to advance the "church" side of the equation.
All the while, someone at the helm is forgetting the Army's original purpose to evangelize the poor. Surely that is not intentional, but you have cited some important examples as to how that happens.
One cannot cut off one's history whether personal or organizational any more than one can cut off one's arm. To do so is to result in losing one's purpose for being.
In our denomination which brought together the union of four different expressions of Christianity, it is the peril of any minister if he or she forgets what that individual congregation was before Church union.
I have served former Methodist and Presbyterian churches and discovered that it was only when I was in the former Wesleyan-Arminian theological culture that God was able to use my full potential as a minister.
I think I am going to work on a post as to why and how churches lose their original purpose, and the difficulties of recovering it.
Thanks again as always for your stimulating posts. <)))><
DW
Not thinking while typing my friend. I hope you read my first sentence as "You never disappoint"!
My humble apologies.
Anonymous DW,
Thanks for your reply, I think you have misunderstood what I have written. I don't disagree with your points, only the current extensiveness of the problem you outline. Middle class used to mean well educated, probably graduates, employed as professionals, clergy, in the Arts, Finance or middle to senior rank civil servants or the military. Possessing a bank account and with a disciplined work ethic, a tendency to vote conservative etc. We have had a few of this type but this has never been the profile of the average Salvationist. My last corps appointment had 150+ soldiers on the role and even more adherents. We had a large band and songsters in a city with a university. In total we had less that twenty graduates, one senior civil servant, one former bank manger, Most of the rest were blue collar workers some held mid line manager positions. About half were approaching or past retirement age. Until ten years before when DHQ moved to a different city we were the ‘premier’ corps in the division.
I discussed the tendency towards exclusiveness in both of my previous responses.
You are also ignoring the ministry to the poor of the Social Services department, The Social Justice Network, and representations to Parliament.
However, I think we both have a heart for the poor and the fallen. These folk have been the main focus of all of my officership.
Your concern for our reduced effectiveness in reaching ‘outsiders’ is matched by my own, but I have learned that we cannot demand that people care... we can only provide information, opportunities and experiences that break down fear, apathy, prejudice, and self interest. During the last three decades Governments of both main parties have effectively projected a negative stereotyped image of people in need. The have used non - empathic highly condemnatory language; rough- sleeper instead of people with no home. They have set groups against each other; shirkers or strivers. They have continually claimed that unemployment is the product of lazy people who do not want to get out bed in the morning rather than admitting that it is the product of of too few jobs. They have encouraged a low wage economy necessitating the taxpayer to subside wages through low wage tax credits etc.
All of this propaganda impacts negatively on how a society views and helps the needy. This includes Salvationists.
There is no doubt that the SA has lost contact with its roots. Social Mobility, increased life chances, better use of available cash, raised self esteem, raised expectations, support from previous generations, are all reasons why this is so. We should thanks God for this. But the price is a estrangement from the people we once identified with and understood better than most. Nevertheless I have dozens of friends who keep me up to date with their corps activities through Face Book and find more cause for optimism that pessimism.
John Sullivan, Please do not write the article you suggest in your reply to DW. Encouragement to act in a proactive committed and creative way now is needed, not need a guilt trip because present day Salvationist cannot match the heroic efforts of previous generations, who served in a very different social milieu.
With respect and warm regards and not a little frustration! Joseph.
Sorry Joseph, I had already written it on the private site and sent it before reading your article. There is nothing derogatory in it, an analysis originally written by Brian MacLaren about Methodism which I have adapted with regard to the Army. No need to be frustrated. Apparently Sven plans to use it later on this blog so he must see it as having some redemptive value. Many blessings to you,
John <)))><
Anonymous DW,
I have re-read your response and think I have been too combative in my response to your analysis. I'm sorry about this.
I love and owe so much to TSA and have found it has been so right for me, that I get a little protective...
I know that you are writing from a good heart and about your experience. Forgive me if I have offended you by my combative approach.
Respect and warm regards. Joseph.
Hello Joseph,
No offence and please do not apologise, at least in your dealings with me, for a combative approach. I sense that you write with understanding, both of the subject and those that you are addressing.
We are discussing things that mean much to us and many of us write from the heart: such passion is both expected and understandable.
DW
DW
As always graciousness personified.
JS
Major Joseph,
you said you couldn't think of any corps that had moved to a better district about from Tottenham (hadn't realised that one), but what about Sale
Post a Comment