
… If we want the sort of
young people who care more for truth than for privileges and places, we shall
have to consider a matter of such vital importance without fear or prejudice.”[1]
With Colonel Baird, I
believe we must encourage and nurture our radical thinkers. We need them. I don’t
believe that retreating into reaction is a way forward for us. Fundamentalism
may seem a refuge from hard questions, and its current surge may offer an
apparent highway, but it’s a dead end. I wonder about the latest revision of
the Handbook of Doctrine, announced in recent weeks, described as a “correction
for clarity”. It appears to retreat from Booth’s position on Scripture, perhaps
to accommodate more comfortably our Fundamentalist comrades?[2] Or perhaps it just leaves more options
open. In that case can we please move beyond the totalitarian, sectarian ethos
where any opinions expressed are assumed to be representing the Army, and
therefore must be vetted for doctrinal soundness? As Dean Smith has cogently argued, Liberals and Evangelicals
may not be singing from the same song sheet, but could “agree to disagree
without moral judgement.”[3] Perhaps what I’m asking for is, in Brian McLaren’s phrase, a “generous
orthodoxy”.[4]
If, like that polarity
of Word and Deed, the polarity between theological conservatism and innovation
is also intrinsic to the myth and vision inherited from our Founders, it is in
the tension of such polarities that new vision is generated – as it was in
Booth’s day. So:
1. What was Booth’s
vision? One of hell, and salvation, here and hereafter.
2. What do we now see?
Perhaps not quite the same vision, or with the same clarity of vision.
3. How did that happen?
Quite naturally.
4. Can the vision be
re-found? Yes! But it will look different.
The alternation of
renewal and decline as the context within which we have attempted to place our
visionary theme reminds us that entropy and dissolution are not the whole
story. In the Salvationist micro-climate, we may occasionally have our
equivalent of what in the Catholic Church Karl Rahner called a “winter period”,
and we may regret the repetitive pattern of institutionalisation and decline,
but we can rejoice also in the reiterated springtime which, God-willing,
ensues. May the Holy Spirit give renewed vision for our times.
And
for all this, nature is never spent;
There lives the dearest freshness
deep down things;
And
though the last lights off the black West went
Oh, morning, at the brown brink eastward, springs –
Because
the Holy Ghost over the bent
World broods with warm breast and
with ah!
bright wings.[5]
Major Harold Hill
New Zealan, Fiji and Tonga Territory
The paper was given in response to an invitation to speak at a tri-territorial theological conference (NZ, AUE and AUS) in Sydney last year – the topic was set for the conference, not my choice… For the past 10 or so years the papers given at these have been published by the three territories jointly. This one isn’t out yet – there’s usually about a 12 months process and they’re available by the time of the following conference. Sydney Booth College website usually has the details of publications.
Bibliography
Gerald Arbuckle, From
Chaos to Mission. Collegeville MN: The Liturgical Press, 1996.
William Booth,
International Staff Council Addresses. London: The Salvation Army, 1904.
William Booth, “The
Millennium; or, The Ultimate Triumph of the Salvation Army Principles”, All the
World, August 1890, 337-43.
William Booth, Visions.
London: The Salvation Army, 1906 [1998].
Callum G. Brown, “What
was the religious crisis of the 1960s?” Journal of Religious History 34:4, December 2010, 468-479.
John C. Izzard (edited
by Henry Gariepy), in Pen of Flame: the Life and Poetry of Catherine Baird.
Alexandria: Crest Book, 2002.
A. M. Nicol, General
Booth and The Salvation Army. London: Herbert and Daniel, 1911.
H. Richard Niebuhr,
Social Sources of Denominationalism. New York: Meridian, [1929] 1957.
Allan Satterlee, Turning
Points: How the Salvation Army Found a Different Path. Alexandria VA: Crest,
2004.
Edward Schillebeeckx,
Ministry: A Case for Change, London: SCM, 1981, 3.
Dean Smith, “Are
Liberals and Evangelicals singing from the same song sheet?” The Heythrop
Journal XLVIII (2010) 1-16.
Francis Thompson (Ed.
Wilfred Maynell), Prose Works, London: Burns and Oates, 1913, 3, 57. (Kessinger
Publishing 2003).
Max Weber, The Sociology
of Religion. Boston: Beacon Press, 1964.
P.W. Wilson, General
Evangeline Booth of the Salvation Army. New York: The Salvation Army, [1935]
1948.
[1] Quoted by John C. Izzard (edited by Henry
Gariepy), in Pen of Flame: the Life and
Poetry of Catherine Baird (Alexandria: Crest Book, 2002) 112.
[2] “On behalf of the
General, I am pleased to announce a change of wording for a paragraph found on
page 11 of the Handbook of Doctrine (Chapter 1 – ‘For further exploration’ -
1.A.3. - page 11).
“The old wording in question
includes:
“The inspiration of the Bible provides a foundation for our understanding of the reliability of the divine revelation in Scripture. It is uniquely inspired in a way that is different from other writings or works of art. However, this does not mean that the Bible is infallible or inerrant, so that it is incapable of misleading and contains no human error. Whereas we believe that the overall message of the Bible is inspired and reliable, each individual passage must be read and interpreted carefully, in context, and with careful reference to the whole of biblical truth.
“Effective immediately, two paragraphs will replace the one above:
“The inspiration of the Bible provides a foundation for our understanding of the reliability of the divine revelation in Scripture. It is uniquely inspired in a way that is different from other writings or works of art. However, this does not mean that the Bible is infallible or inerrant, so that it is incapable of misleading and contains no human error. Whereas we believe that the overall message of the Bible is inspired and reliable, each individual passage must be read and interpreted carefully, in context, and with careful reference to the whole of biblical truth.
“Effective immediately, two paragraphs will replace the one above:
“We believe the message of the Bible
is inspired and reliable. However, each individual passage must be read and
interpreted carefully, in context and with reference to the whole of biblical
truth.
“We affirm that we can rely upon the Scriptures for instruction and guidance in matters of divine truth and the Christian life, because in Scripture we meet the Word of God himself, Jesus Christ. The Holy Spirit who inspired the writers also illumines those who read its pages and leads them to faith.”
The War Cry (NZ) 11 August 2012, 17.
“We affirm that we can rely upon the Scriptures for instruction and guidance in matters of divine truth and the Christian life, because in Scripture we meet the Word of God himself, Jesus Christ. The Holy Spirit who inspired the writers also illumines those who read its pages and leads them to faith.”
The War Cry (NZ) 11 August 2012, 17.
[3] Dean Smith, “Are Liberals and Evangelicals
singing from the same song sheet?” The
Heythrop Journal XLVIII (2010) 14.
[5] From “God’s Grandeur”, by
Gerard Manley Hopkins. Gerard Manley
Hopkins: A Selection of his Poems and Prose by W. H. Gardner
(Harmondsworth: Penguin, 1953) 27.



6 comments:
What can one possibly say to do justice to a brilliant historical and theological essay which covers all the bases of the contemporary ethos in the Army and in the Church?
One can only wonder how many others there are like Major Hill whose voices apparently go unheard by those in places of high leadership. Radical and prophetic they may be, but to class them as reactionary is laughable. Those who close their ears to what they have to say are the reactionaries, taking cover in their safe, unquestioning fundamentalism.
The concluding chapters of four and five are literary works of art. How could anyone who believes "in growth in grace and in the knowledge of our Lord Jesus Christ" not agree with Catherine Baird, when writing to General Kitching defending her colleagues being harassed for their theological positions? "One should be ashamed", she wrote, and I paraphrase, if "after thirty years one would not have a deeper understanding of the atonement, holiness, last things, and other great doctrines, than one had at the beginning!"
But only a poet and a cat-lover could pen a line like this: "Given the alphabet a child can write simple words and little more. In (adulthood) one may write a sonnet. But that does not mean one no longer believes that c-a-t spells cat." Amen to that!
Then the Major disarms us with a quote filled with hope, from Victorian poet, Roman Catholic convert and Jesus priest, Father Gerald Manley Hopkins. Who could forget his memorable lines, once learned, in the poem God's Grandeur?
"And for all this, nature is never spent; There lives the dearest freshness deep down things; And though the last lights off the black west went Oh, morning, at the brown brink eastward springs - because the Holy (Spirit) over the bent World broods with warm breast and with ah! bright wings."
Aha, there is nothing to fear, the Holy Spirit continues to brood over the world, convicting, converting, consecrating, and leading us into all the truth, and the truth will set us free. Hallelujah!
I've really enjoyed this series! Now if I can just buy the book ...
former, USA Central
Major Harold Hill prefers to be called a historian rather than a theologian. Yet, in this paper he works his way through the more interesting, intriguing and influential figures in SA history and highlights their distinctive theological contributions. Initially penned by the founder Hill lays out how the SA's theology evolved, albeit without any significant new or unanticipated change; a virtual lock on any change to the Army’s doctrines and theology was inscribed in the Army's ethos. Their achievements created a theological culture that stifled and silenced those seeking to guide us toward additional truths and growth.
The Major shares names of Salvationist who like him, expressed the need for the necessary freedom for genuine search for truth beyond the most fundamental, the faith the SA employed and embodied. To embrace a different truth or experience, whether the intent was to vitalize one’s own or a corporate spiritual reality, was taboo. The most searching, creative and intellectually vibrant members of the latter half of the 20th generation were silenced and made inaccessible; their attempt at a re-formed, re-charged Army destroyed and defeated.
The clenched fist of authority continues its claims of intellectual anti-modernist confidence, a campaign continued from the early part of the twentieth century; reasoned judgment...
So where are we today? Mired in an impoverished theological culture of our own design. What Major Hill has advocated in these latter years ought to have been integrated into the contemporary SA theological scene when time was still on our side!
Our family, with many others departed Sweden in the mid-fifties and moved to the USA. We grew up in the Rockford Temple Corps, USA Central Territory where we were confronted each Sunday by enormous letters on the large wall behind the platform, beneath a painting of Jesus that read: 'Jesus Christ is the same yesterday and today and forever. Hebrews 13:8'
It took us some months of studying English to recognize that it was poor grammar. However, it took me several years to move away from the spiritual connection I made as a child suggesting to me that, 'what served me yesterday, serves me still and will carry me tomorrow..." Oh what bliss - if only!
Major Hill; thank you again, for your fine paper. It is a much needed ‘breath of fresh air’ but I am not sure that you have done justice to Booth and his genius!
He did not have the luxury of a theological education, but neither did he think this would have been of any great help in reaching the lost, the poor and the fallen. For right or wrong he was a superbly pragmatic activist. The massive, complex internationally admired movement he built in less than forty years (1877 – 1912) proves that he was not a small-minded fundamentalist preoccupied by hell. He simply accepted that to achieve his goals his taskforce must be totally focussed.
His long experience of the divisiveness that resulted from doctrinal disputations (1865 – 1877) made him keen to fix our doctrines thereby to screen out people who would create doctrinal disputes.
Are we yet sufficiently distant from his influence to release our selves from his pragmatic priorities, and the limiting nature of our doctrines? I think not. I believe we will reach that point, possibly in the second half of this century, but we will probably fragment into a kind of republic of SA territories first. Rich western territories will claim increasingly more local self-determination, and the General will become more of a figurehead than a director of the SA. In the UK the commitment towards denominationalism will lead us down the path that the Methodists have taken before us. This will be the time when the doctrinal changes you suggest can be introduced. Activists leaving the SA to join, or form ‘churches’ which focus on experience and action rather than denominationalism or greater theological freedom, may speed up this process. I believe this is trend in the UK already.
Your paper is vital because it helps us think through the desirable changes that could be introduced when we are ready, as self - determining territories, to reassess our needs for the future.
I do hope you will continue to produce these potential blueprints for our future. Major Joseph Smith. (UKTI)
Cheryl Hagedorn,
The publication with Major Harold Hill's paper will be launched in October 2013.
contact:
donna.evans@aue.salvationarmy.org
Joseph.
Post a Comment