Saturday, May 11, 2013

Free will or forced?



In his foreword to this new 2010 handbook the international leader of The Salvation Army, General Shaw Clifton, says of Salvationists; ‘Our faith, grounded in Scripture, and validated victoriously by personal experience, has been the motive force of our obedience [to God]’. 


“Once saved, always saved” is not part of our Salvationist vocabulary.  The Salvation Army teaches that we can “lose” the salvation God has begun in us. It also teaches that a sustained Christ-fellowship is offered freely to all: “I stand at the door; I knock; if you hear me call and open the door, I’ll come right in and sit down to supper with you”.  Revelation 3:20 MSG  This offer is motivated by a belief, that true Christian growth and sustained faith requires a profession of faith and growth in holiness, for God’s saving grace to continue to work in us.  We remain free to resist God’s grace, but as a consequence, we could experience spiritual death, and eternal separation from God.

We differ with those, who hold to the ‘elect and eternally secure’ principles as summarized in the Synod of Dort in its Canons under the acronym TULIP.  They are:

Total Depravity: (many Salvationists question the reality of this position) Humankind has been utterly and completely ruined by the ‘Fall’. There is no redeeming factor or quality within us.  Only the act of a Sovereign God can deliver us from an eternal destiny in Hell.

Unconditional Election:  As such, God’s decision to save us is based on no conditions we can or could ever generate.  God has chosen whom to save and whom not to save.

Limited Atonement:  God created the means to deliver us from the merited consequences of our total depravity through the death of Jesus on the cross.  He suffered the consequences of God’s just wrath and judgment on behalf of all who had been elected for salvation, but only for these.  Jesus’ death was of no value or virtue to those outside those elected by God.  The Salvation Army song, “Whosoever will may come” is a false assertion and promise.

Irresistible Grace: Just as there is nothing one can do to change our depraved state; there is also nothing the elect can do to resist the gracious initiative and power of God to bring them to salvation.

Perseverance of the Saints:  The result of all of the above is that those whom God has elected to salvation, and acted to save in the atonement and in the ongoing irresistible work of the Spirit, will “persevere unto the end,” that is, those who are the elect cannot help but be faithful and thus experience the promised salvation.

With time, the winds of change have weakened the hardness of some of the claims.  The majority of Calvinists in the United States have adopted a softer, modified version of this account of God’s saving activity, most frequently by eliminating “double predestination”.

A highly respected Calvinistic theologian and USA radio personality with a nationwide audience, and a former professor of mine with SA roots, has opted to believe that there is a limited role for free will.  His son was a rock group guitarist and dabbled in drugs and ‘appeared to love living with that crazed lot’.  Perhaps the father’s overwhelming love and compassion for his son awoke his emotive accepting spirit and enlarged his concept of God’s atoning love?

In classic Calvinism, God saves us and our participation is not required.  Salvation is not ours to control in anyway.  We can neither gain nor lose it.  The saved person will hopefully confess certain beliefs at some point, and once done, he or she is saved then and always.

In a loving relationship is not free will the key characteristic?  Where is the saved person’s free will response?  Or is love irrelevant in entering into a relationship with the God whose character is Love?

The theology of John Wesley and the Salvationist understands: that salvation is both something God does and in which we cooperate, ‘though not as equals by any means’.  Only God can initiate salvation.  But only by our ongoing, living relationship through faith can God’s saving intention be fully realized in our lives.

Doctrine 9 declares:  “We believe that continuance in a state of salvation depends upon continued obedient faith in Christ”.

“This means you and I will work at doing Jesus’ work in response to our faith in the work he has done for us as we are turned towards God.  That is the outward sign of what is happening on the inside.  It also assures us that God makes that possible because of all that has gone before.” Allyson Essex FSAOF Blog, Doctrine 9 Sunday, May 5, 2013

Only faith, an exercise of our will is required to lead us to and remain in God’s grace.  This means it is possible for us to “fall from grace”, by not sustaining our faith.

Calvin addresses this problem of “falling away” in his Institutes of the Christian Religion.  He writes that: “experience shows that the reprobate are sometimes affected in a way so similar to the Elect”.  In fact, they can “truly feel the efficacy of the Gospel,” and there is no reason why the Lord could not allow the reprobate “some taste of his grace”, or “irradiate their minds with some sparks of his light.”  However, this is only what is called a “temporary faith”; the unsaved person in this situation lays hold to the “shadow” instead of the “substance”.

Louis Berkhof in his Systematic Theology also covers “temporary faith” as being distinguished from “true saving faith”.  He writes that temporary faith is most likely “grounded in the emotional life and seeks personal enjoyment rather than the glory of God”.

John Wesley in his sermons and journals frequently quoted Hebrews 12:14: “Pursue peace with every-one, and the holiness without which no one will see the Lord”. NRSV  His point was, that “despite whatever the condition of our souls may be, God is always calling, always wooing, always pleading, and always working and leaving the way open for our faith to be renewed, our hearts to be quickened by grace, and our souls to be brought to life and health again”.

Once saved, always saved?  No!  But the who-so-ever, always loved, always welcome, always called to a return to the fullness of God’s salvation.

Sven Ljungholm
Former Officer
Birkenhead Corps, UKTI




website

30 comments:

Anonymous said...

Thanks Sven! This will help me with my exam question xx

Glad

Active UKIT

Peter J. said...

This is a complicated one where I have observed that those in the extreme camps are both vulnerable. Is God sovereign, some of the greatest evangelists were Calvinists. Limiting the sovereignty of God verses the free will he gives us should not be limited to our human understanding. Ultimately makes for interesting discussion but the more we get set in our camp, closed to the truth of the other Biblical view (whichever of the two both are Biblical I argue)the more we shut out the truth.

Anonymous said...

We walk through a door that states, "Whosoever will" and as we enter and look back upon the door it states,"From the foundation of creation". God in His foreknowledge looked ahead at our lives and between His plan and our free-will , He molded and shaped what was to be. Only God can do that. We do not know all, as God is all-knowing.

Robert Deidrick , Major- Western Territory USA

Anonymous said...

Again I find St. Augustine helpfull in understanding predestination type Theology. I see it rather as pre- or for-knowledge. As God is outside of time and space (as elucidated by St. Augustine), he knew from the foundation of the world who would choose to be saved. I know this isn't realy predestination, but by slightly changing the language etc, Calvinist Theology becomes a lot more acceptable. Call it an editing process.

Graeme Randall
Former Australian East in London.

John Sullivan said...

I remember struggling with this issue as a young officer, and discussing it with an old (like myself now) United Church minister.

"It's like this", he said, "God has already cast the vote in our favour that all should be saved; we cast the deciding vote in our acceptance of the free gift of salvation, which results in our being 'elected'.

John Sullivan said...

PS

For anyone wanting to explore the subject further, I would recommend a doctoral dissertation by Robert Shank and published with the title "Life in the Son".

Shanks wrote it when a student at a Southern Baptist Seminary - what better place to question the doctrine of "The Perseverance of the Saints"? Even his faculty advisors were left speechless.

It is a book that should be on bookshelf of every Wesleyan-Arminian. It certainly settled the issue for me.

Anonymous said...

I am consistently rewarded each time, albeit too infrequently, that I spend a few minutes reading your always timely, challenging, engaging and refreshing discussions, even though the subject, in this instance predates both Wesley and Calvin.

I'm especially heartened to note that this blog and the excellent compelling articles and exchanges are the work of former SA officers. My parents were officers their entire lives.

Where is the official SA equivalent of this type valuable and telling exchanges? One might correctly assume one of two narratives. The SA is a tacit supporter of the ongoing prodding of issues remaining unspoken by SA officialdom in the public arena; not PC. Or, the SA will sit on the fence as long as necessary to see in which direction the led are leaning.

What effect, for instance, would the Army's tolerance and support of official church membership for GLBT persons in loving relationships have on fund raising, corps direction, and international stability?

One thing is clear beyond doubt. The Salvation Army has lost some incredibly gifted Christian thinkers and spokespersons. And had you not resigned the Army's influence would have less relevance and its voice would be more dismal and distant than ever.

Thank you for speaking on behalf of so many.

Inactive soldier - active Christian
Hawaii

Joseph Smith (Major) said...

Inactive soldier, Hawaii, do you not feel your energies might be better focussed on helping make the SA become what you believe it should be?

As your brother in the Lord, the cynical tone in your message concerns me: If the Lord has led you to withdraw from the SA to serve him and fellowship with believers in a local church, it will not be so that so that you can stand at a distance and throw insults at his imperfect children in the SA. Instead use your eloquence, understanding and opportunities to help build up the Kingdom of God where you are now.

If you have withdrawn from fellowship and service in the SA without being guided into another part of the Church, please be careful that this is not evidence that the deceiver has caught you at a weak point and is using the imperfections of other believers to lead you away from the Lord Himself.

If your concerns about the SA are hindering your fellowship please approach your local leaders and talk about your concerns. Try to ensure that you follow the Scriptural pattern for dealing with sin in the church. If your concerns are ignored the Lord will help you to know what to do next

Turn your eyes upon Jesus,
Look full in His wonderful face.
And the things of earth
will grow strangely dim
in the light of his glory & grace.

Yours in Christ, Joseph.

John Sullivan said...

Joseph, I do not think it is neither necessary for you to be defensive nor for you to rebuke the writer as being cynical.

It seems to me that you have been pretty heavy with your judgment, which leaves you vulnerable to the judgment of others.

Grace and peace,

John Sullivan said...

PS Sorry for the double negatives Joseph, the sentence should have read:

I do not think it either necessary for you to be defensive or for you to rebuke the writer as being cynical.

It seems to me that you have been pretty heavy with your judgment, which leaves you vulnerable to the judgment of others.

I believe the writer was referring to a series of previous posts dealing with some very sensitive issues, which were handled with great grace by the moderator and a number of contributors.

This took place a number of weeks ago before you started writing to the Fellowship. Obviously, the writer felt that the posts were helpful to him and he was expressing his thanks.

I am sorry that I could not remain silent, any more than you felt that you could.

FORMER SALVATION ARMY OFFICERS FELLOWSHIP said...

Joseph, don't you agree with our friend from the Aloha state that it seems more than a little odd that the SA doesn't have an official site where questions relative to one's eternal destiny are discussed and deciphered? It’s a whole new world out there but with a need of God’s message of salvation as old as the earth itself! It can’t be simply a lack of money - The FSAOF has been doing what we do for six years at our own expense because we believe we are appointed to do God’s work. Yet, without resources beyond our own times and talents we press on.

Or as we sang in my precious corps family just a few hours ago;
We’ll go in the strength of the Lord,

In paths he has marked for our feet;

We’ll follow the light of his word,

Nor shrink from the dangers we meet,

His presence our steps shall attend,

His fulness our wants shall supply;

On him, till our journey shall end,

Our unwavering faith shall rely.

Chorus:
We’ll go, We’ll go in the strength,
We’ll go in the strength of the Lord
-
We’ll go, We’ll go in the strength,
W’ll go in the strength of the Lord.

FORMER SALVATION ARMY OFFICERS FELLOWSHIP said...

I had the pleasure of serving alongside Majors Joseph and Pamela Smith as we re-opemed fire in Russia and beyond.

While living as ex-pats in Russia the subject of tradition and culture became topics of real interest.

I wrote a study guide on Paul's letter to the Ephesians and it was published, in Russian, just 5 years after Russia celebrated Chritianity's 1,000 birthday in their nation, and a few years later, Moscow's 1,000 birthday.

In writing about the first chapter of Ephesus, I emphasized that Paul, his Roman name, was speaking of 'tradition' as Saul, the Rabbi, using an analogy, the predestined security of an entire nation and that was now being passed on to the entire world. Russians related immediately to the notion of a destined people.

I explained that, in my view, God predestined that whoever is in Christ would become holy and blameless in his sight. The offer is to all, but the choice is the individual's, i.e., what was predestined for the group becomes 'predestined for you, the new Russian believers, and can now say with Paul; "we who have chosen to be believe are now in Christ, and therefore were predestined to be holy and blameless."

blessings, Sven

Joseph Smith (Major) said...

Dear John Sullivan.

I can accept that my message to 'inactive soldier' seems defensive and judgemental to you. But with all due respect my message is not to yourself, a non salvationist, but to someone who refers to himself/herself an 'inactive soldier'.

As an spiritual leader in the SA I have a God given responsibility to help this person understand the impending danger that he or she faces. If this blog was for former ministers in your church, and the writer was 'inactive member', you would have the same responsibility.

Why does this seem strange?

Joseph.

Joseph Smith (Major) said...

Dear Sven, I addressed you question in a previous blog:

Joseph Smith (Major) said...
What would the benefit of such a website be? The Army cannot change its doctrines without permission of the British Parliament.

Is it assumed that the Doctrine Council are not aware of the range of views concerning our doctrines?

If contributions were canvassed on a web site, who has the scriptural/moral authority to insist that a particular doctrine is only taught in a certain way? How could this be monitored? What is to be done with officers who already teach the doctrines from a different perspective?

I have observed that dissenting voices have been heard, dogmatic interpretations of doctrines have been challenged, dissenting officers have risen to positions of influence and changes in emphasis have been made. Comparison of the succeeding Handbooks of Doctrine demonstrate this.

The emphasis in recent years has been on addressing the inadequacies of our set of doctrines to meet the needs of the SA now redefined as a denomination of the Church and a Charity.

I suspect that our executive officers need understanding and prayer, rather than controversy and debate concerning our doctrines.

The current challenge is to maintains our unity, plus our internationism and our mission - effectiveness, while being clear about our identity as a body of Christ - controlled believers and a Charity that is increasingly controlled by secular government legislation.

Your prayers that we steer the right way through these challenges will be valued beyond what words can say.

Meanwhile the much appreciated discussions and debates can continue on this very welcome site! In Christ, Joseph
Saturday, 11 May, 2013

FORMER SALVATION ARMY OFFICERS FELLOWSHIP said...

Joseph, the doctrine series represented about 15 of the more than 1,400 blog articles posted in our brief history.

If you've followed the comment sections of our blog in the last 12 months or so you'll have noticed that a great many people including officers, from IHQ to DHQ s in far off places are echoing each other asking 'where's our blog'? Why isn;t a HQ, corps or social service institution using this contemporary method to speak to our Army and also to reach out to a hurting world?

If I was still an active officer, the FSAOF blog would be my personal mission, blogging from my basement, ala Stephen Court!

Anonymous said...

How can honest open discussion on an official site be seen as wrong. The Army has been hiding far too much for far too long.

Anonymous said...

Give me one example of a church denomination that has an open discussion forum on an official site? The biggest problem for the majority of Christian forums of any kind is that it becomes very quickly hyjacked by extreme fundamentalist thinking. Self regulation does not work!

Give the ihq forum a try and see how far it is willing to be tested by differing perspectives in faith and doctrinal matters. One might be pleasantly surprised!

Ns

ACTIVE UK

John Sullivan said...

Dear Joseph,

I am sure this will seem strange too you, but I would feel no responsibility whatever. I do not know the poster, or his or her situation. It does not appear that he or she has turned his or her back on God. It is more likely that the Church has turned its back on the person, and therefore the person is in need of understanding,love and healing.

My approach would be had the person been a member of my denomination I would just be pleased that from time to time he or she keeps in touch, just as I do with TSA. After all his or her parents were officers, just as mine were, and for a large part of his or her life the Army would have been the only family he or she knew. Most of all I would be glad that he or she had found a new church home where one now finds love and acceptance.

The only criticism I was able to detect coming from the poster was that he or she wondered why some of the issues discussed on the FSAOF site were not dealt with on the official TSA site. He pondered the possibility that the reason might be political or financial, a justifiable thought I should think. The truth is that the issues were discussed a number of years ago on the IHQ site, but resulted in a fire-storm. Over the years the opposition on the Discussion Form has been so strident at times, that people like the poster have taken their leave one by one. This is through no fault of the Army, as the moderator of the site has always been most generous and protective, but it has been due to some of the Salvationist posters who have neither been sensitive or kind.

So yes I find it strange, that you would think it your personal responsibility to make a judgment on a person you undoubtedly do not know. I believe the Holy Spirit is quite capable of speaking to the heart of anyone, and is not totally dependent exclusively on me or you to set anyone straight, particularly when the person has professed to be an active Christian. That the person no longer would belong to the UCC or TSA is irrelevant, and I am sure God doesn't care.

If the person is hurt or angry over previous treatment that is not going to be resolved by any amount of warning or condemnation. It takes time and love, and a personal relationship with the wounded one before any healing can take place. It is my understanding that the purpose of the FSAOF site is to be just such a place. A safe environment where people can vent their hurt and anger and doubt, and find themselves loved just the same.

My hope is that you will be able to respect that. Grace, and peace, and love to you.

Anonymous said...

IHQ doesn't have an open forum as far as I know. Where might I find it?

TD
Active USA East

Anonymous said...

Well said John, we both know from experience how difficult it is to enter open and honest discussion with intimidating, dominating, sexist and often downright insensitive fellowcontributors.

Ns

ACTIVE UK

John Sullivan said...

All you need to do is type into Google The Salvation Army Discussion Form. It will be the first posting on your monitor.

You will then have to register and come up with a password and you are on, it is just as simple as that.

If you are a member of the Tea Party, a card carrying member of the Republican Party, hate Obama, are anti-Islam and an ardent fundamentalist, you will find yourself in good company. Happy posting!

Anonymous said...

Just ask for a password......to allow for open access would allow for its it systems to be compromised by maliciousness.......no other organisation would allow that to happen.....be realistic!

ACTIVE UK

Anonymous said...

Amen John, amen!

The ihq forum can do with some challenging of firmly held positions. You will be welcomed with open arm's, listened to and treated with great respect by those who may not agree with you.......

ACTIVE UKT

Joseph Smith (Major) said...

I have given the reasons for sending a message expressing my concern for the danger facing an inactive, misguided member of my church'.

The Scriptural pattern for dealing with sin or threatened harm in the church is clear. It requires us to privately approach the person concerned. The next step is to see the person with witnesses. This is the advice I gave to 'inactive soldier'

The Salvation Army, like every other church, has additional procedures for addressing concerns about positional statements, strategies or tactics.

Onlookers should respect these procedures, just as Salvationist respect the procedures that other churches set up to deal with these kinds of questions.

The notion that the desire for a site for anonymous outpourings justifies bypassing Scriptural and church procedures is not only naïve; it is potentially dangerous as discovered when David J Taylor, a self deceiving brother managed to access this blog. Brothers and sisters in the Lord let us not fall out over this matter. Joseph.

John Sullivan said...

Correction Joseph, the article you referred to was written by David J. Stewart, not David J. Taylor.

FORMER SALVATION ARMY OFFICERS FELLOWSHIP said...

The above comments confirm that an open forum, in the setting provided by the FSAOF, inviting respectful dialogue and honest exchange, is the most helpful way forward in offering any and all the opportunity to express what they deem God's purpose and intent is for the individual. the church and the world

No passwords required - free to post with your name - anonymously (but may lose one a degree of credibility) - semi-anonymously; initials (earn some minute degree of credibility) -or, with rank or earned university credentials (let your words and tenor speak for themselves)

No comments are ever deleted or edited unless the are unsolicited adverts or laced with expletives; has only occurred twice in 6 years.

Articles that speak to topics of interest to our fellowship and visitors are invited. On rare occasions an article may be edited or clarity sought. In all such instances the author's permission to post the edited piece is required prior to publishing.

Anonymous said...

Dear Sven (and John Sullivan),

Yesterday was Mother's Day in the U.S. so I suppose that's probably the reason why most of the comments yesterday came from the UK and Canada. Also, this a.m. when I came on the site and saw 26 comments I thought for sure one of those hackers had broken in again with advertisements for God only knows what!!?? The truth is this was a great discussion and I'm sorry I initially missed it!

First of all Sven, one of the reasons I luv your site is that even though I can tell from stuff I've read on your personal Facebook page that we are worlds apart politically you don't seem to get your politics mixed up with anyone's Xianity (like so many other people on both the right and left do!) and your FSAOF site is open for all to express their views on both TSA and the Xian faith no matter where their political allegiances may lie.

Secondly, John I luv'd your comment above about the official discussion site at IHQ--"if you are a member of the Tea Party, hate Obama, are anti-Islam and an ardent fundamentalist you will find yourself in good company!" So true, so true, which is one of the reasons why I gave up on it a long time ago! There seemed to be little room for anyone else. If someone from the outside were to read it they'd think the Army (in the U.S. anyway) was full of reincarnated Jerry Falwell clones!

Strangely, I've met quite a few (well, maybe not SO many but certainly enough) Salvationists, and in rather high positions here too, who've admitted to being quite the opposite (one even admitted to being a borderline Socialist!) who told me they learned to survive in the system by keeping their mouths shut, though they sometimes felt like they were living in a desert when they were around other Salvationists and to survive emotionally made sure they had at least some friends and connections from outside the Army.

Daryl Lach
USA Central

P.S. Btw John, you left out two other groupings from the USA on the official blog site: Those who seem to think that ALL roads in the Bible lead to six un-related verses covering one subject that has nothing to do with that subject as we know it from a scientific viewpoint today, and those who think that John Nelson Darby's 180 year old take on the End Times actually has something to do with historical Xianity and is part of SA Doctrine! (Oh Lord, save us all!)

"You Must Go Home By the Way of the Cross, To Stand with Jesus in the Morning!

john sullivan said...

Yes Daryl, both are considered sacrosanct and without exception.

FloridaFlamingo said...

Thank you Darryl and John for keeping a sense of balance and logic to this (and many other) conversations.

Anonymous said...

You're quite welcome Deborah! Though we would never question their salvation like so many of them might question ours, we can't let the fundamentalists take over every Xian and/or SA blog out there---especially one as excellent as this one!

Daryl Lach
USA Central