Wednesday, May 1, 2013

Help my Unbelief, Lord...


The current series on the SA doctrines, penned by a most erudite group of ‘formers’, has proven to be one of the most popular in our six-year history of blogging. We have compiled more than 1400 articles during that period and built up a treasured archive should we wish to revisit a particular topic.  

The popularity of the doctrine series, based on the number of blog visitors and comments shared directly to the blog and on Facebook prompted me to 'pull' the below article from the 2012 files and post it below. We'll let it 'run' for 48 hours and follow it with a post sharing all the responses it elicited when first posted.

Sven Ljungholm

______________________

My friend recounted to me a conversation with a SA Cadet who doesn't believe a few of the SA doctrines. 

Not a big deal, you say? 

Well, this person has covenanted with God based on the SA doctrines.

He has applied for officership based partly on his belief in these doctrines. He feels 'called' to officership, which is basically the vocation of establishing these doctrines in the hearts of every human on the planet. He has confirmed verbally and in writing his belief in the doctrines. And he avoids confessing his disbelief to his superior officers (not wanting, I gather, to jeopardize the free car and home- in the West- and tenure for life). 

So here we are, The Salvation Army, stuck with a lying, deceitful, underhanded, misled (in beliefs) scoundrel. If things follow form, this lying, deceitful, underhanded, misled scoundrel will be a leader in The Salvation Army, maybe at your corps, in a matter of months. 

Here's one for you. He's not alone. 

When do we draw a line in the sand? At what point do we say 'enough is enough'? 

It is bigger than officership. It goes to all of soldiership. 

I am asking a common courtesy, which may be naive in this situation. How about having the honour of quietly stepping out of the ranks if you don't believe what you covenanted that you believed? How about having the modesty to relinquish your soldiership if you are intentionally, habitually not living up to your covenant promises? How about helping us cleanse the ranks of compromising hypocrisy? Either that or repent. 

Not only will it go better for you in eternity, but your resignation of your soldiership (and, for you officers who fit the bill, your officership) could be the best thing you'll ever do for The Salvation Army. 

I'd prefer repentance. 

Mafor Stephen Court

11 comments:

Anonymous said...

Not much compassion or hope of forgiveness here. No wonder they stay in hiding.

FORMER SALVATION ARMY OFFICERS FELLOWSHIP said...

It’s a conundrum that no one has picked up on the Cadet’s doctrinal stance during the assessment and acceptance process. Or is it a case of coming to terms with question that first came to ‘light’ while in college when the doctrines became a key focus of study?

One more reason perhaps why Corps Cadets, or a pre-application course on the corps level ought to be re-introduced.

Divisional leaders too ought be more vigilant; quality not quantity.

Anonymous said...

I have some difficulty with the scenario presented here. The cadet has verbally and in writing affirmed his adherence to the doctrines. Two scenarios present themselves. Firstly- the cadet has said explicitly he no longer believes some doctrines. I agree that in this case, the Cadet having concluded he does not believe the doctrines , he should resign. This is a matter of integrity. The second scenario is that the cadet believes the doctrines, but Major Court's informant has concluded he does not believe the doctrines. there is no compulsion in this case for the cadet to resign. And for soldiers and officers, just because they believe differently to Major Court about the scope and meaning of the doctrines does not mean they disbelieve the doctrines. Unfortunately, again, in an effort to portray things as black and white and clear cut Major Court has not allowed much room for grace. Perhaps with grace there could be a more nuanced discussion with the cadet, and one which will allow God ot be glorified.

Anonymous said...

Two points here....

First, as was mentioned when this post originally ran, it would be interesting to find out what and how this Cadet disagrees with the doctrine. TSA doctrine, as we are discovering, was intentionally written so that it can be extremely inclusive. You can be an extreme liberal or an ultra conservative, or anything in between, and still agree 100% with TSA doctrine. Perhaps it's simply that the Cadet disagrees with the way the doctrine is taught. If that is the case, then he has a point, and the college staff need to reassess their understanding of doctrine and the way it is taught.

From the way I look at TSA doctrine, and the handbook of doctrine etc., the only way anyone could say they disagree with any part of the doctrine is if they no longer believed that God exists, and there is no such thing as Salvation etc. The doctrine is inclusive enough to hold all Theological views.

Second, if there really is a fault in the doctrine that we haven't come across yet (which after all, we are all human, and it is possible), then surely, we need to open up the discussion, and look at it, for the sake of our own salvation. We need people who are willing to stand up and disagree, so that we can move forward, and not stagnate. It may be as I said above, that it is simply in the way doctrine is taught. But there may be something deeper. At least let's have a discussion so that we can make sure as few as possible are lost, and that we don't put our own salvation in peril.

Yours in Christ,
Graeme Randall
Former Australian East in London

FORMER SALVATION ARMY OFFICERS FELLOWSHIP said...

Well known SA composer and lyricist Rob Little shared with me words he's just written that speak directly to God's expectation of all who call themselves Christians and to today's article. And they serve as a poignant reminder to all who wear a SA uniform.

The song in its entirety will be shared in a few days.
_________________

v1
In the Gospels Jesus made it very clear
He wants us all to walk His narrow way;
To take a step of faith and trust His saving Grace;
To walk along His road, eyes fixed upon His face
He really doesn’t want hypocrisy
For only truth can truly set us free

Chorus
He doesn’t want me acting
He wants me to be real
He needs my authenticity,
my passion and my zeal.
Pretending to be Christ-like – my life will be a sham.
Jesus made it very clear – He wants me as I am.

Rob Little

John Sullivan said...

I think that Rob Little has nailed the flag to the mast.

Authenticity and integrity is all about "being" more than it is about "believing". When the risen Jesus appeared for the final time to his followers he commissioned them with these words:

"All authority in heaven and earth has been given to me. Go therefore and make disciples of all nations, baptizing them in the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit, and teaching them to 'obey' everything that I have commanded you."

It is worthwhile while discussing the importance of maintaining purity of doctrine to consider what that last phrase really means - it is not just about believing the things that Jesus may have told them, but about obeying what he commanded.

When the latter is lived out in a life, the believing will take care of itself.

Anonymous said...

Sometimes soldiers have to leave the Army, not because of their hypocrisy, but because:

A. The corps officers don't lead by example and have numerous double standards.

B. The local officership is cold, stand offish, elitest, and two-faced.

C. There is not another corps in the same town or county.

D. The family has to leave because one of the parents was in ministry as a soldier but was let go for no cause.

John Sullivan said...

Would it be rude to ask what it is that the Army promises to provide the cadet besides "a free car and home - in the West - and tenure for life?" In other denominations one's colleagues make promises to each other, and each time one goes to a new congregation, the people make promises to support the one who has been called! Should one make a profession of faith the congregation make promises to support the new member - it really should be a mutual ministry to each other on every level.

Anonymous said...

Stephen Court wrote this indictment over one year ago. I wonder if he can bring us up-to-date as to the cadet's well-being.

Will he be commissioned next month, or has he been drummed out of the session, or joined the atheist movement?

Active officer in the USA Central territory

Tony Hussey-Former USA West said...

While in a general sense I agree with Court's opinion, I do think that everything is not always (maybe never) so black and white when looking at human behavior and thinking.

I think that if a soldier/officer truly does not believe a doctrine they owe it to the Army and themselves to move on to a church that is in line with their belief.

On the other hand the words, "... let he who is without sin cast the first stone", come to mind.

We have to ask if the individual is suffering a short term period of doubting or is there an actual disagreement, or perhaps a misunderstanding.

When I was at CFOT, the staff intentionally did not evaluate the cadet's spiritual well being, not in a formal way. The thinking was that evaluation belongs only to God. I heartily agree.

To call out the so-called "lying, deceitful, underhanded, misled (in beliefs) scoundrel" and demand his resignation is to minimize the power of God and His protection of the Army as an arm of His Church.

If you really believe that God has raised up the Army for His purposes, can this one "unbelieving" individual do any harm? Will not God protect His Army and the mission?

It's a risky place to be in when you make such dramatic judgments regarding another persons spiritual well being and fitness to serve in the place where God has placed them.

To paraphrase, "Before you concern yourself with the speck in the other's eye, take a look at the timber in yours".

Matt Clifton said...

If the soul of the Salvation Army is about preserving a rigid, immutable orthodoxy, then I complete endorse Stephen's counsel to resign and would add this: resign and be liberated to found something new and revolutionary in the spirit of the Booths, Wesley, Luther, Paul and Jesus.