Monday, August 25, 2014

Distortions of Christian Leadership 4 (Conclusion)

Wellington Theological Consortium Colloquium – 16 Saturday 16 August
Booth College of Mission Wellington NZ

The keynote speakers:
·         Dr Peter Lineham –
·         Major Dr Harold Hill –
·         Bishop Peter Cullinane –

Distortions of Christian Leadership 4  (4)
Major Dr Harold Hill

So, having referred to Scripture, and Tradition, and made a long excursus around Reason, what about Experience? Bad experiences may be had in all faith traditions. The worst experiences may be had when religious sanctions are brought in to reinforce what are just bad management practices, the “spiritual” used to serve the “natural”; when the best of reasons are marshalled behind the least worthy of purposes, when the loyalty of the led is manipulated to the benefit of the leader, when mere moral blackmail becomes spiritual abuse. That’s probably the main way in which Christian leadership is capable of greater distortion than leadership in general. Religious leaders claim to speak for God.


I recall a Salvation Army leader speaking with a group of concerned Salvationists who wanted him to deal with a case of sexual abuse by an officer. There was, worse still, a non-Salvationist party, a counsellor from Rape Crisis, involved in the proceedings. The leader rebuked the concerned Salvationists (who included a retired Territorial Commander!) for their lack of loyalty to the Army in raising this matter. It was the lady from Rape Crisis who laughed out loud in amazement at this distortion of leaderly authority!

But of course the Wesleyan “experience” in discernment does not mean just anything one happens to have experienced. It is about how the Spirit enables us to reflect upon and utilize our life experience in decision-making – like the Quakers’ Inner Light. Jackie Leach Scully, a Quaker and biomedical ethicist, speaks of “pay[ing] attention to intuition and gut feelings, not holding that they are always right but believing that they can be pointing towards something I’m aware of at some level but overlooking.”[1] Our own experience may also set us up for mistakes. The Talmud allegedly says, “We don’t see the things the way they are. We see things the way WE are.”  Scully goes on to say that she also seeks collective discernment for weightier matters.

The leader who committed the Salvation Army to a leading role in opposing homosexual law reform in New Zealand in 1985 believed, rightly or wrongly, that he was supported by Scripture, Tradition and Reason, but led by his inner convictions he rejected the collective counsel of all but one of his Heads of Departments here and the guidance of his international headquarters in London. Thirty years and several apologies later, we are still picking up the pieces. Leaders will consciously or unconsciously take cognizance of that intuition derived from their experience, but for that very reason must heed the scriptural injunction to “test every spirit” – including their own – by seeking and paying attention to wider discernment.

I have structured this paper on the Wesleyan quadrilateral and sought under Scripture, Tradition, Reason and Experience, to explore some of the ways in which leaders’ discernment – and consequently their leadership – might be distorted. But why the deplorable stories, which reflect no credit on the actors involved, or on me for telling them? Memories of good leadership naturally inspire and encourage us, but my bad memories have been offered intentionally. Both Christian individuals and Christian institutions might well emulate John Newton and hang that text over the mantelpiece, “Remember thou wast a bondman in the land of Egypt and the Lord thy God redeemed thee…”[2] Or, less solemnly, take on board Elizabeth I’s Memo to a recalcitrant bishop: “My Lord, remember what thou wert before I made thee what thou art. Now do as I bid or I’ll unfrock thee, by God!”

One of John Baillie’s Private Prayers includes a confession which ends: “Use these memories, O God, to save me, and then forever blot them out.”[3] Memories of distorted leadership may indeed help save us if we heed their warnings; but their blotting out had better be postponed to another world. We need to be reminded of our shadow, because it can help us to let go of the ways and works of pathological power, the better to do what Jesus would do.

Major (Dr) Harold Hill
 New Zealand 




[1] “Back page interview”, The Church Times, 16 May 2014, 48.
[2] Deuteronomy 15:15 AV.
[3] John Baillie, A Diary of Private Prayer (London, Oxford University Press, [1936]1958) 35.


MAJOR (DR) HAROLD HILL


The fourth quadrant of the quadrilateral; Church Experience as a source for Leadership discernment.

4 comments:

Anonymous said...

A brilliant series! Thank you Harold Hill!
SA London

Anonymous said...

Am I the only one wishing there were 4 more parts and 1st hand stories from officers past and present?
Who reads these posts at IHQ/THQ/DHQ? Would there be any value in printing Hill's paper out and mailing hard copies to the Cabinet?
USA Active

Anonymous said...

Any value in mailing hard copies to the cabinet? Not in a million years. The Howard Hospital fiasco proved that - at the time of the election for the new general. Subscribers to this blog were filled with hope then that their lobbying on behalf of the Chiweshe people and the HH doctor Paul Thistle would have a positive effect, but those sentiments were rudely and sinfully ignored and the disgraceful actions by the SA international leadership were allowed to float away like flotsam and jetsam. TSA has long forgotten the main reason it came into being - to save souls and to live as Christ would have us live. Its leaders are so immersed in the salvation army structure and image that they can see no further, and that is why they have appeased the people responsible for such immoral issues as child abuse within its ranks, and actively ignored other sins within the ranks. It 'protects the SA brand' at all costs, and has totally forgotten the phrase that 'The Salvation Army must not become so much of a middle-class movement that it forgets 'the rock whence it is hewn'. It is called to proclaim salvation to all classes, but its special glory should be its concern for and its ability to appeal to the lowest and most forgotten, and to be their champion in every respect'.'
The rock has been consigned to history for the sake of expediency, but leaders forget that there is no spiritual future where there is unconfessed sin. Hypocritically, the message of salvation is preached every Sunday - confess your sin and come to Jesus - but at the top level there are all these unresolved issues. If you look at the Movement today all you'll see are the celebratory lights of past glories, and a mainly elderly soldiery too set in their ways and 'at ease in Zion' - Zion being their declining corps and their comfortable lifestyles - to make a difference to society today.
So don't hold your breath for any improvements soon, unless the wind of the Spirit blows mightily through the ranks, blowing away all that hinders the Gospel. Now there's a thought.

Anonymous said...

Weberian sociology, as I understand it, reflects on subjective processes. For instance, verstende is amplified to translate as empathetic understanding. That is, comprehending the action from the actor’s perspective. This adds a very different experience to a leader’s response and actions – and responsibility. For Weber, we privilege rational thinking above traditional thinking. We intentionally move away from tradition in favor of rationality.

Today’s Army, in tune with modern society are predominantly based on rationality- 'what works most efficiently' not 'how did our founders and fathers do it.

Sociologists should study not just the objective aspects of society ie. 'what we do'. but should address the meaning of behavior...'why we act. Weber argues that modernity creates greater efficiency, wealth and justice, but modern people, he said, are also at risk of becoming: dehumanized, becoming ...... 'Specialists without spirit, sensualists without heart'

Long time fan of the FSAOF blog articles - opening the minds of Salvationists 'round the globe.
USA officer serving in the UK