Sunday, August 24, 2014

Sacrifice in Reasonable Service
 Part 1 (2)

Two true stories

An officer accompanied his young son to school for a teacher/parent interview. The teacher suggested some project the father could do together with his son. The officer was floored when the boy asked, “Is it all right if I get someone else’s father to help; mine would be too busy.”

An old soldier of a country Corps died. The family went and knocked on the Quarters door. The young officer said, “Sorry, I’m on furlough. I’m not able to come.” (It’s OK…The family contacted the previous CO, who drove half-way across the country in order to be with them in their bereavement and conduct the funeral.)

Regarding the first story, we have in the Army a long tradition of the “better to burn out than to rust out” kind.  The Orders and Regulations prescribed suffering as part of the officer’s commitment: “The F.O. must choose not only the Salvation of Souls as the end of his existence, but that suffering, without which they cannot be saved. He embraces not only the end, but the means by which alone this end can be accomplished.”[1] Bramwell Booth confessed in a letter that “This feeling that you are a poor sinner loaded with guilt if you stop work for ten minutes, even in a railway train, is really dreadful.”[2] Most of us received some initial conditioning in Sunday School, when we learned to sing, “Jesus first, myself last, and others in between.” Sometimes family came last, with “myself”, rather than in between, with “others”. So the first story rings true.

Now, looking at the second story, we have a less-trumpeted tradition of this kind too. Mrs General Bramwell Booth, when in charge of the British Territory in the 1920s, was dismayed to learn of an officer who stated that “as a Field Officer she would be in little home where she would be able to rest whenever she desired, and go to meetings occasionally.”[3] Some might characterise that attitude as typical welfare-dependency, or perhaps a public service mentality. I don’t think that’s entirely fair, but I gather that senior officers today may be as frustrated as Mrs Booth at a like reluctance of some officers to be accountable to anyone but themselves for their time or for the discharge of their responsibilities.

You will gather that the particular angle of “sacrifice” I am addressing is that which concerns “the Work”, as “service”. Here we find these two opposite poles, workaholism and laziness – or at least such a clarity about the need for self-care that, as one church-member said of his pastor, “Unfortunately the church doesn’t seem to figure in his ‘core business’.” Organisationally, have we swung from one to the other? Why do some people always need a rev up and others need to slow down? What causes these extremes? How can we maintain a realistic balance between having no boundaries at all and erecting a Maginot Line around the Quarters?


Sacrifices then and now

Once upon a time the sacrifices involved in serving God through the Salvation Army were fairly obvious – poverty, suffering, hardship, persecution were par for the course. You sometimes depended on charity to eat, if you collected enough for the corps expenses but not enough for your allowance as well. Riots and terms of imprisonment were left behind with the nineteenth century, but you were not too highly regarded in the community until the movement had earned a grudging respect through its social work or war service, and you might still endure some name-calling from the rowdy element and a measure of contempt from their betters. There was also the expectation of obedience to superiors, and sometimes a degree of harshness, of arbitrary unfairness, about the administration of the Movement. Of course, that would never happen now, but frustration with the organisation is nothing new. Even the loyal and saintly Brengle confided to his wife in 1912 that

I think probably most of our difficulty at present in this country arises from this multiplicity of details and the infinite red tape with which we are tied up which sap the strength and frustrate the piety of our people… To my mind it is one of the paradoxes of history how the General, with his free, large spirit which refuses to be bound by the mild rules of a Methodist conference, could have developed a system which binds men hand and foot with red tape, which is to Methodist rules what… calculus is to the multiplication table.[4]

Officer-recruitment in the good old days was like Churchill’s famous offer to the British people in 1940; “nothing but blood, toil, tears and sweat”. However, the Salvation Army officer’s boat has risen with all the others on the rising tide; it’s nearly forty years since officers in New Zealand were not virtually guaranteed their allowance. We have come to expect a moderately comfortable middle-class life-style. If we still maintain some of the rhetoric, the reality is a little different. And most, if not all men, think well of us.

So what are the sacrifices asked of officers today? Is there anything which might occasion suffering?

I suspect that most discomfort arises internally, from within the movement itself, both from above and from below. The officer is caught between the upper and the nether millstones, like Hopalong Cassidy in the first moving picture I ever saw. Unfortunately it was just part two of a three-part movie and I never saw the final instalment, so for me Hopalong Cassidy is forever crouching beneath the slowly descending grindstone of a bad injun’s grinding mill…

The “lower” millstone? I suppose there have always been some Salvationist families whose staple Sunday lunchtime fare was roast officer; that won’t have changed. Keeping the peace amongst our comrades in the war remains an onerous responsibility, and the energy expended dodging friendly fire is no longer available for prosecution of the war itself. Perhaps more significant is that in any people-helping role, you cannot have a more than ordinary exposure to a toxic environment of sadness and badness without risking some personal damage.

The “upper” millstone is the expectations of the organisation itself, augmented by the ever-growing burden of compliance fashioned by those who rightly seek to save us from ourselves. This is not a Salvation Army distinctive. Ask any professional person or anyone in the “people-helping” industry. Of the making of forms, all for the best of possible reasons, from Occupational Health and Safety to Statistical Returns, there is no end. Computers have not yet delivered the paperless office, and the officers no longer visit the comrades at home because they are bent over their keyboards far into the night... Mat Badger describes it as “death by paperwork”.[5] The end result is that we continue to kick against the pricks with renewed energy as far as accountability to the organisation is concerned.

Biblical perspective

The Biblical text which most commonly springs to mind as linking the concepts of “sacrifice” and “service” is of course Romans 12:1: “Offer yourselves as a living sacrifice… which is your reasonable service”.

Here we have firstly  the notion of sacrifice, thusia. Sacrifice implies costliness; we remember David saying that “I would not offer to the Lord my God that which costs me nothing.”[6] What is being offered as sacrifice to God is the Christian's whole self; in T.S. Eliot’s words, “costing not less than everything.”[7] Once offered, ownership of what is sacrificed passes into the hands of God. If, as in the feast that followed a temple sacrifice, we get to share the meal, we receive it as God’s gift to us, not as something we own ourselves.

Then we have Paul’s play on the word “service” – latreian  – meaning both cultic worship and the tasks of ordinary servitude. It embraces both the “religious” duties we may discharge, the tasks which maintain the corporate life of the church, and the necessity of doing everything else, our “secular callings”, the “trivial round, the common task”,[8] all in the name of the Lord Jesus.[9] They are all means to worship and glorify God. “Service” reminds us that our faith includes both vertical and horizontal dimensions; both heart to God and hand to man. It is a word rich in prophetic associations, reminding us of Isaiah’s warning that offerings are useless if justice is neglected, of Hosea’s declaration that God requires “mercy and not sacrifice”, of Jesus’ own “inasmuch” parable and his warning that it is not those who merely say “Lord, Lord” who will enter the Kingdom.[10] This is all about “walking the talk”.


Major Harold Hill

1 comment:

Anonymous said...

'We have in the Army a long tradition of the “better to burn out than to rust out” kind.' Thank goodness or we'd still be in the East End!