Monday, August 11, 2014

Changing Course: A SALVATION ARMY ETHIC’S PRIMER 101 (8) PRICE OR DIGNITY

PART ONE- 

PARTS 2-3 WILL FOLLOW SHORTLY


‘There is nothing sadder than walking out the Headquarters’ door, following the exit interview 
and handing in one’s SA identity papers, laptop - 
with scores of reworked sermons, the resignation briefcar, office and the quarter’s keys, virtually unnoticed by friends and colleagues of 14 years”.

THE EXIT INTERVIEW


Ninety-five percent of companies conduct exit interviews or surveys, but only 30 percent report that they ever take corrective action based on what they learn. “In the past, exit interview data was being collected by the organization but not much was being done in terms of interpreting the data and making it actionable. Today there are metrics, analytics, benchmarks, and best practices that help organizations make sense of and use the data towards proactive organizational retention programs. Recently an array of exit interview software has been developed and popularized. These programs facilitate and streamline the employee separation process, allow surveys to be completed via the web, make separation and retention trends easy to identify, and amass actionable data which can increase organizational effectiveness and productivity. Additionally, some of these programs make it possible to quantify data gleaned from the surveys to more accurately understand why employees are leaving the organization.” The AMA

FSAOF SURVEY CONDUCTED IN 2010 & 2012

MY EXIT INTERVIEW WAS FAIR/PROFESSIONAL:

Yes
17.4%

No
54.5%

The interview was biased
  3.0%

I would have liked peers/colleagues present
  5.3%

Other (no proper exit interview conducted)
14.4%

My views were ignored
  5.3%


Almost 75% of the officers resigning or being dismissed believe the exit interview was conducted unprofessionally; 54.5%, 
 was biased; 3%, or were denied an exit interview; 14.4%.


The Officer May-June 2014

The Salvation Army should be above reproach in the way that we deal with people…. We owe it to God to be above reproach, we also owe it to our people…. General Andre Cox

The role of management: The FSAOF expect Salvation Army officers of every rank to serve with honour recognising the dignity and worth of each officer resigning from full time ministry.

Value – Dignity
Immanuel Kant offered the best-known philosophical theories on the definition of dignity in his Groundwork to the Metaphysics of Morals, which states “In the kingdom of ends everything has either a price or a dignity….
and humanity insofar as it is capable of morality, is that which alone has dignity.”

“Dignity” is the English translator’s term and those of us who speak German or a Germanic language recognize that Kant’s German term “würde” can not be translated without a fair bit of leeway as “dignity” its most common translation. “Würde” or ‘varde’ is much closer to “worth” than our term “dignity” is. Further there is no particular reason to use the term “dignity” to convey
“worth”.

Worth signifies a value, while dignity defines status. The distinction may seem minor, however in returning to the officers councils we acknowledge that in moral theory, yesterday’s article, a person’s status can derive from an estimation of a person’s fundamental worth. And all persons, may have dignity because he or she has worth. (“Würde” in Kant’s sense) And anything or any person of value needs to be promoted and/or protected thereby maximizing ranking. In the case of a person the status is to respect and defer to the person who bears it.

Kant’s use of dignity (or “Würde”) is complicated as he also uses the term in ways that align more closely to the traditional connotations of nobility. Kant talks of “the distribution of dignities”…. “no human being can be without any dignity, since he at least has the dignity of a citizen.”

Integrity is the foundation of any leadership relationship and in 2 Corinthians 1:12 (NIV), Paul tells us; "This is our boast. Our conscience testifies that we have conducted ourselves in the world (the workplace), especially in our relations with you, in the holiness and sincerity that are from God."  Translated; My conscience testifies that I have sought to conduct myself with integrity, wholly seeking to conform to Your holiness and recognising the status of the person(s) with whom I just met.

General William Booth, Field Officer (December 1900) pp. 453-4. recognised fully the value and dignity of the resigning officer:
“The ex-officer, no matter what was the cause that resulted in his loss to our fighting forces, is still a child of the Army. He entered the sacred circle. He became one of us, sharing our joys and sorrows, losses and crosses. He received the commission of a divinely- appointed authority to proclaim Salvation, build up men and women in their most holy faith, and help to win someone to God.”

General Shaw Clifton wrote in his New Year 2010 Pastoral letter...

“This season of new beginnings allows us to place before the Lord also the hopes we have in our hearts concerning our daily work. Many of you reading this are Salvation Army officers making plans for the spiritual advancement of those you lead and those you serve in Christ's name. I say to you, 'May God bless those plans, those sacred ambitions for the souls of others.'

Just two years later, more than 700 of the officers addressed in that Pastoral letter are no longer serving in the Army, having giving up their sacred ambitions in the role of SA officers.

If we use the accepted formula across Christian denominations acknowledging that; fifty percent of all Pastors/Ministers resign from their appointed ministry role within 
a decade of their ordination the SA would have to acknowledge that there are at least 10,000+ former officers in the world, with the majority living in North America and Western Europe. (FSAOF BLOG 2012)

The FSAOF counts about 10% of them, 1,100 as members of our fellowship with between 15-20 additional formers joining us every month.

FSAOF SURVEY  2010 ~2012


I COMPLETED 2 YEARS OF TRAINING AS A CADET?

YES
90.4%

NO
  4.4%

Other
  5.2%







I  SERVED AS A SA OFFICER:


Less than 5 Years
19.1%

6 - 10 Years
33.1%

11 - 16 Years
23.5%

More than 16 Years
24.3%







WHEN I RESIGNED I HELD THE RANK OF:

Lieutenant
11.8%

Captain
68.4%

Major
16.2%

Aux Captain
  1.5%

Lt. Colonel
  0.7%

Other
  1.5%







I TRAINED IN: (Territory)

UKT
22.6%

Canada & Bermuda
17.0%

USA:       East
21.1%

Central
10.5%

South
12.0%

West
  9.8%

Australia
  3.8%

New Zealand & Fiji
  1.5%

Other
  1.8%







I SERVED IN: (Territory)


UKT
17.6%

USA EAST
18.4%

USA CENTRAL
11.8%

USA SOUTH
12.5%

USA WEST
  9.6%

AUSTRALIA
  4.4%

NZ &FIJI
  1.5%

CANADA & BERMUDA
11.0%

SCANDINAVIA
  1.4%

NL
  0.7%

Other: South Africa, Zambia, Zimbabwe 
12.5%







WHILE SERVING IN TSA I WAS MARRIED:


YES
72.8%

NO
22.8%

Other
4.4%










MY SPOUSE AND I RESIGNED CONCURRENTLY:


YES
60.6%

NO
15.7%

Other (infidelity, divorce, sexual preference,
PTG, retirement)                                23.6%









WE HAD CHILDREN LIVING IN OUR QUARTERS:


Yes
60.3%

No
35.1%

Other
4.6%




CHILDREN FACTORED INTO DECISION TO RESIGN

Yes
12.8%

No
68.4%

In part
6.8%

Other
12.0%



MY RESIGNATION WAS:

Voluntary
59.3%

Mandatory
17.0%

Conditional
3.7%

Other (spouse resigned)
20.0%







I/WE WERE OFFERED:

SA counseling
13.0%

Professional counseling/treatment
11.3%

Residential care at SA expense
0.9%

Leave of absence
6.1%

Other (change of appointment, etc.
68.7%

Sabbatical
0.0%



 S Ljungholm
Liverpool














No comments: