Sunday, August 24, 2014

Sacrifice in Reasonable Service 2 (2)


Then there is the qualifier, logikon, “reasonable”. (We’ll set on one side the NIV’s “spiritual service” because although the translators have their reasons, frankly, I think they’re wrong. “Spiritual” conveys far too restricted an application.) So, “reasonable”. What is “reasonable” in this context?  Does he mean something like “moderation in all things… Sure, make some sacrifice… just don’t go overboard about it…” I think not. “Intelligent worship” says Philips. “The most sensible way to serve God,” according to the CEV. “Understanding worship” in Cranfield’s phrase. Paul is not referring to “reasonableness” or “rationality” in our modern, colloquial  sense, but as Cranfield puts it, to what would be “consistent with a proper understanding of the truth of God revealed in Jesus Christ.” Logically, given that (the mercy, the grace of God), then this! (our whole-hearted response).

Cranfield sums up: “The intelligent understanding of worship, that is, worship which is consonant with the truth of the gospel, is indeed nothing less than the offering of one’s whole self in the course of one’s concrete living, in one’s inward thoughts, feelings and aspirations, but also in one’s words and deeds.”[11]

Then of course that opening is followed up by Paul’s injunction not to “let the world squeeze you into its mould”, in J.B. Philips’ memorable paraphrase, but to let God  re-mould, transform us from within. And all of this as introduction to, and in the context of, our involvement in the Body of Christ. So although I’m taking that particular text as a springboard, I’m not intending to use it as a “proof text” on which all depends, without context, but as one directing us towards the whole grace-filled Christian life-style implied by the qualifier, “reasonable”.

So what does that mean in practice; what does it involve? And how does it relate to the two poles of workaholism and hyper-self-care illustrated by my opening stories? Living for others and living for myself are both needful, but either, if not balanced by the other, is deeply dangerous. But a whiff of paradox is not uncommonly a sign that a truth lurks nearby, so let us tease it out.

“Living for others” is obviously Biblical. Paul urges that “those who live should no longer live for themselves but only for him who died and was raised to life for their sake.”[12] He also says that “We should not please ourselves. Instead we should all please our brothers for their own good, in order to build them up in the faith.”[13]  He says that we should “look out for one another’s interests, not just your own.”[14] (Note: not “instead of your own”.) To live by these principles, by the power of the Holy Spirit, is a needful and powerful witness to a self-centred and hedonistic society. (Though we remember that countless non-Christians also live or die for causes greater than their own pleasure or self-interest, from the care-giver for a disabled person to the suicide bomber making the ultimate sacrifice.) That side of things is pretty well covered anyway.

At the same time, what about “self-care”? Is that just “another gospel”, derived from pop psychology? No string of supporting texts springs readily to mind here. Perhaps it’s more a matter of inferring what kind of life-style was being enjoined by one who promised not only suffering but an “easy yoke”. Who not only warned of homelessness but emphasised the need not to get stressed out about the things the Gentiles were all uptight over because “your Father knows you need that stuff”. Who was sufficiently sensitive to our lack of self-love that as an update on the second-greatest commandment, “Love your neighbour as yourself”, he proposed “Love one another as I have loved you”. On a merely utilitarian level there’s a case for calling self-care the wise stewardship of God’s resources, but the recognition that we are loved takes it to another level altogether. More than anything else the thread that ran through all Jesus’ teaching and example, the central truth of the Gospel, as Paul’s great insight had it, was “grace”. That is, the undeserved favour of God, independent of merit or earning capacity – the antithesis of Law, and of the slavery to shoulds and oughts to which we are prone. This “grace” is fundamental to, inseparable from, the “truth of the Gospel” to which Cranfield alludes. Self-care is actually integral to that perspective.

Addictive behaviours

Sometimes we get a different message from that, partly because, fairly or not, Paul comes across in his letters as a classic, driven, workaholic. But chiefly because Law is the default position of humanity; and because workaholism is one of the devil’s classic imitations designed to deceive even the elect. No use having a temptation if it doesn’t look a bit like the real thing; a Bangkok market Rolex looks like a Rolex until the gilt wears off. Or it stops. So: love is distorted to lust, gambling demonstrates a parody of faith, low self-esteem masquerades as humility, rescuing presents as care, co-dependence is mistaken for mutuality, hope has been displaced by expectation – workaholism is rewarded as diligence and laziness can hide behind self-care.

So there is a connection between the rhetoric of sacrifice and the phenomenon of resistance to sacrifice in the name of self-care. Both are good things made bad by over-use. Both are addictive behaviours, at opposite ends of a continuum. Both arise from unmet needs for attention and approval, which we attempt to meet in our own ways – whether over-working or under-working – instead trusting in God to meet our needs. Like all addictions, workaholism and laziness are characterised by selfishness and self-centredness, by the using of other people for personal ends. And both consume the one afflicted by them as well as creating a zone of toxicity, hazardous to others. They give rise to one or other of two opposite and equally adverse reactions. One is the “headless chook” syndrome, the revving out of control. The other is the reactive, “tell someone who cares” complex, which brings the wheels to a grinding halt. Both extremes are “unreasonable”, in that both are incompatible with the gospel of grace.

Without a sacrificial commitment to God and the people, the inconsistency between what the Salvation Army claims and what I actually do as a Salvationist soon becomes destructive of my own integrity as well as a disincentive to those who might look to “imitate me as I imitate Christ”[15]. If I’m known as a lazy slob, hardly motivated to countersign the salary cheque if it can possibly be avoided, the word will get around quite soon. The same is true of course if what we model is unhealthily driven and obsessive behaviour. If we have within ourselves a deep and addictive need to be needed, we will run ourselves (and others) ragged, and eventually burn out. And as far as serving either the Lord or others is concerned, that soon becomes counter-productive. People are not silly; nor is God.

This is not beat-ourselves-up time. Of course we are always people of mixed motivation, and our needing to impress our peers, or to please our boss, or to placate our own sense of inferiority, may have to be acknowledged. Any blame and shame we might have taken on from family of origin or absorbed by osmosis from a shame-based society, and the perfectionism of a holiness theology gone sour, are burdens to be laid aside so that they do not get in the way as we address ourselves to the race that lies before us.[16]

The application of “reasonableness”

Which brings me back to Paul’s key word, logikon, “reasonable”; that is, “consistent with the gospel of grace”, in Cranfield’s exegesis. If you like, that is the fly-wheel on the engine of sacrifice, the weight of which not only helps keep the engine turning but also prevents it from revving out of control.

So, what would be “consistent with the gospel”, and by what means might that be secured as our “default setting”, instead of being the unattainable ideal of over-responsibility on the one hand, or a complete discarding of responsibility on the other? A proper application of “reasonable” is the answer. That is, bringing our needs to the only one who can meet them, a transforming experience of grace; a conversion from self-salvation, to trust in the love of God. Grace sets us free from the need to earn brownie points and free to get stuck into the job. And that attitudinal change can be followed up by (1) on-going, practical measures taken to ensure accountability, with appropriate supports (which are all part of being part of the Body in the world), and (2) an on-going, deepening, personal relationship with Jesus (which goes on transforming from within).

Major Harold Hill

[1] Orders and Regulations for Field Officers, (London: Salvation Army, 1886) p. 9.
[2] Catherine Bramwell Booth, Bramwell Booth (London: Rich & Cowan, 1932) p. 199.
[3] Florence Booth, Powers of Salvation Army Officers, (London: Salvation Army, [1928] ) p. 18.
[4] S.L. Brengle, in letter to his wife 22 July 1912, in William Clark (ed.), Dearest Lily: a selection of the Brengle correspondence (London: SA, 1985)  p. 112
[5] Mat Badger, “The Changing Nature of Salvation Army Officership: An Examination of the Impact of Institutionalization on the Mission of the Salvation Army”, eJournal of Aggressive Christianity  40 (December 2005/January 2006), on www.armybarmy.com.
[6]   2 Samuel 24:24.
[7]  TS Eliot, from “Little Gidding”, in Four Quartets.
[8]  John Keble in SASB 668.
[9]  Colossians 3:17
[10]  Isaiah 1:11-17, Hosea 6:6, Matthew 25:40, 45; Luke 6:46.
[11]  C.E.B. Cranfield, A Critical and Exegetical Commentary on the Epistle to the Romans, II, p. 605 (Edinburgh: T&T Clark, 1979).
[12] 2 Corinthians 5:15.
[13] 1 Corinthians 15:1-2.
[14]  Philippians 2:4.
[15]  1 Corinthians 11:1.
[16] Hebrews 12:1.



1 comment:

Anonymous said...

Why is it that now, into the Major's retirement years we first benefit from his wisdom? I've downloaded all the FSAOF posts and look forward to part of of the quadrant series.

In fact the entire abuse series has boarded us with some very challenging and sobering stuff!

Active DHQ