Wednesday, August 13, 2014

Changing Course: A SALVATION ARMY ETHIC’S PRIMER 101 (10) OUT OF SIGHT - OUT OF TOUCH ...

Writing to a deadline doesn't always bring out one’s best, something, of which I am painfully aware. One would think that being in retirement would allow ample time to edit, correct, re-write and right, but it just doesn’t work very easily for me. Perhaps the greatest distraction (evil) is when I conduct research. I’ll find articles far more interesting than the one I’m trying to write! And then there's my need to catch up on the news - I often find myself pouring another cup of coffee while typing away but my wheelchair steers itself from the coffee pot to our living room where the BBC, CNN, RT, share highlights on the hour, every hour – digressing is a major fault, as you’ve just witnessed! Which book was I re-reading? Right-

INTRODUCTION
The attention to ethics in business organizations has never been greater than in the last 15 years.

When talking about ethics in organizations the view of moral responsibility and the kinds of ethical principles that should be used to resolve ethical problem often reflect the "individualistic approach" to moral responsibility, meaning every person in an organization is morally responsible for his or her own behavior. Efforts to change that behavior should focus on the individual.

The other behavior is communal where individuals are viewed not in isolation, but as members of communities/corporations that are responsible for the behavior of their members.

“Effective solutions to ethical problems arising in organizations requires that we take both approaches into account.  When we draw upon the insights of both approaches we increase our understanding of the ethical values at stake in moral issues and increase the options available to us for resolving these issues.

There are times, however, when our willingness to consider both the good of the individual and the good of the community leaves us in a dilemma, and we are forced to choose between competing moral claims.

When facing such dilemmas, the weights we assign to certain values will sometimes lead us to choose those organizational policies or actions that will promote the common good. At other times, our values will lead us to choose those policies or actions that will protect the interests and rights of the individual. But perhaps the greatest challenge in discussions of ethics in organizations is to find ways in which organizations can be designed to promote the interests of both.”[1]

 Arthur Andersen LLP is a USA holding company and formerly one of the "Big Five" accounting firms that include PricewaterhouseCoopers. Both these global entities provided auditing, tax, and consulting services to large corporations. Both companies collapsed and voluntarily surrendered its licenses to practice as Certified Public Accountants in the United States after being found guilty of criminal charges relating to the firm's handling of the several fortune 500 companies and foreign governments. (I conducted seminars in both companies’ Moscow offices while completing my PhD thesis)

Those with investments affected by the unethical practices of the two companies and their clients paid special attention the legal wrangling’s and where responsibility for the corporate moral failings were blamed on the CEO at the top to the night watchman at the bottom. Special attention was also paid by their smaller competitor who issued the following statement claiming ethical principles being practiced both by the "individualistic” and “communal” approach:

“Corporate leaders have a duty to build and foster a values-based culture that thrives on high ethical standards and makes corporate and social responsibility a top priority. Only by instilling these values in our respective organizations will we be able to bestow a promising future to the next generation.”
Sharon L. Allen
Chairman of the Board
Deloitte & Touche USA LLP

This statement can certainly be seen as both self-serving, bringing reassurance to their existing clients, while also touting their principles to the abandoned AA and PW clients seeking their much-valued business.

THE SEPARATION FROM OFFICERSHIP AND THE SA’S  "INDIVIDUALISTIC” AND “COMMUNAL” APPROACH (or lack thereof):

The experience and pain of isolation can be debilitating for those leaving officership. In the absence of good organization, social and spiritual supports people’s health deteriorates and some formers return to drug and alcohol usage, and mental illness in the form of depression is exacerbated.
At the very moment when those resigning from the ministry need us most we can’t ignore their plight. They will soon become socially marginalized in SA communities, intentionally or not. These are our faith partners whom God tells us to love unconditionally and generously.

Some honest self-examination is needed to identify the various factors that have led to this tragic episode. We may not be guilty of all the things we're currently being accused of, but we're not innocent either. SA Active UKTI

 “How much after care would be sufficient is definitely one of the things that should be discussed. But, you should know that in many cases, including mine, no aftercare was offered to us. In fact, no one spoke to me personally about my reasons for resigning, or about how I was doing spiritually.

No one offered to pray with me until the day before I moved out of the quarters, and that was done over the phone. 

I try hard most days to not be too discouraged, because the ultimate decision was ours when it came to resignation. However, in my case - and in the case of many other formers - very little was done to keep my husband and me in the ranks of officership. And it still makes me very sad. 

”[2]
Former, US Central
_________________
There are more than two dozen subjects for discussion in the formers private site with more than a thousand comments. Included among the comments are scores of very personal stories of why our colleagues, session mates, prayer partners, family and friends left Officership and where they are now.

The Army’s espoused values speak of the redemptive work of the Church of Christ on earth, and as such they/we must make a genuine commitment to this ideal, beginning with every Officer. This has nothing to do with benefits, appointments or position, rather the true worth of those who are charged with genuine Christ-like love for the individual. This true love will begin the healing, help stem the tide of those leaving, and bring blessing from God. It may not change the course for those leaving but it will ultimately bring God’s blessing upon the Army! This is what we all want, and this is what God wants to give.
*
“I have a 'former officer' in my family and as you would no doubt imagine I have heard much of their pain, disappointments, frustration to name just some emotions. However, even being this close to a 'former' I dare to suggest that none of us will ever really know what another has been through or is going through. Just as one person’s grief is very different to another's we are all individuals and respond differently. 

”
Active UKT THQ
*


”Serve 25 years and then resign in good standing and still have people treat you with a cold attitude and see how you feel. 
It is not only aftercare but also appreciation for years of service that would be helpful. No one would like to think that many years of hard work and sacrifice were not respected and acknowledged
 in an appropriate and graceful decent manner. 
My thank you was, "Please return your officer medical card and ID to territorial headquarter." I enjoyed wearing my LS pin for one month on my uniform, now I wear it on my pajamas. 

Sorry, but I am out of sight and you are out of touch. 

”
USA East, residing in Arizona, USA West.

*
“I recently re-read the letter from THQ accepting our resignation. In it we were told of the Army’s appreciation for our 21 years of service, immediately followed by the perfunctory reminders that our healthcare would cease at the end of the month, to turn in our identification cards and not to in any way represent ourselves as SA Officers. Sadly there was nothing encouraging us to stay connected with the Army as potential soldiers, no offer of counsel or advice to assist in the financial, emotional, practical, and spiritual transition…no more, “The Army loves you and you have worth?”
USA East (Son of the Regiment)
                 
*
“Sadly this cultural weakness goes back to the very roots of the Army…Booth’s treatment of his own family when they became some of the first Formers. They were literally ex-communicated by their own father. They remained faithful to God’s call and enjoyed incredible ministry outside the Army like many of today’s Formers…and I am sure God used the experience gained from The Salvation Army.
                 
So, why am I taking your time and mine to write about this? Because from my perspective the emphasis of the FSAOF  (Sven’s) “White Paper” must not become some resource to retain or even restore Formers, rather a call for true reform within the organization. If the Army says that it loves a person at the beginning of their officership, that love if genuine must follow them out of officership, or one must question its authenticity.

*               
“To 'Former USA'


Thank you for your comment in response to my posting. 
  It is obvious from your posting that the total lack of after care was preceded by a total absence of care during your period of distress as an 'active' - this is indefensible and unacceptable behaviour on the part of your line-management and the SA as a whole. 

How much after care would be sufficient is definitely one of the things that should be discussed. Especially for those people who have moved on by choice and conviction into new spheres of service. The need for intensive and extensive after-care would be far less acute than for those who feel they have been put in an untenable position by the organisational structures (or maybe even by self) and feel they have not being listened to. 



Personally speaking, if I left officership either by free choice or not then I would expect the SA to follow a clear exit strategy that is humane, affirming, generous and appreciative... after that I am on my own and become responsible for self and would not want to be in regular continued contact with my former employer. That is not always very easy when you have been part of a controlling, paternalistic movement that took care of most of your practical and emotional needs. 

 I am also a firm believer of keeping a door ajar so that after a dignified exit there is always a possibility of a dignified re-entry.

Having been an officer for some decades, I have witnessed some very undignified and ugly exits that made a possible re-entry nigh impossible. Yet some of these folks have been reaccepted and serving once again as officers in the UKT. 

As I said at the beginning of my original posting: 

"The dynamics of officer terminations are very complex and complicated. 

With much grace and good wishes to you and yours.....”
*
The discussion of aftercare and consideration of our own reaction to resignations and terminations is the beginning of better transitions "away" from the Army. Prior to my termination due to separation and divorce, I too needed to reach out more to fellow officers leaving the work. But busyness and awkwardness also kept me from always doing the right thing of keeping contact and offering support. 
The painful experience of being "cast out" has changed me entirely. Rather than seeing people through my former legalistic, judgmental lens, I see that enduring awkward situations to show love and choosing people as a priority practices true grace. Grace should be offered to all whether terminated or some other situation beyond a person's control. This needs to apply to former officers, soldiers as well as former Christians. 
As a former officer and current Presbyterian, I accept your challenge "to support, comfort, confront and care for each other." I feel uniquely qualified to understand the painful and difficult transition from the Army. Thank you for the reminder to practice grace both to all types of "formers" as well as Army administration at every opportunity. 


USA West, residing in California.
_______

Sven Ljungholm
Liverpool




[1] Santa Clara University
Mark Kula Center for Applied Ethics
Ethics in Organizations
By Marvin Brown

[2] A FSAOF survey conducted in 2012 revealed that 21% of the officers who’d resigned would have considered an immediate return to active service if contacted and the topic explored within 90 days of resigning. World wide, and if the percentage were accurate across borders, that means that more than 3,000 formers would discuss a return.

5 comments:

Anonymous said...

Thanks , I've been looking for information about this corporate ethics applied to ministry for a while and yours is the most comprehensive I've discovered til now. However, what concerns me is how do we apply it? That must be the conclusion?
UMC Detrot

Anonymous said...

'Get over it' is a phrase that comes to mind - move on.

Anonymous said...

Excellent article.I am an officer of 28yrs service and recently found myself being bullied by the D.C.A situation that needed the said person to be understanding and sensitive instead showed very little compassion.
Officers are people not simply names in the dispo.

Anonymous said...

Dear Anonymous who said, "'Get over it' is a phrase that comes to mind - move on.":

Thank you for your concern and compassion toward many who even now experience great pain and the feeling of loss upon leaving officership! I should say, "Forgive my sarcasm" but I am not sorry for pointing out the obvious!

Anonymous said...

'Get over it - move on'.
Admirable advice - but we are talking about CHRISTIAN leadership skills (or the lack of them) here. This shouldn't be happening, and it's a tragic indictment that articles like this have to be written to highlight the problem that our CHRISTIAN leaders in the Salvation Army do not treat people with compassion or consideration. There are too many examples of hurt people for it to be a passing problem. Christian service is fraught with satanic attacks whenever the Holy Spirit is at work, and officers in the front line are caught up in it, and sometimes need encouragement to carry on. We are not dealing with earthly things - the Bible says we fight against demonic powers, and these are increasing daily as the world hurtles into secularism and a global anti-christian agenda. To the person who wrote this terse, unsympathetic comment - do you not think there is anything amiss at leadership level when dealing with HR matters? Just look at the long list of 'formers'. There is no doubt that some of these people could have stayed within officer service if they could have spoken reasonably to their leaders in the spirit of Barnabas, and their problems worked out according to the methods used in the New Testament early church.