INTRODUCTION
– Respect for, and the dignity of all persons
“Kantian
ethics provides a philosophical basis for moral pronouncement.”
And the
FSAOF believes that individuals, leaders and all others in the Salvation Army
with a wide range of theoretical commitments can and should recognize Kant’s
arguments concerning respect for persons.
In Kant’s
words:
“Humanity itself is a dignity; for a man cannot be used
merely as a means by any man… But must always be used at the same as an end. It
is just in this that is dignity…. consists, by which he raises himself above
all other beings in the world that are not men and yet can be used, and so over
all things.”
Kant argues
that respecting people means that we cannot be indifferent to them and their
needs. Indifference is a denial of respect. We have an obligation to be
concerned with the physical welfare and their spiritual well-being.
Although
there is a formatted streamlined exit policy outlined in IHQ O&R and
personnel manuals there is room for interpretation at the local level. The
question then becomes: is there a consistency in how the process is enacted and
the level of aftercare that’s offered? Surveys conducted by the FSAOF reveal
that most officers believe that they were not provided sufficient information
and/or support to enable them to process themselves and their family into an
acceptable living standard on their separation from officership. And the
disparity in after-care was evident in the assistance offered when my then wife
and I resigned on our separation and eventual divorce. (will be shared in a
future article)
Perhaps the
most obvious dismissal of an officer’s respect, value and dignity is the total
absence of a professionally conducted exit interview. Those who resign or are dismissed are
provided a poignant written pronouncement that a dis-connect between then and
their ‘SA Covenant’ is imminent and that any expected high level of care and
concern is over. It consists of a preformatted letter from THQ in which
officers are told of the Army’s appreciation for ‘your 2, 6, 11 or 311 years of
service’ – fill in the blanks- , immediately followed by the perfunctory
reminders that healthcare will cease (USA) at the end of the month, to turn in
all SA identification cards, car and office keys, clean your quarters in time
for the inspection next Thursday, and “not to in any way represent yourselves as
SA Officers”. Sadly there is nothing encouraging one to stay connected with the
Army as potential soldiers, no offer of counsel or advice to assist in the
financial, emotional, practical, and spiritual transition…. And promises of
prayer support or the intent to stay in touch are all too soon forgotten.
‘This
cultural weakness goes back to the very roots of the Army with Booth’s
treatment of his own family when they became some of the first ‘Formers’. They
were literally ex-communicated by their own father. They remained faithful to
God’s call and enjoyed incredible ministry outside the Army like many of
today’s Formers…and I am sure God used the experience gained from The Salvation
Army. When William Booth's children (well, three of them), decided that the SA
was not for them, Booth cut them off completely. No contact, no love, no
inheritance - they were even banned from family occasions such as funerals and
weddings.
Basically,
Booth was a despot, and that sort of thinking is still ingrained on the Army's
psyche. To leave the ranks was seen by
Booth and Bramwell as an act of betrayal for which there could be no
forgiveness and no way back.
Sadly, things haven't changed much in 150
years.
’
Former
UKT
**********
Right from early days the SA has operated a revolving door policy with people being expendable. In percentage terms to membership, the world-wide SA must have trained more people for full time ministry than any other church denomination on earth, and also lost the most for one reason or another. We hear usually only one side of any story - the aggrieved former officer one - and then only what such good people want you and me to hear. What we also have to realise is that as there are people who move on and move out by conviction and are released as such - on the other hand, many former officers who say they have resigned by choice, they have only had a choice of resigning themselves or being dismissed for misconduct and/or blatant betrayal of trust. - I dare to say that with some of the 1,000+ FSAOF members, the SA has been very patient and generous in spite of many ‘formers’ never being able to return to officer rank because of for various betrayal issues. How much after care is sufficient? For some nothing will be good enough as they have lost their ministry and living somehow. In my medium sized UKT corps I have got 14 soldiers who are former officers - some elderly others not so - all lovely and helpful folks with no real axe to grind, this is largely because they have moved on from the past.
Right from early days the SA has operated a revolving door policy with people being expendable. In percentage terms to membership, the world-wide SA must have trained more people for full time ministry than any other church denomination on earth, and also lost the most for one reason or another. We hear usually only one side of any story - the aggrieved former officer one - and then only what such good people want you and me to hear. What we also have to realise is that as there are people who move on and move out by conviction and are released as such - on the other hand, many former officers who say they have resigned by choice, they have only had a choice of resigning themselves or being dismissed for misconduct and/or blatant betrayal of trust. - I dare to say that with some of the 1,000+ FSAOF members, the SA has been very patient and generous in spite of many ‘formers’ never being able to return to officer rank because of for various betrayal issues. How much after care is sufficient? For some nothing will be good enough as they have lost their ministry and living somehow. In my medium sized UKT corps I have got 14 soldiers who are former officers - some elderly others not so - all lovely and helpful folks with no real axe to grind, this is largely because they have moved on from the past.
One married
couple in particular has every reason to be aggrieved with the way they were
basically dismissed with only a couple of years to go to retirement and thus
forfeiting, for example, pension rights build up over nearly 40 years service
each. Harsh? Yes it sure is.... I have only heard a little part of their story
though!
I think DHQ
and THQ personnel should be given a little more credit for caring and often
bending over backwards to accommodate officer' personal circumstances -
sometimes at a real cost to other officers.
Just a
thought..... how much aftercare do we as corps officers give former soldiers
who for one reason or another have gone through a revolving door and left the
fellowship?
A strongly paternalistic movement that is ruled by International
O&R's (with local discretions allowed) has very little leeway but to apply
these to the letter, may it be done with divine grace!
Every
blessing to you and the FSAOF in your ministry...
Active officer UKTI
_______________________
Tomorrow
August 10 : The Exit Interview





1 comment:
"It’s hard to imagine the freedom we find from the things we leave behind." - used by Colonel Henry Gariepy in an article in the FSAOF blog - But I believe the quote came from a the Christian song writer/composer Michael Card. I will be using it in the new FSA0F blog banner.
Post a Comment