Friday, July 12, 2013

The Great Physician's African Bush Apprentice


Every goal begins with a dream…

It has often been said that missionary doctors have a special calling – a voice from God guiding their desire to serve. 

When Paul Thistle was asked when he first realized that he wanted to be a missionary doctor, his natural humour came into play.  “As a boy growing up in Scarborough, canvassing for The Scarborough Mirror, I would never have forecast the signs. ‘Beware of Dog’ was the only sign to look out for. I did not know what to expect. Life is like the road at Karanda Hospital, a washed-out road of twists and turns, with unexpected pot holes. You cannot see what’s around the bend.”  He had no way of knowing that his “wildest dream” would land him “in the wilds of Zimbabwe”.

Dr. Paul Thistle’s calling came in 1981, the year he turned eighteen, while attending Urbana Inter-Denominational Missions Conference.  The call was a need for medical missionaries, especially where the health of mothers and children were concerned and he knew that he wanted to fill that need and make this his life’s work.

It helped that he was fond of study and good at math and, as an added incentive, had the encouragement of a staff of dedicated teachers in a caring community.  As he recalls, his days spent at David and Mary Thomson Collegiate in Scarborough were “great formative years, where we could excel beyond our wildest dreams and expectations. The Thomson spirit was such that kids from middle class families in Scarborough could reach for the stars”.  

After high school graduation, Paul was off to the University of Toronto to begin medical studies.  He earned his medical degree (M.D.) in 1989 and completed further training in his elected specialty, Obstetrics and Gynecology.

During this time, he made his first foray into overseas medical work as a summer student by electing to serve as a Salvation Army volunteer.  His first experience in the summer of l985 took him to an Afghan refugee camp in Pakistan during the Afghan-Russian conflict.  This was followed by three summers (1987, 1988, and 1989) working at a rural Salvation Army hospital in East Java, Indonesia.

In 1995, at the peak of the HIV/AIDS pandemic in sub-Saharan Africa he accepted a position at the Salvation Army Howard Hospital in Zimbabwe, 80 kilometres north of the capital, Harare. He loved the work, providing all-too-rare health care to the local communities. He became the chief medical officer in 1999.

As part of a team of several physicians and a handful of nurses, Paul provided physical, social and spiritual care to over 270,000 people in rural Zimbabwe.  300 people a day sought assistance on the hospital’s doorsteps, not including the thousands served by the community outreach programs. 



The sheer volume of needy people placed huge demands upon Howard Hospital’s scarce resources, whose operating budget was one percent of a similar size institution in North America.  The miracle of the loaves and fishes was enacted daily.    

In 1998, he married Pedrinah, a nurse-midwife who worked alongside Paul at the hospital, assisting in surgery and training nurses and midwifes.  Two sons, James and Alexander were added to the family, James in 2001 and Alexander in 2004.

In 2005, Paul and Pedrinah were invited to become Salvation Army Officers.  It was a natural fit, since the work they had been doing was typical of an officer’s duty, and then some.  This involved attending Booth University College, and the officer-training facility in Winnipeg, Manitoba.  They completed their training in 2007 and were commissioned as officers, with the rank of Captain.  

Paul’s decision to become an officer had deeper, spiritual meaning: “The challenges and achievements of providing medical and spiritual care to an underprivileged corner of God’s kingdom have promoted maturity in my Christian witness.  God had called me to commit my life to full time Christian service.   The desire to become a Salvation Army officer was an extension... a gradual, natural extension of this calling. I have always believed that a commitment to Christ must be wholehearted.  Salvation Army soldiership is a sincere, enthusiastic expression of Christian commitment” 

His first exposure to Christianity began at the age of 10 when he was invited to attend Sunday School at a neighbourhood evangelical church.  Several years later, as a young person still searching for value and purpose in life, he was prompted by the HoIy Spirit to ‘check out’ the Army.  When he walked into the Salvation Army corps in Scarborough for the first time, he was positively influenced by Sunday school classmates and teachers to make a decision for Jesus Christ.  

As he explains, his work made his ministry rewarding, “with fulfillment in the little tasks of our mission at Howard:   a mother saved in childbirth, a malnourished infant restored to health, an adult living with HIV counseled on healthy living.  The axiom I was taught in medical school remains true, ‘cure sometimes, comfort always.’
Despite the huge challenges of missionary service, his faith remains strong “by taking moments for reflection, prayer, Bible study, even when the demands of work forbid it.  Add the support of godly wife, faithful friends around the globe, and a great cloud of witness above.” 

Asked what keeps him grounded and committed, he replies:  “Commitment to and perseverance in the task at hand, using the resources of the Holy Spirit to sustain me during the darker days.  Goodness can spring out of the most desperate situation. Joy will find a way.”

Tina Ivany
Toronto
All photos courtesy: © Douglas MACLELLAN |Copyright 2013. Douglas MacLellan. All rights reserved.

18 comments:

Anonymous said...

The dismissal of Captain Paul Thistle, the only qualified surgeon at Howard Hospital was a result of his questioning his superiors about financial and equipment donations earmarked by friends and private donors for HH that were never received.

Every missionary worth their salt works harder than their counterpart at 'home' and with challenges others can't fathom. It's the 'private' support that makes the difference. The in-house book keeper's vision is controlled by ledgers, the missionaries' by the needs of those they're called to serve.

Many Salvationists, soldiers and officers, are expressing the solidarity with Dr. Paul by attending their corps out of uniform. The SA's integrity has been compromised and our colours sullied!

former officer - SA missionary UK

Anonymous said...

Why hasn't the true story of Dr. Thistle's removal been made public?

Speaking for the thousands of Salvationist being patronised and kept in darkest England! C'mon FSAOF lead us out!

Rathcliffe Highway
East London

Anonymous said...

There is a need for repentance at our highest levels over this one.

TSA can change this decision if they have the will to make right what went wrong. It is never too late, and instead of a sullied reputation they would regain respect.

What will it take to make them realize they cannot continue doing business as usual any longer? For many this is the last straw and it will break the camel's back. No more loyalty to such leadership who demonstrate such lack of caring for the poor people of Chiweshe and who persist in not retracting a decision which has caused loved ones to die.

Canadian territory

Anonymous said...

An aside: How ironic - Major Dean Pallant's book title - "Keeping Faith in Faith-Based Organisations"
LOL!!

Standing in the present and looking ahead, is this whole discussion going to affect anything moving forward?

Some people in Canada are highlighting this situation among soldiery by removing their uniforms - both soldiers and some retired officers are doing this. The intention of this action is to make leadership aware that increasing numbers of Salvationists are hearing about this debacle and it cannot be swept under the rug. This visual action is also a statement to leadership that Salvationists are very unhappy about all this and have lost confidence in our leadership as an organization/church.

I know some who have highlighted this by walking with their feet right out of the Army, perhaps permanently.

Social media plays a big role in these times and just last evening a young Canadian man, brought up in the Army, sent out to 100's of Facebook friends - mainly to young peers, notice of the discussion on this website, with his own comment that until reading the discussion here, he had heard nothing about this debacle. He went on to say we are the only Army that repeatedly shoots its own soldiers in the feet - how true that friendly fire casualties happen far too often.

Some Salvationists have stopped giving to Partners in Mission until something is done to change the tithe system as money goes through various HQ's, and certainly outside donors have stopped with significant donations to the HH because they have lost confidence in the Army's leadership.

As to what can be done taking this forward?
1. I ask that at the upcoming High Council, Commissioners and territorial leaders discuss this debacle and question nominees for the General on what they would do going forward to both rectify past wrongs and prevent future situations like this.
2. I ask that leadership repent of this particular situation and then at the very least, the new General authorize IHQ to acknowledge a tragic error was made, by officially and publicly apologizing in writing to the community of Chiweshe for leaving them with no surgeon for a year (and likely longer), resulting in loss of lives and very compromised health care.
3. An apology to the Thistle's would also be in order from IHQ, for allowing Com. Chigariro to order them out of their appointment in 24 hours with a 48 hour deportation order, causing Dr. Thistle to break his solemn oath as a Dr. by forcing him to abandon his patients without an adequate replacement.

Should Dr. Thistle also be offered back his position as CMO of HH? Of course - perhaps as an employee since they terminated his officership. That would be rectifying a wrong of the past. Can it be done a year later? Yes, if there's a will to make some form of restitution, but acknowledgement of error is the first step. He could even be invited to train the new incoming Dr. from Sweden and they could work together.

Do I think any of these things will actually happen? Nope, but I see it as the way forward for the Army's leadership to re-gain lost respect and confidence, if at the very least they were to do #1,2, and 3 outlined above.

Canada

Anonymous said...

To Canada

Dream on! I live in the UK, and we have heard nothing at all about this sad episode - we are still bewildered about the General's mysterious departure. I can't see it popping up in the War Cry or Salvationist publications any time soon - the General only warranted an 'aside' on page 2. So I don't see the UK Soldiery becoming aware of it - who would tell us, and how?

UK Soldier

Anonymous said...

U K Soldier, I understand where you are coming from. I only discovered a few days ago the reason for Commissioner Henry Mapp's court-martial when he was Eva Booth's Chief of Staff. It seems to take a long time for the secrecy veil to lift!

Anonymous said...

Might I suggest that the letter posted by Canada be copied and sent to every TC ? It would make compelling reading as they wing their way to the Heathrow Renaissance !

Anonymous said...

So, Murray's ability to spin tales about the Christmas swindle earns him a promotion? And now the spinmeister's doing it from London.

May we suggest you visit the FSAOF blog to double check the double talk being fed you at IHQ! It's what we call 'speaking with forked tongue' in the west,

Former on Wabash

Anonymous said...

I was also thinking of a letter campaign - but maybe more personal letters sent to the hotel for when the officers arrive. If lots of people would do perhaps the chief of staff, their own TC and one or two others at random everyone should get a few, hopefully with Stamps from a few different countries to highlight the fact that the secret IS NOW OUT!

FORMER UKT










ly with stamps from several f

Anonymous said...

Excellent idea to bombard our TC's and the CoS with letters, prior to the High Council - copy and paste mine above if you wish and sign your names to it, or even send group letters petitioning for these things to happen at the High Council.

Like I said, I expect nothing to happen but I believe, like theologian Paul Tillich, that we have an ethical and Christian responsibility to speak up against what institutions are doing, for to not do so, is to be complicit in their actions. These institutions are often the very ones that have supported and nurtured us, but the course of all institutions is to go this way, and people of conscience must speak out and in our case 'up' to the hierarchy of TSA.

Canada

Anonymous said...

I'm not sure of the effectiveness of sending letters to TCs and the CoS - aren't these the people who have allegedly been lacking in honesty/clarity so far? Do you think they would inform the people lower own the pecking order? Can't see it myself.

UK Soldier

Anonymous said...

Oops - typo! 'own' should read 'down'.

UK Soldier

Anonymous said...

UK soldier, surely there are a good percentage of strong and honest people in leadership who won't be compromised regardless of where the pressure comes from!

If not, what's left to invest in ?

No uniform this Sunday for me- 1st time in 45 years...

Anonymous said...

To Anonymous (no uniform this Sunday) - watch with interest the reaction of your co-worshippers to your 'no uniform' stance - I had a real eye-opener when I couldn't wear mine because of a (temporary) medical condition. Despite faithful service over many years, you'd swear the gates of hell had opened up and swallowed me whole!

UK Soldier

Anonymous said...

Too hot for uniform any way! Seriously, what are you trying to achieve by this protest? What next? Stopping your personal giving to your fellowship in protest? Is that not what people usually do when in disagreement? And then just slip away into oblivion through the backdoor?

Surely there must be a better and more dignified way!

Blessings

Anonymous said...

Former UKT, the fact that this debacle is not widely known does not mean that it is a closely guarded secret!

Anonymous said...

What would you suggest would be a more dignified way Brother Blessings? Is the uniform now considered the badge of being a Christian? What does that say about the increasing number of Salvationists who choose not to wear uniform?

Anonymous said...

I agree - anyway, SA uniform is increasingly becoming a 'blast from the past'. It's frumpish, and unless you have the perfect figure (male AND female) it looks awful. I don't think anyone would buy a 'suit' like it if they had to choose it. Summer uniform is even worse - it highlights the flab of those who ARE flabby, and it's not, in my opinion, very edifying. It highlights that very few of us make any conscious effort to take on board the biblical truth that our bodies are the temple of the Holy Spirit - overindulgence is much in evidence. I went to an Army roadshow recently, and they are supplying much larger sizes than they used to!!! It also highlights the ageing nature of TSA membership - there are few younger people willing to subject themselves to this uncomfortable set of clothes. And increasingly, youth events run by TSA do not feature uniform at all, either by leaders or those who attend meetings.
Of course, there are a lot of soldiers who DO look smart in uniform, but I have to ask myself what relevance it has in today's society? It looks so out of touch, and not a lot of people know what it stands for any more. The ladies hat is all but obsolete, and I don't see too many men wearing caps either.
Sorry - this is just a personal 'rant' -nothing to do with the subject of the Thistles and their painful situation. I realise there are far more important things to comment on. I just saw 'uniform' and went nuts. Just humour me for today. Probably too much sun! Thank you.

Malcontent uniformed soldier, UK territory.