I thought we just needed to try harder. Maybe
we needed to focus more on loving the sinner, and less on protesting his sin.
But I’m done. I can’t look my gay brother in the
eye anymore and say “I love the sinner but hate the sin.”
I can’t keep drawing circles in the sand.
Even if I was able to fully live up to that ideal,
I’d still be wrong. I’d still be assigning him an identity, viewing him as
something other, something different. - Not human. Not friend. Not Christian. Not
brother.
Sinner.
And despite all my theological disclaimers about
how I’m just as much a sinner too, it’s not the same. We don’t use that phrase for
everybody else. Only them. Only “the gays”. That’s the only place where we make
“sinner” the all-encompassing identity.
Then we try to reach them, to evangelize them. We
speak of “the gays” in words reminiscent of the “uncivilized headhunters” from those
epic missionary stories – foreign and different and far away, the ultimate conquest
for the church to tame and colonize and save. Maybe we accept them in our midst.
But even then, it’s sinners in our midst – branded with a rainbow-colored scarlet
letter. They aren’t truly part of us.
Even that word “them” makes me cringe as I speak
it, as if my brothers and sisters are somehow other, different from me.
It’s a special sort of condescending love we’ve reserved
for the gay community. We’ll agree to love them, accept them, welcome them – but
we reserve the right to see them as different. We reserve the right to say “them”
instead of “us”. We embrace them with arms full of disclaimers about how all the
sinners are welcome here. And yet, they’re the only ones we constantly remind of
their status as sinners, welcome sinners.
In all this, we turn our backs on all the gay brothers
and sisters already in our church, already saved, already following Jesus. Our us
vs. them narrative leaves little space for those who didn’t choose to be gay but
did choose to follow Jesus. Using “gay” and “sinner” interchangeably, we force them
away from the Table and into the shadows.
__________________________
They say Jesus was a friend of sinners, but he didn’t
describe himself that
way. His motto wasn’t “eating and drinking with
prostitutes and tax collectors.” Those were the labels used by the religious community,
by the disapproving onlookers. What’s amazing about Jesus is that when he hung out
with sinners, he didn’t act like they were sinners. They were just his friends.
People with names. Defined as beloved children of the Creator, not defined by their
sins. Icons of God’s image. His brothers and sisters.
It was the Pharisees who looked at them and scrawled
“sinner” on their foreheads. It was the accusers who drew circles in the sand with
themselves on the inside and “those sinners” on the outside.
Those words, “a friend of sinners”, were spoken with
an upturned nose and a self-righteous sneer. And that’s the same phrase the church
has adopted to speak of our own brothers and sisters – “Love the sinner, hate the
sin.”
It’s the same self-righteous sneer heard in the words
of those who dragged the woman caught in adultery to Jesus: “What should we do with
such a woman?” They defined her by a moment. She was “one of those”. Not a sister.
Not a human. Just a pawn in a political debate. A sinner.
But Jesus knelt with her in the sand. Unafraid to
get dirty. Unafraid to affirm her humanity. “Neither do I condemn you, go and sin
no more.”
He could have said “You’re a sinner, but I love you
anyways.” But she knew she was a sinner. Those voices were loud and near and they
held rocks above her head.
Jesus refused to let his voice join theirs. By
telling her “go and sin no more”, he affirmed that sin is not her deepest identity.
It’s not how he saw her. It’s not who she was at the core of the being.
__________________________
I am a sinner.
But before I was a sinner, I was created in the image
of God. While sin has twisted and smudged that image, it can’t erase it. Sin,
my sin, is so terrible that it killed Jesus. But it doesn’t define me any longer.
I am a new creation.
Because of Jesus, “sinner” is not how God sees me.
It’s not how I see myself. And it shouldn’t be how I see my brothers and sisters
in the church.
There is no condemnation for those who are in Jesus.
To look at my gay Christian brother and say “God loves the sinner” is to set myself
against Jesus and bring condemnation again to those he’s already redeemed.
So I’m done.
I’m done with “Love the sinner, but hate the sin.”
I won’t say it anymore.
I’m done with speaking as if I’m different, better
than you.
I’m not going to define anyone by their sin. That’s
not my identity. It’s not yours.
We are icons. We are children of the Creator, redeemed
by Jesus. We are brothers and sisters. And today, that’s enough.
I’m indebted to Pastor Jonathan
at Renovatus for his teachings on Jesus and the women of the Bible. See “Everything I’ve
Ever Done.”
Micah J. Murray

18 comments:
Love this!
I also like this post and it gets sort of at what I tried to say previously in another comment. Let's be silent and both sides stop talking about this.
Gluttony is a sin and we don't go up to fat over-eaters and say I love you, but hate your sin of over-eating.
However, Jesus did say to the woman found in sexual sin, "Go and sin no more". That,perhaps, can be said by the Lord but can we as disciples say that to each other? Am I prepared to say to every glutton - go and sin no more, or to every gossiper - go and sin no more. Perhaps if we can't say that to other sins, we shouldn't be saying it just to homosexuals either.
I really think people on both sides of this discussion get very hurt by these discussions and certain things are just better left unsaid. God will be the judge and will judge in perfect justice.
Canada
This article is very one-sided, as if 'straight' people hate 'gay' people (and shouldn't, obviously). But in a previous article, the 'son and product of the regiment' said this: 'I have been accused, much to my chagrin, in the past of being ‘straight-acting.’ Why does he experience 'chagrin' that he looks 'straight'? What's wrong with looking 'straight'? It's what the majority of the population are.
The writer refers to a 'rainbow-coloured scarlet letter'. It's all rather flowery. Scarlet is red - not rainbow-coloured, not even with the related 'gay' meaning for 'rainbow'. I have to say the phrase means nothing to me. The writer also says about Jesus hanging out with sinners. These meetings weren't social events - Jesus was with sinners and prostitutes because He was trying to win them for the Kingdom. He told the prostitute 'go and sin no more'. Carrying on with her usual lifestyle wasn't an option for Jesus.
I think this article is much too simplistic - the reality is much more complex, but I'm sure it's made the GLBT sector feel good.
Salvationist in UK Territory
Salvationist in UK Territory- There are two reasons "stright acting" is a slur. Firstly, because acting as something you are not is hypocrisy. Secondly, straight acting also implies there is only one "expression" of homosexuality, and there isn'. Homosexual people are as diverse and interesting as heterosexual people.
'They say Jesus was a friend of sinners, but he didn’t describe himself that way. His motto wasn’t “eating and drinking with prostitutes and tax collectors.” Those were the labels used by the religious community, by the disapproving onlookers. What’s amazing about Jesus is that when he hung out with sinners, he didn’t act like they were sinners. They were just his friends. People with names. Defined as beloved children of the Creator, not defined by their sins. Icons of God’s image. His brothers and sisters.'
A profound reminder of the Saviour's instructions. Simple yes, but far from simplistic!
Excellent series so far.
Salvationist
Sydney
I'm indebted to you for this fine series on Gay and Lesbian issues. It's opened my eyes.
I've blindly followed the political correctness push and simply been swept along like a mindless victim!
Like every other liberal invention, whoever dared to oppose political correctness was called intolerant and bigoted.
Time for me to speak out; Same sex marriage - rubbish! Same sex unions only after traditional type religious pre-wedding counseling.
SA officer
Anonymous from Canada -
I understand what you say about these discussions causing hurt for people on both sides. However, I really need to remind you that conservatives are hurt on this subject only when the discussion takes place. GLBT's are hurt EVERY SINGLE DAY and EVERY SINGLE MINUTE that they are not included in the fellowship. Every day, GLBT's are reminded that they are less than, that they are sub-human, that they are excluded. These discussions need to happen so that 'straights' might get a glimpse into the issues and feelings etc. I would agree with you that both sides need to be silent in the debate, IF and only IF there is full inclusion within the church - including ordination and same sex marriage. Until then, these discussions MUST happen so that 'straights' can understand how hurt GLBT's are just because they exist.
Yours in Christ,
Graeme Randall
Former Australian East in London
Thank God there are SA Officers out there who oppose this liberal minded thinking. I was beginning to despair. We live in a victim culture for sure - I am convicted of my sins every day, maybe not every single minute - that's a bit of an exaggeration, even for GLBTs I would think - and that's why I pray to God for forgiveness for my sins - every day. There is not much said in these articles about the sordid side to being gay, which results in disease and death, and innocent people are also caught up in its wake through no fault of their own. It cannot, in my opinion, be of God. Many people have left the GLBT lifestyle - if it's so wonderful, why would they even want to leave it behind? I cannot accept that it isn't a sin - alongside all other sins, yes - and it doesn't prevent me being compassionate - but marriage? Same sex unions? How does legitimising something make it all right? Statistics show that over 80% of HIV/AIDS cases originate through homosexuality and bisexuality. How can this be God-honouring or originate from a loving God who only wants the best for His children? I would like to read an article by someone who used to belong to this fraternity. This is a good series, but it's hardly balanced.
UK Salvationist
UK Salvationist - your suggestion that the series is unbalanced is unfair if directed to the FSAOF.
None of the articles in this current series have been solicited. Consequently, we depend totally on articles submitted to us for posting. None have been received from "someone who used to belong to this fraternity" or sorority. We welcome such articles but need them in our files by July 5 for inclusion in the series. If not received in time we'll file them for future use.
A quick update- the SA Cadets in Chicago took to the streets again to share free water with the thousands who celebrated Gay Pride Day.
UK Salvationist -
Please point us to any other SA linked blog that has made an attempt similar to our in addressing the LGBT issues? There isn't any!
Ours is the only one current enough to do so and who welcomes LGBT persons openly and in a Christian spirit of love.
Do some diligent research and get back to us please.
Long time proud FSAOF member and blog supporter.
US East
To Graeme Randall - Jesus according to the record was silent on the issue of homosexuality but did describe marriage as between one man and one woman and upheld the OT view of marriage in Matthew 19. I think His recorded words in verses 11 and 12 are significant - "not everyone can accept this statement, only those whom God helps. Some are born as eunuchs, some have been made that way by others, and some choose not to marry for the sake of the Kingdom of Heaven. Let anyone who can, accept this statement."
I think that's what Christian LGBT people have to do by God's grace. They have to accept that Jesus viewed marriage the OT way, between a man and a woman and regardless of how people were born or how nurture made them, this is Jesus's words about marriage.
Sorry Graeme, my heart breaks for you as it does for any people who have to accept things in life that they cannot change. But I do believe God walks beside us in the most difficult of life's circumstances. My heart equally breaks for many single Christian women who have never had the opportunity of marriage and children. My heart breaks for people with many forms of incapacities, but God can help us deal with whatever our circumstances are, even though those circumstances may never change. I'm always struck by the OT story of Mephibosheth with the crippled feet and the end of his story is bluntly - his feet were still crippled. Life is not fair and being born different from the norm in many ways is frustrating, hurtful and agonizing. But a shining testimony is to be able to live with whatever is one's situation, and to learn to be content in all things by God's grace.
Canada
Canada - well said and put most eloquently. Sums it all up in a nutshell. Thank you.
Sven - my contribution was not meant as a criticism of the FSAOF - it was merely an observation that the articles seem to be mainly from a 'pro-gay lifestyle' viewpoint, whether by gay people themselves, or by people who support them in their lifestyle choice. I appreciate that you can't 'magic' articles from nowhere.
UK Salvationist
Anonymous (Canada) I think the issue is there are people of good faith and compassion who see marriage as restricted biblically to between one man and one woman and people of good faith and compassion who don't. It turns on what you believe about understanding the bible in its context. Leaving aside marriage and faithful, long tern, monogamous relationships, and any physical expression of sexuality., gay people are gay. Yes there are some who "pass" as straight, but there is no peer reviewed research which demonstrates the possibility of becoming straight. And therein lies the problem because it is simply impossible in many churches to acknowledge you are gay without someone (a) assuming you are promiscuous and (b) assuming you need to become "straight" the damage done to the partner of gay people who marry at the church's direction to "overcome" their homosexuality is devastating. Graeme's point is being gay is not a sin, but we dod need to work out how to live our lives within the gospel, and we need to have honest conversations about that some of which are uncomfortable and challenging for all concerned.
I accept that gay people for some reason are attracted to the same sex either innately or by nurture or a combination of both and as I said before it must be so hurtful, frustrating and agnonizing to realize you live with a circumstance which you cannot change. But, since Jesus defined the marriage relationship, supporting the OT view of one woman and one man, I don't think any Christians gay or straight can re-define that. According to the written record, Jesus Himself acknowledged this teaching about marriage is difficult for some to accept, and He even says for some they can only accept it with God's help. He refers to realities that cannot be changed , but these realities do not change his teaching about marriage. So as I see it all Christians by God's grace, have to accept this teaching, whether they be heterosexual single women or LGBT Christians.
My heart breaks for all people whose unchangeable life's circumstances deprive them of the experience of marriage and family. How hard it is for heterosexual single women who see their biological clock ticking away without ever knowing the experience of giving birth. I'm sure we all have many questions to ask God someday when we see face to face.
Canada
I agree wholeheartedly with the writer from Canada. God is perfect - his plan for the human race is perfect - He has given us the Ten Commandments as a blueprint for our lives. We have all broken them - none of us is perfect. But He also gave us other guidelines by which to live, and His marriage definition is one of them. (I know there are others, but this site is devoted to GLBT issues, so I won't explore the others). We re-interpret God's Word to suit our circumstances at our peril. The verses in Genesis are crystal clear - it was Adam and Eve, not two people of the same sex. He made our male/female bodies to fit together in the marriage relationship. Children are a natural result of this union, to fulfil His word to 'be fruitful and multiply'. This is naturally impossible in a gay/lesbian relationship. You don't have to try to interpret any other Bible passages or say Jesus did not mention homosexuality in the Bible, or any of the other arguments already mentioned - the truth in Genesis is incontrovertible - only male/female relationships in God's blueprint can keep the human race going - GLBT relationships are physically sterile - there is no 'next generation' to be had from within these same sex unions. Like the previous writer, I too feel sorry for those who are caught up in this lifestyle, but obedience to God and His word bring blessings without measure.
UK
I think I need to point out that there are far more passages that talks in favour of things that we allow today - that if we were to accept the biblical teaching on those issues, we would all be appalled and would all leave the faith. Things like slavery, mixed-race marriage, polygamy, peadophilia, genocide, etc etc, etc. The point is, we have contextualised these issues, and have read those passages as historical perspective that don't apply to us - that gives us an understanding of the journey that people of God have trod to come to where we are today. Why is the GLBT issue any different? There is considerably far less teaching on this subject than any of those others.
As to disease etc. Please, do a bit of research. HIV has actually been around for a VERY long time. Do a bit more research, and you will discover that worldwide, it is actually more prevalent in heterosexuals than the GLBT community. Do a bit more research, and you will discover that the vast majority of those who have been recorded as dying from HIV/AIDS, have actually died from Hep C infections as they were co-diagnosed. In fact, until the late 1990's, the only way to 100% confirm with blood test that you had HIV was if you also had Hep C and had an unusual test result. In the late 1990's, they discovered people with HIV who had been positive for 20-30 years without any symptoms. Likewise today, most 'new' diagnosis in people over 50 are thought to have contracted it when they were in their 20's. HIV/AIDS does not lead to death as many believe. It has been in the Heterosexual population probably longer than it has in the homosexual population - particularly when you look at symptomotology of patients with various diseases over the years. In fact, there are detailed descriptions of people in ancient Roman times (before Julius Caesar), who showed the exact symptoms one would expect who had HIV/AIDS and some other terminal illness.
Please do some research before you start casting aspersions against a group of people.
Yours in Christ,
Graeme Randall
Former Australian East in London.
To Graeme Randall
The only part of your response that relates to my posting is when you talk about historically contextualizing issues. I am actually not a conservative fundamentalist in my approach to scripture, and thank you for challenging me to take the issues you have listed to see why I contextualize those and not the teaching on marriage.
Generally speaking I think we contextualize when another teaching of the Bible over-rides something at issue, and as I see it, nothing in scripture over-rides the teaching about the nature of marriage. If I may discuss the issues in particular which you have raised:
slavery - this is very different from the LGBT issue and many black people are offended by the comparison. Gay people say they are born gay and it is an unchangeable thing. People are not innately slaves. There was good reason to contextualize the cultural belief in slavery because in scripture it is superceded by a greater belief that all people are created in the image of God. The life circumstances of slavery can be changed to give the lives of slaves equality. But some of life's circumstances cannot be changed and I accept that the reality of being gay may very well be one of those circumstances. As Jesus pointed out, unchangeable realities make the teaching about marriage very difficult to accept.
The other topics you mention -
mixed-race marriage - does scripture say anything about this? I don't think so therefore it became a non-issue
polygamy - obviously practiced by people of God in the OT, but not God's ideal, and not defined and supported as an option for marriage by Jesus
peadophilia - to my knowledge never sanctioned in scripture, and over-riding seems to be that harming a child is serious business
Genocide - the slaughter of the Canaanites appears to be genocide sanctioned by God, but an over-riding biblical teaching calls for historical contextualization - Thou shalt not kill.
However, Graeme, there is no over-riding teaching about marriage that would lead to contextualization of the Biblical teaching about the nature of marriage. Realities of existing circumstances or changing cultural norms are not alone what leads to historical contextualization. There also has to be an over-riding Biblical principle at stake and there is no such over-riding teaching about the nature of marriage.
I totally agree that the unchangeable life circumstances that one is born with is not sin, so having a heterosexual or LGBT orientation is not sin. But crossing God's boundaries, including boundaries for sexual behaviour, is sin, and there seems to be no justification for historically contextualizing the teaching about marriage boundaries and sexual behaviour.
I like what Jesus says that this teaching some cannot accept, except by God's help. I somtimes wish for gay people that this teaching were not so, but I can find no justification for historically contextualizing it. I will pray Graeme that as Jesus said, by God's help, you personally may find peace in accepting this very difficult teaching about marriage.
Canada
How can one then continue to love and a revere a God who allows a child to be born gay? I love a child who has recently come out. A child who has been raised as a faithful follower of Christ, who has been prayed for by many since conception and who was dedicated to God at 6 weeks of age. This child is so angry at God for not 'changing' him that he now wants to leave the church knowing it's hopeless and he will not be accepted. He has been told by the youth pastor that gay people are not welcome at youth group. My heart is broken.
Post a Comment