Thursday, July 18, 2013

The trail leads to Harare...


Major (Dr.) Jim Watt (R) wrote in response to questions focusing on Captain (Dr.) Paul Thistle’s dismissal as the Chief Medical Officer of the Howard  Hospital, Zimbabwe

“I'd like to answer two questions:”

On the "centage" question (SA administrative costs assessed when transferring funds), when things are working well, I have not found it to be a problem. Donors can understand that there are administrative costs, and are willing to pay if it guarantees that the donation arrives quickly, safely and is used appropriately. A delay just 30 days can affect the donation by 10% or more: fluctuating exchange rates and inflation.

For some years, we would get a list of donors from IHQ, and were able to write letters of thanks and send photos. The Salvation Army differs from World Vision in having a large number of indigenous officers at the front line. These have been invaluable in finding those most in need, distributing aid in emergencies and training their congregations in healthy living. A University study in 1974 showed that the key factor in development among peasant farmers was religion, with the Salvation Army and Seventh Day Adventist regions coming out on top. So key to our preventive programs were our officers, with their teaching that was Biblical and practical at the same time. The centage and the (then) Self-denial funds taken for supervision were well worth it. In fact, when World Vision worked in our area, much of the "volunteer" labour was done by SA Officers.

The second question is "What was unique with Dr. Thistle's situation?"

Following Independence from an oppressive white government, African leaders objected to anything smacking of white control. This perception and defiant attitude was very evident  at THQ Zimbabwe, where even auditors from IHQ, London were seen as neo-colonial. Both the International Secretary for Africa and the TC (Africans and who were very good friends with each other) felt this way, the former balking at any supervision of the building of the new Howard Hospital, and the latter insisting that all donations come over her desk, be spent as she wished, and not be accounted for. A $250,000 donation for Dr. Thistle's work was refused because the donors could not assent to these conditions. Donations had a habit of being delayed or disappearing altogether.

So more and more, Dr. Thistle had to rely on direct donations to keep the hospital going, often brought by hand by volunteers.

This could not be tolerated by the Territorial Commander, so she terminated the volunteer program (volunteer Doctors and Nurses from Zim and abroad) and set about to get a more pliable doctor in charge of Howard.

Without his knowledge, various charges were brought up against him at IHQ (I have a list) until, at the present time, Dr. Thistle has a very low reputation among IHQ and THQ officers. All this is in sharp contrast with the views of the Zimbabwe people at all levels, who think very highly of him. So when the TC asked for Dr. Thistle to be removed, the General consented and tasked the International Secretary Africa and TC to carry out the task, which they did in a vindictive way that was negligent in not providing (even a year later) a replacement for his skills.

I wrote the General at the time (August 15, 2012) warning her that this would result in deaths, with consequenses bordering on the criminal, but she refused to inquire into the veracity of what she had been told by the International Secretary for Africa.

I have seen a letter from the office of the International Secretary telling Paul to forget about his patients, forget about his nurses, "they are in God's hands now," something his medical ethics, let alone Christian ethics, would not allow him to do. It was an illegal and unethical order, and refusing to obey it cost him his officership.


A gag order has kept people ignorant of these things. Official reports continue to give glowing reports of the restoration of the hospital, while visitors are not allowed to see the wards -- last week there were 5 patients on female ward and 4 on male ward, while the two Zimbabwean doctors kept busy with private practice. Many are dying. Visiting donors have been refused permission to give SA schools fees for AIDS orphans -- they have to go through THQ.

That is what is unique about this situation, and so different from the Army I once knew. Compassion, honesty, transparency, Godliness -- core values are missing, replaced by a false "loyalty" that amounts to idolatry. I pray for our leaders.

Major (Dr) Jim Watt (R)
Former; Chief Medical Officer
Howard Hospital, Zimbabwe
___________________________________
The FSAOF welcomes articles relevant to the Howard Hospital debacle. Opposing views with supportive information and documents are most welcome.

7 comments:

Anonymous said...

A Zimbabwean woman whose sister had just given birth shared this story in a Zim newspaper -

"They made a 3-hour trip to receive treatment at Howard Hospital in Chiweshe (Mashonaland Central). For over 16 years, Dr. Paul Thistle and his medical team have provided advanced medical care in rural Zimbabwe. It is this care that draws villagers from all over the province, many from several hours away.

The typical fee to be seen in the hospital is two US dollars. Often patients do not have enough to pay, but they are never refused treatment.

FORMER SALVATION ARMY OFFICERS FELLOWSHIP said...

Excerpt from upcoming blog article-

Financially, the leadership must become accountable to the soldiers and to those who donate monies and materials. This accountability must be provided by means of external accounting and auditing firms. No longer is our internal accounting and auditing sufficient to answer questions. We must bring in external auditing to address our financial accountability.

Jolinda Cooper
Former Officer
USA Southern Territory

Anonymous said...

As a result of the deplorable decision making that resulted in this tragic situation, donors and some Salvationists who know what's gone on, have lost confidence in the leadership of TSA and have stopped giving financially to the Army.

The Rotarians who used to support Howard Hospital gave a large donation this year to Karanda Hospital where Dr. Paul Thistle is now a volunteer.

Despite all the consequences -
people still dying in Chiweshe for want of needed surgery, compromised health care, loss of confidence in the Army's leadership, the loss of a dedicated brilliant surgeon officer who has brought much glory to Christ and the Army, the exposure of corruption in high places - this debacle will NOT be discussed at the High Council apparently even within the context of how a future General might deal with this and future crises of this nature, and the persistent stories that all is well at the HH, is all that we hear from IHQ.

Incredible! May God help our leadership to discern the truth and to act rightly upon it.

Anonymous said...

31 May 2013 Herald Reporter
VP Mujuru hails mission hospitals Howard and Karanda Mission Hospitals in Mashonaland Central province for playing a critical role in providing treatment to Zimbabweans across the country. The two hospitals in Chiweshe and Mt Darwin are run by The Salvation Army and Evangelical Church respectively.

Acting President Mujuru, herself a Salvationist, made the remarks at the handover of comforters and shoes from a local manufacturing company, Waverley Blankets for distribution to people in her constituency. “I have a long request that I have been given by two hospitals that have done us wonders in this country,” said Acting President Mujuru.

“These are Howard Hospital which is under the Salvation Army church. Howard treats people from all over the country like Bikita, Masvingo and Bulawayo. We also have Karanda Hospital in Mt Darwin, they also treat people from all over. Again from Masvingo, from Gwanda, from everywhere.

“I am going to take them there because I want them to benefit not only people from my constituency, I want them to benefit Zimbabwe because every sick person who visits those hospitals benefits from their warmth.”

Acting President Mujuru hailed Waverley Blanket director, Mr Victor Cohen for his continued support in uplifting the lives of Zimbabweans.

The same company recently donated water purifiers, oral rehydration salts and blankets for distribution to the needy across the country’s provinces through Acting President Mujuru’s office.

A representative from Waverly Blankets, Mr Patrick Chiremba said the consignment worth about US$35 000 was meant to complement Acting President Mujuru’s efforts in uplifting lives of all communities.

Anonymous said...

One of the above blogs says 'this debacle will NOT be discussed at the High Council apparently even within the context of how a future General might deal with this and future crises of this nature...'
Future crises of this nature? Surely even TSA should be trying to stop the rot and not compounding it with future incompetency?
It beggars belief, and it pains me to say it, as I have always been proud to be a member of TSA, but maybe this shambles at the top is God's judgment on an incompetent organisation that has not brought glory to Him, the Kingdom, or the poor souls who have suffered at the hands of these people who are charged with serving 'suffering humanity'.
After all, it's not the first financial scandal that TSA has experienced, and if we haven't learned from those events, then God help us.
Tragic.

UK

Jolinda Cooper said...

The track record of handling of past crises, financial or not, is a sure indicator that there will be future crises. The Salvation Army rarely gets to the root of problems, instead chosing to sweep things under the rug and declare all is well. Too often, the focus of and direction from the leadership at all levels is on the outward appearances (statistics, high-profile connections, top-dollar donations) to the detriment of spiritual development, leadership development, and truly expanding the work of God.

Thankfully, there are some bright sparks in Army leadership. But it is tough for bright sparks to ignite wet blankets.

Anonymous said...

Most of us have not been to Zimbabwe and are relying on the reports of others. The question is who to believe? Always the information coming from the Army is totally different than reports coming to Canada from staff, from sources considered reliable in Zimbabwe, and from Zimbabwean news media.

However two non-Army people who have no conflict of interest, travelled to Zimbabwe - the free lance photographer whose photos the Army has often used in their periodicals, was denied entry to the compound by the Army, but he photographed and posted to the internet an empty scene at a normally crowded main gate. Also Dr. Fenton, who went to retrieve medical equipment as we read on this blog, was told by Major Dean Pallant not to wander around the hospital and was shown equipment that was not his - he never did get his equipment. Also an outside financial supporter of the Howard, Brian Nichols, has confirmed last week that although he had receipts for a $31,000 donation - $18,000 in building materials and $13,000 in cash from his group, those materials went missing and have never been recovered, nor has the cash portion been found. And, in the face of all this, there has been a constant refusal to have an independent external investigation done of the circumstances, despite numerous requests that this be done.

After the way the Army in Zimbabwe had their HH nurses arrested and imprisoned, reportedly tortured and starved while in prison, obviously people are going to be afraid to speak to any Army officers conducting an internal investigation. There must be an independent and external investigation.

But we can dream on when we are told this debacle will not even be discussed at the high council in the context of questioning nominees.

TSA's leadership does not learn and never makes significant changes to systems/policies/procedures that are in some instances archaic. This is to the organization's detriment.

I wonder at this point if there are more former than active officers? Not surprising if it is so.