Saturday, July 6, 2013

THREE DOCTORS: HIV, snake bites, 4,000 operations a year and no quitting whistle!


YEAR 2012  REPORT – Dr. Paul Thistle shared the below report with a Rotary Club in his native Canada.

Here’s the story of a (hospital) place named Howard. It began in 1923.  The school commenced first, in recognition of the need for education among the native population in rural Zimbabwe.  A clinic was attached to the school which grew into a hospital, ward by ward, wing by wing.  Today, Howard Hospital is well known across the nation having served, schooled and saved hundreds of thousands, perhaps millions of Zimbabweans.

Sub Saharan Africa has always had a lions’ share of poverty, pestilence and political unrest, but for Zimbabwe in the last dozen years it has been something different again.  We still fight inflation, 80 percent  unemployment  and a scarcity of health care professionals, medicines and surgical supplies. Old Mother Howard’s cupboards are often bare.  The escalating costs of transportation alone make travel to Howard prohibitive especially for the disadvantaged, the widows, orphans and child headed families in our villages.  Many will travel 18-20 miles by foot to seek medical attention ….  if they can walk.  Others will use wheelbarrows and ox driven carts.  On the other hand, half of our patients are from the cities and towns of Zimbabwe, in search of affordable care in a privatized system. Public health care in Zimbabwe remains underfunded, semi-privatized, a pay as you play. This has been exacerbated by the political stalemate in the unity government.  June is winter in Zimbabwe with shorter days, but when you are poor and sick, the nights are a little longer all year round.

We are a 144 bed general hospital with 3 doctors, 50 nurses, 100 general staff serving a catchment of 270,000 people on an annual government grant of $7,000 US.  Our outpatient services had 110,000 total attendances in 2011. That’s more than a mouthful of stats. The number of operations have tripled to 4,000 a year in the last decade due to the unmet demand for affordable surgical care in Zimbabwe. 

I am a Salvation Army officer and gynaecologist by training, not an orthopedic surgeon but I still need to set bones and reduce fractures; in the operating room they call me ‘Captain Crunch’.  

There is nothing sensational about treating the poor in rural Africa - just hard work day and night - and the following day. We are Club Med without the Club.

By the grace of God, our doors remain open to welcome the sick, and in turn, for us to reach out into the community with our messages of prevention, treatment and care.   It is HIV and AIDS that still places the single largest demand on our scarce resources  at Howard.  The good news here is that we know what works. Our HIV prevalence has dropped from 29 percent in 1999 to 5.7 percent in April 2012. We have our HIV clinic called Hope Clinic in Shona translation. With 3,000 people on treatment and 4, 000 more decentralized to our district clinics AIDS has changed from being a byword of shame and suffering to become a chronic disease to live with, like diabetes or hypertension. 

Talk is cheap. To the thousands in our community accessing lifesaving antiretroviral therapy they would agree with Benjamin Franklin, ‘Well done is always better than well said.’

HIV, pregnancy and poverty is a triple whammy.  There is the story of Unity, a 30 year old, HIV positive mother of three from a village 15 miles away, who has no antenatal care, and therefore no access to life saving ARVs. She presents in a coma secondary to fits at home for several days. We call this condition eclampsia. There was no affordable means of transport.  Her twins have already died in the womb. And Unity dies a few hours after arrival.  To top it off, it is the middle of the night and the hospital has no oxygen, and there is no money in the bank to purchase oxygen. 

It is the straw that breaks the camel’s back.  But when your back is broken from a night of broken rest, you still have to get up for work the next morning with a 100 more in the queue.   
And when your get up and go just got up and left what motivates you to continue on: professionalism, a sense of duty, compassion, and a glimmer of vision. 

A glimmer of vision. As Proverbs (29 v18) reads, ‘Where there is no vision the people perish.’  However, vision can be clouded by indifference. To quote Elie Wiesel, Holocaust survivor, it is indifference to suffering that makes the human being inhuman. At Howard we have to counter this indifference, apathy and despair with a message of hope and healing.  For we are not talking politics here but people.  At Howard and elsewhere, people are more important than programs.

There is nothing more liberating to serve people irrespective of race, colour, religion, and social status, …. simply because they are human, created in the image of God. 

A vision that sees a better world tomorrow than today, and a plan to bring it into place. 

I am privileged to report that Howard Hospital has captured this vision thanks in a big part to our network of international supporters, particularly Canadians. 

At a time in history when there is increasing skepticism over large NGOs and government to government aid, our friends have rallied to provide holistic care to the underprivileged in our corner of the country.  We stretch dollars on a shoestring budget (even when we have no shoes) and deliver the assistance to the community on the ground.  Rotarians are part and parcel of the community and know and apply this concept well.  In the past few years, Rotarians working together within their districts across Canada, with Rotary International and Rotary Foundation Matching Grants have improved the short and long term health of men, women and children at Howard through the support of laboratory services, the provision of antiretroviral drugs to pregnant women, and general medical and surgical supplies to our hospital and neighbouring clinics.

Bicycles have been provided for home based care volunteers.
Nurses have been able to complete their degrees at Howard by long distance learning. A cervical cancer screening program has been set up. Cancer of the cervix is the number one cancer of women in Zimbabwe .. and it is preventable. Diesel fuel has been purchased to fire up the generator when the national power grid fails day and night.   A four wheel drive vehicle was provided for our community care program and now an ambulance for our patients in distress out in the village. 

Vision without action is but a daydream. And Rotarians did not need skype or twitter to do all of this, but patience, perseverance and a personal touch.    Maita basa!  You have done work.
 
I am most grateful for my parents who taught me the value of a day’s hard work, my loving wife, Pedrinah, who holds down the fort at home, and our two boys, James and Alexander who have taught me on numerous occasions how to pick up the broken pieces of our lives and move forward … in grace.

At Howard, we must remain focused on our purpose, not our problems to providing quality affordable health care to an underprivileged corner of rural Africa.

Theodore Roosevelt  said ‘Do what you can, with what you have, where you are’ 

 Some believe we cannot, at least not in Zimbabwe, not at this time.  I believe we can, … or else I would not be standing in front of you today. 


10 comments:

FORMER SALVATION ARMY OFFICERS FELLOWSHIP said...

“The place God calls you to is the place where your deep gladness and the world’s deep hunger meet.” Frederick Buechner

Seems the perfect match - A gifted missionary physician who speaks the tribal language whether on a 'hut call', attending to an injury in the bush or the hospital's operating theatre, but with Christ's accent- 'His peace I give unto you'...

Anonymous said...

n the one minute he has with a patient, Thistle assesses, reassures, educates and decides on a course of action. He speaks to the people in their native tongue of Shona. Within 60 seconds he connects with them on a human level. He's brisk, but caring.

Howard Hospital, a Salvation Army facility in the rural north of Zimbabwe, is a teaching hospital.

Nurses, midwives and student doctors learn from Thistle's approach. His idea is to combine health care with an equal combination of quality and compassion.

Roselyn Ndawona, 22, holds her five-year old boy Denzel on her lap while waiting her turn. Denzel has a large burn on his back from a cooking oil accident. In broken English, Ndawona offers a few short words that exemplify the service at Howard.
"They treat you good. The people care," she says.

While Howard is the central hospital for the Mazowe district of the country's Mashonaland Central Province, it's not rare for people to travel here from distant parts of Zimbabwe and neighbouring areas.

A different type of care is what attracted 51-year-old Peter Chidouvi away from a district hospital in the capital Harare where he was being treated for chronic illness.

"Here is better than Harare," he said. "Dr. Thistle, he talks to the people. He loves the people. He doesn't throw people out." In a country that is 98% black, it can be challenging for a white Canadian to fit in.

But Thistle walks among the people here, not as a revered white man, but as a member of their own, a man they know will treat them as equals.

PETERBOROUGH EXAMINER

Anonymous said...

Does any one wonder why the Army in Africa is the fastest growing in the SA woeld? It's because people see Christ's love reflected in Salvationists like Paul Howard and his wife.

Active officer
USA Southern

FORMER SALVATION ARMY OFFICERS FELLOWSHIP said...

There are few public displays that are more damaging to the cause of Christ than Christians squabbling on the world’s stage.

One Christian leader’s ungrateful dismissal and disrespect of a servant does greater harm to the kingdom of God than scores of atheists.

Our strength is found in truth and gentleness. And SA corporate policy ought never to supersede the effective outpouring of God’s grace through on-the-spot services aimed at alleviating suffering.

We need to respect and differentiate between high rank officer opinion and principal.

Anonymous said...

ZIM Newspaper Aug 2012

'The Salvation Army International Headquarters in London declined comment on the transfer of Chigariro referring all questions to the Harare office.

Sources said with Chigariro shunted to Kenya, Dr Thistle was likely to get his job back.'

The SA has since that statement turned their back on Thistle.

Thank you former officers for making this travesty known.

UK

Anonymous said...

Is the FSAOF going to wait for the SA to respond before sharing the details? I think you are being more than fair in waiting for their response. In the meantime why not share what has already been documented?

And if any leaders were less than fair and unethical in their evaluation and decision making it needs to be made known before the High Council meets. Perhaps the FSAOF reporting will result in a reversal of IHQ and THQ Harare's unfair dismissal.

Active soldier and former missionary. USA

Former, USA said...

Dr. Captain Paul Thistle has in his own words stated the need, and left little to question that God indeed called him and his wife to this work. It is obvious God has blessed their service at HH in many ways, and expanded this loving service many times over because of their dedication to the Army and those they serve.
How can The SA IHQ and THQ disregard the need at HH and overwhelming ways God has used the Thistle family there. They should be placed back, assigned to HH, in the ministry where God needs them, not the limited vision of a few SA Leaders who
chosen to move them for no logical reasons causing thousands of local people suffering and I am sure even death because of this decision and perhaps even the abuse of power when the Thistle family was suddenly moved with 48 hr. notice, and no explanation and/or replacement at that time in hospital where more, not less Dr. are urgently needed."
"Except I am moved with Compassion, How dwelleth Thy Spirit in me......"
Where is the compassion from the SA in this sad, tragic situation?

Anonymous said...

Dr. Thistle has been referred to as the Mother Theresa of TSA because of his work amongst suffering human beings who are among the world's poorest.

His work has been recognized in Canada especially in the field of AIDS - mother to baby transmission. His work was featured on Canada's National news when he delivered the co-joined twins and arranged for their successful separation at Toronto Sick Children's Hospital. He was guest speaker at a university convocation and awarded an honorary degree by a Canadian university in recognition of his wonderful work.

He has glorified God and brought nothing but great respect to TSA through his work. No thinking person can understand why TSA would remove him from his work and terminate the officership of he and his wife. There has been as a result (among people who know what has happened) a total lack of confidence in the Army's leadership.

The fact that no Commissioners have stepped up to the plate at IHQ to issue an official apology not only to the Thistle's but also to the Chiweshe people for removing their only surgeon resulting in deaths. This just shows that the Army's leadership cares more about their policies/procedures and loyalty to the system and to the hierarchy than about the people they claim to serve - suffering, impoverished humanity.

This decision making is indefensible.

Canada

Anonymous said...

what is th procedure to b member of ths group. Im a former officer who resigned after serving more than 2 decades due t emotional torture

Anonymous said...

what is th procedure to b member of ths group. Im a former officer who resigned after serving more than 2 decades due t emotional torture