Thursday, February 28, 2013

WE NEED SOLDIERS

Recognizing that officers are recruited from the pool represented by SA soldiers, we've pulled an article out of the archives.



Let’s stop “cooking the books” says Terry Camsey

 In Shakespeare’s “Hamlet” these words appear spoken by Polonius…

“This above all, to thine own self be true,
And it must follow, as the night the day,
Thou cans’t not then be false to any man…”

My father used to quote that frequently to me when I was a young lad growing up. The words have stuck with me ever since.

A few years ago, a colleague Salvation Army Officer shared with me a book entitled, “Lies, Damn lies and Statistics - the Manipulation of Public Opinion in America.” As I recall it basically said that statistics can be manipulated to “prove” whatever you want to present as truth.

It is difficult to get accurate statistics from the very early days of the Army because few records were kept. One source has suggested that, if such accurate stats were available, they may not have affirmed the early gains claimed as Booth reached out to his initial primary target group…the submerged masses!

Ed McKinley, describing the Army’s membership in the USA in his book,“Marching to Glory,’ indicates that membership failed to keep pace with the overall population of the country as a whole and started to decline after the mid 1960s. This, despite the fact that in 1975 religious periodicals hailed the Army as the “fastest growing U.S religious body,” and cited a 5% increase. He goes on to say that…

What those periodicals may not have known is that such growth was the result of the Army changing its accounting procedures to include everyone who had made use of its community-center youth programs and corps facilities!

Many corps officers have been frustrated over the years in finding that attendance figures reported by the outgoing officer have failed to reflect reality! For example, an officer who “inherits” a corps with, say, a reported average attendance of 100 in Sunday morning worship…then finds it to be actually 50, can be chided - even if he increases average attendance to 75 (a fifty percent increase!) - for failing to reach the previous officer’s figure! 

This can be both demoralizing and de-motivating! If corps officers’ morale is to be significantly improved in such circumstances, there is an urgent need to insure that what the new officer inherits is true reality, not an inflated version of it.

We can also find statistics manipulated when, for instance. corps are challenged to compete in increasing Sunday School average attendance over the year to reach preset goals. I have seen for instance a desirable prize - such as a new van - offered to the winning corps during a competition at the “eleventh hour” in the twelfth month! It pushed average attendance up for one month. There was no significant increase in average attendance over the previous eleven months…and, without that final sprint, the average attendance per week would have been much lower.

A few years ago, a good friend of mine - soldier at a “large” corps - attends a corps that seats 300, sees an average weekly attendance of around 240 people, and 868 on the roll…many of them dead! The stats are sent to HQ and used along with the collective reports of other corps, as the basis for its statistics. Now, we all know that some on the roll are merely (merely!) inactive so we hesitate to take them off. But, surely, those who have passed on to their reward belong on a memorial, rather than active roll.

But who is willing to correct such misleading statistics? Year after year corps officers may be forbidden to take anyone off the rolls!

It seems as if we can do addition, but not subtraction! While God’s math is multiplication! It’s as if no-one wants reality to be faced on their watch. But how on earth can we move forward if we cannot look the facts face-on in order to move on.

We need an amnesty, a “no blame” truce, so that we can again level the playing field and move on. We need “net” results, not additions without reflection of losses…. and our “net figure” should be “fish caught!” That’s what the Master Fisher of Men” taught us.

Let us at least be true to ourselves!!

What do you think?



Writer: For thirty years Terry Camsey has been immersed in Church Growth and Health issues at local, middle and upper administrative levels. He is author of the book “Slightly Off-Center” (Crest Books) and is working on “Beyond the Cusp of The Curve..exploring the single most critical influence on the life, health, growth, vitality and decline of Christian denominations and the churches within them.”

4 comments:

Anonymous said...

When I was an officer, one of my colleagues told me that he always added three more at every meeting indoors and out: "one for the Father, one for the Son, and one for the Holy Ghost".

He was recently "Promoted to Glory".

Former Canada and Bermuda <)))><

Anonymous said...

As a young person just coming into Senior Census Board leadership (the old terminology) I was shocked to realize how padded roles were.

The old transfer slip process was one method - as soon as people appeared on the scene they were added to roles without their transfer slips arriving, but if a family was moving out they were never removed until the return portion of their transfer slip came back to the corps they had left - so this padded rolls.

Also dead people were removed whenever.

Another thing to consider re the connection to officership is that at some point in Canada we started adding adherents to our membership numbers and while this may be very legitimate, adherents don't usually become officers - if they can't make the lifestyle vows of soldiership they will not be able to make the covenant vows of officership either.

I can remember a day when our soldier rolls outnumbered our adherent rolls - such would not be the case I suspect today.

Anonymous said...

Although true that one must be able to be a soldier in order to be an officer I often find that adherents sit on the sidelines until they feel some calling to ministry to become a soldier. Then the progression is quite fast.

Anonymous said...

I fear amnesty equals heresy in this sense. To this Army anyway. Too bad. A reality check and wake up call is far more necessary than self preservation.