Tuesday, February 19, 2013

We need Officers ATTRITION SERIES IV

                                                                                                                                    (not real - spoof)
Assuming resignations  remain at a percentage level of between 1.5 and 2 of officers per year, one ought also remember that each departing officer represents a significant number of years of active service; experience and commitment.

The average service represented by members of the  FSAOF is approximately 12-14 years, or a combined 4,620 years (400+ members worldwide). Further, at the current rate of departure, this represents a staggering 2,500 (minimum) experienced and tested officers ‘leaving the work’ every decade. There’s little doubt that the count exceeds the number of those still in active service. FSAOF members share that on average fewer than 50% of their college (seminary) session mates remain in active service a decade subsequent to signing their Covenant, being ordained and commissioned.  

And the cost?

In 2011 it cost the UKIT between £50 and 60,000 per annum to train a Cadet. ($80,000.00+ USD) 

Over a two-year period the cost will be a minimum of £100,000 per commissioned officer ($160,000.00) and if the current attrition rate continues it translates as a loss of ROI (return on investment) or CBR (cost benefit ratio) of more than £1,000,000.00 per year. 

For the record, while no consolation, the ROI loss is roughly equal to that of the SDA Church and other USA denominations.

Should consideration be given to an agreed upon reimbursement if an officer resigns prior to a substantive period of service? The amount could be withheld from any separation allowance the officer might be entitled to.
 __________________________

It's unlikely that anyone knows for certain the exact numbers of those who have resigned their officership, or the real financial cost (loss on investment)  to the army. However, a simple statistical review will reveal that the total number is in the several thousands, and perhaps it's to everyone’s advantage to keep the count and cost private. Nonetheless, there's little doubt that the count exceeds the number of those currently on active service (16,000+). 

The personal loss to those resigning cannot, of course, be measured only in economic terms. The private FSAOF FB site includes hundreds of private heart wrenching stories detailing family break-ups, financial ruin,   families living in their cars months on end, spiritual derailment and much more. Not all of the misery experienced could have been prevented but only a very few of the hundreds of formers speaks of any measure of Christian concern or care being exhibited, or any effort at reconciliation being made by TSA. Admittedly, the cause and blame associated with an officer's separation from active service finds its genesis in many corners in and outside the army.

"I have to say being part of the Army all my life and then leaving a few years ago on not so good terms, was not an easy time. I was bitter and angry. But over the course of time I have come to understand that forgiveness is not for the other person but rather for me. The people who were involved were also human and made mistakes, just like I make mistakes."
          __________
"Being in the position they were in, did not make them perfect, as I suspect some thought they were. Would I have done things differently if I were in their position, who knows?"
_________________
"I have by the grace of God been able to put those things behind me and I am moving on toward the prize of a higher calling. My husband and I are now part of a wonderful church where I am still able to be used of God in my calling to "preach the gospel". I have never been happier in a church in my life, I feel I am just were God wants me to be."
__________________
"Do I miss the Army? You bet I do. I would love to attend a Congress again, I know it would be an experience with many tears."
__________________
"Will I ever go back? I will always be obedient to the call of God, "just where He needs me," I don't know what the future holds but I know who holds the future. I am praying for those of you who are struggling with the pain you have suffered because of what you have experienced. I pray you will be able to reach a place where forgiveness is possible."

God bless you all.   
Canada andBermuda
_________________
"There are many other issues involved in my leaving as well - too many to go into in a short response.

For me, such mediation as suggested would not have made a difference, as most of the people suggested would be the ones that pushed me to leave. There needs to be fundamental changes in TSA - pastorally, theologically, organisationally etc. - if we are to have a hope of stemming the flow of Officers becoming 'formers', and win some of us 'formers' back."
Australia

         _________________
"Who gives pastoral care to the parents, siblings and family of resigning Officers? Where do they go to get help dealing w/the questions from curiosity-seekers in their Corps? Where do they turn to get help w/dealing w/the sarcastic comments and nasty remarks?"
USA South
_______________

"A 'loneliness void' is both, the most intense occupational hazard, or ministry killer, an officer will face; the Sunday evening ‘Am I alone in this’ syndrome. And then there’s the realization that I no longer fit, no longer perfect to serve. 

Even when people know we’re dealing with something as difficult as resigning from officership we and they minimize the issue because they assume we’re strong enough to handle it ourselves. In addition the now ‘absent ministry’ obligations contribute to the loneliness."  
UKIT

How does an individual know that he or she should enter, remain in, or leave officership? While many factors play into such a decision, beyond the obvious, “calling”, officers are surrounded by the many demands, expectations and projections to excel, and with it redefining their private goals and the education necessary. And there are the directives from family and tradition, adding confusion as officers seek to distinguish God’s unique call?” It is an essential question for every person committed to ministry, and at every level.


All who commit to a life of full time ministry need to be quite sure that the battle is worth the effort, especially at those times when we find ourselves wondering whether we are remaining and staying true for the right reasons.

It must grieve God's heart to see the number of steady resignations; scores who promised a lifetime of loyalty to ‘the cross and the colours’.

                                     
                        They bid me choose an easier path,
And seek a lighter cross;
They bid me mingle with Heaven’s gold
A little of earth’s dross.
They bid me, but in vain, once more
The world’s illusions try;
I cannot leave the dear old flag,
‘Twere better far to die.

(Salvation Army Songbook, #780)
Part IV


Dr. Sven Ljungholm
Former SA Officer

10 comments:

Cheryl Hagedorn said...

Thank you for your faithfulness, Sven. Over the years I have said and continue to say, "What a waste! why don't they care?!" The loss of fine officers (I was not one) is inexcusable when it is within the power of God's servants in leadership to avoid it.
Former, USA Central

Anonymous said...

I still contend that the attrition rate has ALWAYS been very high and during some periods of SA history (the first decade of the 1900s after the Army's initial early advance and during national war time for instance) probably even much higher than today.

The "problem" is at the other end. Droves of young people between the ages of 17 and 21 are not entering into the training colleges anymore and not because of a "falling away" as some might suggest but because of major societal changes brought about by a post industrial/information age, more gender egalitarian world.

In order to go back to "the good old days" it would require smashing all computers, outlawing birth control pills and making higher education available to only a few (usually rich) elites.

I can still recall sitting in a meeting back in 1971 at the Centennial Memorial Temple in New York City and noticing how impressed everyone was when Commissioner Norman Marshall mentioned that he had just attended a reunion of the "Holdfast" Session (1940)that he had trained. Out of 75 cadets commissioned in the "Holdfast" Session in 1940 55 were in 1971 still active.

The reason it was news and everyone was so impressed was because IT WAS SO RARE! I rest my case.

Daryl Lach
USA Central

"You Must Go Home By the Way of the Cross, To Stand with Jesus in the Morning!"

Anonymous said...

Continuing the comfort versus achievement thing I elaborated a bit on the "keep calm" posters. This because I really don't get it why churches don't think big. For me that IS the Gospel. To me Christianity is equal to success. Otherwise I don't want it.

I've been hated by those I guarded because I refused to see the Church decline and religion fail. I don't want to meditate. I don't want to gather and share Christian feelings. I don't want to keep calm.

I want to achieve. That's me. And it make me feel lonely. Isn't it remarkable that especially, I couldn't fit in an army-like church?

Pieter Raaijmakers
Former
NL

Anonymous said...

Just asking: 'Is there any former officer family who were left literally homeless 'living in their car' from the UK within the last ten years?

This certainly was not our experience as a family as TSA did accommodate us and gave us a quarters to rent in a suitable place to try and help us get back on our feet asap. Is this not the way it is always done?

Former UKT

FORMER SALVATION ARMY OFFICERS FELLOWSHIP said...

Former UKT

As the creator of the FSAOF (Former Salvation Army Officers fellowship), our blog and private Facebook site, I must assume that you're not a member.

If you are on Facebook you're more than welcome to join with us and where you can read first hand of the many former officers who did indeed live in their cars and/or homeless shelters.

How many of them were offered assistance by the Army is not known, but no doubt some thought they'd find employment and affordable accommodation soon after resigning and were proved wrong. Others may have been too proud to accept it.

Anonymous said...

No! Anonymous Former UKT. They took the car as well - lol

Peter J. said...

There is a churn in most places and the cost of training is a normal expense. There is no reason for TSA to think they special.

One of the ways to retain staff is to train them up, which does have the risk of them being able to get employment elsewhere. The proposal to make it costly to leave only keeps the wrong people with the wrong reasons. You have to do better than that.

Former
New Zealand FT Territority

Anonymous said...

$80,000 a year seems a bit exaggerated? What is the breakdown on that? And god help us...what is the cost the keep that office? In that mansion. With the big car.

Anonymous said...

The best decision I have ever made was "to leave the dear old flag", and instead of dying, I found life and joy and freedom in another denomination!

Former
Canada and Bermuda

Major (Dr) Jim Watt (R) said...

Our territorial leaders do not need to look far for the reasons for the latest officer casualty, Capt. Dr. Paul Thistle. A personal vendetta with his TC in Zimbabwe(over issues that are not complementary to the TC) led to his abrupt removal (24 hours to leave)from Howard Hospital in August. Although the TC's actions led to the deaths of patients, the imprisonment and torture of nurses (one still in jail) and serious damage to the Army's reputation, she has been praised and promoted, while the good doctor has been maligned and terminated. He has chosen to remain in Zimbabwe to defend his nurses and continue to serve suffering humanity in a nearby hospital. His request for a leave of absence to allow time for reason to prevail has been denied by Canada. Already one young person who was moved by the dedication he saw in Paul to follow in his steps has wondered if he should even remain a Salvationist. If an immediate review of the circumstances of this move, which I believe amount to a crime, is not undertaken, the Army will face further loss of reputation and officers. Forcing silence and covering up will not work in this generation. Honesty and reform are our only hope. I pray that someone will listen.