Thursday, February 14, 2013

Faithful and exclusive ? GLBT Series 2013

This is the next to the last in the GLBT Series 2013- We've had more than 3,000 hits since we began sharing the conservative (prefer that to 'fundamentalist") the middle-of-the-road (confused-searching-undecided) and liberal viewpoints. 

Tomorrow's article, the one suggesting 'our way forward', reflects what I perceive to be a  a collective prayer.

Among the many visitors to our blog have been TSA on many levels. and we've been commended for focusing on this divisive church issue by more than a few within its ranks.

Thank you for your many kind, insightful and supportive comments.

Sven Ljungholm
FSAOF
_________________________________________________


Are homosexual relationships sexually faithful and exclusive, like Christian marriage?


When McWhirter and Mattison published The Male Couple in 1984, their study was undertaken to disprove the reputation that gay male relationships do not last.  The authors themselves were a homosexual couple, one a psychiatrist, the other a psychologist.  After much searching they were able to locate 156 male couples in relationships that had lasted from 1 to 37 years.  Two-thirds of the respondents had entered the relationship with either the implicit or the explicit expectation of sexual fidelity.

The results of their study show that of those 156 couples, only seven had been able to maintain sexual fidelity.  Furthermore, of those seven couples, none had been together more than 5 years.  In other words, the researchers were unable to find a single male couple that was able to maintain sexual fidelity for more than five years. They reported: "The expectation for outside sexual activity was the rule for male couples and the exception for heterosexuals.  Heterosexual couples lived with some expectation that their relationships were to last “until death do us part,” whereas gay couples wondered if their relationships could survive" (p.3).

McWhirter and Mattison admit that sexual activity outside the relationship often raises issues of trust, self-esteem, and dependency.  However, they believe that “the single most important factor that keeps couples together past the ten-year mark is the lack of possessiveness they feel.  Many couples learn very early in their relationship that ownership of each other sexually can become the greatest internal threat to their staying together

4 comments:

Anonymous said...

And I wonder what a survey of straight couples of similar ages and backgrounds would have found in 1984.
McWhirter and Mattison's research outlines the stages of the development of a healthy couple relationship for gay males n the social context of the time. There has been considerable research since then which adds to this understanding. Let's deal honestly with what the research says. And let's also be clear that this is gay male behaviour of nearly 30 years ago, with no delineation as to religious belief. To make a valid comparison with heterosexual behaviour you would need a matched cohort of heterosexual unmarried couples of similar duration.

The study says nothing of gay female behaviour or behaviour when long term mongomous relationships have become normalised in the gay community.

I am all for an open conversation, but lets look at all the research, not selectively quote research that only defines one cohort.

Former
Australia Eastern

Anonymous said...

Fair enough, Australian Eastern!

Anonymous said...

From my reading, there have been no shortage of viewpoints expressed. In the interest of fairness and accuracy to simply dismiss a study because it wasn't conducted last month lacks total credibility.

Provide your own up to date researched survey and I'll consider your argument afresh.

Active UK

Anonymous said...

Active UK,
I am questioning whether the study ( which I have read) says what the author is saying it says. The methodology of the study does not support the contention in the article.

As to other sources, a good place to start is Solomon, SE, RothblumE.D, and Balsam, K.R (2004) Pipnerrs in Partnership: Lesbian and Gay couples in civil unions compared with those not in civil unions and married heterosexual siblings, Journal of Family Psychology 18(2) 275-286, there is a follow up article by the same authors comparing Vermont, massachusetts and Californis in the journal of family issues, a search of the available online academic references libraries will bring up a wealth of others.

The research is not definitive, but ethereal is much more data and newer research which also includes gay women available.

former Australia Eastern