Thursday, February 28, 2013


ANNOUNCING THE INTERNATIONAL COMMISSION ON OFFICERSHIP
24 September 1998


THE General (Rader) has decided that ‘all aspects of the concept of officership’ are to be reviewed ‘in the light of the contemporary situation and its challenges, with a view to introducing a greater measure of flexibility.’

This follows a recommendation of the International Leaders’ Conference held earlier this year in Melbourne, Australia, that a commission be appointed for this purpose.

The International Commission on Officership will be chaired by Commissioner Norman Howe, Territorial Commander, Canada. Commissioner Howe is a British officer and has held appointments as corps officer, divisional commander and relevant senior executive positions including, more recently, Territorial Commander, Australia Southern.

Implicit within the terms of reference is the recognition that the Army's mission in the new millennium will require the development of a strong concept of spiritual leadership which is both doctrinally sound and pragmatic in approach. The prayers of Salvationists around the world are solicited for the Commission as it reviews issues of vital importance to the future of the Army.

The 23 Salvationists appointed to the commission are drawn from each of the five geographic zones into which the Army’s work is divided. They include 11 women and three non-officers; of the officer members, two are lieutenants, four captains and five majors, with only three holding the rank of commissioner.

The commission will hold its first meeting from 19-23 October at the UK Territory’s officer training college, Denmark Hill, London, and after further meetings, and consultation with territorial leaders, will aim to present a report to the General in time for review by the Advisory Council to the General at its July 1999 meeting.

14 years on: 
UPDATE, ANY ONE?

16 comments:

Anonymous said...

... the structure is not the issue as ‘its success depends totally on the smarts and goodness of the people at the top’. The right people in the right places doing the right thing and what we have would work as it is meant to.

I work in an organisation that is more bonsai than mighty oak. (I am not sure if you can have any organisational chart that is not hierarchical). It is very wide and three levels high with just the MD perched on the very top of the tree. Believe me, it is no panacea for the ills of tyranny and abuse! Machiavellian characters, power seeking despots, those sitting at Teflon-coated desks – we have them all – cause all of the same problems that some think the Army only has because of what is termed an archaic and autocratic structure.

My company prides itself in its ‘consultative, collegiate and collaborative approach’: all of the management administrative processes, at some point and to varying degree, measured to ensure that outcomes fulfil the base premise. Our biggest problem and I am sure that the company is no different to others, is managing the expectations of our staff: if only so much was invested in producing what we produce. We have staff, just like anywhere else that come with their own ideas of how to do things (creativity is welcomed) with, often, supreme notions of their own ability (confidence is welcomed) and a clear plan of where they want to be in five years (ambition is welcomed).

However, the problem starts when their creativity does not produce what the company needs; that they think they are far better at the job than they actually are and that their goal(s) is/are unachievable due to either inability or the fact that the person who is actually doing the job they covet is making a rather good fist of it. Yet, individuals press on regardless, sowing seeds of dissention, exhibiting considerable disloyalty and playing all manner of games to undermine and usurp any individual who they feel gets-in-their-way. The problems are not always top-down: my experience, in a broad range of enterprises, informs that the biggest problems are bottom-up.

Accountability and transparency, and models of governance, is not about pleasing people or giving them the answer/rationale that they want to hear. Often the calls for such frameworks hinge on the desire of some people to personally affirm or approve of the decisions made and processes undertaken and when the answer or insight that they so desperately seek does not match or mirror their own understanding or view they are still not satisfied and claim the process or whatever has not been transparent enough. Transparency and accountability is, often, by its essence retrospective and the damage, if it can be called such, is done by the time people through due process of notification realise such. Of course you can have caveats within governance models that make corrective action quickly and obviously you would, in an ideal world, frame processes in such a way that damage would not be done in the first place. But again, we are working people and the hopes of expectations of the ideal world: such utopia I fear exists in few if any organisations unless peopled by automatons programmed to spew out all the right answers first time and, in an Army context, we have come across those types all too frequently and can all testify that they were not right either!

DW

Anonymous said...


DW

Are the initials DW an acronym for "Doing well" or "Don't worry"?
I'm dying to know! I think I can guess, so I won't expire waiting for an answer. Anyway, I enjoyed the comments. "Keep, keeping on!"

Anonymous said...


DW... You're supposing that system can work well with the right people doing the right thing. In your organization, you are an employee and your org is subject to the laws governing employment standards.

However, in the SA officers are not employees, not subject to Human Rights legislation and employment standards. Let me give you a "for instance." We pay into employment insurance and qualify for all the benefits a proper employee does, like say... maternity leave. In Canada, that means you get almost a year off with government support and your employer keeps your job open for you. With that benefit available to us, the SA in all its infinite wisdom, still brings out a brand new policy giving officer women a 3 month maternity leave - not parental leave where both spouses have an opportunity to stay with a child and which is allowed by law, but only for the mother. And you can't apply for the government benefits.

I'm also sure in your organization that you apply for available positions, discuss your career with your employer, are not arbitrarily moved to another city or province without consultation and not asked what you'd like to be paid.

I don't think officers want the moon. I think many are still willing to make some sacrifices. However, basic respect and consideration needs to be there or the sacrifice becomes too heavy to bear. Many, after 20 or 30 years of giving unstintingly, have their concerns dismissed and are told to suck it up and are reminded of what they signed up for.

This is not honouring to their covenant or their sacrifice. When an organization wants total control of you, then they need to make sure they take care of you as a result of that.

Anonymous said...

DW

Let me guess - you're an MBA in administration of some medical org?? Your gobbledegook style of written communication sounds like an MBA - no offence.

Hierarchy, autocracy, military tends to attract the overly ambitious, power/control hungry people who tend to put ends before means in decision making and they usually specialize in policy and procedure and protocol.

I would suggest such people often have problems in Christian leadership which is based on servanthood and which considers means to be as important as ends, prioritizes human needs and maintaining healthy human relationships over maintaining power and the hierarchical system and its policies and procedures.

Even within democratic systems there obviously is hierarchy, but the leadership is more accountable in democratic systems, decision making is more transparent and involves grassroots people, thus placing more value on them
by giving them a voice in decision making.

In a more democratic system people tend to take ownership of what they participate in, they also tend to support financially organizations whose leaders give them the opportunity to participate in decision making.

No system is perfect but a system which values the Barnabas's and the Paul's equally is more appropriate to the Christian church. The apostle Paul made a wrong decision but Barnabas wasn't terminated in his ministry because he disagreed with Paul over the issue of John Mark. Similarly Christian doctrine was arrived at through a political process - the church councils. The final decisions were not dictated by a few leaders.

Interestingly in TSA we have no statement of the doctrine of the priesthood of all believers. Although we don't believe in the infalliblity of the General, in reality we practice the doctrine of infalliblity throughout the hierarchy when there are disagreements. The higher positions in our hierarchy are always more infallible than the lower positions. The will of God is known more by those at the top of the Army's hierarchical pyramid. We are Roman Catholic, not truly Protestant. Further evidence that the Army leaders practice infalliblity is they never apologize and they never change a decision once it is made known, even when it is obviously a mistake. The exception would be when a court rules them wrong and makes them change their position. But most court cases are settled out of court with financial settlements that often include gag clauses.

In a democratic system it is easier to admit error and make things right, after all decisions are made by a group and there is not as much face to lose or ego involved. The less democracy in decision making the more vulnerability to power abuse by egotistical leaders.

Having been in both types of churches, I would much prefer a governance system with more democracy. It seems much more suitable to a culture based on love.

Anonymous said...

The gobbledegook does sort of give the writer away doesn't it? There are not too many former officers in Canada who can speak with such managerial authority. DW (don't worry) it's OK we promise not to blow your cover.

Anonymous said...

Caniac Steve Henderson: Dear Sven..knowing and have talked with general rader 2 times in my life..and based on the statement you posted..All Aspects of the concept of Officership..now and as a lowly college grad who never took humanities or other type of courses that makes one sound like the general's comment..to a practicle,nuts & bolts soup,soap,salvation Christ & Him Crucifed type of minister of the Gospel (who grew up on the streets) it sounds like that a "through review of all the hats a TSA officers have had and are expected to wear to shed light upon how the ministry of the Army of today and it's challenges and hassles can be dealt with so a officer can have "some' flexabilty & how to do the job assigned..and keep DHQ/THQ Happpy all in the name of Jesus " ...is that the point that's is trying to be made ? As that is what a plain spoken person like me sees & understands that opening sentence..how far off am I if at all ?

Anonymous said...

People, I think we need to step back and be a little realistic and honest here. Something I have had difficulty doing myself.

I work in a large secular organisation. I can, and many of my colleagues have, been told on Friday that this is their last day in the branch, on Monday, they start at a different branch. No consultation. Just a directive. Whilst it does not require a change of house, it may require extra travel time of up to an hour. If you want to keep your job, you do it.

Whilst there are employment laws in most countries, most organisations find ways around those employment laws as much as they can. In my organisation and country, the ruling is that employees who have been with the company for 3 years of more, are entitled to 6 months paid sick leave if signed off by a doctor per year. But I assure you, all those who have tried to take more than a few weeks off when signed off by a doctor, are managed out of the company by other means. It's unethical, but there is nothing illegal about it.

The problem we face is that being a church, we expect something different. However, all denominations that are large enough to be self-sustaining all end up falling into the same traps we are complaining about. From the ultra conservative Catholic and Anglican denominations to the extreme liberal Metropolitan Community Church. All have the same difficulties, the same power hungry people etc etc etc.

Whilst we would want the church to be different, the very fact that there are human beings in it means it won't be. When we understand that, then we can begin to move forward.

Graeme Randall
Former Australian East now in London

Anonymous said...

Graeme,

I for one am not prepared to accept the statement that because we are human beings the Church will not be any different than the corporate world, and that the sooner we suck it up the better!

Whatever happened to the doctrine that we are made in the image of God?

I am getting the impression by reading some of the posts that there are those who think that we are just highly developed animals, who if we measure up will be rewarded, or like beasts of burden
whose only reason for living is to serve the purpose of the corporation, or like machines, who are expected to function well, to produce what we are supposed to produce, or as victims who are to be treated as those most pitied.

It seems to me that what we think makes a huge difference in the way we treat the people we work with, the people we like or don't like; and also the way we treat our self, the way we handle our life, tackle our problems and meet our opportunities.

As Christians, we "believe" we are made in the "image of God": that we share in the act of creation; that we can take words and weave them into sound; can take sound and integrate it into patterns of music; take material and make it into something beautiful; and that we have a certain mastery over history, over time, and over ourselves.

Granted that we have a limited mastery: no one of us has been able to completely master the tendency to turn inward instead of outward; to always be completely in control of ourselves; to not avoid being dependent upon powers other than ourselves.

For all of this that the writer of Genesis knew, he still believed that the image of God was there: it might be blurred, buried, and sometimes blotted out, but that no matter how far a person might fall he or she couldn't drop out of God's love, and that no matter what, we should be handled with reverence because somewhere buried in us is the image of the Maker.

What has happened to this image? Do people in authority in the Church see us as made in the image of God, or do they see us as beasts of burden simply there to serve the purpose of the institution; like machines that are expected to function well, to produce, to increase statistics, to raise money, and when we do not meet their expectations, or break down, to be abused, and assigned to the scrap heap?

And is it possible that we have been one of the ones who helped to cut it down by treating people like victims of heredity, environment and circumstances with no capacity to transcend the conditions of life, and thus serve no purpose but to be terminated?

Whatever happened to the gospel of grace, reconciliation and restoration? Should we not be handled with care even if we look like nothing but a bunch of failures?

Somehow or other I can't help but feel that the corporate image that is being granted acceptance should not be the model for the kingdom of God. Am I missing something?

Former Canada and Bermuda <)))><

Anonymous said...

Just found another gobbledegook comment! :-)

Perhaps, quoting the poster, my 'managerial authority' comes because I am not a former from Canada

DW

Anonymous said...

Alas our intuition is shattered. You must have a clone and be unaware that you have a double in Canada, so many coincidences. He really was quite "enlightened"!

Well all that "managerial authority" most certainly must come from the United States of America. Americans are geniuses when it comes to organization.

How would I know? I'm married to one.

Blessings,

Former Canada and Bermuda

Anonymous said...

Not an American either: merely, a humble Brit!

Grace!

DW

Anonymous said...

I'm glad you have a sense of humour Brit, and I'm just an Irish leprechaun. Grace and peace to you.

Anonymous said...

DW I can't believe it, the light has just gone on in my poor brain. You and I have met before on another SA Forum. DW is not an acronym it is your own name, and I have complimented you in the past. I feel like I can now hang up my shingle as a detective. It's me again, the Irish leprechaun. Joy!

Anonymous said...

Ah! .... I was right; I thought I recognised your writing style.

Yes, we have 'met' before.

Though we are not alone: to my certainty, there is another one of those correspondents from 'that other place' on here as well. I recognise, all too well, the style, content and angle of that writer also. In fact, I would bet (not that we do anything like that in Army) my house that it is they that charged me with writing gobbledegook and, I have to say, not for the first time! :-)

DW

Anonymous said...

I do not think your house is built on the sand, so you can probably sleep well!

Anonymous said...

I worked at a college for many years. One time I had the opportunity to interview the college president and one of the questions I asked him was what did he believe his most important role to be. His answer was simple...to empower faculty and staff to safely try new endeavors. Further conversation revealed he knew full well the failures would be as frequent as the successes. But how do you advance without attempt?

Years later he left and a new president came in. One with a very different everyone under the thumb mentality. The change in the corporate culture was fast and vicious.

As quickly as the pendulum swings one way it can swing the other. The fear must be removed for change to happen. 'Nuff said.