Monday, February 25, 2013

We Need Officers ATTRITION SERIES X



Margaret Thatcher, former Prime Minister of England: 
"First, you win the argument," she said, "then you win the vote."

We have posted more than 1,200 articles in our six-year history, but never has there been such a preponderance of arguments and questions raised against a position articulated by someone in high SA office. Consequently, we are breaking with custom and posting comments received in response to Commissioner Brian Pebble’s interview in yesterday’s blog as today’s featured article.
We hope to elevate the argument and pray that it leads to the highest human experience; valuing what’s virtuous and right. People look at and are often guided by policies and paths based on their impact on efficiency.

Has the Army selected efficiency at the cost of excluding reality and fairness? Have they lost the argument and our confidence? Are they too proud to accept that others may have convincing arguments and solution?

How would you vote?
_________________________

 ‪Anonymous‬ said...

Well, that was all very politically correct, safe, you know....

O well, what did I expect?


Active Canada and Bermuda
Saturday, 23 February, 2013

 ‪Anonymous‬ said...

I would like to have an interview with the Commissioner myself. I have a lot of embarrassing questions to ask him.


Former Canada and Bermuda <)))><
Saturday, 23 February, 2013

 ‪Anonymous‬ said...

'Peddling' safe for General - let's not upset the apple cart by being honest or controversial.


Former Canada and Bermuda
Saturday, 23 February, 2013

 ‪Anonymous‬ said...

Well said, former Canada and Bermuda, and the play on words is more truth than fiction.


Another former Canada and Bermuda
Saturday, 23 February, 2013

 ‪Anonymous‬ said...

Why would any person want to give the total determination of their life to any 3rd party organization, particularly a hierarchical Christian movement/church?

Commissioner Peddle sounds dishonest in facing this reality or he's out of touch. People today expect to interpret and determine God's will for themselves and not just obey others' ideas of God's will for them. 

Many more officers might leave if they could, but find themselves financially bound owning very little and having no equity. They have to keep going to get the lump sum at retirement.


Canada and Bermuda
Saturday, 23 February, 2013

 ‪Anonymous‬ said...

Following the previous comment by Canada and Bermuda, whom I assume is not either an active or former officer, I am wondering if anyone has seen the cartoon from Sherman's Lagoon by Jim Toomey. 

It is a pity that it can't be pasted in the comment box, but here is a description, which might add some levity to the comments:

In box one Hawthorne is being welcomed by two rats.
The caption reads: "Hawthorne welcome to the Brotherhood of Traveling Rats". Hawthorne replies, "Uh thanks".


In box two Hawthorne that states: "Sounds like a cult". The rats respond, "Heavens No, just a Gathering".


Box three reads: "A Gathering of Rats that all blindly follow our beloved leader and never question orders given by him".


In the final box the rats ask Hawthorne: "Can we fit you for a robe?" and Hawthorne answers: "Sure, now that I know you're not a cult".
Saturday, 23 February, 2013

 ‪Anonymous‬ said...
Following the previous comment by Canada and Bermuda, whom I assume is not either an active or former officer, I am wondering if anyone has seen the cartoon from Sherman's Lagoon by Jim Toomey. 

It is a pity that it can't be pasted in the comment box, but here is a description, which might add some levity to the comments:

In box one Hawthorne is being welcomed by two rats.
The caption reads: "Hawthorne welcome to the Brotherhood of Traveling Rats". Hawthorne replies, "Uh thanks".


In box two Hawthorne that states: "Sounds like a cult". The rats respond, "Heavens No, just a Gathering".


Box three reads: "A Gathering of Rats that all blindly follow our beloved leader and never question orders given by him".


In the final box the rats ask Hawthorne: "Can we fit you for a robe?" and Hawthorne answers: "Sure, now that I know you're not a cult".


There's a line in the next article on this website which says something similar to the cartoon - officership can be viewed as a cult of blind obedience and in the next article it says about Commissioning Day that "One press reporter called our Commissioning ‘the annual miracle of blind obedience ‘." 


Canada and Bermuda
Saturday, 23 February, 2013


The right questions are being asked - finally. But no-one seems to be listening or seeking the right answers. The attitude seems to be 'the horse isn't moving, we need to flog it harder' not realising that the horse might have either died, or is about to die. Perhaps the horse needs resuscitation for it to get moving again.


Yours in Christ,
Graeme Randall

Former Australian East in London
Sunday, 24 February, 2013

 ‪Anonymous‬ said...

A great series Sven! 
The question is, are you preaching to the choir while the clergy are in the board room commending themselves for having made it through another Sunday?! And wondering, how many more Sundays are left?

I pray God uses the FSAOF in getting the message through to those in command! Or, I and a friend will soon be joining your ranks.


Active officer

UKIT Midlands
Sunday, 24 February, 2013

 ‪Anonymous‬ said...

I continue to be fascinated by this web-site! And try not to abuse the privilege of being allowed to comment.

The angry comments about Mr Peddle's statements are very revealing and would indicate that you feel he is toeing the "Party line".


I know not of the gentleman but as I read his comments I thought it contained a lot of what I might call "ideological gobbledegook" completely divorced from what seems to be the reality of life in the SA in Canada. 


He can prattle on about the will of God and the Holy Spirit until the end of time but that will not resolve the problems that from what you say seem to exist in his patch.


Reminds me of an elderly man who maintained a beautiful garden outside his cottage: next door the garden untended was infested with weeds and nettles. 

The Vicar passing by leaned over the gate and said to George "Lovely garden, George, wonderful what God can do with a garden!"

"Yes Vicar" said George "just look next door and see the mess He makes of it on His own!" 

I just sense that the Army has little care for the lost resources of its ex-Officers. And that is sad!



Sunday, 24 February, 2013

 ‪Anonymous‬ said...

I can only say that I wish our leaders expressed even an inkling of the care and concern for former officers that your fellowship shows.

If your several hundred members all lived in one region what a mighty Army God could raise up through you. 

I understand that your fellowship has already met with leaders from the Eastern territory and that a tentative meeting is planned with the Southern territory. 

God bless you!


Active officer

Chicago

USA Central Territory
Sunday, 24 February, 2013

 ‪Major (Dr.) Jim Watt (R)‬ said...

I have posted the following after a later article, but believe it belongs here: Our territorial leaders do not need to look far for the reasons for the latest officer casualty, Capt. Dr. Paul Thistle. A personal vendetta with his TC in Zimbabwe (over issues that are not complementary to the TC) led to his abrupt removal (ordered to leave in 24 hours) from the SA Howard Hospital in August, 2012.
Although the TC's actions led to the deaths of patients, the imprisonment and torture of nurses (one still in jail) and serious damage to the Army's reputation, she has been praised and promoted, while the good doctor has been maligned and terminated. He has chosen to remain in Zimbabwe to defend his nurses and continue to serve suffering humanity in a nearby hospital.
His request for a leave of absence to allow time for reason to prevail has been denied by the SA Canada. Already one young person who was moved by the dedication he saw in Paul to follow in his steps has wondered if he should even remain a Salvationist.
If an immediate review of the circumstances of this move, which I believe amount to a crime, is not undertaken, the Army will face further loss of reputation and officers.
Forcing silence and covering up will not work in this generation. Honesty and reform are our only hope. I pray that someone will listen.
Monday, 25 February, 2013

 ‪Anonymous‬ said...

Reform can only happen when there is a recognition that there is a problem. TSA does not recognize that they have one. They still view ‘Formers’ as those who were not good examples of leadership and therefore their leaving did not affect the TSA at all.
There appears to be a loathing of most Formers, and actives do not usually associate with them for fear of ruining their own reputations within army circles.
TSA has their head in the sand if if still believes that it has a good reputation here in Canada. It has become obsolete in many communities as scandals over sexual issues (ie. abuse),ethical issues ( theft of millions of dollars which was conveniently swept under a very large rug) have plagued it for years now.
Commissioner Peddle is either towing the party line or is somewhere in LA-LA land. You cannot get ahead in TSA if you do not agree with everything they (leaders) say and do. As one other commentor has said,(and I paraphrase here) if you want to run for the General's job you better play the game TSA's way!!


Former 
Canada & Bermuda
Monday, 25 February, 2013 

8 comments:

Anonymous said...

I am compelled to express my gratitude to Major Dr. Jim Watt for his courage in speaking out about the mistreatment of the former Captain Dr. Paul Thistle, the former CMO of the Howard Hospital, a gynecologist and obstetrician, highly honoured by his peers and academia.

To the Canadian media, Dr. Thistle has been our Mother Teresa, following in the footsteps of other sacrificial missionary doctors, like Dr. Bob McClure, Dr. Helen Huston, and Major Dr. Watt himself.

What the Army doesn't realize, is that someone like me, an OK, and a former, though leaving the work fifty five years ago, has been a staunch supporter of TSA with the people I serve in another denomination. Never once, have I may disloyal remarks about the Army when people have praised it for its good work, in spite of the fact that my officer parents were also treated poorly, my father being a fierce opponent of the Army's policy of the segregation of the races in Africa, where they served in the black and coloured communities.

I find it painful to confess, that as a result of the string of situations which have previously been mentioned, I can no longer remain silent when people say good things about the Army. I am sure many Canadian formers, retired and active officers, and a number of soldiers who know of the situation, are similarly suffering.

My guess is, that the Administration was caught between a rock and a hard place. No doubt political pressure from Zimbabwe, a looming election in the near future, a Salvationist in high places, all played a part in Dr. Thistle becoming a sacrificial lamb, like his Lord before him.

All I can do is to cry Shame, Whenever a Church places its polity and protocol above an individual's personal integrity and morality, in this case forcing Dr. Thistle to place his loyalty to the Army over his Hippocratic oath, that institution is in danger of losing its soul!

Anonymous said...

Thank you Dr.James Watt for the courage in posting about the termination of Dr. Paul Thistle and his wife Pedrinah as officers. This was done by the Canadian territory but with the full knowledge and sanction of IHQ. As the previous poster pointed out, IHQ values loyalty to protocol, procedure and obedience to the Army's system and leadership over integrity and ethics. If people have had reason to suspect this before, this situation is a clear example of this happening yet again.

TSA has blood on its head because in removing Dr. Thistle from the Howard Hospital under a 24 hour notice to get out, news has come out of Zimbabwe and news media have reported of many deaths that have resulted from the lack of needed surgery as a result of Dr. Thistle's removal without suitable replacement. Also the disruption in the administration of anteretroviral drugs will no doubt lead to many other HIV deaths as a result of inconsistent administration of those drugs which happened after the removal of Dr. Thistle from his medical practice by TSA.

I would also thank this website for allowing Major Dr. James Watt(R) and the previous poster to use this site to expose this situation, because any mention of this on IHQ's discussion forum has been removed. The censorship of this situation by IHQ has been abominable.

In Canada this situation has been protested from within and outside TSA to no avail. Dr. Thistle continues his calling as a doctor to the those who are among the poorest of the world's poor at the Karanda Mission hospital in Zimbabwe as a volunteer supported by many outside donors and a few Salvationists who know about this situation.

The Army's leadership reminds me of Caiaphas - it was expedient that one man should die for the sake of the nation. In this case it was expedient that Dr. Paul Thistle's officership should be terminated for the sake of maintaining the Army's protocol, procedure and power over an officer. The comparison also includes the lies and misinformation that have to be disseminated in such situations. The refusal to hold an external investigation into these circumstances allowed for cover-up of the truth. But truth always tends to eventually emerge.

Leadership will need to repent of their decisions and will be dealing with the fall-out for some time.

Anonymous said...

To the Commissioner:

I am an active officer of the Canada and Bermuda Territory. I love my job, I am thrilled for the opportunity to serve in the capacity I am - a Corps Officer in a rural setting.

You might wonder why someone like me would frequent a site such as this. It is because life has not always been so grand. I have been mistreated and my soul has been crushed. For a time I wondered if there was a way out. I felt like a failure to God, to my family and to The Salvation Army. It is hard to find a site with the words "Salvation Army" in them that is not as politically correct as your blog post. Unfortunately it serves no good purpose to a hurting and searching officer. This site provided respite when I most needed it.

I know many other hurting officers now. Not because they do not love their ministry, but because they feel judged and misunderstood by their divisional leadership and in some cases the territory. They cannot go to leadership because their views are either ignored or they are cautioned against expressing them. They do not know who they can trust if anyone.

My recommendation to you and to some other key leaders in your command is taken from scripture - you may find it familiar.

“Therefore, if you are offering your gift at the altar and there remember that your brother has something against you,leave your gift there in front of the altar. First go and be reconciled to your brother; then come and offer your gift.

Commissioner, you talk a lot about prayer, but first you need to reconcile with your officers.

Anonymous said...

Same active officer as above here. I wanted to add one more thing.

A very long time ago I felt muc the same way about our General Linda Bond as I do about you right now. In fact I swore if the lady ever became general I would resign.
There were limits!

A few years ago, before she became general, Linda made a profound influence in my life. I felt that she had truly felt the brokeness of the human condition. That she had truly changed. I never thought it was possible. One of the things she did was to apologize to those she had hurt. At this time we never dreamt she would become General, but God restored her fully and she is now in my eyes, a respectable leader.

What I'm trying to say, is that there is hope, you can, by the grace of God, do this. We might forgive you in our human strength, but God can work a miracle of restoration - he did for our General.

Anonymous said...

Dear Active,

I hate to say this, but I am afraid that we all have short memories the General included. I happen to know that Linda was very much complicit in the decision that people are writing about.

All of us who have been in positions of authority and power need to continually examine our hearts, not just once and for all.
That's why prayers of confession are needed daily.

Former Canada and Bermuda

Anonymous said...

Amen---I think the Army caved in here to a repressive regime. And as far as the high ranking Government Official who is a Salvationist--I would personally question how anyone in that government could claim to be a Christian when we view their repressiveness. Paul Thistle indeed is a shining example of a saint being sacrificed for politcal gain and expediancy. IHQ and Canadian THQ need to hang their head in shame.
John Stephenson
Canada and Bermuda

Anonymous said...

This fsaof blog and articles are fascinating, especially this one about attrition. The thinking person, no matter what country they are from, is seeing the same issues within TSA leadership everywhere. How can this be? Well you don't get to be the leaders unless you "sacrifice". What do you sacrifice? Everything that hints of reality.. Honesty, vulnerability, emotional health -( all things that lead to growth).. in today's TSA leadership it's about appearance.
I have previously been part of a "family" (aka Godfather style) who thrive in the system. For many years, any attempt at objective reflection with a view to healthy consideration has been labelled as negative or critical. A powerful mechanism - sometimes called denial. Powerful enough to block out sinful unethical immoral actions for the sake of the TSA machine.
The saddest thing is that this is not a local problem but endemic. And as i see it, the people with the power to change this, are the stakeholders in keeping things as they are.
To me it appears the TSA machine is becoming increasingly frantic in trying to keep the spin going. .... And the drums bang ever louder to drown out the beautiful silence heard in the peaceful heart that lives honestly......

Former Aust East

JoAnn Shade said...

Nearly 15 years ago, General Rader and then General Gowans set the Salvation Army on a path that had the potential to address some of the concerns from around the world concerning officer retention. In that process, they actually surveyed all officers, had a commission on officership that made a number of recommendations, and then the General issued a final paper on this, to be carried out in the territories around the world. The proposals included consultation on appointments, the potability of pensions, gender concerns, single spouse officership, etc. It appeared at that time to be a first step in addressing many of the issues. Sad to say, those recommendations have, for the most part, been disregarded in most territories. That exercise stands as a symbol to me that the "if it ain't broke, don't fix it' mentality continues to operate in TSA. It seemed as though Rader and Gowans knew that officership as it stood was in danger of breaking - and now, years later, that danger is even greater.
Retired (early)
USA East