SA Duty of Care of its
Expats
I received a message yesterday thanking the FSAOF for initiating expressions of concern to IHQ requesting their intervention in seeking the safe return of two ex-pat Salvation Army officers stationed in Simferopol (Russia) to their home base in Kiev, Ukraine. The officers, both Ukrainian nationals, felt themselves ‘abandoned’ during the recent Crimean conflict. They, alongside thousands of their fellow Ukrainians; tourists, residents in the region, military personnel and those traveling on business suddenly found themselves behind ‘enemy lines’ and immediately sought a return home. In the short span of a few days they became persons in a foreign land. However, their request for an immediate return home went unfulfilled for four long months. The IHQ initiative was not ours, however, perhaps our blogs focusing on Ukraine played a part?
I received a message yesterday thanking the FSAOF for initiating expressions of concern to IHQ requesting their intervention in seeking the safe return of two ex-pat Salvation Army officers stationed in Simferopol (Russia) to their home base in Kiev, Ukraine. The officers, both Ukrainian nationals, felt themselves ‘abandoned’ during the recent Crimean conflict. They, alongside thousands of their fellow Ukrainians; tourists, residents in the region, military personnel and those traveling on business suddenly found themselves behind ‘enemy lines’ and immediately sought a return home. In the short span of a few days they became persons in a foreign land. However, their request for an immediate return home went unfulfilled for four long months. The IHQ initiative was not ours, however, perhaps our blogs focusing on Ukraine played a part?
Within days of the Russian invasion banks were closed and
currency used to pay for petrol, a Big Mack or a tram ticket just yesterday was
no longer accepted as legal tender. The only accepted currency was the Russian
Ruble. In fact the city’s main fast food outlet, McDonalds, began packing up
their gear to head out of Dodge City as Russian tanks rolled across the city
square. Airports were closed down tight, railway service suspended and the FSS
(formerly Russian KGB Комитет государственной
безопасности (КГБ), came
a-calling on the SA officers in their quarters and in the office.
The
officers' Ukrainian surnames and noticeable accent when speaking Russian, was
considered offensive to the KGB and they made no secret that they wished the officers
would make a hasty departure from Crimea. They had not received a sufficient allowance
to pay for the emergency transport of their family, furniture or SA equipment.
In fact they went without any further funding for an additional two months, relying
solely on the money wired monthly via Western Union by the FSAOF (Former
Salvation Army Officers Fellowship) and one other private source. Our initials support was sent in the form of
wired funds to the SA but was soon changed to Dr. Igor whose Russian surname
caused less KGB interest.
Contact
from SA leaders was infrequent and no visits were made by either the RHQ Kiev,
Ukraine or THQ leaders Moscow, Russia (the TC was on holidays in the USA and
stayed put until the fighting ceased) Moneys received from the FSAOF allowed
them to purchase food for hundreds, including themselves, and to sustain Drs.
Igor and Elena and their free dental service to the poor, and fuel for Oleg's
old and rusty van, a ‘free’ service to the Army.
During
the 4 months they were behind unfriendly lines The Zuevs provided free
assistance to more than 400 Ukrainian military soldiers and officers including
a General ‘rescued’ by Captain Marina Zuev, all seeking a return to their home
land.. They provided clothing, food and safe houses as the Ukrainians sought to
escape the Russian troops who'd annexed the Ukrainian peninsula.
__________________________
"He who controls the past controls the future.” A George Orwell dictum
All bodies of authority and administration of the USSR Union, and autonomous republics, territories, regions, cities, districts, villages and settlements should ensure unfailing compliance with state-of-emergency regulations in keeping with the USSR law 'on the legal regime of a state of emergency' and with the state committee for the state of emergency's resolutions.
State of Emergency Committee; from Radio Moscow World - 19 August 1991
· A large number of tanks is heading towards Leningrad
· In Leningrad a demonstration of over 100,000 massed in Winter Palace Park
· Tanks are confirmed to be stopped outside Leningrad
We were glued to the radio and TV in our small flat trying to decipher the Russian news broadcast, and the 8:00 pm announced what many had forecast; “Gorby's under house arrest in the Crimea.”
An hour later we saw the visual report- The TV broadcast from Moscow showed a number of tanks with a column moving directly behind the USA Embassy compound at earlier that day, at lunchtime very near the Russian Parliament, just over the west wall from the townhouses inside the Embassy compound.
The Bely Dom, Russia's White House, was the seat of Soviet Russia's republic government. The Kremlin a few miles further down the Moscow River was the power center for the whole Union of Soviet Socialist Republics, and where the coup plotters were organizing. The Bely Dom was surrounded by tanks, and the tanks were surrounded by people scrambling to get onboard the tanks!
Just a few hours later came an update, we learned that tanks were nearing Leningrad and that a curfew would be imposes as well as a veil of silence. We’d been informed through official Soviet channels that all fax and photo copying machines would in short time be confiscated and turned in to the KGB. We were also warned that telephone service to the ‘west’ would be disrupted. It already took anywhere between 30 and 48 hours to connect, via Russian telephone operator, to a phone or fax machine in the ‘west’. And if the number called was busy or not answering one had to rebook the call and be prepared to wait up to another 48 hours. Could the service possibly be any worse?!
It would be another ten years before the internet and mobile phones became a routine part of one’s communication network.
The Russian Salvation Army staff in Leningrad, secretaries, social workers, translators and volunteers were informed that if they thought it best for their and their families’ safety to limit their association with us, or not continue to attend SA religious services we would fully understand. They did not need a second reminder.
If THQ Moscow had taken the time to read the SA
re-entry to Russia history, written by the 1991 pioneering team they’d realized the predicament in which they found themselves had already been played for them; they’d be moving forward in Ukraine instead of beating retreat! And the ex-pats would have
felt far less forgotten - less abandoned …




15 comments:
Sven,why not take the necessary time and write the story of the Army's return to Russia- I'm certain no one knows the history any better or can tell the story as well as you can. Maybe a team effort, you and Cathy? It would be a wonderful tribute to your grandparents early work in pioneering the Army work in in Russia 1917.
Chicago
My information is that the TC served in the Eastern Europe Territory for five years and that neither he or his wife bothered to learn the language. With no language skills it's virtually impossible to appreciate and move into the culture of a people. Consequently you'll always be a temporary plant from the west imposing your culture and values on them.
I recall a comment that all the expat officer from the HQ worship at the same corps but are unable to join in the singing or scripture reading because they can't read the cyrillic text. How difficult can that be? A few hours mandatory lessons per week will serve them well.
And here is a simple reminder. Raising your voice and barking orders does nothing in helping someone who doesn't know your language understand you any better. It only highlights one's lack of dignity and grace.
The typical assignment when completing a Russian tenure is a high THQ post in a large territory. In this recent reassignment we witness a five year Peter principle at play.
Good points all Sven
When will the SA learn that a 3 month introduction to culture and values precede taking up an appointment?
SA on assignment overseas
I am very pleased to see that someone has both the experience and ability to tell it as it is. We are sending out Major Peter Principle and his equally ill prepared colleagues and all too often the headway made by the pioneers slows to a trickle. Poor management, lack of creativity and courage find an escape under the bureaucracy banner.
Why not invest in sending those officers offering for overseas service to a professional team for training prior to their taking up management duties abroad. Yes, it's costly, but no more so than sending retiring officer couples to foreign lands for 'study visits' which are in fact simply a perk for lengthy service well done. Or cut back on the UKT DC Pakistani jaunts. Or how about the last minute sending out of all the Cadets to the European Congress?
Can you say "abuse of executive power" ?
London Former missionary
Here's a management training programme that might serve the Army well. Why not ask for a corporate discount based on the number of expected officer students over the course of 5 or 10 years.
INSEAD The Business School for the World
As one of the world’s leading and largest graduate business schools, INSEAD brings together people, cultures and ideas to change lives and to transform organisations. A global perspective and cultural diversity are reflected in all aspects of our research and teaching.
With campuses in Europe (France), Asia (Singapore) and Abu Dhabi, INSEAD’s business education and research spans three continents. Our 146 renowned Faculty members from 34 countries inspire more than 1,300 degree participants annually in our MBA, Executive MBA, Specialised Master’s degrees (Master in Finance, Executive Master in Consulting and Coaching for Change) and PhD programmes. In addition, more than 12,000 executives participate in INSEAD’s Executive Education programmes each year.
In addition to INSEAD’s programmes on our three campuses, INSEAD participates in academic partnerships with the Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania (Philadelphia & San Francisco); the Kellogg School of Management at Northwestern University near Chicago, and Johns Hopkins University/SAIS in Washington DC. In Asia, INSEAD partners with Tsinghua University in Beijing and with CEIBS. INSEAD is a founding member in the multidisciplinary Sorbonne University created in 2012, and also partners with Fundação Dom Cabral in Brazil.
INSEAD became a pioneer of international business education with the graduation of the first MBA class on the Fontainebleau campus in Europe in 1960. In 2000, INSEAD opened its Asia campus in Singapore. And in 2007 the school began an association in the Middle East, officially opening the Abu Dhabi campus in 2010.
Around the world and over the decades, INSEAD continues to conduct cutting edge research and to innovate across all our programmes to provide business leaders with the knowledge and sensitivity to operate anywhere. These core values have enabled us to become truly "The Business School for the World."
One comment- I served as a ex-pat officer in Russia under two different Commanders; different but identical. Both had that air of, I can't wait until my next step - UP!
USA East
When leaders don't "walk the talk" people lose faith and trust in them, and it's almost impossible to be recaptured. When staff sense an inconsistency it triggers a cascade of events.
It's best that expat leaders not use phrases like 'we are all equal' and follow that up by jetting off to an in-country conference, taxi to a 1st class hotel as the native officers, staff and soldiers travel by bus, train and are lodged in student guest houses. I remember Kiev 2012.
USA former ST
PLEASE NOTE - We will not post comments that identify any persons by name or those that are particularly offensive and critical of the SA without sufficient substantive backup information.
Sven Ljungholm
A Barma study concluded that 92% of Protestant ministers consider themselves leaders, though less than 2/3 of this pastors possess any discerable eldership skills. Being a competent Finance Secretary does not equate as a person with people or leadership skills. Try as you will sooner or later your weakness will be recognised. There's no shame in admitting that you lack all the skills and charisma necessary to successfully lead a team of SA officers in a foreign land.
Been there - WT.
I wonder if the leader who went fishing when tanks rolled into Leningrad in 1991 would have stayed in the boat if one of the anxious officers sat in Leningrad cut off from communicating with anyone outside Russia were his child? And I ask the same of the TC who couldn't be bothered to haste his return? Sure CNN's on the spot reporting in the Crimea should have raised the alarm. I'm guessing I know why both were returned home.
SA Toronto
I am very pleased to share that the recently appointed Regional Commanders, Kiev, visited Simferopol and replenished the much needed SA funds and officer allowance. Bank or wire transfers to the Crimea were suspended in February. The FSAOF July donation will in all probability be sent via a Yalta connection. A SA soldier whom I enrolled in 1992 and a local business owner.
One can only pray that the 30+ % inflation they were experiencing has slowed.
And equally heart warming was to learn that the new Commanders travelled by overnight train and met with the people to whom they're appointed to serve. May God richly bless them in their ministry.
Major Glad and I hope to connect with them when they visit the UK next month. We have about 12 -15 brass instruments that need delivering to the Kiev Lighthouse Corps.
Welcome news indeed-
UK officers heading for overseas appointments are all sent to cultural awareness classes for months prior to them arriving at their given destination. This has happened for at least the last twenty years that I am aware of. Officers are also given support to have a grounding in language too prior to leaving our shores. I would be very surprised if this were not so in other territories too and especially more affluent ones financially.
RTD UKT
I would like to add something to this article – Russian Army used unprecedented tactics during annexation of Crimea. They (Russian Army) gave modern weapon to drug addicts, alcoholics, criminals and other unemployed folks to act against Ukrainian unitary setup.
Also, Russia actively involved women and children for blocking Ukrainian military barracks (phenomenal tactics for a great nation).
Ukrainian government has submitted a number of cases to International Courts worth billions of dollars against Russian annexation of the Crimean peninsula. Russian economy will be in a deep trouble if Ukraine wins.
Coming back to SA officers being abandoned – it is absolutely unacceptable to leave members of staff abandoned on occupied territory full of armed criminals.
Thanks Sven for the article as it does not represent either of the sides.
I know of three recent cases of UK officers being appointed to senior leadership appointments on the continent. None, no one, nada were given any professional cross cultural or language training - simply not 'sop'; a SA myth!
I've been there; 6 years total and never met a single reinforcement officer who'd had any advance training. And worst of all are the Americans. At least those of us in the UK have some exposure to other cultures and languages in advance of being sent out.
UKT Officer
I would like to state here that the Overseas Department in the UKT is first class and extremely supportive of anyone going overseas. The so-called SA myth about language training is simply not true in all cases.
Former UKT, now elsewhere
TO: "The so-called SA myth about language training is simply not true in all cases."
You've been misinformed- I know of at least 15 instances where UK officers were sent to Russia, Latvia, Estonia, Ukraine and Moldova, make that 20, without any formal language training, and few if any took the necessary time to learn the language once in place. Demonstrates a rude indifference toward their host country and weakens their effectiveness; a barrier to cultural understanding and their mission.
1st hand experience
Post a Comment