Monday, June 16, 2014

CHANGING COURSE - A SALVATION ARMY ETHICS PRIMER 101- Lesson 3 The locus of Right and Wrong based solely on the consequences






Utilitarian Ethics

Utilitarianism is an ethical theory that places the decision of right and wrong solely on the outcomes (consequences) of choosing one action/policy over other actions/policies. As such, it moves beyond the scope of one's own interests and takes into account the interests of others. A simple definition: utilitarianism refers to "the Greatest Happiness Principle" -- it seeks to promote achieving happiness for the largest number of people.

Utilitarian Ethics places the locus of right and wrong solely on the outcomes (consequences) of choosing one action over other actions seeking the greatest good for the greatest number. As such, it moves beyond the scope of one's own interests and takes into account the interests of others.  

Criticisms of this view point to the difficulty of ascertaining full knowledge and certainty of the consequences of our actions. Another weakness in utilitarianism is that in order to achieve ‘the greatest good for the greatest number’ it allows more and more ethical exceptions, and ‘unjust rules’ according to the principle of utility. For example, slavery in Africa might be right if it led to an overall achievement of happiness for poor families to afford to purchase inexpensive chocolate for their children at the expense of some mistreated African individuals; collateral damage – minimum hurt….

Collateral or incidental damage refers to the accidental or unintentional killing or wounding and/or destruction to unintended property during the legitimate pursuit of ‘the greater good’. An example is in fisheries where the by catch of species such as dolphins are called collateral mortality; i.e., they are species that die in pursuit of the legal fishery targets, such as tuna.



In 1996, 75 percent of USA surveyed organizations said they had no bullying in their organization, executives in sum denied that it existed. In a more recent survey (April 2014) by the Workplace Bullying Institute (WBI) more than 65 million American workers are affected by what is called the American Cancer and public awareness is 72 percent.

Bullying is a growing issue in our culture — in schools, businesses, organizations, families and communities. It is also a major problem in churches and other religious organizations. It often hides in the shadows of being the Christian thing to do, it’s politically right or, it gets us back on the right track.

Has bullying increased in the workplace or have we finally given this unethical practice its rightful name? According to Dr. Gary Namie (co-founder of WBI), the three verticals with the highest percentage of bullying are government, medicine and education. Can it be that religious institutions were excluded from the survey simply we’re immune from such unchristian behavior?

In real numbers, approximately 9.8 million workers are currently experiencing bullying at work by 74,000 bullies. This means that each bully is responsible for 132 direct targets. It doesn’t add up because … bullies don’t admit or see themselves as bullies.
Their behavior is irrational and insidious.

The prevalence of bullying, resorting to aggressive physical force, threats or coercion to intimidate and abuse employees has reached unprecedented proportions. And in a survey reported by Forbes, conducted in 2010 thirty five per cent of the American workforce (or 53.5 million people) has directly experienced bullying–or “repeated mistreatment by one or more employees that takes the form of verbal abuse, threats, intimidation, humiliation or sabotage of work performance”. And more than 70% of those bullies are bosses.

Church bullying is growing across the country as churches struggle with declining attendance, finances, commitment and community impact.
Many Christian leaders are authoritarian bullies practicing the art of bullying themselves, demanding obedience and discouraging dissent.

The message is all too plain:  Bible rhetoric that is calculated intimidation. A bullying senior officer finds ways to intimidate DHQ and field staff members to establish control over them. In a non-SA setting the person who is the object of the bullying has three choices: submit, run away, or fight back, but none of these standard responses offer a solution or opportunity of compromise. Submit or be damned!

“He has a great reputation as being a highly effective administrator, but is completely clueless on how to supervise or motivate any of us long term ”.


But his two 'wacky'  behaviors literally destroyed the confidence and effectiveness of a well working diverse team; 20 corps in a metropolitan area, a large PR and fund raising department, creative arts department, large social service departments, and more than 500 persons in total in the Division.

His was a brilliant and tactical mind able to quickly recognize and recommend solutions to the score of menial and complex challenges landing on his desk each morning. The mental and emotional abuse levied on his staff members was well hidden. His impressive effectiveness at running a tight and productive ship was commented on by THQ, he told us. But, was it only a matter of time before the abuse would become known?

More on Utilitarianism tomorrow and Case Study Three

Sven Ljungholm










6 comments:

Nancy Sampson said...

This article is excellent and pertinent. Bullying is very real within The Salvation Army and tolerated. Unfortunately, the issue is not fully addressed and it is questionable as to whether or not bullying is even recognized as being wrong behavior. For those who have been bullied in the organization the pain is very real and irreversible. It is not only the behavior of the perpetrator (the bully), but the dismissal by administration as to the importance of the infraction. Often it appears as if The Salvation Army operates in its own sphere not being impressed by the potential legal ramifications of the bullying offense. School systems have zero tolerance policies in place and the backing of state laws. Other religious institutions are now forming committees setting up severe punishments for those who bully whether they are fellow clergy or parishioners. The Episcopal Diocese of Newark has taken a stand about the issue of bullying and this is spreading around the country. It is time for The Salvation Army to remove those from the officership ranks who bully other officers. It is only humane to take this action.

FORMER SALVATION ARMY OFFICERS FELLOWSHIP said...

Dear " Unfortunately, the issue is not fully addressed and it is questionable as to whether or not bullying is even recognized as being wrong behaviour."

We invite your furthers comments once you've read the 2nd part of the bullying article.

Anonymous said...

Thank you FSAOF- It's about time someone introduced the abuse committed in its many forms within the Salvation Army.

"Doing the most good"? It may appear so to those watching from the outside. But inside we're not much different from other religious organisations even including those with no particular conscience or virtue ethics.: maximising their ROI (return on investments)

Please keep reporting

SA corps officer

Mark Vanover said...

Sven.... Having been an officers kid and moving so often I was bullied in school everywhere we lived... Sadly I can recall overhearing conversations my officer parents had about some divisional officers and commanders, that as I reflect back on were clearly bullies. I personally experienced bullying by officers at every level of service in the army, from my time as a corp helper, to training school, to officership (ultimately the reason we left officership), to our recent return to "officership" that ultimately ended in less than a year largely because I stood up to the bullies. I can safely say that everyone of my officer friends has experienced bullying by a superior officer in one form or another at one time or another in their career, because the quasi military format and hierarchy structure of the organization lend themselves to multiple opportunities to bully, or be bullied. It is one of the most ungodly behaviors that ministers of the Gospel could allow themselves to practice, yet in an environment that would seem to encourage and even promote such behavior it has almost become the norm and could in fact advance you up the proverbial ladder and seemingly often does.

Mark Vanover
Former Officer USA East

Anonymous said...

The question as to whether or not some people even realize that what they do is bullying is pertinent. What is clearly bullying and abusive behaviour to me seems lost on some officers. I am not sure why that is since we have policies and training programs within our territory to make sure that people know that this is not acceptable. I think in many cases that people act out of their own weakness and deficiencies. Some officers feel like they need to "be somebody" because deep down they feel worthless. Most times this has nothing to do with the Army. It is often psychological and emotional needs that have been present for years and left unattended.

I know of some officers who are quick to point out abuse of authority by DHQ and THQ personnel, but fail to recognize it in their own lives. I see some officers writing articles about what it means to treat people with respect and humility, but yet they come off as the most arrogant and disrespectful people around. If we want to talk about humble leaders, let's look at ourselves.

Active Officer
C&B Territory

Anonymous said...

Whatever happened to 'discipleship'? I'm shocked reading about all this bullying on a christian church blog, especially a salvation army blog, where people are supposed to act out christianity to a greater extent than other denominations, according to their reputation for good works and their motto 'doing the most good' - which in itself is hardly a biblical focus. Being a christian is much different to being a disciple. Perhaps if discipleship courses were mandatory for both officers and lay people, you wouldn't be in this sad, unchristian position. If the leaders are rotten, what hope is there for the sheep?
Disciples aim to be like Jesus - they ask 'what would Jesus do?' in the circumstances they face. They act like the disciples in the early church, sitting at the foot of Jesus and drinking in His advice and example. They aim to be people of compassion, acting out all that the Lord taught when He was here last. He IS coming again - do you officers and soldiers want to be known as christians or disciples? The choice is yours. The wrong one will ignite the Father's anger, and we know what happens then, don't we? God is not only a God of love, He is a jealous God, and metes out judgment on those He deems unworthy. Perhaps a starting point would be for the whole of the salvation army to read psalm 119. It's a great psalm to focus the spirit. Good works without substantial faith is dead.
I do think your love of all that is 'the salvation army' has gotten in the way of what should be the true path - of following the Lord's example. If everyone did this, the rest would fall into place. Sorry for the criticism, but something basic is obviously wrong.