CASE STUDY 1.
ETHICS IS ALL ABOUT
CHOICES
The town center had long offered its residents and visitors alike a 800 yard ‘walking street’, antique shops, florists, butchers and candle stick makers. Dusk heralded the gaslight’s flickering and strolling window shoppers of all ages and nationalities. Motorized delivery traffic was allowed only between 22:00 and 07:00.
One
of the regulars on the walking street would be seen every weekday morning
between 08:35 and 08:40 like clock work! In fact his one regular habit was to
stop in front of the jewelry shop and there, check the time on his watch with
the time on the big clock in the store window. He did so day in day out, week
after week.
One
morning the jewelry store owner was outside his shop sweeping the sidewalk, as
they do in some of these quaint serendipitous villages as the man approached,
checked the time on the clock in the window, and then set his watch
accordingly.
The
jeweler approached the man and said, “I’ve seen you stopping in front of my
store more times than I can remember, checking the time on my clock and setting
the time on your watch – time must be very important to you”. “Oh indeed it
is”, replied the man, “especially the accuracy! You see I’m the foreman at the
big plant at the edge of town, and hundreds of people depend me to keep
accurate time every day. Because at 4:00 PM each day I blow the quitting
whistle and work ceases for the day…”|
“Now,
isn’t that a coincidence? You see I wait until around 3:55 every afternoon and
listen for the factory whistle and immediately set the clock in the window to
4:00 PM”!
Each person valued time and accuracy, but by relying on non-reliable sources could have been off by several valuable minutes.
_______________________________
By
what ethical compass or moral measure ought Salvationists establish our individual
and corporate values/standards?
Ethics (value choices) centers on what are good and acceptable principles for individuals, organizations, and society and is culturally driven, affect how people make value decisions and lead their lives. Sociology, the fundamental character or spirit of a culture is the underlying sentiment that informs the beliefs, customs, or practices of a group or society; the dominant spirit or disposition of the group. The term is derived from the Greek word ethos which can mean custom, habit, character or the spirit of a people; the characteristic spirit of a culture, era, or community as manifested in its attitudes, values and life styles.
Ethics (value choices) centers on what are good and acceptable principles for individuals, organizations, and society and is culturally driven, affect how people make value decisions and lead their lives. Sociology, the fundamental character or spirit of a culture is the underlying sentiment that informs the beliefs, customs, or practices of a group or society; the dominant spirit or disposition of the group. The term is derived from the Greek word ethos which can mean custom, habit, character or the spirit of a people; the characteristic spirit of a culture, era, or community as manifested in its attitudes, values and life styles.
The
‘ethical action’ maxim refers to the series of rules provided to an individual or
institution by an external source, and in the Salvationist’s instance, the
outside sources are typically represented by our culture, profession education,
and religious instructions, understanding and adoption.
The
Salvation Army is active in more than 100 countries. Consequently, one can say
without fear of contradiction, that what is ethically acceptable in one country
according to local SA values may not be in dozens of others.
EXAMPLES
In
some countries the SA raises funds through the sale of lotto tickets in corps
and institutions. In some, alcohol is made available at SA sponsored social
events and at wedding receptions celebrating the marriage of Salvationists.
Some SA corps and institutions celebrate the sacraments of communion and
baptism. And an increasing number of Salvationists question the Army’s long
held conviction of abstinence. A cursory glance of the world’s most popular
social networking sites,
some already 30 years old, will reveal thousands
of Salvos are signed on to Facebook’s online networking. And many wonder if
it’s socially acceptable in this day and age to be pictured with a glass of
wine, cordial or beer at a palm fringed resort – or is it a sign of rebellion
or of ‘coming out’?
Have we taken our eye off the immovable symbols to which our
standards have been grounded since our founding? Are we, like the characterS on
the ‘walking street’ listening to or watching the wrong sources?
The Greek philosopher Socrates claimed that “the unexamined life
is not worth living,” and this statement captures the essence of an ethical
life. Each day each one of those faces innumerable questions that were down to
a choice of values: how should I live my life? In the intro to the textbook
Contemporary Issues in Business Ethics we’re challenged: “Answering these
questions is unavoidable: we either go through life explicitly answering these
questions, or we implicitly answer them
by the choices we make each day.”
Ethics in our instance refers at its simplest to a system
of moral principles, impacted and formed primarily by one’s culture, in and
outside the Salvation Army (church), and our ethics are dependent on others
within our culture/society/church for definition. Sometimes morality becomes watered
down and tends to
be consistent within a certain context and experience, and can vary between
contexts. A person can follow ethical principles but not have any expressed morals
at all; amoral – indifferent to right or wrong choices. Conversely, the moral
person could violate ethical principles
within a given system of rules in order to maintain moral integrity.
(Approve
of or participate in culturally accepted practices: Abortion, Social drinking. Apartheid,
Child labor, Same sex unions, Abuse of Power, Rights of minorities, Rights of
work place subordinates, etc.)
Ethics refer to the intellectual and academic discipline
infusing our debates and action on topics management encounters regularly, like
human rights and professional conduct. We hold that all ethical beliefs and
values are relative to one’s own culture, religion and beliefs and is nothing
more than spirit or custom.
Ethics, personal or in the corporate setting covers the
following common dilemmas:
- How to live a good life
• Our rights
and responsibilities
• The
language of right and wrong
• Moral
decisions - what is good and bad?
• Situational
control
• Equality
• Etc.
In order to avoid the tragic consequences of the factory
timekeeper and the jewelry store-owner we will begin our investigation and
practice of philosophical ethics by developing a clear understanding of the
society in which we live - and the desired new society requiring changes in
customarily accepted behavior.
End Part One
Tomorrow: UTILITARIAN - MAXIMIZING THE OVERALL GOOD





2 comments:
Where's the beef, Sven?! Give it to us straight!
USA East
I can't help feeling that human ethics is a hindrance to the Christian life: the answers to all life's questions are found in the Bible if we dig deep enough. Certainly I have found it so in my personal life. God has not short-changed His people on the advice front, even though the advice is not always welcome, and entails sacrifice. I am always in awe when I listen to a sermon which expounds Bible truths and links events together to clarify some of the Bible's mysteries (sadly these sermons are rare in SA meetings).
Our modern reliance on human ethics and philosophers has diluted our Christian inheritance and has resulted in the moral confusion we see around us today, especially in the church. Although I am not much of a traditionalist, I would echo the words of the old chorus:
Go back to the old wells, where the waters are sweet.
Go back to the old wells, where joy and duty meet.
The waters of the old wells will your spirit restore:
Go right back to the dear old wells:
Leave them no more.
I'm too young to be very sure what the 'old wells' actually were - but the essence of the chorus seems to be the old, traditional Christian ways, where life was simpler and decisions were made according to God's Word, and not open to the human interpretation which confuses Christians today.
Post a Comment