A SALVATION ARMY ETHICS
PRIMER 101- Lesson 2
LEADERSHIP magazine published
a very insightful article on church leaders by Eric Reed and Collin Hansen
entitled Pastors as Leaders. I found it enlightening in preparing for the FSAOF
leaders and abuse series for several reasons; I related directly to many of the
observations through my own both experience, but also because all senior SA
leaders will have evolved through the ‘pastoring process’ described in the
article. SA leaders progress to leadership roles primarily through a series of
roles that include on-the-job training and education to ever-increasing level
of managerial responsibility. Few officers have a university degree or advance level diploma in corporate management or administration.
Joseph Stowell, former president
of Moody Bible Institute, moved on from there after an eight year tenure and
is now in the business of building ministry leaders, and "business is booming".
In fact a ‘google’ search listed more than 1,200 recent books and articles on leadership and church management, and most tend to emphasize business
terminology, suggesting that today's pastors, administrators and regional
managers focus on: ‘managing church in line with corporate business practices’.
Stowell believes in strong
leadership, but concedes that many pastors are “not leaders in the business
kind of way. Perhaps we have taken more the corporate model of leadership and
imposed that into pastoral ministry, as if Jack Welch (the then head of GE)
were the premium pastor in America," Stowell said. “They can't live up to
that standard".
Researcher George Barna
concluded that by contemporary models of leadership, a significant number of
pastors are not leaders. Barna said 92
percent of Protestant ministers consider themselves leaders, though less
than 60 percent of those pastors actually possess leadership skills.
"This research does not
criticize the heart or ministry of pastors, it simply affirms that they will
have their most positive effect through the exercise of other gifts and
offices," Barna told a pastors group. "Pastors are good people,
well-educated and called to ministry, but perhaps not to the ministry of
leadership."
The Enronian Era’s Damage
"We live in a world
where leaders are tarnished," Stowell said. "We have a cynical view
of political and corporate leaders, especially after Enron". Many corporate leaders have exchanged their pinstriped Brooks Brothers' suits for prison striped overalls! And the limo seats for a seat on the correctional services bus bench.
"People long to have someone they can look to and trust.”
Should that not be an absolute ‘given’ in church leadership? Church staff and subordinate leaders want desperately to trust their spiritual leaders.
"People long to have someone they can look to and trust.”
Should that not be an absolute ‘given’ in church leadership? Church staff and subordinate leaders want desperately to trust their spiritual leaders.
Many church leaders (SA
officers) quite frankly, tend to overrate their leadership and management capability and success. By what parameters does one
measure success in managing ‘church’? Is there a church management roadmap
or a paradigm schematic booklet: ‘Managing a Denominational Regional Office (DHQ) for Dummies!”
Success
My adage in defining success when
teaching MBA courses in a New England university was; “Success is the Realization
of a Worthy Goal”. And I would spend whatever time necessary and explain in detail that one
needs to understand, clarify and differentiate between personal and corporate
success. While there are several common characteristics, the most important and
key universal constant found in both are core values and moral principles.
Few ethical values are as
universally recognized as honesty in the business world and an assumed quality
in Christian leaders. Yet, it’s the one rule that is probably broken more than
any other.
Ethics is not only about the morality of particular courses of action, but it's also about the goodness, the moral fibre of individuals and what it means to live a virtuous life: the moral character lived out in human beings. One would think that ALL successful leaders, particularly those working in the Lord’s name and field, would not need constant reminding -
Ethics is not only about the morality of particular courses of action, but it's also about the goodness, the moral fibre of individuals and what it means to live a virtuous life: the moral character lived out in human beings. One would think that ALL successful leaders, particularly those working in the Lord’s name and field, would not need constant reminding -
"My thoughts are nothing like your
thoughts," says the Lord. "And my ways are far beyond anything you
could imagine. For just as the heavens are higher than the earth, so my ways
are higher than your ways and my thoughts higher than your thoughts."
— Isaiah 55:8-9
CASE STUDY 2.
An
Officer couple with two children, and with more than 20 years of field and
headquarters experience, received ‘marching orders’ to take up new appointments
in a DHQ in a Division 200 miles distant. One of the children, 15 years old,
was disabled and wheelchair-bound. DHQ was aware that special provisions would
need to be made and a minimum attempt had been made to accommodate the child’s
needs – an additional hand-rail leading to the 2nd floor, where three bedrooms
were located, was installed.
On
arrival at the new quarters the officers noticed that they were far from being
ready for occupancy. The DC was too busy to personally welcome the newly
arrived officers and left the ‘welcome’ duties to his spouse. The couple
expressed their disappointment about the condition of the ‘home’ and asked if
measurements had been made to ensure wheelchair-accessibility on both the
bottom and 2nd floor levels? “No we hadn’t thought of that…” Further question
were raised but the DHQ officer had no time for further discussion as a
grandchild’s birthday party was scheduled.
The
newly arrived officers were booked into a nearby hotel remaining there for the
time necessary to complete the repairs and renovations to the quarters.
The
couple met the DC when he visited with them a few days later and he was
sympathetic and eager to make the family feel comfortable. The newly arrived
officer expressed her concern that the house was very small, especially as the
tiny room that was expected to serve as a dining room would need to be
converted to a work/study area for the disabled child – he needed to be within
the immediate vicinity/contact of a parent in case of an emergency; frequent
falls requiring medical care and medication.
The
officers were assured by the DC that DHQ had foreseen this problem and would
seek funding from THQ to build an adequately sized conservatory- Florida room
directly behind the ‘dining room’ extending into the ample sized back yard..
Weeks later, and without any word or action by
DHQ, the officer spoke with a colleague in the THQ property department
wondering if he could provide an update on the dining room ‘extension’?
The THQ officer friend informed the couple that the DC knew full well that all
funding for such projects had been halted a year earlier and no recommendation
for such construction would be considered; case closed!
(DHQ location on file)
_________________________________
|
Some will argue that
dishonesty is sometimes justifiable, especially when the truth might cause
someone harm. However, dishonesty is much more troubling, and unjustified, when
it benefits oneself at the expense of another. In such cases honesty overrides
any consideration of self-interest. The above is just such a case - A DC who deliberately misled officers transferred in to serve alongside the DHQ team. Shameful and reprehensible!
Beware that the ends do not
justify the means - many teach that ethics should lead people to ‘decisions’
without necessarily arriving at a ‘ethical conclusion’. In this view, the role of ethics is
limited to clarifying 'what's at stake' in particular ethical problems absent a
value systems that can be applied to a particular problem. Can a church leaders ever be forgiven for this type shaky rationale?
- It was step one that led many to an ongoing lack of trust and which exists to this day - And the euphemism mentioned a few days back fits this DC just like a proctologist's glove!
FSAOF
UK.






12 comments:
Why aren't you lecturing at every CFOT?
Thank you for bringing this troubling and long hidden SA leadership weakness to light. Now how does one get the abuse issues under the noses of THQ and the perpetrators?
I loved the witty glove reference!
Please keep adding to the 'charges' and you'll soon have a booklet ready for SP&S release. Thank you FSAOF.
CO US Midwest
How can never-challenged church executives be made to see the harm they’ve caused, and what steps can be taken to ensure they stop their damaging and destructive behaviour?
Salvationist and SA employee- From the UK residing in the USA
There is not much information on how to handle this type of behavior so I really appreciate your writing this because it will be help to others.
I just wanted you to know how much I appreciate your series and reading your warnings to others on what to look for and what to do….very clear. Not only a Salvation Army problem.
UK Baptist
I would like to take this opportunity to say just how much I really enjoƴ checking out the FSAOF blog posts. They never сease to challenge me and make me think.
God bless you.
Anonymous,
"Now how does one get the abuse issues under the noses of THQ and the perpetrators?"
Dare I say by calling out the abuse directly to the abuser's face! No need to live with an abusive HQ Officer.
It's not just that there are abusive leaders, their policies around officer 'discipline' are abusive. Any officer can be accused of something by a member or employee and it's assumed guilty until proven innocent. None of the principles of natural justice are applied to the process - the officer has no representation, not allowed to talk to anyone and isolated at home while investigated. Although they can ask for others to be questioned, they're not allowed to talk to them first so that when the questions come from the investigators, the others questioned have no idea the context. When you try to defend yourself and add context, you are accused of "not taking ownership" of the problem. You are judged by a secret group that no one knows who is in it aside from the Chief and Pers.Sec, and you are not allowed to sit in front of them and answer questions. You cannot face your accuser. You cannot offer conflicting evidence. The people judging you could have a bias against you if they perhaps don't like you or have clashed with you in the past.
All of this flies in the face of justice, dignity and respect for a Covenanted people.
And I dare not give my name because there will be punishment as I am an active officer.
In one division I know of, the dc has been in place for several years. He has been dishonest and still treats people horribly, depending on who you are. Field officers record conversations with this DC, because of the way this person operates. Officers at DHQ who have served under him request to be moved. Long term employees are "encouraged" to retire. Some employees are afraid daily that they will be fired. The only way to stay in his good graces is to be like him, and suck up- and this does not always help. Many letters, phone calls, face to face conversations have been made with the powers that be at THQ-they are completely aware but do nothing.. so he remains. Not a nice person, and integrity severely lacking. How do you encourage an entire group of people who have not been shown Jesus? How do you reassure them that not every officer is this way- when this is what they have known from this dc and a couple other dhq officers currently serving in the same location?
When HQ uses the abbreviation HR human resources I don´t know if I shall laugh or cry. And we have a leadership in many territories that prefer lies, or at least white lies instead of facing the truth.
Former Scandinavia.
I do agree - The Salvation Army lacks integrity at higher level. This is not a blanket criticism, as I would guess most officers are truthful, trustworthy and operate with integrity. But there are some who are not only dishonest, but lack any biblical respect for what we are supposed to stand up for.
We have to be faithful in the little things first, as anyone who has read the Jungle Doctor books will know!
The persons who posted the comments:
1. It's not just that there are abusive leaders, their policies around officer 'discipline' are abusive. Any officer can be accused of something by a member or employee and it's assumed guilty until proven innocent. None of the principles of natural justice are applied to the process - the officer has no representation, not allowed to talk to anyone and isolated/restricted to their home while investigated.
Although they can ask for others to be questioned, they're not allowed to talk to them first so that when the questions come from the investigators, the others questioned have no idea the context. When you try to defend yourself and add context, you are accused of "not taking ownership" of the problem. You are judged by a secret group that no one knows who is in it aside from the Chief and Pers.Sec, and you are not allowed to sit in front of them and answer questions. You cannot face your accuser. You cannot offer conflicting evidence. The people judging you could have a bias against you if they perhaps don't like you or have clashed with you in the past.
All of this flies in the face of justice, dignity and respect for a Covenanted people.
And I dare not give my name because there will be punishment as I am an active officer.
Saturday, 14 June, 2014
2. Anonymous said...
In one division I know of, the dc has been in place for several years. He has been dishonest and still treats people horribly, depending on who you are. Field officers record conversations with this DC, because of the way this person operates. Officers at DHQ who have served under him request to be moved. Long term employees are "encouraged" to retire. Some employees are afraid daily that they will be fired. The only way to stay in his good graces is to be like him, and suck up- and this does not always help. Many letters, phone calls, face to face conversations have been made with the powers that be at THQ-they are completely aware but do nothing.. so he remains. Not a nice person, and integrity severely lacking. How do you encourage an entire group….
************************
Please contact me privately - Your identity will be kept private - we need to talk, Sven
Post a Comment