Monday, July 9, 2012


In July of 1996 my husband, Steve, and I, along with our two sons, Matthew and Timothy, moved from Canada to South Carolina, where he has been working under the North American Free Trade Act (NAFTA) at a small, Christian university.  Under the terms of the act, our sons and I were considered dependents and not eligible to work for monetary compensation.  When we moved here, Timothy was just shy of his 4th birthday, and Matthew was 8 ½ years old. Each year we had the option to apply to U.S Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) for an extension of our stay, which is what we have been doing annually.

Matthew, our eldest, is autistic. When he turned 21 yrs., he was no longer able to be claimed as a dependent, even though he is and will be all his life.  At that time, USCIS sent us notification of that fact, and after several months of high-stressed phone calls, letters, and appeals, we were finally given the option of changing Matthew’s status to that of a B-2, ‘visitor for pleasure’. This change required us to submit a request for a renewal of the visa every 6 months, accompanied by a dossier that was over 100 pages. This dossier included copies of Matthew’s initial diagnosis from the Montreal Children’s Hospital, psychological evaluations from the school district in Greenville, SC., Individual Education Plans that showed his level of operating, which is approximately at the level of a 7 year old, and a two-page letter explaining what the documents meant, as well as why it would be detrimental to our son and our family if Matthew were not permitted to remain with us. It was a bit of an ordeal to repeat this routine every 6 months (i.e.., submitting the new application and $300). However, we took it in our stride. 

Last week (on July 2) we received a letter from USCIS, which stated that Matthew’s current request (for an extension of stay from July 1st until Dec. 31st) was rejected, and that he must leave the country immediately. Matthew only operates on about a 7 year old level. Where is he supposed to go without any fore notice?! Who rips a 7 year old away from his family? I am physically ill with the stress of this unexpected denial for Matthew to remain in the US with the rest of our family.  The notice stated that “USCIS, in its discretion, has determined that you have had sufficient time to accomplish the purpose for which you were admitted and you have not established a timely departure date.”   We were shocked!  What are they talking about?! He wasn’t suddenly ‘admitted’ as a ‘visitor for pleasure’; he has been here since we moved here. Furthermore, what ‘purpose’ was he supposed to have accomplished?  This change of status was to enable him to remain with his family! Plus, they never told us that at the time, nor did we receive any notice of that until the recent letter, that we had to provide a specific date for the family departing from the US.  Steve is a tenured professor, his contract is renewed on a yearly basis, and we had planned to continue living in South Carolina for another 10-12 years (basically, until his retirement) prior to returning to Canada. Because of the process of the annual contract being renewed, we would not know in advance how many years that offer of employment would continue.

Our first step was contact with Steve’s boss. On Thursday, July 5th, the Provost (of the university where Steve works) contacted the lawyer the university uses for immigration information; however, he is not an immigration lawyer. Following the discussion with the lawyer, the Provost sent us an email with a paraphrase of the lawyer’s response.  The lawyer was not hopeful; but he provided some suggestions, and we are taking it from there.
Our next step is to contact USCIS to get some clarification regarding the letter they sent. We have an option to make a motion to reopen the case—if we can prove they made the decision contrary to the law, or if we have supplementary information.  We have already been sending them a dossier that’s over 100 pages every 6 months, with his medical diagnosis, psych. evaluations from the school district, etc. What other supplementary information could we supply that would change the outcome of the decision?  The other possibility that we also intend to pursue is the currently hot topic re: the President’s Dream Act. This declaration was made official on June 15, 2012, but the Government needs time to put in place a procedure for enforcing or applying it. They have 60 days to do so from June 15th, and then the young folks (under age 30) who are in deportation proceedings will be processed first. By September, USCIS will undoubtedly be swamped with applications. We believe that our sons qualify, including Matthew, because they meet the criteria that are outlined. So, if we do not have a satisfactory response to our motion to reopen Matthew’s case, then the next step would be to make the application for him under the Dream Act. The Dream Act would allow him to remain for a 2 yr. period, with the possibility for renewal at the end of that time frame.  In addition to these two ideas, we have both been researching on the Internet—Steve is focused on the legal information; I’m focused on finding agencies that may help (e.g., advocacy groups for individuals with disabilities, and the Canadian embassy, which was recommended by one of the advocacy groups that I contacted in Columbia this morning, etc.)

After the initial shock, we posted on Face Book and have sent emails requesting prayer support and suggestions.  We have received several additional suggestions (e.g., contacting the media & senators, and the autism society).  I am following through on some of these suggestions, as well as contacting some advocacy groups that I’ve discovered. If none of these steps that we are pursuing works out, we will need to seriously consider some of the suggestions we received, such as getting the media and politicians involved. We had been planning to stay here at least another 7-10 yrs. We certainly want to remain here until Timothy finishes his education. He begins his 3rd yr of university next month, but he may want to continue his education to get his masters & PhD.
We definitely need a solution that provides us with legally being able to keep Matthew with us and for a longer time frame than 6 month visas for Matthew, which we were only able to renew a few times. Pray that God will open hearts and doors so that our family may remain intact…and for our peace of mind and heart. Suggestions are also welcome.

Thank you.  

Many blessings.
Elizabeth Hayduk





Former Salvation Army Officer,
Canada and Berumuda








ADDENDUM JULY 10


After supper this evening I had a call from the Constitutional Rep. from Senator Lindsey Graham's office, South Carolina. The advocacy agency lady from this morning's contact obviously followed through with her promise to contact the senator's office on our behalf. So, after a brief phone conversation, he emailed an 'authorization' form, which we had to print out, fill in, sign, & scan. That's when we ran into a problem: trying to fig. out how the scanner works w/my newer computer (we hadn't yet used it). We also scanned & sent copies of the notice that we received from USCIS (immigration), & a copy of the covering letter that we filed with the application to request an extension of stay. Thanks for the continuing prayers. We'll see what happens next.


Elizabeth 

2 comments:

Anonymous said...

Dear Elizabeth,

I have no suggestions past contacting your two U.S. Senators and district House Rep but it looks like you're already taking that course so I wish you the best outcome possible on that one. I will also put you on my prayer list starting tonight. God Bless You and your family as you seek to do his will.

Daryl Lach
USA Central

Anonymous said...

Anymore updates that you can share, sessionmate?