Thursday, July 1, 2010

RETURN THE NOBEL PEACE PRIZE

Reality check: Obama’s foreign policy
“The Norwegian Nobel Committee has decided that the Nobel Peace Prize for 2009 is to be awarded to President Barack Obama for his extraordinary efforts to strengthen international diplomacy and cooperation between peoples.”

Time for a reality check! Mort Zuckerman recently wrote an article in which he does an overview of Obama’s foreign policies a year and a half after the above announcement from the Norwegian Nobel Committee. Here are some excerpts from the article, slightly edited and subheadings are mine:

“America right now appears to be unreliable to traditional friends, compliant to rivals, and weak to enemies. One renowned Asian leader stated recently at a private dinner in the United States, "We in Asia are convinced that Obama is not strong enough to confront his opponents, but we fear that he is not strong enough to support his friends."

The reviews of Obama's performance have been disappointing. He has seemed uncomfortable in the role of leading other nations, and often seems to suggest there is nothing special about America's role in the world. The global community was surprised by his gratuitous criticisms of and apologies for America's foreign policy under the previous administration of George W. Bush. One Middle East authority, Fouad Ajami, pointed out that Obama seems unaware that it is bad form and even a great moral lapse to speak ill of one's own tribe while in the lands of others.

Obama & Britain
Even in Britain, for decades our closest ally, the talk in the press—supported by polls—is about the end of the "special relationship" with America.

Obama & France
French President Nicolas Sarkozy openly criticized Obama for months, including a direct attack on his policies at the United Nations. Sarkozy cited the need to recognize the real world, not the virtual world, a clear reference to Obama's speech on nuclear weapons.

Obama & Russia
Vladimir Putin of Russia has publicly scorned a number of Obama's visions.

Obama & China
Relations with the Chinese leadership got off to a bad start with the president's poorly-organized visit to China, where his hosts treated him disdainfully and prevented him from speaking to a national television audience of the Chinese people. The Chinese behavior was unprecedented when compared to visits by other U.S. presidents.

Obama & Afghanistan
Obama's policy on Afghanistan—supporting a surge in troops, but setting a date next year when they will begin to withdraw—not only gave a mixed signal, but provided an incentive for the Taliban just to wait us out. The withdrawal part of the policy was meant to satisfy a domestic constituency, but succeeded in upsetting all of our allies in the region. Further anxiety was provoked by Obama's severe public criticism of Afghan President Hamid Karzai and his coterie of family and friends for their lackluster leadership, followed by a reversal of sorts regarding the same leaders.

Obama & Iran (and Turkey & Brazil)
Recent U.S. attempts to introduce more meaningful sanctions against Iran produced a U.N. resolution that is way less than the "crippling" sanctions the administration promised. The United States even failed to achieve the political benefit of a unanimous Security Council vote. Turkey, the Muslim anchor of NATO for almost 60 years, and Brazil, our largest ally in Latin America, voted against our resolution.

Could it be that these long-standing U.S. allies, who gave cover to Mahmoud Ahmadinejad and Iran's nuclear ambitions, have decided that there is no cost in lining up with America's most serious enemies and no gain in lining up with this administration?

Obama & Muslim World
Obama has asserted that America is not at war with the Muslim world. The problem is that parts of the Muslim world are at war with America and the West. Obama feels, fairly enough, that America must be contrite in its dealings with the Muslim world. But he has failed to address the religious intolerance, failing economies, tribalism, and gender apartheid that together contribute to jihadist extremism. This was startling and clear when he chose not to publicly support the Iranians who went to the streets in opposition to their oppressive government, based on a judgment that our support might be counterproductive.

Obama & Syriah, Hezbollah and Hamas
Yet, Obama reaches out instead to the likes of Bashar Assad of Syria, Iran's agent in the Arab world, sending our ambassador back to Syria even as it continues to rearm Hezbollah in Lebanon and expands its role in the Iran-Hezbollah-Hamas alliance.
The end result is that a critical mass of influential people in world affairs who once held high hopes for the president have begun to wonder whether they misjudged the man. They are no longer dazzled by his rock star personality and there is a sense that there is somethingamateurish and even incompetent about how Obama is managing U.S. power. “

SWEDEN



18 comments:

Anonymous said...

Bush was far from perfect and had his weaknesses but he kept the USA free from terrorist attacks in the USA. He was competent. Barach Obama is not. It is evident after 18 months in office.How he uses sarcasm makes our nation look weak and sickly. Respect for God and the American people and their rights is thrown out the window.There seems to be no accountability and the nation seems to have lost her blessings in many ways.

I dread when Israel will be continually denounced and put down by the president. I get a sick feeling in my stomach and my spirit when I even think about it. Israel has been our biggest ally including England. We certainly do not approve of everything that a nation does but we do not need any more chaos between friends and supporters.

There is much talk in the states about the disrespect for whatever is near and dear to people's hearts including God,the Bible and prayer. We have seen enough mockery by this president. He seems to continue to be running for office. He is president of The United States. What is next, world dictator ?

The nation continues to go into deep debt and absurd decisions are being made. Statistics are often stretched and falsified. Unemployment is often much higher than reported. We need another attorney and community organizer to bail us out and give us hope ?

All in all , Christ is our hope. I just had hoped for a more godly president that sought strength from his creator and not his ego.

USA East-United States of America

Former officer

'Fletch' said...

I know that I have no right to enter into a discussion about religion and politics in another 'far away' country but this is a great argument for what the founding fathers talked about in the writing of the original constitution.

Supreme Court Justice Sandra Day O'Conner once said "Those who would renegotiate the boundaries between church and state must therefore answer a difficult question: why would we trade a system that has served us so well for one that has served others so poorly?"

I would not denigrate any expression of Faith because it is so difficult to legislate for and can so easily revert to pre-reformation experiences.

Some Americans may feel that Obama is not their cup of tea (coffee) however there are many people around the world who, despite what Mr Tunehag believes, see his election as a portent of a new world order where colour, creed and preferences are not the most important things in life.

I recognise that I am not in possession of all the facts and so please forgive my innocence in this matter and I also fail to see what the relevance is to Formers, unless we are trying to draw parrellels from the US Government to Army Administration.

Sorry; Former from USA East -United States of America; you lost me on this one.

Cheers

Anonymous said...

The future of the Jewish state does not look healthy and its existence, the Bible warns us, forewarns man's future. Hence the relevance; all Christians ought to be aware of what's taking place.

"International lawyer and author Franklin Lamb told Press TV of the existence of a CIA study that predicts Israel may not survive for more than 20 years.

According to Lamb, the CIA concludes that all Palestinian refugees presently living outside the occupied territories will return home, while millions of Israelis will pack up and move to the US, Russia and Europe.
First, a growing number of Middle East experts now believe a two-state solution is no longer viable given Israel’s continuing land-grab in East Jerusalem slated to be the capital of a Palestinian state and its unremitting expansion of Jewish colonies on the West Bank.
…
The only way that Israel can guarantee its survival as a Jewish state is by choosing peace with all its neighbors that will entail an end to occupation and the creation of a Palestinian state with Jerusalem as its capital. If, on the other hand, Israelis prefer domination to peace and stolen land to security, as the CIA study indicates, their country’s future looks dim."

Active
UK

Anonymous said...

I'm with Fletch on this one. The members and visitors to this site are so diverse in religious expression and theology as it is. Let's not add politics to the mix and divide us even further. I'd like to say more, but I won't - this is not the place.

Yours,
Graeme Randall
Former Australian East

Anonymous said...

Graeme,

I was adding my two cents worth as a US citizen in response to the article. I guess I am not suppose to ? Maybe I should not share my opinion. I was only responding to what was written. A bit of confusion here.

Are you and Fletch saying that this article should not be here ? I cannot say that I am sure of the boundaries here. Is there some protocol that you respond to some things and not others ? Who decides ? I thought that there was freedom to share and express with the exception of belittling someone or using vulgarity.

In the USA on Face Book and other sites formers and active have these discussions. I guess if I were either of you I would be a bit confused because honestly I do not know any of your leaders. The only leader I know that was in Australia is an Army leader and that is Jim Knaggs.

Good Evening from The USA.

Former from the Eastern Territory.

Anonymous said...

Fletch,

I actually think that your comment of comparing the US Government to Salvation Army leadership was
comical , but it did make me think a bit. But , then I thought, Nah, not the time or place. It may stir up a hornets nest. We do not need that.

Blessings, from USA East , Former

Anonymous said...

UK,

Your comments and info from the CIA were quite interesting. I have not heard that info before.
I personally think that Israel will remain intact as long as this earth exists. My interpretation is that history and The Bible have come together and that Israel(for whatever reason)has a very special place in the Lords future plans.
Thank you for sharing your thoughts.

Former USA

'Fletch' said...

Good evening Eastern Territory and everyone else. Its seems a bit sad that the only leader you know from Down under was Jim Knaggs however being the best country in the world we are used to people not knowing anything about us. But let me assure you in BIG CAPITAL LETTERS; we are here.

There is confusion about what is allowed on the Blog and what is not. I have no difficulty with discussions about politics but you will have picked up on my subtlety that I am not a fan of mixing politics with religion, of any breed. I lived in Birmingham UK for a few years and we had a Muslim cleric who was promoting Sharia Law for the City and I feel that it is important to keep them separated.

However I have no drama with what ever you want to talk about but like Graham; I think we have enough to share about our faith and 'former status' without 'national politics' being thrown into the mix, it excludes all other nationalities. There is however a dearth of articles for Sven to post and so I would encourage formers everywhere to get you fingers working on the keyboard and share your experience.

I have found a passion for supporting formers not just on this site and I have people who have written their experiences down and found it to be amazingly therapeutic.

I was never a good mathematician but one real article from a Former is worth a thousand articles by Mr Tunehag. So come on folks get writing.

By the way General Eva Burrows (one of my heroines) was Australian!

Cheers

Anonymous said...

Fletch,

I forgot about General Burrows.She is one of my favorite Generals. I briefly met her a few years back. She is a great speaker.

I would agree that mixing politics and religion is not a good way to go, but once again I was responding to the posted article. Our country is in a load of trouble and I think that much prayer is needed. As to making governments a certain religion , well that is why people left England to come to America. I and about 260 million other Americans would probably agree that we do not want a set religion or denomination slated for our country. However the mention of prayer or God in general terms should not be frowned upon or denied. Slowly but surely people are being denied rights of expressing faith and expression of certain backgrounds but others are permitted. It is more than awkward.

Many of our Founding fathers of The USA were godly men and avowed Christians but they did not promote a certain sect or denomination. Our Congress has a Chaplain paid for with tax dollars but he does not promote a denomination. We have chaplains in the military paid with tax dollars also. Church and state-Keep them seperate. I do not want to be forced to be a Catholic, or Baptist or even Salvation Army for that matter. I want and expect my freedom of choice like every other American. That is one reason why I am a former ! I despise much of the politicking in some of the leadership that I have been exposed to when The Spirit of God was waiting in the wings to do His work.

Several years ago I stood on kettles on Wall Street in New York City. What an experience as a Cadet. I met all types of people from all religious backgrounds.I saw a mix of politics and religion back then that made my head spin. You could not make heads nor tails out of much of the discussion. I was glad to have the exposure to such chaos, bit I had enough of that and do not need any more of it.

All of our prior presidents (even Bill Clinton)followed a certain respect and protocol concerning faith and their participation in prayer breakfasts etc. This president (Barach Obama) is avoiding some of these events and practices. Many have a problem with that.There are many other issues also that I will not describe here because this is far as I would like to deviate on this subject which has taken me away from what this site is primarily all about. However, one final comment to put this subject for me to rest. If someone does not like an elected official in this country , they can voice their opinion and also vote against them in an upcoming election. There is much doubt that The USA will see the current president in the White House after this term. We shall see.

I look forward to many new writings by formers and anticipate their sharing of their lives.

USA Eastern Territory

Former

Anonymous said...

Fletch,

I forgot about General Burrows.She is one of my favorite Generals. I briefly met her a few years back. She is a great speaker.

I would agree that mixing politics and religion is not a good way to go, but once again I was responding to the posted article. Our country is in a load of trouble and I think that much prayer is needed. As to making governments a certain religion , well that is why people left England to come to America. I and about 260 million other Americans would probably agree that we do not want a set religion or denomination slated for our country. However the mention of prayer or God in general terms should not be frowned upon or denied. Slowly but surely people are being denied rights of expressing faith and expression of certain backgrounds but others are permitted. It is more than awkward.

Many of our Founding fathers of The USA were godly men and avowed Christians but they did not promote a certain sect or denomination. Our Congress has a Chaplain paid for with tax dollars but he does not promote a denomination. We have chaplains in the military paid with tax dollars also. Church and state-Keep them seperate. I do not want to be forced to be a Catholic, or Baptist or even Salvation Army for that matter. I want and expect my freedom of choice like every other American. That is one reason why I am a former ! I despise much of the politicking in some of the leadership that I have been exposed to when The Spirit of God was waiting in the wings to do His work.

Several years ago I stood on kettles on Wall Street in New York City. What an experience as a Cadet. I met all types of people from all religious backgrounds.I saw a mix of politics and religion back then that made my head spin. You could not make heads nor tails out of much of the discussion. I was glad to have the exposure to such chaos, bit I had enough of that and do not need any more of it.

All of our prior presidents (even Bill Clinton)followed a certain respect and protocol concerning faith and their participation in prayer breakfasts etc. This president (Barach Obama) is avoiding some of these events and practices. Many have a problem with that.There are many other issues also that I will not describe here because this is far as I would like to deviate on this subject which has taken me away from what this site is primarily all about. However, one final comment to put this subject for me to rest. If someone does not like an elected official in this country , they can voice their opinion and also vote against them in an upcoming election. There is much doubt that The USA will see the current president in the White House after this term. We shall see.

I look forward to many new writings by formers and anticipate their sharing of their lives.

USA Eastern Territory

Former

Anonymous said...

Sven,

I'm really disappointed that you're allowing party politics to be discussed on this site. A discussion of religious views on hot button topics is one thing since we all are or have been Salvationists. Regardless of where anyone is now in their spiritual lives at least there's a common thread in that area and a basis for understanding. Party politics should be steered far away from on any site having to do with TSA whether it's an official TSA site or not.

I suspect Mr. Tunehag represents something in Europe akin to what the Religious and Political Right in America represents. I voted for Barack Obama in 2008 (though I was originally rooting for Hillary Clinton even though I'm from Chicago---actually, come to think of it, she grew up in Chicago too!)and will more than likely vote for him again in 2012 if he's the Democratic nominee again.

I only mention this to show that all theologically conservative Xians in America do not listen to the Jerry Falwells, James Dobsons, Pat Robertsons and D. James Kennedys (among a slew of others)of the world when it comes to political and social views, nor do we all get our news (or care to get our news)from the Fox News Channel as it is so obvious that USA East former does! The rest of the world should know that their are progressive evangelicals in this country and that the people on the far right do not represent all evangelicals in this country.

With that said I still contend that to keep all sorts of slings and arrows from being thrown and to avoid any hard feelings over politics and politicians you really should steer clear of political articles and arguments on this site. That's my take on it!

Sincerely,

Daryl Lach
USA Central

FORMER SALVATION ARMY OFFICERS FELLOWSHIP said...

Friends, the role of political parties is coming under increasing scrutiny and we leave the debates to those working in that field. Nevertheless, it’s essential that we recognize for the sake of clarity that what is perceived in one culture as political conflict is in another, a religious debate. Such is the case with Mr. Tunehag. A brief bio is probably helpful.

Mats Tunehag is as far removed from the Falwells, Dobsons, ORU and Liberty U faculties and their founders as east is from west. I'd classify him as a Jesuit renaissance man.

Mats is a senior Associate on Business as Mission for both the Lausanne Movement and World Evangelical Alliance Mission Commission, and has lectured widely on Business as Mission as well as published numerous articles and papers on the topic. He initiated and led the Lausanne global think tank on the issue of Business as Mission. Tunehag is also the President of the Swedish Evangelical Alliance and a global spokesperson on Religious Liberty & Freedom of Speech for the World Evangelical Alliance. He serves on the Global Council of Advocates International, a global network of 30 000 lawyers in over 120 countries.

Mr. Tunehag has lectured in Europe, Latin America and North America on Human Rights issues and lessons learned in building strategic and influential alliances shaping public opinion and legislation. Recent presentations to groups of European leaders, focused on Global Trends, Concerns and Recommendations Regarding Freedom of Speech & Religion was very well-received. If anything, his lectures were felt to be leaning left.

Tunehag's pro-Israel stance is representative of many in Scandinavia who maintain that God's promises to Israel have been fulfilled, and have found that today the Anglo-Saxon and Scandinavian nations have Israel's fingerprints. His comments relative to Obama stem from his learned Swedish neutral bent, and are much in line with another African-American Nobel Peace Prize winner who shared in his acceptance speech; “…After contemplation, I conclude that this award which I receive on behalf of that movement is profound recognition that nonviolence is the answer to the crucial political and moral question of our time -- the need for man to overcome oppression and violence without resorting to violence and oppression.

Civilization and violence are antithetical concepts. Negroes of the United States, following the people of India, have demonstrated that nonviolence is not sterile passivity, but a powerful moral force that makes for social transformation. Sooner or later all the people of the world will have to discover a way to live together in peace, and thereby transform this pending cosmic elegy into a creative psalm of brotherhood.
...I have the audacity to believe that peoples everywhere can have three meals a day for their bodies, education and culture for their minds, and dignity, equality and freedom for their spirits. I believe that what self-centered men have torn down, men other-centered can build up. I still believe that one day mankind will bow before the altars of God and be crowned triumphant over war and bloodshed, and nonviolent redemptive goodwill will proclaim the rule of the land.

And the lion and the lamb shall lie down together and every man shall sit under his own vine and fig tree and none shall be afraid." MARTIN LUTHER KING, JR.

Finally, although I have used Tunehag material in the past, lifted verbatim from his blog, in this latest instance I copied it directly from a well respected SA blog site.

ARTICLES NEEDED….

Sven

Anonymous said...

Sven ,

Thank you so much for taking the time to explain what was posted.You are to be commended for all that you do. I thought that the article was interesting but did notice it had a different slant ten many others. I really have no complaints. I just felt a little awkward when I was more or less told to keep politics out of this blog. I thought that I broke some sort of protocol or rule.

Blessings.

USA East Former

Anonymous said...

Daryl,

You do assume too much about me. To inform you I watch various news agencies. Fox news is a bit more commentary and comedy than news. I still appreciate much of CNN Headline News that just shares with little or no comment. I also like ABC news but go to MSNBC for more comedy.

As far as not throwing arrows well I am not going to comment much other than I felt a bit of a sting from something from your direction. Also Jerry Falwell and James Kennedy are dead.
What do they have to do with me ? Are you attempting to lump me wit them and you do not know me ?

You may be very conservative and I may be progressive and liberal. You just don't know until it is actually admitted and additional discussion or a face to face takes place.

Thanks for your opinion.

USA East former

Anonymous said...

Sven,

Thanks for clarifying who Mats Tunehag is. I just wrongly assumed he was an American-style far right character from Europe. Also thanks for stating that different cultures see these arguments differently. I could be wrong but I'm wondering if it might have something to do with our different political cultures.

As you well know in America we have a two party system. The voters tend to compromise when it comes to parties and politicians. When the parties don't address an issue most Americans want addressed a third party will usually develop. Eventually the two parties will then address the issue in their own way and the need for the third party dissolves. Because of this political culture no one agrees with all the policies of whomever is in power. I for one thought Obama would've stopped the wars by now and am not happy that he hasn't. However, I do believe that he's working on it and do like an awful lot of the other issues he's tackled. I also am not at all happy with the people who have taken over the GOP in recent decades. Thus I compromise and support who most resembles my political beiefs.

I'm not sure how it exactly works in Sweden but I do understand that in many European countries coalition governments have to be formed because there's a party for everything and everyone and if there isn't one that suits your views on everything you just start your own! That maybe where the crux is.

When Americans see someone being personally attacked on all of their policies we assume the worst of the person doing the attacking, whereas in Europe it's just part of the political process and climate to attack and want out of office any politician who doesn't agree with you 100%. I humbly admit though that I could be wrong.

USA East Former,

You are correct. I don't know you and you do deserve an apology. After reading your comments I probably subconsciously projected on to you all of my own frustrations with several relatives of mine and siblings along with their spouses, who have over the years e-mailed me tons of right wing, redneck, God and America, Rush Limbaugh luvin' material that quite frankly has made me want to puke. Fortunately, over time I've learned to take it all in stride, accept them as fully human with different views from mine and delete immediately anything and everything they send me!

I'm very glad to hear that you watch/read a number of news sources (including MSNBC! lol!)and not just the Fox News Channel. I had no right to make that assumption.

Sincerely,

Daryl Lach
USA Central

P.S. Btw, Falwell and Kennedy may have been dead for a few years already but their spirits still live on in their 3rd commandment breaking, revised American history toting (they were both big fans of Rushdoony and his American Reconstructionist movement)statements. Also you can still catch Kennedy's sermons every Sunday across America. As far as I'm concerned, when it comes to American Democracy, they were(and still are)both very dangerous men!

Anonymous said...

Daryl,

I appreciate this site because it is interesting and there is room for encouragement agreement , support and some disagreement. I have learned a lot from Sven and his patience and teaching as well as many others regardless of their personal views.If we are officers , soldiers , former officers or retired officers, we all have one thing in common. We are serving the same Savior.

Probably my biggest issue with anyone is about the Word of God.Our knowledge of God and some very basic doctrines including the eleven in The Salvation Army (derived from scripture)are understood when there is study and comparing scripture with scripture. To accept certain doctrine we need to believe that the Bible is true and dependable. I do not want to split hairs and use all the other words and I do declare that I am not an idol worshipper of the Bible, but if we do not have faith in God to reveal his way and desire in the form of the written word and /or other sources then we will always be in the dark until we meet our creator. I think that He wants us to see the Light before death.Much is not revealed and so in faith we rely upon all mighty God to reveal through other people, events and general revelation and His Holy Spirit. I happen to have a personal belief that the Bible is primary and all other sources are secondary without offending The Holy Spirit.

I was raised as a heathen (unchurched), but accepted pretty much Arminian-Wesleyan teaching including holiness. In my older age, I am 57, I lean a bit more toward Calvinistic teaching, however I can see where both come from and the slant in the Bible for both. My problem arises when folk talk about throwing out most of Pauls Epistles and other parts of the NT because it may not fit their opinion or theology. It makes me wonder, what is trustworthy then ? I certainly am a work in progress and God is not through with me yet but I do not have big issues with the Bible as we know it today.

I may have a conservative outlook in many ways but I am very aware of beating people over the head with scripture does not work. I am not a legalist and praise God for His grace and mercy and that I fail at times like anyone else. I also have found people from all walks of life have had a good deal of influence upon me regardless of their denominational background. Even some unbelievers have taught me some good life lessons and examples of how to live and act. So, I attempt to show the love of Jesus and reach out with compassion. It works !

Many blessings to you.

USA East former

Anonymous said...

Colleagues in the fight!

Just goes to show how wrong I can be, as if I needed reminding!

Of the almost 500 articles, YES, FIVE HUNDRED, this is one I thought would be the least read and commented on... Instead our visitor count rose a full 10% and comments flooded in. And what? God speaks and moves different people at different times and in different spiritual walks...

ARTICLES NEEDED ! Thanks...

On July 6th the blog will be dedicated to the FSAOF Congress in Sweden and the Latvian Mission through July 17.
blessings, sven

floridaflamingo said...

First, along with Sven and Fletch, I would encourage readers to become writers. We need articles and we need to hear from Sally's of all persuasion; former and active alike. If everyone wrote one a year we would be in great shape. One, that's it. From everyone. Just a nudge.

Second, I thought this article and discussion were fab partly I suppose because I rather enjoy a good hornet's nest. It makes me think and rethink what I believe. Sometimes it causes me to shift position a bit and sometimes if more strongly reinforces what I already believe but, nonetheless, it give me time to ponder how and why someone else's stance could be right. Or wrong.

Third, I have no third. Only to say have a glorious day. Not a bad way to end my thoughts.