After normal niceties our phone conversation transitioned to the soft but urgent noise of tears and moans. The caller from the east coast whispered, “I drink myself to sleep every night.” I could feel the seriousness of his tone and the strength of his agony. The only hope I could sense through the fiber optic lines was not felt but known from the evidence. The fact was he had enough hope to call. Otherwise it clearly felt like he had no confidence he might get better. His world was too dark. His addiction to alcohol too powerful. For some time every night of his life had become disgracefully ugly. He gave in to the urging of the bottle and the seduction of his shame. His life, not just his sleep was dependent on the chemicals.He was obviously a very articulate person, his rich voice was winsome. He emoted leadership presence. He was the Senior Minister of a large congregation. He was anything but a bum in a cardboard box under the freeway but his control over alcohol was nonexistent. He was broken. He was powerless. He was finally reaching for help. There was, however, a huge obstacle.
He was a pastor. Pastors are not supposed to be alcoholics. They know better and they should do better. He knew no one would understand. He knew no one would ever knowingly follow an alcoholic pastor and he knew if he kept doing what he was doing he was going to die a drunk. To get the help he needed someone had to know his truth. If the wrong someone knew his truth he was done as a pastor. If he lost his high profile ministry job he would loose the insurance which could pay for treatment. He was caught between getting the help he needed and loosing everything. Actually it felt to him like he was caught between loosing everything and loosing everything that mattered.
Alcoholism, dependency on prescription drugs and the use of illicit drugs by otherwise wonderful pastors is not as uncommon as each person using chemicals wishes. Alcoholics want to be free. Running from doctor to doctor to obtain bogus prescriptions to abuse medication is a nerve racking exercise in futility. Meeting the wrong person, in the wrong place for the wrong reason, at the wrong time surely does not build one’s self image. The cover up, the coerced enabling of a spouse, the lies and the downward spiral of building tolerance and destroying body functions is not a pretty picture. Certainly not one you want to hang in the church vestibule.
This pastor told the truth, went to treatment, ultimately chose to tell his congregation and is delivering powerful sober sermons from a sober life. Some disappointed people rejected him and left the church. Others went to treatment to deal with their own chemical dependency. No, he did not live happily ever after but sobriety is producing a kind of calm and strength only the Lord brings. If you struggle with chemical dependency your story may be different. You may binge. You may snort. You may smoke. But, no matter how hopeless you feel, you can find a way to be free.
Some pastors believe and teach alcoholism is not a disease and is just sin. Whatever your belief, if you are controlled by it you need help. A pastor who believes it is just sin and is struggling to maintain a sobriety record for which he may be grateful cannot be comfortable allowing sin to have so much power over him. You need not solve this theological/medical issue to get the help you need. You have to reach for help. There is hope. Click here for direction regarding confidential help.
Not convinced you have a problem? If you are uncertain whether you are an alcoholic with a progressive disease or a sinner hooked by sin’s progressive enslavement please click and follow the link (see below) to a screening test which will help you understand the seriousness of your drinking. Counseling Resources has a quality alchohol screening test to help.
If the chemical dependency issue which haunts you is the abuse of prescription drugs or illicit drugs the state of your use can be objectively tested by the screening test Counseling Resources provides. At CRN we urge you to seek the confidential help which will provide you with clearer diagnosis, quality help and the freedom for which you long. You deserve to be sober. Grace is available. We urge you to take this issue more seriously than you think necessary. It is easy to be deceived into deeper levels of pain and addiction. All you have to do is keep doing what you are doing. Stop. Make hopeful contact today. Go to the Finding Help page and begin a life you can respect and enjoy. You deserve it. You are worth it.
Dale O. Wolery
Dale O. Wolery
Executive Director
37 comments:
Is chemical dependency or other addictive behaviours a problem among SA officers, as prevalent as among clergy generally? Or are we refusing to face reality?
The first step in dealing with addiction is to acknowledge its existence !
Active UKT
Interestingly, and perhaps not coincidentally, this very subject is being addressed by several 'formers' in our private FB site. Respect for their privacy doesn't allow me to share further, however, they'll be encouraged to share personally.
I am thankful for this article. It gives example of what is happening to many people in society today. That includes pastors , officers and others in the public eye. We have become a pill -popping dependency generation. I see how easy it is to get mind-altering and pain-killer prescriptions. The Salvation Army insurance-prescription plan pays for many of these drugs. Some are prescribed properly and some are not. I know of abuse and it is sad and sinful. There is help . Many of these prescriptions were meant to be short-term use and have turned into long-term use. There are alternatives in many cases. Addiction and dependency needs attention and will cause much damage. Some type of additional oversight is needed. The problem would be confidentiality. I do believe some oversight can be addressed in the confines of confidentiality .
USA Former
Wow, what timing. This in right on target with a little internal chat. Thank you for writing and reminding all of of that addictions choose many forms and disguises. And that anyone can recovery - day by day by day.
God has amazing timing!
When I read this, I thought that it had come out of our FB discussion on addictions.
I see that addictions and recovery might be more difficult for officers than other members of the clergy because of the additional shame associated with not living up to the behavioral standards expected of and promised by the officer. In churches where alcohol is not a taboo it seems that it is easier for someone with an addiction to admit it and move toward the journey of recovery. For example, I am now an Episcopalian and know of quite a few priests who are in recovery. There is no stigma attached to this- it was their particular issue and they dealt with it. At our conventions there are 12-step meetings offered that are attended by both lay and clergy- no shame involved.
However, in The Army, an officer risks their career (yes, I know it is a calling but when you are looking at losing everything including the bed that you sleep on and the blankets that keep your family warm, your career is very real and very much in jeopardy).
My question is, why are we able to be so loving and supportive to those that are ministered to by The Army but so quick to judge and unforgiving (as if forgiveness is our duty in the first place!) of those who are hurting within the ranks of officership?
God is love and those who love God will love His people.
From my experience, addiction within Officer ranks is possibly more common in TSA than other denominations - although I have no proof. I just know of a lot more officers in active addiction than I do clergy in other denominations. And the addiction is at all levels of leadership.
However, also from my experience, I believe other less known or recognised addictions are more common in Officer ranks - things like Sex addiction. While this may not be illegal etc., the problem is, people in sex addiction do not practice safe-sex, and usually go to 'underground' type places for sex (such as toilets, dark parks, sex-on-premises venues), and can often spend easily £200 p.w on this addiction. This means that the chances of contracting something like HIV or other STI's is extremely high. They then go home and have 'relations' with their wives to get over the guilt of doing what they did. So... How many officers have HIV and not know it? How many have given HIV to their wives and not known it? How many of their children have been exposed to HIV and not known it? It is not uncommon to have HIV for 20+ years and be completely unaware of it and symptom free. How many have given their wives scabies and told them they must have gotten it while working with the 'street workers' in the welfare centre?
Addiction, from my experience, is more of a psychological problem than a medical or theological problem. Having said that, the psychological problem may be a result of a theological struggle. The actual physical dependency (medical part) of the addiction can usually be overcome and 'cured' within a week or two at most - even for severe addictions like herroine. However, what takes the time is the psychological problems.
I have stopped counting how many officers I know who are closset homosexuals. They struggle with it because they believe it to be wrong and evil. This feeds the addiction, and puts the lives of their families at risk.
Those who have acknowledged their sexuality, embraced it (even if it means divorcing their wives) have found that their addictions - at all levels - have stopped almost immediately. However, those who have tried to deal with it as a theological problem, and 'relied on God for healing' have all - without exception - gotten worse in their addictions. Even though they claim to be healed from it. I remember working with a young man in a rehab centre who recognised one of the married officers there as one of his regular 'tricks/johns' - and he was.
We need to understand what the psychological problems are (and there are a lot in officership and the church), and perhaps re-evaluate theology to reflect a more healthy psychological attitude. God never heals anything that isn't broken. When our theology says it is broken, and there is nothing wrong with it in the first place, there is nothing for God to heal, and so the individual (and their family) suffer tremendously. Talk about knowing the right 'tree' by the fruit that it bears. Hmm - bondage, destruction, depression, death as opposed to liberation, life, healing - which sounds like the fruit of the Spirit to you?
It is a problem in TSA Officer ranks. It has far reaching consequences. It needs to be bravely dealt with at all levels. It needs to be dealt with in confidence, love, and understanding. It needs to inform our theology - not be informed by our theology. We need to open our minds to the implications of what we find. Otherwise, we will never have victory in this area, and more and more lives and families will be destroyed. And I don't think that is the fruit of the Spirit.
Just some thoughts.
Yours,
Graeme.
Former Australian East.
Graeme,
I understand where you were going with addictions. You then shared about sexual addiction. Then the topic pretty much switched to homo sexual behavior and addiction. Why does everything from you have to switch to homosexuality ? Once again you are stressing your point that it is (or should) be accepted as a lifestyle.You are actually ridiculing many folk that do not have your type of theology. I grant that you have an opinion and can say what you want but you are promoting something that is detestable unto the Lord.You have defined your opinion and interpretation on this subject time and time again. Who are you trying to convince that the gay lifestyle is wholesome and a productive lifestyle? Men having sex with men cannot have children. It was Adam and Eve in the garden , not Adam and Steve. My opinion is that there are psychological issues at stake. I agree with you on that issue.I also believe that there are addictions of all sort that can be treated including a gay lifestyle. Also (and you may have a problem with this) there is a demonic scene here also.Forces and evil powers from beings that overwhelm people that are not right with God and have entangled themselves in sin and degradation. Christ is the answer , but those addicted need love, counsel,and much prayer and Scripture ! Our loving Heavenly Father did not play a sick joke on anyone by making them the wrong sex either. He can help anyone work through an issue or addiction if that person really desires to change. If the desire is not there then perhaps the person is beyond "feeling" as the Apostle Paul describes in his letters.
USA former
The saddest day of my life was when - while employed by the Army ( I am a former officer of 20 years but at that time, was working as an employee) the Divisional Commander called me to his office. I saw the termination papers on his desk and I knew immediately what was about to happen. I was not going to let him fire me so, I resigned. My big mistake. So, after 27 years of faithful, productive work for the organization I loved I walked out the door. You see, I had experienced a reaction to a medication that the doctor had prescribed for me - the DC however was convinced I was drinking on the job. What happened to caring for our own? I had seen how Army leaders treated some with similar situations - with compassion. But, why was I any different than they? My addiction to prescribed medication got worse but not before my Sunday School Class was taken away, I was told I could not sing in the songsters or play in the band. I was devastated. I was angry. I was hurt. And I was humiliated. I wonder how things would have been different if I had been treated with compassion rather than tossed aside and left to rot. There was no communication with me - no follow-up pastoral care.
Since then, I have been employed off and on - more off than on.
I know I can't go back in time - what is done is done. I have moved on - I am no longer addicted to anything other than my faith in a God who does all things well.
Is there a problem....you bet there is! Army leaders should be aware of how to treat our own. If I had been a person off the street I would have been shown more compassion. Heart to God - Hand to Man - yes - but not always to the person who is one of their own.
Anonymous
Former Eastern Territory
Dear USA Former,
I hope you never find out someone you love is gay. Or bi. Or trans. I can only fear for the hate and condemnation they will receive from you. Someone who is supposed to love them.
Not everything in the world that you disagree with is demonic or addictive.
It causes me to wonder whom else you hate and condemn. There doesn't seem to be a place of love and acceptance in your note.
God help those who were under your mis-ministry, I say.
Sincerely,
Also a Former USA
Former USA,
The spiritual arrogance that I detect in your post is one of several reasons that I left officership. It seems that there are a few areas that the Salvation Army has selected to promote hatred. I have to wonder why homosexuality is such an area. Love is from God and if two people love each other I would encourage them to commit to a life-long monogamous relationship in which they can serve God together.
Graeme, I encourage you in your quest for the same type of love and commitment that I share with my husband.
Some definitions of hatred is why there is such a sin problem. Two people post a different opinion different than me , fine. I guess I could say that you are being hateful to me. Again a few are going by way of the world and saying lets just love one another. Where did you get to know about love ? The Bible talks about it. The Bible also talks about some sin that is (detestable) before the Lord because it is totally unnatural. To speak of spiritual arrogance is to ignore or deny what the Bible says about some practice that will physically or emotionally cause damage to the individual or others.Besides, God said it was wrong and sinful. Your problem is not with me. It is with Almighty God. You are mocking and jesting at the messenger. I am not the one who brought this up in the first place. Addiction was the topic and it swayed right back to a subject that Graeme often refers to. I think it went a bit off topic, but I did not lead it there. Again , he is entitled to his opinion, that is not my problem or issue here.
By the way, the only one that I hate is Lucifer.
You do not know me and assume too much. I have had gay friends before and they knew my stand against homosexuality and adultery and murder and the list goes on. We were friends. We agreed to disagree. So, you don't have to demean me because of my opinion that is based on the Bible. I do not hate those that disagree with me.
To assume that two men having a monogamous relationship is as equal or the same type as a man and woman being married and having a monogamous relationship, is not Biblical.That is spiritual arrogance. How anyone can be a Salvation Army Officer and believe that is beyond me.As what was stated you left because of that. I commend you for that.
For former USA to state what was stated is out of arrogance or ignorance and just plain not knowing who they are referring to. I have no reason to lie when I share that I help anyone and did as an officer. I do not look at their skin color, sexual preference or if they are illegal in this country. I help. I show love.I pray for them and with them.BUT, I would not ordain or knowingly commission someone involved in sexual sin.I do not judge and yell on the street at people and say that they are hated by God or going to hell.We all know here that God loves everyone. God has a standard and a measure of rule-canon.Through it all He reveals in various ways how we are to live and he judges in light of it and His truth.
I thank God for forgiveness and showing us how to live and giving us the strength through His Holy Spirit to do what he asks. And , yes not everything is demonic or addictive. But we were discussing addictions. I was expressing as an opinion also that some addictions are so strong (spiritually) that I think some are demonic.
I condemn no one. People condemn themselves . That is why we have a Savior and he is the judge of who goes to heaven and who does not.
Blessings, USA Former
Former, USA Eastern Territory,
I find it interesting that people are able to pick and choose from the laws that were handed down. If you are going to follow everything that Paul said then over half of the officers in the world need to step down because women are not to have leadership over men. Just one example that is glaring in the Salvation Army where we choose which scriptures to attribute to being culturally bound while at the same time saying that other teachings are for all times.
Administrator,
Could you remove the repeats ? I received a message that there was not enough room to respond,however every time I thought that I failed in sending my response it went through.
Sorry USA East former
I think that Paul was deeply misunderstood. He often praised women for their work and had females support him. I think what you are referring to is where there was some dissension and some women were talking when they shouldn't in a time of teaching and worship.They were told to keep quiet. Paul stated that a woman should not teach and should ask her husband at home. I do not think that was to mean that women should not teach and speak in every case because what do you do about the females that were to prophesy in the last days. I think that females are great teachers at times. Another point of view is that many men and fathers have not followed the Lord and the ladies have to step up to the plate and go beyond other responsibilities. The time that Paul was teaching was also a time of transition and much of the Jewish tradition and culture needed replaced with christian principles. Jesus did not throw away the Law. He fulfilled it and He is the Law.
On the subject of women , I always thought that they were treated unfair in the Army and should have more responsibility. Every female officer should receive a salary and given respect. There should be more ladies in charge and more female DC's and TC's. In Christ there is neither male nor female which means that God will use either one that gives their heart to Him.I am far from being a legalist as you portray. I agree there are many in leadership that stick to old Army tradition but that is another habit and culture issue that needs to be overcome. I also feel that if one of the spouses in a couple felt that God wanted them in Salvation Army ministry and one other not, so be it. All other churches are that way. But, again the Army is a different animal. That is why I am no longer an officer after 25 years.
Blessings
USA East , former
To USA Former (and others),
In my home country of Australia, there is an extremely high level of addiction amongst the Aboriginals. The addictions are many and varied. It is a very major social problem. One of the more predominant theories as to why there is such a level of addiction amongst Aboriginals is that they have been misunderstood and subjugated by whites... made to feel as though they are less than human. As attitudes change, the level of addiction and the social problems associated are lessoning. I believe one would find a similar problem amongst the coloured people in America – addiction being a response to subjugation, prejudice, and hatred – a way of numbing pain in a situation where there is no solution, there is no ‘out’. One cannot change the colour of one’s skin, and when those around will not change their attitudes, what can one do?
In the past, it was quite common for women to be addicted to barbiturates and alcohol – once again, numbing the pain of their own subjugation by men. They could not change their gender, and men wouldn’t cease referring to them as ‘the weaker sex’, and inferior to men.
Our theological forebears used the Bible to support all manner of wrong teaching. It was they who believed and taught that people of colour were not human and so could not gain entry into heaven as heaven was only for humans. It was they who taught that women are inferior. It was they who supported slavery. It was they who handed Jews to the Nazis for extermination. All because they believed the Bible firmly taught it. They believed it was a matter of spiritual authority, and to think otherwise was spiritual arrogance at best, and heresy mixed with demonic influence at worst. They believed that to accept any of the above as equals was to risk eternal damnation.
It was only because people like us stood up and said they were wrong. People like us challenged prevailing interpretation of scripture and said it was wrong. People like us challenged the spiritual authority of the church and said it was wrong. And many of us were beaten and some killed for their beliefs. But as a result, the church changed. It re-interpreted scripture. It changed its’ teachings. At the last high council, TSA almost ended up with a coloured General – how far we have come.
I am filled with rage, and incensed when I see the Bible being used to subjugate people, to incite violence, to encourage murder, to break up families, to keep people in bondage, to cause such destruction – all in the name of God. I will always speak out when I see that. USA Former, we are not that much different when you look at it like that. If the church were to start teaching again that black people are not human and should all be slaves, I am sure you would stand up and challenge it as wrong and a bastardisation of scripture. I am doing nothing more than that.
We are talking about addiction. From the many addicts I have worked with, come in contact with, and my own experience of addiction, I have come to realise that for so many of us, the teaching of the church had to be overcome before healing could commence. God is the great Physician. But it is interesting that there is no evidence that even one person has ever throughout history found ‘victory’ over homosexuality. Either God is impotent to do anything about it (and not god at all), or there is nothing to heal because it is not broken. If what the church teaches is correct, then the God it proclaims is not a God I want anything to do with. It is killing people, including its’ clergy and their families. It is causing so much pain. We must review this.
Graeme.
former Australian East
Which USA former are you speaking to Graeme ? I did see that you mentioned "others". You are so wrong about someone not having victory over homosexuality . I have heard and seen the stories.The same as I have with alcoholism and drug addiction and various gambling and sexual addictions. To deny is to deny God's power and his grace. That does not mean to say that people have not been tempted and had feelings.We are all human and have weaknesses and God is very aware of them.Some people have relapses. Just because you may have not have seen such things does not make it impossible. That was a broad paint brush stroke to proclaim.
You make your own points about your stand on the personal choice of being gay or anyone choosing that lifestyle.People have that choice but with certain lifestyles there are consequences. If I choose to engage in adultery because I want to and it feels good to me and I think that the part in the Bible should be thrown out , well OK. What is good for the goose is good for the gander.Regardless of how I feel or respond it is still sexual sin according to the Bible.
The hate issue comes up quite frequently.I have stated that I am not a hater. I am a lover. We disagree but I love you Graeme. Enough to tell you what I think. Enough to let you do what you think is best. I will not bash you or call you names. I think you were trying to point out that as far as much of the Bible and its principles we agree on many things. Much has to do with personal"illogical-incorrect" interpretation when one says the Bible teaches slavery because there are examples of slavery, so it must be OK.There are people that taught that. You mention various types of people that were looked down upon such as women and people with dark skin as examples of prior mistreatment . The Army should treat their women better. My wife should have had better appointments to use her gifts and serve. She was abused and misused. She should have been paid instead of being classified as a volunteer for over 25 years with no record of income, and so now she has to start anew with credit and social security. How unfair. For some "probably unfair reason" Israel Gather was not made General.He should have been. He was a fantastic God fearing leader, and I feel was slighted. It is sad.
As far as gays, they are often mistreated. I assist homosexuals , illegals, thieves, liars, Muslims , Christians , atheists, Catholics, backsliders, backbiters, baptists, Pentecostals, drug pushers,formers-whoever... without showing hate. Because I believe what the Bible states about certain lifestyles and their consequences does not mean I am a hater.
We have a policy where I am a case manager that we make no judgements of peoples character, actions, race, religion as to whether we assist with basic social services. We help anyone as long as they meet minimal criteria that any agency would require. That is the way it should be . No discrimination because of race or ethnic background or sexual preference or religion. However, if I was asked about the Bible and what it teaches about certain lifestyles or situations, I would use Scripture to respond. We assist people that live together and are not married. I give them food and assist with basic human services. We do it because we care and want to help but that does not mean that I accept that lifestyle.
To treat any human being cruel is plain wrong and sinful.Because I believe that certain practices and lifestyles are sinful according to Scripture is not being hateful. That same Bible states that I should show God's love even if I disagree.There is a balance to aim for.
Would I, if I was an officer make someone a soldier that was living with someone and having sex out of marriage ? NO!Would I make a soldier of someone that was a liar and a thief and unrepentant ?No! Would I attempt to teach them and lead then to Christ ? YES! I think you know how I stand and it is not unreasonable and hateful.I am addicted to Jesus.
Blessings to you.
USA East former
Wow! What blog and such entertaining responses. I wonder if fundamentalism is also an addiction?
Fletch,
Exactly why I do not use my name.Your sarcasm is not that funny.I think there was some more understanding between Graeme and me and when people make remarks and make fun of any common thread it is counter -productive. Fundamentalism in its strictest form is negative. But so is liberalism. Maybe sarcasm is an addiction ? Anyway perhaps others may want to speak about experiences with addictions. Prescription drugs I feel are a bigger problem than most think. I have seen some problems in action. I thank God that I do not have such a need or such an addiction but feel for those that do.
When I was an officer in the ARC I experienced the Christian 12 Step Program. I think that it was helpful to many of the men and I have heard of it used in Corps for soldiery as a training tool.
Former USA
Amen to both Fletch and Graeme!
As far as I'm concerned fundamentalism and all of its accompanying accoutrements such as bibliolatry, pre-millenial dispensationalism, the world is 6500 years old anti-evolution, god's (small g intended) gonna get us if the Supreme Court doesn't start allowing state sponsored school prayer at football games, America firstism, guns, god (small g intended again)and gays theology and politics is both an addiction and a Xian heresy. As far as sarcasm being an addiction---former USA East? NAW! Read Elton Trueblood's "The Humor of Christ". Jesus used satire all of the time. (good satire is always called sarcasm by those to whom it's suppose to sting.)It may be out of print since it's about 50 years old but I'm sure you can pick up a copy at the public library.
God Bless and Keep---And Never Let the Old Flag Fall!
Daryl Lach
USA Central
Daryl you apologized once before for this type of comment. Guess you didn't mean it.It sounds like you are trying to strike out and be hurtful.
You assume once again that someone is a fundamentalist. I am not according to your list that you have written. I don't worship the Bible. I do not demand prayer at all events. I pray if I want to just like you.I do think that the Bible does have some fundamental teaching, such as the atonement , resurrection, virgin birth.I am probably more a moderate than anything but it all depends.I do not vote for people because they are Christians, I look at the issues. My ideal would be to enjoy a Blessing from Christian political leaders but I have been blessed before by heathen. As far as end time views I like pre or mid trib , but if it doesn't happen that way God will provide anyway. I do not think the time of Jacob's Trouble or the Great Tribulation is for Christians . My understanding is that this time is for the unsaved and the work of Israel. That still does not prevent us going through tribulation during some of the end times and today. But, really what's it all about ? What do you think , A-Millenial ? I don't. But if you did , I will not ridicule you.
Daryl, are you an active officer?
You really have some issues with fundamental Christians. Maybe you should find some and talk to them and get to know them. I do not think you will find them on this site.I see many people with a mixed bag and various views and I commend Sven for that opportunity to share and for us to see what goes on in the minds of other people.
Any thoughts on addictions and what you would advise people to do ?
Blessings
USA East former
Getting off of liberal versus conservative and going back to addictions, I understand why it is easy for officers to fall into that trap- despite our belief system and our custom of being an abstinent denomination, officers have so much pressure on them to do it all and be everything to everyone. The expectations can be unrealistic and if there is no pastoral care, the pressure can feel overwhelming. I am blessed to have a DC who is a psstor first, but I know that others may not be as blessed. When support is hard to find and the weight of the world is on your shoulders and God feels a million miles away, it is easy to give in to tempation.
Also, we tend to put the cadets/officers who have overcome addictions, especially those who have come through Salvation Army programs, on a pedastal and that is a dangerous place for anyone to be . The pressure to be a "trophy of grace" can really create a giant expectation, and these folks, while strong in their recovery, the care contsntly held up as models and as recovering whatever, and this can play havoc with the mind. I have been acquaited with more than a few such cases.
None of us are immune to temptation and we all need to practice good self care, and maintain he right boundaries!
Anonymous,
I appreciate your comments and agree. When my wife and I were officers in the ARC several years ago,we had many experiences with people (many good)and we learned so much.We invested time and love and gained the respect of the men and women. These folks needed someone to listen and support them. Most burned all their bridges and lost family, jobs and their old church families. They needed a new family and a good support system. Most really appreciated the spiritual ministry and relied upon the lord. The 12 step program was so helpful and I worked it too. It works !
In over 26 years of ministry I felt more at home with the sinners than with the saints. Ministry was real and stared us right in the face. We saw so much victory and felt at peace with our work. At times we saw death and terrible events but God was good.
I had to remind myself as you stated that we are all tempted and had to set boundaries, which is a healthy thing to do. Much is about discipline and a good plan or program.
Blessings,
USA East former officer
Dear USA Former or USA East Former or USA Former East(s)!!
Please be assured that in my last posting I was not trying to strike out and be hurtful to anyone. I was merely attempting to support the statements of Graeme and Fletch concerning addictions. From what I got from Graeme he believes that many secret addictions (whether chemical or sexual or other) of people such as SA officers who come from abstinent religious groups and sign pledges are often the result of unresolved and very unnecessary guilt stemming from the misuse and abuse of scripture. Fletch on the other hand then asked the question whether or not fundamentalism could be an addiction? I think they're both right on!
I wasn't even going to comment on this article because even though I am a nurse I never really dealt much with addictions in a clinical setting. Also having grown up in the Army I never, smoked, drank, took drugs, devoured tons of pornography (not even danced in my day!)or did any of those things even after I left the Army and became a Presbyterian and later an Episcopalian.
As a result, except for supporting Graeme and Fletch, I did not feel qualified to comment on anything other than maybe an addiction to potato chips and cheezelets. (and please---before some life long skinny former writes in to tell me that it's the same thing as getting lit on crack cocaine--no it's NOT! Potato chip munchers still work, pay their bills, and pick you up at the airport when you ask them to. They may wobble a little while they're doing it but they still show up.)
The NAW in my last posting was addressed to USA Former (did I mistakenly assume it was East since it sounded like so many of the other postings? I dunno.)He made the comment that sarcasm can be an addiction. I don't think so. Whether or not something appears to be sarcasm usually has to do with who is interpreting it. I merely pointed out that according to Elton Trueblood Jesus constantly used satire in the gospels and of course the religious leaders of his day did not like it and accused him of sarcasm and much worse!
Though not related to addiction, you did ask me two other questions so I guess you deserve the coutesy of having them answered: 1. Bibliolatry or the worship of the words of the Bible in place of God is often very subconscious. No one says, "I think I'll worship the Bible today." As protestants we just automatically have a tendency to do it and need to always be mindful of it. 2. You guessed it! My millenialist views tend to be a--. (btw, Booth was a post, not a pre just in case anyone didn't know) Actually, I like to think of myself as an "a-pan-millenialist" as in "ah, it'll all pan out in the end." (cute eh?) Oh well......
God Bless Everyone,
Daryl Lach
USA Central
Daryl,
William Booth was basically a-millenial as well as George Scott Railton.Booth (like others of his day)thought that the world would be evangelized and improved. He thought that the Army would play a big part in this and the Lord would return and there would be a "general" judgement. This would also mean that he did not believe in a literal 1,000 year reign on earth by Christ.Salvation Army doctrine to this day still mentions "general" judgement. When World War I came along and the kingdom was not ushered in with brass bands playing and timbrels waving, peoples opinions and doctrine swayed. Hence, pre and post became more popular.
I heard that Keith Green used the term that it will all "pan out". I always thought that was a good reliable statement myself.Some people even combine some of the views.
By the way, there was another USA former in there as well as another USA Eastern Territory. I am not the only former from the east that is posting on this site.
USA EAST Former
Dear USA East former,
I don't want to belabor the point here since this posting is suppose to be about addictions but I'm pretty sure Booth was a post -millennialist who thought (the same as Phineas Brezee of the Nazarenes, etc.) that his group would usher in the Kingdom of God (millennium)on earth. If I'm not mistaken other sources such as Murdoch and Hattersley would agree with that. I suppose the crux would be that literal 1000 year reign detail of which I never remember anything written about it one way or the other concerning Booth. At any rate he wasn't a pre-millenialist dispensationalist which seems to be the dominant view among conservative American Xians these days and for the past 60 years. As stated though, since this posting is suppose to be about addictions, anyone (Sven?) care to start a new topic/posting for eschatology detail freaks and fanatics? (There'll probably be a huge response from the states. Actually Sven, forget the probably, it's guaranteed!! 'Nuff said from me.)
Daryl Lach
USA Central
Daryl,
Same here. This would not be the best place for continuing end times discussion. It really does not matter anyway.I thought that I read about Booth being a-millenial but post must be correct. The other items mentioned were as you stated. Just as someone may be dogmatic or set on an end -time belief, things do not always pan out like one would think. Booth , Railton and others thought that the world would get better. It does not look that way, in many respects.I think that society will continue to neglect God, beyond even neglecting a religion or place of worship.
Thanks for responding.
USA East former
(going to be multiple posts as cannot post large responses anymore)
Getting back to addiction.... Thanks Daryl, that’s exactly what I meant about addictions etc.
I think some of the disagreements we are having regarding addictions and recovery comes from having different understandings as to what is addiction and recovery. There is the classic understanding of Alcoholics and Drug addicts, with recovery being complete abstinence. However, I don’t agree with that understanding. The acknowledgement that food addiction and relationship addiction (often referred to as sex & love addiction) adds a very different understanding. Recovery from these looks very different. Abstinence cannot work as one cannot be abstinent from food and live. Recovery then is where the individual is able to be around and partake in their drug of choice and not be affected by it or go back into their addiction. This understanding is unthinkable to traditional Alcoholics and Drug addicts. If you were to go to a Sex & Love Addicts Anon. Meeting (SLAA), you would find that almost all the people there have been through AA or NA, and all of them would say that they are doing far more work on themselves etc. then they ever did in AA or NA – even though they have been ‘clean’ from Alcohol or Drugs for many years. Abstinence is not the same as recovery. It is also interesting to note that almost all those at a SLAA meeting would talk about conservative church teaching as the thing that started them on their addiction, and they all had to reject church teaching in order to find recovery (I’m talking about SLAA as I have a lot of experience with people in this group).
(Graeme - part 1)
When I was appointed to the Rehab. Command in Australia East, I saw a lot of emphasis placed on how much more statistically successful the Bridge program was as opposed to the secular programs. The stats were that in secular programs, about 2% of people found a certain level of recover, while in TSA program, about 40% of people found recovery. I also noted though that the two lots of stats were not comparable – they had different definitions of recovery and the data came from different types of sources. I re-jigged the data myself, using similar definitions of recovery and drawing data from similar sources. I discovered the 2% figure for secular programs, but I found 0.04% of people in TSA found a similar level of recovery – 2 out of every 100 found recovery where no theology was asserted, while 2 in every 5000 found recovery where a particular theology was asserted. Why is the success rate so low in cases where the church is involved? My work with those in SLAA answered that for me.
That was why I brought up the issue about sexuality. It helps us to clarify what addiction and recovery is, and it helps to understand what some of the issues are. I am not anti-bible or anti-God. I am if anything, anti-church. I am a person who will re-interpret the Bible if I find that traditional interpretations are wrong, or just don’t work, or are contrary to what we know scientifically. I also measure the Bible against itself. Christ said ‘17Likewise every good tree bears good fruit, but a bad tree bears bad fruit. 18A good tree cannot bear bad fruit, and a bad tree cannot bear good fruit. 19Every tree that does not bear good fruit is cut down and thrown into the fire.’ (Mat. 7:17-19). What does the fruit of the church in this case prove? What does the fruit of the secular programs show? We can say that it is just hard work to follow the church’s teachings, and many just can’t do it. But that doesn’t gel with what the Bible said. The church is bearing bad fruit, and Christ said that a good tree cannot bear bad fruit.
With regard to ‘recovery from homosexuality’ (or reparative therapy), the former leaders of Exodus International (Australia) have publically stated that not one person in their entire movement worldwide has ever been able to change their sexuality. Many of the counsellors/psychologists involved in reparative therapies have also stated that none of the clients undergoing reparative therapy have ever changed their sexuality. I was not painting a broad brush. There is a lot of ‘kidding’ each other where people think it is successful. As I said in an earlier post – most of these people end up taking their sexuality underground – to beats and anonymous sex on premises venues, and those that don’t, end up getting more and more psychologically disturbed. This is the cold reality. This says to me that either God is impotent to do anything (and therefore not God), or there is nothing wrong for God to fix, and we need to re-interpret scripture etc. and realise that a lot of our theology etc. is causing destruction and death – including addiction.
Yours,
Graeme Randall (part 2)
Former Australian East
When I was appointed to the Rehab. Command in Australia East, I saw a lot of emphasis placed on how much more statistically successful the Bridge program was as opposed to the secular programs. The stats were that in secular programs, about 2% of people found a certain level of recover, while in TSA program, about 40% of people found recovery. I also noted though that the two lots of stats were not comparable – they had different definitions of recovery and the data came from different types of sources. I re-jigged the data myself, using similar definitions of recovery and drawing data from similar sources. I discovered the 2% figure for secular programs, but I found 0.04% of people in TSA found a similar level of recovery – 2 out of every 100 found recovery where no theology was asserted, while 2 in every 5000 found recovery where a particular theology was asserted. Why is the success rate so low in cases where the church is involved? My work with those in SLAA answered that for me.
That was why I brought up the issue about sexuality. It helps us to clarify what addiction and recovery is, and it helps to understand what some of the issues are. I am not anti-bible or anti-God. I am if anything, anti-church. I am a person who will re-interpret the Bible if I find that traditional interpretations are wrong, or just don’t work, or are contrary to what we know scientifically. I also measure the Bible against itself. Christ said ‘17Likewise every good tree bears good fruit, but a bad tree bears bad fruit. 18A good tree cannot bear bad fruit, and a bad tree cannot bear good fruit. 19Every tree that does not bear good fruit is cut down and thrown into the fire.’ (Mat. 7:17-19). What does the fruit of the church in this case prove? What does the fruit of the secular programs show? We can say that it is just hard work to follow the church’s teachings, and many just can’t do it. But that doesn’t gel with what the Bible said. The church is bearing bad fruit, and Christ said that a good tree cannot bear bad fruit.
(Graeme - part 2)
It would be nice to see a few other opinions on this subject.It seems that the subject has about three basic opinions and that is all that is repeated.I also see some fuzzy rational.I think I hear an old topical sermon where thought , opinions, and ideas are laid out and then some Scripture is used to make it all fit.I have seen some victory in lives over various sexual sin.One person was a minister that was involved with prostitution and was a pimp.His life is restored once again. Some people are happy with where they are with certain problems , compulsions and addictions. Since we are complex beings with various backgrounds with pre conceptions and private thought it goes to show that much counsel and interpretation needs to take place in addictive personalities.I had an officer share with me that has a PHD that some folk with strong addictions combine their theology and addictions together to come up with a plan to recovery or rationalize the continuance of addiction. I think he is right.
It would be easy to say that if a person just had Christ as Savior that every thing will be fine. It goes way beyond that. I am not diminishing the power of God or taking away His control but humans have a lot of freedom of choice and we would agree that certain choices can cause a host of problems that affect many other people. It often is a chain reaction of destruction or perhaps blessing.
I notice that many American Native Indians that I work with have addictions to alcohol. For some reason these folk have more addictions than some other cultures or race. Is it some chemical reaction in American Native Indians or is it because the white man has abused this culture over the years. It may be both. Addictions are very complex.The road to recovery needs a good plan. Perhaps a very "personal" plan . The 12 step plan is one of a few examples. It looks at a step by step continual progress that really never stops.Regardless of the plan for recovery, the spiritual part of ones life and the relational part are very important and need monitoring and growth.
As far as some stats over a period of months and not rechecking I often saw a recovery of about 25% a few years ago. I have not been in touch with most people in this program since I am no longer an officer , however I am involved with case management with homeless men and women now.
USA East former
This certainly has been a lively conversation and I LOVED Fletch's post about addictive fundamentalism. Made me office mates wonder as I laughed out loud at my desk. While I'm sure there are valid reasons to post anonymously I'm concerned about those spew such vitriolic language and ideas under that guise. They make me very, very nervous. Just my two cents.
Deb,
I go anonymous because of your post. Some ,I have been told will not come here for fear of attack. It really is not important who I am. It is more important for discussion without defacing.
Have a great day.
USA East former
Many comments back I posted the following:
So..... what do we do to help those within the ranks who deal with a fractured heart by turning to whatever their addiction of choice may be (it really doesn't matter what the controlling item is but the reality is that anything- yes even fundamentalism can come between a person and wholeness).
My own perspective is that in order to live healthy lives we have to learn in our developmental stages how to do so. Would it behoove The Army to be proactive in teaching self-care early and often?
USA West Former
USA West Former
Thank you for your post and yes it would be an amazing step forward if the 'Army' were pro active in providing self care and (I believe) personal development early and often and then it may transpire that we have less formers and more Officers who are able more actively care for people in their care, and even their leaders. We sometimes forget that all our people's souls are wrapped up in a fragile emotional and physical package that really does not concern itself with their theological standpoint, no matter what it is.
What happens after I leave this life will echo a great Australian article of belief "She'll be right mate" as I simply have no control over it, but what happens here between me and the people I have dealings with on a personal level is my responsibility.
My we all aspire to live health emotional lives and seek wholeness in all things.
I fully agree with the above two posts. We must also look at the things that are psychologically dammaging to people. And if that means changing our theology, then we need to change our theology. If we don't, then it won't be long until TSA and the wider conservative church will be viewed as a nut-case dangerous cult. People can be severely psychollogically damaed with the best of intentions and in the name of God and love.
Yours,
Graeme Randall
Former Australian East
Graeme,
You touched on something that is often avoided because this site is often promoting The Salvation Army.You stated that because of psychological damage to people there needs to be a change of theology. If that does not change than the wider conservative church and TSA will be viewed as a nut-case dangerous cult. You stated that people can be psychologically damaged with the best of intentions and in the name of God and love.
To some it would seem that has already affected them in an obvious way.Interesting that you mention cult. To some hearing that word about the Army "cult", would be worse than saying something demeaning about the Bible or God. What I have seen is that many formers have had huge differences of "opinion" or different views with the Army in general or with a prior leader,(most often a DC.) Once again a power or "control" by either set creeds by the organization or regulation "policy" is used often in a "legalistic" way and not enough grace. Ironically the Bible is often (not used) or vague mentioning of it when officers leave the Army or when presenting an issue.
I do not see in the immediate future that the Army will change it's doctrine, theology, or practice. Most of all I do not see much change in operation and style of leadership (lording it over ) or the hierarchical system. The Army is The Army. Some things will most likely never change and you and I can agree on that. It is too bad. I also do not think (regardless of opinion or theology) that openly gay people will be allowed to serve as officers in The Salvation Army
The subject of addictions has been interesting, but I have responded to your statement mentioned here.
USA former
Взмахом руки консьерж заставил Беккера остановиться и нервно оглядел фойе.Эти слова его удивили. Никто никогда не называл Джаббу дураком, свиньей — быть может, но дураком — никогда. [url=http://www.cooksequipment.com/wp-content/themes/famous/style/seks-znakomstva-pyatigorska.html]секс знакомства пятигорска[/url]
[url=http://123-thai.com/wp-content/themes/wp-soul/css/nizhnevartovsk-seks-znakomstva.html]нижневартовск секс знакомства[/url]
— Я сказал тебе — подними!Слева послышался звон разбитого стекла. Беккер повернулся и увидел человека в красном одеянии. Тот вскрикнул и испуганно посмотрел на Беккера. Как кот, пойманный с канарейкой в зубах, святой отец вытер губы и безуспешно попытался прикрыть разбившуюся бутылку вина для святого причастия.
Хотя Энсей Танкадо никогда прежде не видел компьютера, он как будто инстинктивно знал, как с ним обращаться. Компьютер открыл перед ним мир, о существовании которого он даже не подозревал, и вскоре заполнил всю его жизнь. Повзрослев, он начал давать компьютерные уроки, зарабатывать деньги и в конце концов получил стипендию для учебы в Университете Досися. Вскоре слава о фугуся-кисай, гениальном калеке, облетела Токио. [url=http://www.niccoloagliardi.it/wp-content/plugins/captcha/style/znakomstva-intimnie-v-novosibirske.html]знакомства интимные в новосибирске[/url]
[url=http://www.pastorjasonlim.org/wp-content/themes/tranquil-reflections/icon/seks-znakomstva-na-odnoklassniki.html]секс знакомства на одноклассники[/url][url=http://blog.b2c.so/wp-content/themes/twentyten/images/img/intimnie-znakomstva-nizhniy-novgorod.html]интимные знакомства нижний новгород[/url]
[url=http://crjunglistcrew.com/wp-content/plugins/akismet/seks-znakomstva-baku.html]секс знакомства баку[/url][url=http://www.everydaylifeinsurance.org/wp-content/themes/everyday/css/intim-v-nizhnem-novgorode.html]интим в нижнем новгороде[/url]
[url=http://digitalelectronicscale.net/wp-content/themes/twentyten/icon/luchshiy-sayt-intimnie-znakomstva.html]лучший сайт интимные знакомства[/url][url=http://blogsir.net/wp-content/themes/ips/js/seks-znakomstva-kostanay.html]секс знакомства костанай[/url]
[url=http://wp.therisingpath.com/wp-content/themes/arras/css/style/intimnie-znakomstva-v-gomele.html]интимные знакомства в гомеле[/url][url=http://www.recetaslacocinera.es/wp-content/themes/chip-life/css/individualki-intim-moskva.html]индивидуалки интим москва[/url]
— Понятия не имею.
Post a Comment