Saturday, July 3, 2010

Where is the celebration and affirmation ?


As a person who encountered and entered Salvation Army soldiership and then officership in young adulthood, I have often wondered at the emotional enmeshment or peculiar belongingness Salvation Army officers experience within the organization. I have entered and departed from several groupings of people in my life, some with very strong personal and spiritual ties, but I’ve failed to experience the kind of heart-wrenching angst that many former officers I know have experienced. I have to wonder why this is, and whether understanding some of the ‘why’ would help both the officer and the Salvation Army administration to address the concerns that are frequently expressed by people who have left officership.

Is there something in our institutional history and practice that makes the transition more difficult? Could it be that the strong family pattern beginning with the Booths gets played out in the parent/child relationships that are so common throughout the Army world, resulting in a sense of disappointment and what feels like an emotional shunning at resignation? While I have the utmost respect for William Booth, his devotion to his mission was so fierce and his belief in his own authority so great that, especially after Catherine’s death, William appeared to be unable to remain in relationship with his children who disagreed with him.

Roger Green quotes David Bennett’s biography of Booth: “Ballington, Herbert, Katie and their families were absent [from Booth’s deathbed]. They were almost no longer part of the family, certainly they were no longer part of the family business.” These children, once trusted and valuable Salvation Army leaders, were forbidden to be present and/or to participate in the funeral of their sister Emma, and did not appear to be at their father’s funeral either.

There is an institutional memory that does not easily fade, and while we would not directly relate the Booth family history to an officer resigning in 2010, that memory appears at times to be long and unforgiving, often subconsciously. The shame involved in being disowned by a parent is deep, and this is a part of our institutional memory.

Perhaps related to this are the patterns of secrecy in our institutional history and practices. Consider General John Larsson’s description of ‘1929’, when the “constitutional storm that had long been gathering suddenly burst, sweeping from office General Bramwell Booth, the son and successor to General William Booth. So traumatic was this event that for many years 1929 – for that is how it was known – was only talked of in hushed tones in Army circles. The telling of what happened was left to those from outside the Army family.”

Those same hushed tones are often used when certain names are spoken in current Army circles. There have been a number of resignations and early retirements within the international Army of officers who have served faithfully, courageously and effectively in a variety of appointments, with a number of these being high profile leaders. Yet in most cases, they’ve simply ‘gone away.’ It is only in the last few years that there has been any written or verbal acknowledgement or explanation surrounding an officer’s departure, and I’d venture to say this has begun to happen because the individual officer has avenues such as e-mail and Facebook to share their message of their transition, requiring the Army leadership to acknowledge the departure in some way.

Where is the celebration and affirmation of what has been accomplished through their ministry? Where is the blessing upon their future work? Where is the mediation that can bring closure to these transitions, rather than leaving them seeping blood long into the future? We can’t afford to translate Booth’s dismissal of his children into the practices of twenty-first century mission.

Having recognized something that may contribute to the shame and sorrow of officer resignation, it is easiest to suggest that the Salvation Army change its practices and policies to better ease the transition for those who leave. But in the end, we each continue to be challenged by Paul’s message to the Romans: “If it is possible, as far as it depends on you, live at peace with everyone” (Romans 12:18 NIV). While we may wish that those in our organizational history had found ways to resolve their difficulties, our story is that of this century.

We each have the privilege of the person of faith who can “draw near with confidence to the throne of grace, so that [we] may receive mercy and find grace to help in time of need” (Hebrews 4:16 NASB). We also have the privilege of reaching out our hand in reconciliation from where we are: former, active, retired, on the edge, not sure, tired, fulfilled, broken, whole, frightened, courageous. We each can encourage organizational change, but we can also reach out our hand and heart to another today.

Major JoAnn Shade ministers with her husband Larry as the corps officers and Directors of the Ray and Joan Kroc Corps Community Center. She received a B.A. in sociology from S.U.N.Y. at Binghamton, a M.A. in Pastoral Counseling, and a Doctor of Ministry degree from Ashland Theological Seminary in June, 2006. She is a prolific writer, lecturer, and busy counselor and has been a valued contributor to this blog since its inception.

20 comments:

Anonymous said...

The term 'belongingness' is new to me. I first saw it when Sven used it and now again by you. Yes, an apt description of what we had, but apparently some more than others. It's clear that those at the top protect 'their own' when it's time to step down or to the side, while the rest of us are left to fend for ourselves.

I have no interest in knowing why Commissioner "J" or Colonel "T" suddenly retired or was appointed to an assignment on the other side of the country. It mirrors too closely the unsubstantiated accusations we witness in the corporate and political arena, by now far too common. But, please do not follow the world's ways, instead be forgiving, fair and faithful in loving all equally.

Active
USA West

Anonymous said...

JoAnn, thank you for what you have written. I think that you are always fair and have a healthy outlook when you present your opinion and the facts. Sven, these articles have been open and honest. Sometimes the truth hurts, but we move on.

USA East former

Anonymous said...

Between our 1st. and 2nd. year of Training, some of us 2ND. year Cadets were in our house Sitting Room @ the Training College, when one of our Session who had left during Out-Training came in. We were chatting with him, when the House Officer came in, and said to him “If you’ve come for your trunk, it’s in the basement. Take it, and get out.” We told the Captain that our friend had come to see us too, and he was staying. This is the same Captain who used to keep in touch with us, but never contacted us again after we resigned – not even when he was moved to a position in the Division where we then soldiered.

At our last Officers’ Councils, (before we ever thought about resigning) there was some unrest among some Officers, because we had been given a room in the main building at Swanwick, rather than the Garden House, which is further away, as my husband had been ill. People wanted to know why Lieutenants were in the main house, when they should be in the Garden House – the Main House was for senior Officers.

At the same councils, one of the Senior Leaders from our area of work stopped to enquire after our welfare. He was a lovely person, and did care about his Officers, but he asked us how the children were, and we’ve never had children! Now I can appreciate you can’t remember everything about all the Officers under your command, but you could at least read their files before you speak to them, to avoid making basic mistakes like that. At the time, it made me feel that and showed how well he really knew his Officers!

When our furniture was being moved when we resigned, the Officer in charge of where we were couldn’t even come and say goodbye to us, but came out to the removers to tell them to be careful of the carpet in the foyer! In contrast, the Chaplain, who hadn’t been told we were going, came over to see us as soon as he heard, in spite of the fact that his Quarters had been burgled the previous day. He was annoyed that nobody had told him about us. He and his wife kept in touch with us after we left.

I think the subject of Clergy Burnout should be taught in Training College, and addressed by DCs etc. in relation to their Officers. We too were just left to get on with things, sometimes with no help, often with no full-time help, and in 1 Appointment running 3 centres on our own, so we could never leave the Centre together, never mind get a day off.

As others have said, the physical repercussions of that continue in our lives today, and it only gets worse as you get older.

“Former, UKT.”

Anonymous said...

Curious that while the Army chooses not to affirm, let alone celebrate, those who resign, there are congregations who rejoice to receive their ministry!

former, USC

Anonymous said...

Well said Major !

Last week your blog shared from an editorial written by the General, " the realization that in another 125 years my work may be looked at in a similar vein". General, with respect, unless we alter our belongingness and retention strategy, the only SA work those interested in our work can look to will be in libraries, or through visits to third world countries.

Active officer
London

Anonymous said...

The issues are easily identifiable as being relevant in the USA 'East' and fast becoming an epidemic.There is no doubt that there would be a mass exodus if the officers could afford to leave everything to resign…most cannot, hence their indentured servitude.

The varied issues being addressed (culture, history, etc.) must be dealt with before any real change can occur.

Please keep writing and including authors with the skill and talent of JoAnn and others...

Former
USA East

Anonymous said...

General Eva Burrows preached to the Cadets last week a day before they were commissioned. Her main points were:

“5 Effective Habits of Highly Effective Officers”.

Habit 1 - Keep studying
Always remain a student of the world around us and a student of the Bible. That way we will understand the context of mission and be able to offer the Word in a relevant way.

Habit 2 - Nurture yourself
With devotions, with good coaches or mentors or spiritual directors. Defects in spiritual life affects our leadership more than anything else. So have a plan for our personal spiritual development and follow it.

Habit 3 - Use your uniqueness in your ministry
God wants us to be who he made us to be. Be who you are and do what you do best. This way you will do wonders for God’s kingdom.

Habit 4 - Exercise competence beyond your gifting
Don’t use gifting as an excuse for not doing what is our responsibility. Learn about what we don’t know and talk with others and utilise others who can help. Don’t monopolise your ministry, but multiply it.

Habit 5 - Be a spiritual leader
Cast vision. Have a clear and passionate focus for mission. Be ready to adjust strategies. Above all, like Jesus be a Servant Leader.

Australia

Anonymous said...

hello... hapi blogging... have a nice day! just visiting here....

Anonymous said...

I have to say it: much of my motive for resigning issued from pride. Pride prevented me from talking to others, from considering options, from taking time off, from exercising, or from just falling apart in the arms of a brother who might have cared. Pride kept me from saying, "I don't know what to do," as opposed to saying, "I'm going to quit—end of discussion!"

I wish I'd known how hard ministry really is, when you think you're alone in the fight.”
USA

Johnny said...

This is a wonderful article. Thank you so much.

Anonymous said...

Great article that is relevent and very true. True change will take place in the Army when hearts are set right with God and officers that gave so much "including formers" are treated fairly and with more concern.

Are officers things that are discarded and thrown away ? Did the Lord get rid of Peter ?

USA East former

Anonymous said...

Spot on!!

This article is a real psychological eye opener and one that should be researched and explored further.

Thank you for sharing your articles they always give 'food for thought'.

Time for me has been the greatest healer of a very painful experiences but I hope my experiences can be of use in His service to support others who are at the beginning of a very painful journey.

“Getting over a painful experience is much like crossing monkey bars. You have to let go at some point in order to move forward.”

This fellowship is what I describe as 'the safety net' under those monkey bars, people are ready to catch you when you fall. As a fellowship we reach out our hand to support others.

May God continue to bless and use those who continue to inspire us.

This is a unique fellowship and I am blest to be a part of it.

Blessings

Tracey Oliver
Former, UK Territory

Eleanor Burne-Jones said...

I think the key problem is that the charism of salvationism is trapped inside the institution. Whereas one can be a Franciscan, for example, in any number of different denominations and orders, or even none, there has generally been only one way to be 'a salvationist'. Until we manage to understand the two as not being inevitably bound up together, the angst will continue. Before people panic, that doesn't mean TSA as an institution fragmenting or 'rival' organisations (how could there be?). It simply means welcoming diverse expressions, and allowing the grace that is salvationism to pour over the top of the cup.

FloridaFlamingo said...

Sometimes we have to make our own celebration and affirmation, eh? I remember hearing someone (I think Harville Hendrix)say that we always have all the love we need in our lives, it just might not be in the form we think it should be. We may expect it from former officer/friends etc but it is coming from somewhere else.

Good to hear from you again Tracey. I missed you.

Anonymous said...

Thank you Deborah.

Blessings to you.

Tracey
(Former UK)

Anonymous said...

tracey - email me sometime......

R - not far from you!

Anonymous said...

Deb,

I like your comment about love being supplied through various sources. I think affirmation or appreciation is linked also. I have seen this in action over the years. It is nice when someone shows you love and appreciation in various forms.
We need this as human beings,and God provides in these various avenues. I receive a lot of love from my cat. May sound far fetched but when the world has got me down and I feel bad, I can always get appreciation and a purr from the cat. "Unconditional Love" I think we need to look more at nature and the creation that we have as a very precious gift.

Thanks for making me reflect and think more on this matter. It hit home with me.

USA East former

Anonymous said...

My past officers just recently left the work. They were given a great farewell and the Divisional Commander came out and did their farewell and presented them with a plaque for their service. They are staying in the area and it is our hope that they will decide to come back to the corps as their family is greatly missed as a family.

Amber Imhoff
Accepted Canidate for the class of 2010-2012

Anonymous said...

Sorry R not sure who you are!!

Tracey
Former UK

Anonymous said...

When we resigned with less than 30 years we received a plaque from our Advisory Board and a farewell lunch from the corps members. Those folks looked at us as though we were retiring , and were generally happy for us.The Divisional Commander was very immature about everything and pouted like a child. He visited with us for 15 minutes because THQ requires an exit interview.He did not attend our final meeting nor was a representative there. Honestly, I expected that but was grateful to spend the last of our time together with the people that supported us for nearly 5 years. I would not want anyone to feel awkward because we left on our own accord under good conditions. In fact the territory where we live now has offered us an appointment . We declined with appreciation.

USA East former