Saturday, December 20, 2008

ERRONEOUS LEADERSHIP

I served as an officer for 25 years along side my wife who served for 31 years. I am a third generation Salvationist with deep roots in the Army. I lay that foundation to provide a broad frame of reference.

During my service as an officer, I worked diligently to fulfill the mission of the Army I love and thought I would die for. The Army was gracious enough to enable me to obtain a BS and MA degree at their expense. Both those degrees focused on leadership. I sought permission to pursue doctoral studies in Organizational Leadership (I became deeply interested in leadership studies because of the educational experiences) but was denied as I was told officers did not need doctoral degrees in Army ministry (all the while I observed a number of other officers working toward and accomplishing that same goal- The SA paying tuition, books, etc.). I was also told – verbally by a friend who was privy to written correspondence on the matter –I was not leadership material, which was a factor in the decision to deny my request for Army support of a doctoral degree. I am presently working on my dissertation toward an EdD in Organizational Leadership.

Gretchen and I resigned in April of 2008 when I was offered a position to teach at a local university. I am teaching management and leadership courses, a course in faith and worldviews, and personal and business ethics. Many factors contributed to our decision to leave the work, but will reserve for another time, as I choose to discuss the tremendous debauchery of leadership that permeates the Army. Making such a broad statement seems to indict all leadership in the Army, which I realize is an unfair assumption. I do know of some very good and well-meaning leaders in the Army.
However, a leadership culture permeates the Army that is counter productive to Christ’s Kingdom growth and is far afield from a Biblical perspective of leadership. Contemporary leadership theory contends that autocratic self-serving leadership model is out of date and destructive. The vertical top-down model gives way to power struggles and is generally concerned with the personal desires and wishes of a few top leaders. The new models emerging in corporate directing is a lateral leadership structure involving teams and shared leadership to accomplish mission and goals.

1965, Robert Greenleaf proposed a new Servant Leadership model. In recent years, I have heard a number of high profile people in the Army speak of servant leadership. However, the actions of leadership do not match that model. Essentially servant leadership is as Greenleaf suggests, “The servant-leader is servant first…to make sure other people’s highest priority needs are being served…do they, while being served, become healthier, wiser, freer, more autonomous, more likely themselves to become servants” (from The Servant as Leader). This type of leadership, while not exclusively Biblical, has Scriptural foundation as exemplified in the life of Christ. “Who, being in very nature God, did not consider equality with God something to be grasped, but made himself nothing, taking the very nature of a servant…” (Philippians 2:6-7 – see also Matthew 20:26). Perhaps a simpler definition of servant leadership is “Servant leadership is an understanding and practice of leadership that places the good of those led over the self-interest of the leader” (Dr. James Laub).

The leadership practices of this contemporary Army, especially in the United States, are quite contrary to the servant leadership model. For an organization highly motivated by service, this provides a huge conundrum. Several experiences in my career supported the premise that the talk about servant leadership by senior officers was merely lip service. One recent conversation with a general secretary confirms that assertion when he stated we must protect our assets. This demonstrated a long time assumption that the organization is more concerned with its own interests relegating the care and concern of its personnel, which is a distinctive premise of servant leadership, to the lowest priority. Essentially, the human resources that are the most valuable asset to any organization are disposable to the Army.

The unfortunate result of an organization that places a high value on positional leadership is self-aggrandizement and disregard for personnel. A warning by the Apostle Paul places this in proper perspective, “For by the grace given me I say to every one of you: Do not think of yourself more highly than you ought, but rather think of yourself with sober judgment, in accordance with the measure of faith God has given you” (Romans 12:3 - NIV). The grace of God demonstrates the equality of human beings. Regrettably, man creates a hierarchal structure with a view that some individuals are more important than others creating a caste level culture.

The resulting cultural mindset in the Army implies power is control. The fear in the organization is that advanced degrees in leadership suggest knowledge is power, which creates a knowledge-based organization contrary to an autocratic power and control form of leadership. The more knowledge one gains is a direct threat to current organizational culture opposed to increased knowledge for all members (officers). Clearly, a high degree of practical and spiritual knowledge is intimidating to Army leadership, which often results in threats, unrealistic transfers, and pressure to resign. An officer of lower rank and position is viewed as inexperienced in all areas, even though there may be a high degree of functional and spiritual knowledge. A fallacy exists when the organization views experience or tenure as wisdom.

The Army does not provide realistic and immediate (extrinsic) reward, albeit the intrinsic reward should be the expectation of “Well done, good and faithful servant!” (Matthew 25:23 - NIV). Therefore, appointment and position are a determined and strived for reward. This creates a deeper leadership issue since many individuals striving for those positions are unqualified in leadership ability. Many leadership lessons learned in the organizational structure are contrary and counterproductive as suggested above. The basis of those leadership lessons come from antiquated models focused on authority, control, and power. Void in those lessons is any specific integration of the Scriptural model of leadership. Early in my officer career, a general secretary acknowledged that spiritual or Biblical considerations are not regarded in Finance Council (Board) meetings. They are merely business meetings viewing business decisions from a secular perspective. Many of the comments on the discussion board support this theory.

My heart says that the leadership culture will remain unchanged in the Army. Change takes courage and a deep trust in our sovereign Lord. It requires a decisiveness that places Christ on the throne and allows His leadership to reign. Change demands an uncompromising commitment to the purpose and plan of God. It requires the organization to surrender to the authority and leadership of God.

My sense is many of us 'formers' captured the need to be released from a leadership culture that increasingly ignores the supremacy of Christ is all areas of Army tradition. A freedom exists now for me, and clearly in many of those writing for and in this fellowship, allowing God to use all the gifts, abilities, talents, desires, passion, and skill He designed in me.

Randy Savage
Former Officer
USA

21 comments:

Anonymous said...

Thanks Randy, you have given us much food for thought. As I read two very simple thoughts came to my mind. I think it was Mother Teresa who said: 'No one is so poor they have nothing to give and no one is so rich they have nothing to receive.' I considered this in terms of leadership. My thinking then moved me on to the verse of a song that says:
'Brother let me be your servant,
Let me be as Christ to you.
Pray that I may have the grace
To let you be my servant too.'

Active officer (24 years)
UKT

Anonymous said...

Randy, your article aptly describes the growing struggle with the notion of leadership within the SA; the strength of this blog in terms of its growing membership is a case in point. I may be wrong, put the presence of FSAOF in itself, appears to be unique phenomenon amongst denominations.

I feel that there is also a need for the Army to theologically reappraise its understanding of presbyteral ministry.

Now as a Methodist I share the , the Uk connexion's understanding of ministry as "Christ's ministers in the church are stewards in the household of God and shepherds of his flock. Some are called and ordained to this sole occupation and have a principal and directing part in these great duties but they hold no priesthood differing in kind from that which is common to all the Lord's people and they have no exclusive title to the preaching of the gospel or the care of souls. These ministries are shared with them by others to whom also the Spirit divides his gifts severally as he wills."

William Willimon in his book, Pastor, a reader in ordained ministry writes "Although called to exercise wise and loving leadership on the basis of the Word of God, they (ministers/officer) are bound to the faithful in interdependence and reciprocity."

Leadership is not in the Leaders themselves but in the followers. It is the followers who determine whether someone is a leader or not.

Rev'd Paul Collings

Former UK

Anonymous said...

Hi Randy, thanks for sharing. I believe you are about 20 years too early, and if you were an officer down the track you would be utilised to implement change in the leadership structure of the Army.

Its interesting that I found your comments from a link from the current TC, so its good that the TC is open for differing opinons.

Your statement was excellent ....

The vertical top-down model gives way to power struggles and is generally concerned with the personal desires and wishes of a few top leaders. The new models emerging in corporate directing is a lateral leadership structure involving teams and shared leadership to accomplish mission and goals.

FORMER SALVATION ARMY OFFICERS FELLOWSHIP said...

Some interesting comments on a relatively new topic for this fellowship's blog. I'm in the process of selecting a few articles/comments from those shared by the more than 55 contributors and 8,000 visitors to date, with SA leadership, London, at their request.

With regard to Randy's article, I recall when the then CEO of Scandinavian Airlines System, Jan Carlsson (his personal assistant was a salvationist from the Stockholm Temple Corps and dear family friend) turned the management world upside down with his book TEAR DOWN THE PYRAMIDS (Swedish), eventually translated into many languages.

Many MBA schools, including Harvard, Wharton, Kellogg, Stamford, etc. immediately heralded Jan as the new international management guru. He traveled the lecture circuits throughout the nineties attracting disciples near and far. The unrivaled decade long success of SAS was ‘proof’ that his theories, when correctly applied, were working. I recall well how SAS changed their management style; I was the NY Regional Manager of their chief trans-Atlantic foe, Finnair. We quickly followed suit.

It was a testing period for many as a number of Fortune 500 companies emphasized the transfer of people possessing valuable knowledge between projects rather than the transfer of valuable knowledge between people. The Salvation Army began adopting this policy to some extent some 20 years behind the times. I can share however, that I saw it in action in developing territories where veteran officers of high rank shared equal responsibility with junior rank officers, or where Colonels and Majors reported to Captains; transfer of people (regardless of rank).

Carlsson wrote a number of pieces on management and employee empowerment including his excellent book on customer service, "Moments of Truth' describing how empowering front line employees
to put the customer first turned SAS around. It became the primer for a whole new concept in marketing (management); customer relationship. I have written a number of papers on the subject adding to Kotler's theories by developing a 4 Ps concept similar to that used in product marketing.
In time, and with support, I intend to write a MARKETING YOUR CORPS FOR GROWTH, based on the exact same management principles, moving beyond the simplistic formulas offered by far too many well-intentioned, but woefully lacking in management skills, Pastors. We used the concepts to great advantage in NY, and later in Russia, Ukraine, and beyond. (600 recruits trained and enrolled during a 5 year period) Let me be clear, we were led by the Captain of our faith Who inspired and provided the vision.

John, please give thought to sharing with us, as Paul and Randy and others have already done, by writing an article for the blog.

HAPPY CHRISTMAS ALL !

Anonymous said...

Sven, would it help to have a Corps to work with in your 'Marketing your Corps for Growth' process? If so, please work with us at Exeter Temple. The timing could be perfect as we commence our Mission Development Plan in conjunction with DHQ, mid March - Mid May. I would see the two going hand in hand and being of much benefit to the Corps.

GBY real good!
Glad Ljungholm :-)

FORMER SALVATION ARMY OFFICERS FELLOWSHIP said...

The 4 Ps of services marketing could be implemented by any corps/institution with the necessary resources; enough willing and dedicated staff/volunteers, sustainable target market and sufficient budget.

Your corps could perhaps be used as a case study. Figure a minimum of 1-2 years and 5-6000 GBP.

Perhaps preliminary discussions can be held at the Corps' retreat the second weekend in January ? I could include it in my seminar on 'Vision results from a deep dissatisfaction with the status quo !'

Anonymous said...

Sven and Glad, My heart is warmed at he intended work at Exeter temple.

I've been following Bishop William Willimon's blog, former Dean of Duke University Chapel. In a recent blog he quoted the following regarding the marks of an effective church.

EFFECTIVE CONGREGATIONS:

1. Love their particularly community. Their pastors have found a way not only to love their congregations but also their neighborhood. Effective pastors help their congregations move beyond love of themselves, turning their congregations outward.
2. Rise above mere contentment with things as they are and do what is necessary to expect and welcome change, disruption, and movement, similar to that of the Risen Christ.
3. Find a way to welcome the stranger and to practice radical hospitality in the name of Jesus Christ. They find a way to be as interested in those who have yet to join the church as those already in the church.
4. Have a clear sense of their primary purpose and keep focused on their primary God-given missions.
5. Enable lay leaders to lead, not just manage. Lay leadership that feels a strong sense of responsibility for the future of their congregation.
6. All have a strong, change oriented, gifted pastor.
7. Make growth a priority and figure out how to grow.
8. Keep focused upon Jesus Christ as the originator of, and the purpose for the church (rather than church as just another human oriented institution).

How does your church answer to these qualities of effective churches? What specific steps would your congregation need to take to live into the future in a different way?

http://willimon.blogspot.com/

At Topsham Methodist Church, not may mile from you, we are going use this as a basis for exploring our call to ministry and our mission within out community. I look forward to reading more of the Temple's initiative.

Paul
Former but active in ministry.

FORMER SALVATION ARMY OFFICERS FELLOWSHIP said...

Paul, # 7 on Willimon's list is the make/break component. Without real breakthrough oriented methods the remainder will never be more than a wish list. The 4 Ps that I chose, and from which the services marketing plan evolves are; PERSONNEL, PROMISES, PERCEPTION and PERISHABLES. By comparison the product marketing 4 Ps are; PRODUCT, PRICE, PLACEMENT and PROMOTION. And yes, the marketer is free to borrow from the other...

Somewhere in my files I have the remnants of an award winning corps advert campaign that my 'former' and I created when stationed in Sweden; drew much talk in the marketing/advert AND SA world. The photos I used would be helpful in sharing the concept visually, but in brief (all thoe persons in the news ads were soldiers of the corps)

picture of surgeon in hospital; line:" When you visit me I work on your heart !"

picture of surgeon in SA uniform in SA Hall listening to sermon with Bible open in hands; "On Sundays I worship at The SA and God works on my heart ! Come join me- free heart surgery with permanent healing...

picture of SA soldier in hair salon uniform tending to customer's make-up and hair-do; "I am an expert at making you look better, clean and more attractive."


Photo of same person singing in SA songster brigade in uniform; "On Sundays I sing for joy at the army because God makes me more beautiful and pristine on the inside. Come join me- free and permanent cleansing treatment for all."

There were three more - all ads were followed up with a visitation campaign by soldiers- 5 weeks running - turned the town upside down - led to corps establishing a daily radio program with a totally revitalized fellowship-

Let's do lunch Paul (as they say in the marketing circles in Manhattan - on my dime after the 1st of the year)

Anonymous said...

I thought this to be a very well thought out and articulate posting by Randy Savage. One does not have to read too hard between the lines to discover the real pain and stresses of unfulfilled ambitions and promise over a quarter of a century in a highly structured and hierarchal - still very paternalistic? - US Salvation Army.

Likely to be in his mid 50's and the body clock ticking towards retirement within a decade or so, Randy has the integrity and honesty to admit that there are some other issues attached to their decision to resign from officership. These are probably more relevant than the unfulfilled stated one(s).

I think the Army leadership was probably correct in stating that for the average Salvation Army ministry setting a doctorate is a very expensive luxury and not really relevant nor needed so why should they fund it? In no other sphere of secular/ religious employment would this be allowed. Nor is a MBA/ MA or even a 'lowly' BA for that fact UNLESS the SA intends to use a person in present/ future specific roles. That they are willing and able to provide many officers with an expensive BA and MA level education is not just gracious but also very generous and commendable investment in my humble opinion.That some others may have been able to pursue a further course at SA expense is not really an issue here. At least the advanced education provided has opened the present door of opportunity to move on into the secular educational setting with the current university employer funding a doctorate?

Like with so many other things, reality and perception can become easily blurred and cause an overall distorted view, usually in favour of those who have the stated and unstated issues.

Best wishes and a happy Christmas to you all

Active
UKT

FORMER SALVATION ARMY OFFICERS FELLOWSHIP said...

I am heartened by the most recent comment by an 'active' UK officer. It's interesting to note the compassionate spirit the officer demonstrates; would that he/she in actively involved in officer counseling.

I find it interesting too to read the comments on officer education having recently moved to the UK and currently getting my feet wet in the higher ed structures here in Exeter. My wife, the corps' CO, and I have recently begun hosting non-SA uni students in our quarters to learn just what their struggles are and how the corps can assist. I was surprised to learn that the cost of the average MBA program in the UK is not that much less expensive than a US degree.

The officer shared in the comments; 'That they (The SA) are willing and able to provide many officers with an expensive BA and MA level education is not just gracious but also very generous and a commendable investment in my humble opinion.' This is certainly true as it pertains to the US in that one is no longer required to repay the army's outlay. (used to be the 5 year plan) I would add though that the army's contribution is to a great extent lessened by the resourceful officer. There are dozens of grants and scholarships available in each and every state in addition to Pell and other government grants. I don't recall the army's total investment in my BA and Master's degree, but would estimate it to have been around $5,000, plus my time in the classroom and studying at home.

Concurrent with, and subsequent to earning both degrees I served a total of 14 years using what I learned at university on a daily basis. I dare say we both got our money's worth...

I paid for my PhD while working for a British company in Russia, and managing a hotel (my background is in the travel industry) in Sweden while writing my dissertation; 2 +years.

In closing, and I'm certain Randy would agree, to walk directly from an army platform to a university lecture hall is far from the norm and far from what I expected. The average faculty salary in the state university where I taught for 6 years was $ 85,000.00; 9 months per annum. I considered myself very fortunate to have had a secure position immediately, and one where the teaching side of my ministry could continue, all thanks to the army and God's leading.

I hope you become a regular visitor/contributor 'active' UKT ! When in Exeter, I make a fine coffee and Glad a good tea, she tells me !

HAPPY CHRISTMAS TO YOU AND YOURS !

Anonymous said...

Marriage Plans Could Unseat Salvation Army Officer!

Oshkosh (AP) - The leader of the Oshkosh SA will lose his job if he goes ahead with plans to marry outside the organization.

Captain Johnny Harsh is engaged to a woman who's not affiliated with TSA. They're planning to marry in June.

Harsh says he's well aware of the agency's rule which says an officer may only marry another officer of TSA. But, doesn't think it's fair.

TSA advisory board member Helen Lord Burr says the agency has specific rules and they're the same all over the world.

Harsh became engaged after losing his wife, Captain Yalanda Harsh, to complications of a heart atteack last June.

FORMER SALVATION ARMY OFFICERS FELLOWSHIP said...

Thank you sharing that story- it crossed the Atlantic a couple of weeks ago... Sad that the army in the USA hasn't yet come into the 21st century relative to this subject. Perhaps to get the ball rolling someone ought to inform the Board member that the ruling was changed by the 'mother' church in England several years ago.

I may be biased in my views, but it works for me, being married to an active officer. I would add though that both my wife (CO) and I knew well in advance the demands on her time and person. To that though, one must also give credit to what a 'former' can bring; an understanding spirit willing to share in visitation, speaking at HL, doing corps Bible study, the occasional preaching (twice in 2 weeks), sharing old sermon notes, camp counselor, doing the corps' blog, hosting visitors in our "home", conducting seminars at the upcoming corps retreat!

Wait just a minute... thinking about the above I want a substantive rank right away- (it's a joke dear...)

I'm not certain, but I sincerely hope that the situation here in the UK is monitored and that the results of these non-officer spouse cases are shared. If indeed they have resulted in stemming the flow of resignations then it would seem a non-brainer for the US Commissioners to follow suit and endorse the same system.

Maybe a letter to the Editor of the Oshkosh newspaper would also help the matter along. In the meantime I pray that the army will find him suitable employment within The SA.

I will pray for the couple's happiness.

Anonymous said...

Thanks for the invite Sven, its a deal.

At one of my previous church appointments, also in Exeter, the Church wanted to renew its property, and after careful consideration I managed to expand the congregation's thinking and penned the slogan, "Faith Forward - Renewing People, Purpose and Property"

Using another business management concept, I adapted the change management tool of Thousand & Villa. T & V writes that for change to happen it is important to have vision, skills, incentive, resources and action plan. Miss any one of these components and change becomes difficult to achieve because instead of change, confusion or anxiety or resistance or frustration or treadmill mentality or even isolation happen.

Could not the same be said for mission?

I'm intrigued by the notion of perishables in the theological sense. I'm just wonder if there is not another P and perhaps a very topical consideration at Christmas time, that of presence, in the sense of being still in the presence of the Lord and being the presence of the body of Christ where-ever we are called to minister.

With regards to your new rank, I think that we ought to ask for suggestions from the FSAOF's members. How about CO's Batman! (Dictionary definition - an orderly assigned to serve a British Army officer)

May you have a truly Christmas presence. Blessings Paul

Anonymous said...

Randy,

'The price one pays for pursuing any profession or calling is an intimate knowledge of its ugly side.'

James Baldwin


Cadet
USA East

Anonymous said...

'Education makes a people easy to lead but difficult to drive; easy to govern but impossible to enslave.'

B. Borum

Anonymous said...

'Your corps could perhaps be used as a case study. Figure a minimum of 1-2 years and 5-6000 GBP.'

I've got a better salary allowance for you ... the one I always offer ... 'love'!!!

In relation to Paul's comment ... I want a batman called 'Boodle' ... from a joke that needs to be heard not read ...

Looking forward to your sermon on Christmas Eve, Sven. If any readers are in the area our service at Exeter Temple is at 11.15pm Carols by Candlelight and Sven is the preacher. You would be very, very welcome!

God bless you all and may Christmas be everything you need it to be.

Glad Ljungholm
Active UKT

FORMER SALVATION ARMY OFFICERS FELLOWSHIP said...

For the record, the "minimum of 1-2 years and 5-6000 GBP.' " will cover printing, advertising and misc. only. There was never any though given to a fee for my services. I do it as a loyal soldier/servant of Christ active in the Exeter Temple Corps.

You better not get 'farewelled' in the middle of this campaign ! And if you do, please know that I will miss you but will see you each year at the Congress !

FORMER SALVATION ARMY OFFICERS FELLOWSHIP said...

Paul, there are a number of "P" words one might add; Persistence, Persuasion, Persecution, Pulmonary, Priority, etc. However, in following the concept of the 'marketing mix' (the 4 Ps) we are limited to 4 Ps as it relates to services marketing. And, Kotler's theories, while they only dictate the first 2 Ps, clearly lead us to the others, the ones I have added, written and lectured on for the last eight years; perception and perishables. I'll share this in more detail when we meet.

'Fletch' said...

There are very few officers who have not had some sort of experience such as Randy describes, mine started before I even arrived at the college, and although the reason for my leaving was nothing to do with 'leadership' per se, it was to do with individuals who did not have the people skills, or in these modern times, shall we call it 'emotional intelligence' to cope with the vast array of difficulties that we officers give/gave them. Granted there were a bad apple or two, but in the main I found most to be simply struggling like the rest of us in postions that had been given, not asked for, and lacked the skills to perform to 'my/our' expectations. Yes! I too would oftimes blamed the 'system' as did Gowens and Larson in 'Take Over Bid', but in reality it was individuals who caused my grief not the organistion.

Yes; there is need for reform but it is going to be individuals who bring it about and one of my burdens is that I can never again be involved in bringing it about because now I am 'without the fold'.

Bless you Randy for your stand and I am sure that you will always make a stand against incompetence and ignorance in your new role, and in doing so; at the same time make a real difference wherever you are, and whatever you are doing.

'Fletch'

A.P. Boynton said...

Let me first make a disclaimer that the author of the post, Randy Savage, is my uncle.

That being said, I take umbrage with the following remarks made by Randy:

"My heart says that the leadership culture will remain unchanged in the Army. Change takes courage and a deep trust in our sovereign Lord. It requires a decisiveness that places Christ on the throne and allows His leadership to reign. Change demands an uncompromising commitment to the purpose and plan of God."

This statement taken at face value implies that there is a lack of all of those things within the Army; that the Salvation Army doesn't have its priorities straight. Now, I cannot really know all the true intentions or emotions based on the written word but I can take away some feelings based on the part I quoted above.

I don't know what goes on between officers and their divisional & territorial leadership but as someone working towards a Master's in Organizational Learning & Human Resource Development, I have spent time studying Leadership and the idea of change is not a one way street. There has to be mutual agreement and submission for change to occur.

I need to contemplate the post a bit more but the paragraph I highlighted saddens me and seems a bit "me vs. them" mentality instead of a "What could we have done as an organization to work together to plant the seeds of change in order to improve how things worked while still fulfilling the Calling from God to be servants of the Gospel?"

Anonymous said...

Congratulations A.P.Boynton on your willingness to take a stand and say that change is always a two way street. How many heartaches would have been prevented if this was understood and implemented in any organisation. It does at times appear that the 'me' attitude of the world has the ability to seep into even the most sacred of professions, Salvation Army Offficership.

Also thank you to Cadet James Balswin for his quote about 'the price one has to pay for persuing any profession .... etc'. Fantastic insight; I know many Officers current and former at all levels who would value your counsel in 'together' trying to bring about change. For me a significant part of this Debate is the apochryphal story of the one word cable to all the officers in the world to cut down on costs; 'OTHERS'

May it be so in our lives.