Posted
by request from a long time FSAOF member, USA Central
By
Denny Burk
- February 18
Part
TWO
Is
there a difference between desire and lust?
Sometimes
it is claimed that we must make a moral distinction between mere desire and
active lust—the former being morally neutral and the latter being sinful. But
this is not a particularly biblical distinction. The word Jesus uses for lust
in Matthew 5:28 (epithumeō) is used elsewhere in neutral and even positive
ways.[7] For example, Jesus says that “many prophets and righteous men desired
(epithumeō) to see what you see, and did not see it” (Matthew 13:17). The word
clearly means “desire,” and in this case the desire is a good thing. Whether
the desire is good (as in Matt. 13:17) or evil (as in Matt. 5:28) depends
entirely on what it is a person desires. That is why the same Greek term is
rendered “desire” in some texts and “lust” in others. If you desire something
good, then the desire itself is good. If you desire something evil, then the
desire itself is evil. Same-sex attraction is clearly a desire that God
forbids. How then can we possibly treat a persistent and enduring desire for
the same-sex as morally neutral? Biblically, we cannot.
The
apostle Paul also addresses the propriety of same-sex desires in Romans
1:26-27. To be sure, Paul says that homosexual behavior is sinful:
Romans
1:26-27 “Women exchanged the natural function for that which is unnatural, and
in the same way also the men abandoned the natural function of the woman… men
with men committing indecent acts.”
But
he also says that the desires themselves are equally morally blameworthy and
stand as evidence of God’s wrath against sin: “For this reason God gave them
over to degrading passions… and [they] burned in their desire toward one
another” (Rom 1:26-27). Sexual desire that fixates on the same-sex is sinful,
and that is why God’s judgment rightly falls on both desires and actions.
Again, the issue is not merely sexual behavior but also one’s enduring pattern
of sexual attraction.
Answering
an Objection
A
common objection to the foregoing goes like this: “If a person cannot control
whether they have same-sex attraction, how can that attraction be considered
sinful?” This objection bases moral accountability upon whether one has the
ability to choose his proclivities. But this is not how the Bible speaks of sin
and judgment. There are all manner of predispositions that we are born with
that the Bible nevertheless characterizes as sin: pride, anger, anxiousness,
just to name a few. Why would we put same-sex attraction in a different
category than those other predispositions that we groan to be delivered from
and that we are morally accountable for? As we mentioned above, Jesus says that
all such sins proceed from the heart and that we are therefore morally
accountable for them (Mark 7:21). And this assessment is in no way mitigated by
the fact that we come by it naturally or were born that way. As
Richard Hays
writes,
The
Bible’s sober anthropology rejects the apparently commonsense assumption that
only freely chosen acts are morally culpable. Quite the reverse: the very nature
of sin is that it is not freely chosen. That is what it means to live “in the
flesh” in a fallen creation. We are in bondage to sin but still accountable to
God’s righteous judgment of our actions. In light of this theological
anthropology, it cannot be maintained that a homosexual orientation is morally
neutral because it is involuntary.[8]




