Saturday, May 10, 2014

LGBT ORIENTATION IS SINFUL - A SIN - THAT REQUIRES FORGIVENESS


Posted by request from a long time FSAOF member, USA Central

Part One

By Denny Burk - February 18
In contemporary discussions of homosexuality, it is commonplace to distinguish homosexual orientation from homosexual behavior. Usually, the distinction goes something like this: Orientation refers to one’s inner disposition while behavior addresses one’s moral choices. John and Paul Feinberg state it this way:
Homosexuality as a sexual orientation means that a person has a strong and abiding preference for members of the same sex and desires to act on that sexual preference… Homosexual behavior refers to specific sex acts between members of the same sex.[1]
Some Christian ethicists take this observation a step further and argue that we must make a moral distinction between orientation and behavior. On this view, homosexual behavior is a choice and thus morally blameworthy. Homosexual orientation is not a choice and thus not morally blameworthy. This point of view has become routine even among some who identify themselves as evangelical. A couple examples to illustrate the point. Dennis Hollinger writes:
I would suggest that orientation is not the primary ethical issue. From a theological perspective, it is a result of the fallenness of our world… But orientation is not usually a result of a person’s willful, sinful choice. Hence, the ethical judgment on homosexuality is not about orientation or homoerotic impulses.[2]
Likewise, Joe Dallas and Nancy Heche write:
If a person’s primary sexual attractions are toward the same sex, the person’s orientation is homosexual… If a person’s sexual attractions are toward both sexes, the person’s orientation is bisexual… The Bible does not condemn homosexual or bisexual orientation as a deliberate sin, but any deliberate expression of homosexuality, through actions, sexual fantasy, or lust, is biblically prohibited.[3]
I do not dispute that there is a legitimate distinction to be made between orientation and behavior. I do question, however, whether the Bible supports the notion that only homosexual behavior is sinful while homosexual orientation is not. Evangelicals would generally agree with Hollinger that homosexual orientation in some way stems from the Fall. But in what way? Does homosexual orientation comprise a natural evil only? Or is it also a moral evil? Is it something that primarily requires healing (like cancer), or is it something that requires vigilant repentance (like pride)? How we answer these questions has enormous pastoral implications for those brothers and sisters who experience same-sex attraction. What follows is my attempt to answer these questions biblically and to suggest some pastoral implications.
Does the Bible address sexual orientation?
It is sometimes claimed that sexual orientation is a modern concept that would have been completely foreign to the writers of scripture.[4] But is that really true? It depends entirely on how one defines the term “orientation.” The American Psychological Association defines sexual orientation in this way: “Sexual orientation refers to an enduring pattern of emotional, romantic and/or sexual attractions to men, women or both sexes.”[5] Notice that orientation involves a person’s enduring sexual attractions and that sexual attraction is a virtual synonym for sexual desire.[6] Thus sexual orientation is one’s persistent pattern of sexual desire/attraction toward either or both sexes.
If that is the definition, then the term “orientation” does not somehow take us to a category that the Bible doesn’t address. The Bible says that our sexual desires/attractions have a moral component and that we are held accountable for them. Jesus’ remarks on the nature of heterosexual desire are a case in point:
Mathew 5:27-28 “You have heard that it was said, ‘You shall not commit adultery’; but I say to you, that everyone who looks on a woman to lust for her has committed adultery with her already in his heart.”
The word that Jesus uses for “lust” is the exact same term used in the tenth commandment’s prohibition on coveting: “You shall not desire/covet your neighbor’s wife” (Ex. 20:17; Deut. 5:21 LXX).  Thus both Jesus and the tenth commandment censure not merely adulterous behavior but also the desire that precedes the behavior. The locus of such desire is the “heart.” As Jesus confirms elsewhere, adultery and every other kind of sexual immorality proceed from the heart (Mark 7:21).
The married man who experiences an adulterous lust for another woman is a man who experiences unwholesome attractions. His attraction may indeed be spontaneous and uninvited. It may indeed reflect his sexual orientation to be attracted to the opposite sex. But that married man may not appeal to his heterosexual “orientation” to absolve him of having feelings that he ought not feel. Jesus says such feelings are adultery within the heart. Likewise, a man who experiences a sexual attraction to another man may be experiencing feelings that are spontaneous and uninvited. His attraction may well reflect what he perceives to be his natural “orientation.” But that does not absolve him of having sexual feelings he ought not feel. The Bible judges such attractions as sinful lust—as coveting someone sexually. Thus the scripture does in fact speak to one’s enduring pattern of sexual attractions.

END PART ONE

4 comments:

Anonymous said...

To the person who said 'WELL SAID!!! End of discussion! AMEN!' - I fear your hope is sadly in vain - I think they'll still be covering this topic at Christmas and beyond - but at least this article displays biblical ethics, and not 'man's' wishful, LGBT-tolerant interpretation. It's one of the few articles on the subject which makes perfect sense, both biblically and morally. I commend them for printing it and actually look forward to part 2. But....await the 'active' LGBT paranoid response. The only time they comment is when their lifestyle is challenged. Interesting.

Anonymous said...

I agree that to entertain wrong desires - whether they be wrong heterosexual desires or same sex desires - is sin. Sin germinates in the mind and all Christians must control their thoughts and emotions. To not do so appropriately is just as sinful as acting out on those desires.

As soon as inappropriate sexual thoughts come to mind, a person has to say "Get behind me Satan" and put those inappropriate thoughts out of their mind immediately and repeatedly, as often as necessary.

There is victory in Christ over thoughts as well as over actions.

Unknown said...

Ok Anonymus, you got me there. This topic is one that drives me to participate in the discussion, and I'm may be not so "on top" to respond on other subjects.
Why is that?
I read in your comment that you actually are questioning my Lifestyle? ?
Well.... what do you know about that? I guess you're quite biased when it comes to us (quite few actually) who dares to take a stand in defence for all those LGBT persons, not least within the SA.
But this action of us does not say anything about our life's and our choices in life, does it?
We are all different as to our personalities, of course. But I have found that we all share in faith and commitment to our Lord Christ.
Some of us are still within the ranks of the SA, some are not for many different reasons.
As for me, I'm eager to question the "fact" that The Salvation army is in the same evangelical-fundemantalist-conservative trench that for example the Southern Baptists. This is not (!) the Army I was raised and trained in.
My Army was a pragmatic, warm Christian fellowship who wanted to lead mankind to Jesus.
Kjell - Erik Edlund
Former officer of the Salvation army
Sweden

Anonymous said...

I find it very strange that anyone would think it is not the desire of 'evangelical-fundemantalist-conservative' Christians to 'lead mankind to Jesus'. The only difference is the method, surely. Speaking as one of these Christians, it's certainly my desire. I want the whole world to belong to Him. I'm not prepared to be pragmatic, though. I'm also surprised that you think being on the 'conservative' end of Christianity is a cold experience. Trust me, it's not.
Pragmatism as a philosophy has only existed for a relatively short time, and imho rather denies the absolute nature of biblical guidance. And therein lies the confusion which pragmatism brings. You don't like what God has written in his Word? Fine - consult a pragmatist/philosopher and evaluate his/her theories instead. The extent to which this has been adopted by Christian liberal thinkers has resulted in much confusion, and is the reason why discussions like this can go on for months on end - because people these days are not willing to submit to the discipline of the Lord. They want to go their own way instead. The Bible says that 'whom the Lord loves He chastens' and that discipline is necessary to strengthen us. The following words from the Bible emphasise this:

Deuteronomy 8: Know then in your heart that as a man disciplines his son, so the Lord your God disciplines you.

Psalm 94: Blessed is the one you discipline, Lord, the one you teach from your law.

Proverbs 3: My son, do not despise the Lord’s discipline, and do not resent his rebuke, because the Lord disciplines those he loves, as a father the son he delights in.

Proverbs 5: For lack of discipline they will die, led astray by their own great folly.

Proverbs 10: Whoever heeds discipline shows the way to life, but whoever ignores correction leads others astray.

Proverbs 12: Whoever loves discipline loves knowledge, but whoever hates correction is stupid.

And these lovely worlds from Hebrews 12:
And have you completely forgotten this word of encouragement that addresses you as a father addresses his son? It says, ‘My son, do not make light of the Lord’s discipline, and do not lose heart when he rebukes you, because the Lord disciplines the one he loves, and he chastens everyone he accepts as his son.
Endure hardship as discipline; God is treating you as his children. For what children are not disciplined by their father? If you are not disciplined – and everyone undergoes discipline – then you are not legitimate, not true sons and daughters at all.
 Moreover, we have all had human fathers who disciplined us and we respected them for it. How much more should we submit to the Father of spirits and live!

They disciplined us for a little while as they thought best; but God disciplines us for our good, in order that we may share in his holiness. No discipline seems pleasant at the time, but painful. Later on, however, it produces a harvest of righteousness and peace for those who have been trained by it.

Human 'theories' and 'opinions' should have no place in our walk with God. We should be guided by His Word alone - imho.