Friday, May 2, 2014

GO YE INTO HALF THE WORLD… Part One


2014 has been heralded as the year that presents a turning point in a global struggle for the right of as many as 600 million people around the world to be openly homosexual without fear of humiliation or violence. (Many suggest that a more accurate figure is as low as 2.4 Million)

An international community of human rights activists have made hard-won gains for LGBT (lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender) rights in traditionally conservative countries such as Spain and Argentina and rapidly changing societies like India. Absent from their list are the many Southern hemisphere countries where more than three quarters of the world’s Salvationists are enslaved, along with their countrymen, to a culture where discrimination, humiliation, violence and death are constant threats.  Salvationists are swept up in a society where politics dictate culture and where religious beliefs are twisted, thwarted or simply dismissed.

A well-mobilized counterassault from evangelical Christians and conservative Catholics across Africa dispelling the belief that homosexual orientation is a mortal sin has yet to be mounted, one that society could embrace, dispel and help control. A change and commitment to this new and credible position on the theological significance and enormity will require a sizeable, credible and influential commitment by an honest and intellectually credible Christian movement. Is the Army God’s choice to head up this initiative in partnership with other denominations? The Salvation Army has a long tradition and rich history of effecting social change.

On what authority do we go dorward.

The Reformation in the 1500s had several slogans.  The two best known are the " sola scriptura "and" sola fide. In my native Swedish language it translates simply as "Scripture alone" and "faith alone ". The concept of ‘Scripture alone’ is today debated and questioned and by many as being solely the highest authority on Christian beliefs and lifestyle. And few things in today’s world divide churches and Christian communities more deeply than the issue of homosexuality. What lies at the very heart of the matter is the Bible and its interpretation. I’ll return to this debate in the next article.

For Luther, it was about whether it was synods and the pope, or Scripture that had the highest authority, and his conclusion was that it was Scripture. Hence came the term ‘Scripture alone’ as the credible authority on how we Christians act clearly and consistently on the basis of our beliefs, including, matters of sexuality and what it means to follow Jesus with wisdom, humility, and grace.

Martin Thielen, Senior Pastor of Lebanon First United Methodist Church, Lebanon, Tennessee shares in his What’s the Least I can believe and Still be a Christian?, his church’s mission statement: “OPEN HEARTS, OPEN MINDS, AND OPEN DOORS’.  The FSAOF would not have been far from that same vision if we’d introduces our three LGBT Series similarly: Read with an open heart and mind, and you are bound to be changed. Positive and fundamental change comes not only from a 180 degree turn-around in one’s long-held or traditional position on the LGBT controversy, but more importantly in recognizing the integrity of the views of those holding contrary or a somewhat differing position. We have witnessed and been commended for contributing to those with open minds and open hearts, recognizing too that for some, it’s taken months or even several years. Change in one’s long-held commitment to a theological ‘truth’ is often long in coming. The very few biblical verses that touch upon same-sex-related matters and those that fuel the divide say nothing about love and enduring relationships between people of the same sex. This has led theologically conservative Christians to condemn altogether what is today called ‘homosexuality.’

Some LGBT folks within the FSAOF community have offered both a scholarly and profoundly personal reconciliation of a duality often depicted as hopelessly at odds. And as we embrace the LGBT folk in our ‘family’ we recognize that we are doing nothing more than exhibiting the same love and grace that Jesus extends to all.

Did we leave the third world Army behind as we Europeans and North Americans debated the three views represented by the Christian Right, Left and Center, leaving the rest of the SA world to move forward at their own pace. Were we aware of how splintered our fundamentally ‘cohesive’ SA theology was being developed?

Candidates at the High Councils are expected to give a speech outlining their expectations of the worldwide Army and their own effectiveness in moving their vision forward.

1977 Arnold Brown, point 6,  he (the General) must speed the progress of the Army in the developing countries.

1981  Jarl Wahlstrom … he (the General)must strike a balance between some cornservatism and courageous new thinking.

1993 Bramwell Tillsley … I long for an Army that is International in its outlook and recognizes its responsibility to the whole world.

1994 Paul Rader … we must go forward in finding cost effective, supportable means for entering new areas of ministry; … forward in compassionate and creative response to the Aids pandemic … We must move forward together in all our rich cultural diversity …We must share a common strategic vision as we move aggressively forward to the 21st century.

1999 John Gowans … I will do what you tell me to do.

2002 John Larsson … I will need to encourage the renewal of confidence in the unique contribution that the Army was raised up to make … The Army is a force … it is a force that is visible … a force with a mission to the whole person … a force with a genius for inclusion and releasing of potential.

2006 Shaw Clifton … He (God) wants us to be a truthful Army, an honest Army, never pretending that all is well, never wanting ourselves or seeking plaudits of men … He wants us to be a united, International Army.

2011 Linda Bond … It is vital that we are convinced of why we exist, when we have such certainty, this one mission will bring us together as one Army, every nation, every generation, every Salvationist totally sold out to our calling by God.

2013 Andre’ Cox … In conclusion, my dream for this great organization is that the SA will be characterized as being a force for good, a force for change and a force that lives by the values it proclaims.

To be continued…

Sven Ljungholm
Former Officer
Liverpool

9 comments:

Anonymous said...

Bring back Easter, when this sordid topic was confined to the back burner. Unfortunately, no-one put out the fire.

Anonymous said...

Sordid Topic? So people who love God, who love each other, who want the world to be saved, who want to show the love of God to all the world is a sordid topic?

This is why we need this topic, and we need a long, extended discussion on this subject.

Yours in Christ,
Graeme Randall
Former Australian East in London

Unknown said...

This issue is important! I hope no one will put out the fire...
The stiring point right now is, may be, the situation in the southern hemisphere and the SA soldiers in this part of the world.
I guess that we in the developed and mostly well educated part of this globe, will, in time, be able to come to some agreement about the LGBT (Q) situations, even within the Army.
I agree with author Sven about the possibilities for the Salvation army to be in the forefront in respect of questions about social change in those countries. Social changes will free people to get better education, which leads to a healthy view of the world and all circumstances.
So - I for one, is lookin forward to follow this blog and all kinds of comment's that are bound to follow.
In all kinds of respect!
Kjell Edlund
Former officer of the Salvation army
God's messengers 1980-1982
Sweden

Anonymous said...

'....we need a long, extended discussion on this subject.'....
How long, how extended? This is the 5th month of long, extended 'discussions', and it isn't the first 'series' either. It will be until everyone agrees with you is my guess. There is no room for conservative thinking on this subject, by the look of it, otherwise the subject would have been put to bed long ago.

Anonymous said...

LOL!! I laughed out loud reading the various General's comments - John Gowans was truly unique!! Shaw Clifton's comment begs one response - actions speak louder than words. Clifton is quoted as saying:

"He (God) wants us to be a truthful Army, an honest Army, never pretending all is well..."

Allegations in the Australian abuse scandal were emerging during Shaw Clifton's watch, in fact the media has reported recently that at the Royal Commission hearings in these recent weeks and months since Jan 2014, a victim has testified that they asked Shaw Clifton to make an apology to victimes on behalf of the Army.

The transcripts of all the testimony under oath at these hearings which are published on the internet for all to read, clearly show that the Army's leadership were using cover-up strategies - moving officers, even promoting one officer into administration, and disciplining whistle blower officers - to cover-up, to sweep under the carpet the whole scandal. This is hardly a truthful and honest Army. Actions will always speak louder than words.

It has taken this Australian government's Royal Commission which is investigating TSA's actions in handling this whole matter, to get a public and tearful apology from the territorial commander. The apology by the Australian Commissioner Condon made on video on a TV news channel at the following link:

http://www.abc.net.au/news/2014-02-10/salvation-army-reputation-27no-longer-a-priorty27/5249332

This apology comes only after the Royal Commission hearings have publicly shamed TSA. Also the accompanying written article reports an officer's testimony at the hearings:

"Another senior ranking officer with the Salvation Army says the inquiry has disgraced the organization.

Major Peter Farthing is co-ordinating the Salvation Army's response to the royal commission and also serves as the principal of the organisation's Booth training college in Sydney.

When he was sworn in on Friday, Major Farthing opted to take an oath of affirmation instead of an oath on the Bible.

He admits that when victims began to come forward in the mid-1990s, the organisation's legal advice was flawed.

"Our policy was: we will be compassionate, but WE WILL NEVER ADMIT WRONG," he told the inquiry.

"So WE WON'T SAY SORRY, and we won't make a payment unless the person can prove in court that the offence took place."

Quite a revelation under oath of how TSA operates! The actions of leadership were so loud they drown out the words of General Clifton.

Anonymous said...

As an aside, the comments by Generals in this article are very interesting. John Gowans gets the award for most unique comment. Shaw Clifton's comment begs one comment in response. I guess the actions of leadership during his watch spoke much louder than his words.

"He (God) wants a truthful Army, an honest Army, never pretending all is well..."

Compare the reality to these good sounding words. Just read on the internet the testimony given at Australia's Royal Commission hearings that have been going on since January to investigate the actions of TSA's leadership. The actions of leadership during Clifton's watch were anything but truthful and honest. The strategies leadership employed - moving officers who had allegations against them, even promoting one to administration etc etc etc - were taken for the purposes of cover-up, sweeping things under the rug.

Most revealing are the comments of Major Farthing under oath as reported in the media recently, where he is quoted as saying the decision of the Army was to admit no wrong and not to say they were sorry. Shamed at the Royal Commission, Commissioner Condon is on the internet now tearfully apologizing.

One could say the actions of the Army's leadership spoke so loudly, they drowned out the words of General Clifton.

Anonymous said...

"He (God) wants a truthful Army, an honest Army, never pretending all is well..."

2013 Andre’ Cox … In conclusion, my dream for this great organization is that the SA will be characterized as being a force for good, a force for change and a force that lives by the values it proclaims.
***************************************************

With this website’s continuous obsession with LGBT issues, is it not failing some central spiritual essentials that appear to be missing from this Army that all its members love?

I’ve just accessed the link above concerning the Australian sex scandal, and have been appalled by the failure of Salvation Army leaders to address the issues at the time. Shaw Clifton’s words that ‘God wants a truthful Army, an honest Army, never pretending all is well….’ have more than a hollow ring to them in the light of the fact that he and others at the top table knew what had gone on and did nothing about it. As a citizen that would be reprehensible, but as the spiritual leaders of the worldwide Salvation Army it is unacceptable indeed. It is bewildering how the upper echelons of this Christian organisation failed a generation of children by doing nothing to end their suffering for a staggering quarter of a century, and who still maintained a stance of ‘innocence’ until shamed by the media. How this silence equates with biblical values escapes me. It smacks of protecting the brand at all costs.

Major Farthing’s comments under oath (one of Affirmation instead of on the Bible – what’s all that about?) said that the decision of the Army was to admit no wrong and not to say they were sorry. That remains the case, as we have also seen in the case of the Howard Hospital scandal. Still there is no remorse for that humanitarian tragedy either.

Is it not telling that out of 9 Generals’ quotes, only 2 mentioned God? Andre Cox’s is the most disturbing. If we are all meant to be called by God to fulfil the great commission of going out to the world to preach the Gospel, why don’t the leaders say so? Are they so in hock to the world that they now only speak the world’s language? It’s a disturbing thought. It also may account for the ever-declining membership of Salvation Army corps in the West. (If yours isn’t one of them, give thanks to God, because you are in the minority).

Why do we stay in this deeply flawed movement? (I ask myself the same question). I am deeply saddened by all these events – these are not the only issues – and if I was asked for my dream for the Army, it would be to put God, Jesus and the Holy Spirit at the heart of all we do, regardless of what people think of us. Is the Salvation Army under judgment? It certainly appears so. God demands our love and commitment, but it makes you wonder when you don’t even see the leadership showing it. I do have serious doubts about remaining within the ranks. I have enjoyed my service in ignorance of these tragedies, but with awareness comes responsibility, and I have to consider my position – not easy after a lifetime’s service.

And to the FSAOF I would say – your commitment to the LGBT cause reminds me of Nero – to continue the ‘fire’ references on your site – he allegedly played music while Rome burned around him. With great respect, there are more pressing issues than continued debate on a subject that is going nowhere – the very survival of the Salvation Army.

Anonymous said...

How long will long-overdue discussions continue?! Wow! Somebody believes that 5 mths. is already too long? Yikes! William Booth said, "While women weep, as they do now, I'll fight; while little children go hungry, as they do now, I'll fight; while men go to prison, in and out, in and out, as they do now, I'll fight; while there is a drunkard left, while there is a poor lost girl upon the streets, while there remains one dark soul without the light of God, I'll fight-I'll fight to the very end!...If Booth were alive now, I believe that he would be adding to this, "As long as there are 600 million people around the world who live with the fear of humiliation and violence, I'll fight." Those of us who are heterosexual have other challenges, but nobody should have to live their lives in fear.

Elizabeth Hogan-Hayduk,
Former SA Officer
Guardians of the Truth, 83-85
Canada & Bermuda Territory.

Anonymous said...

I echo 'Wow! above, but for different reasons. I just love how pro-LGBT people pluck statistics out of the air at will. I was staggered at the quoted figure of 600 million people above alleged to be LGBT (by the tone of the sentence), but even dedicated 'gay' websites cannot put a figure on it - I looked them up and I quote from one of them 'The Total Number Of Gay People In The World Can't Be Counted' (headline figure).
But persecution is not limited to LGBT people alone - there ARE actually 200 million people in the world today who have no control over the persecution they face daily for their faith alone, not just for a gender issue. Let's hear it for these brave people who endure the most horrific existence imaginable for their faithfulness to God.
And who could imagine that Booth would say those words today? Only a person who wants to believe that he would. It's just wishful conjecture - it will never happen - he's actually dead. He was very much an autocrat in his day, and he didn't have so many liberal thinkers around him denying biblical truths and watering down his beliefs, so I doubt it very much.