Posted
by request from a long time FSAOF member, USA Central
By
Denny Burk
- February 18
Part
TWO
Is
there a difference between desire and lust?
Sometimes
it is claimed that we must make a moral distinction between mere desire and
active lust—the former being morally neutral and the latter being sinful. But
this is not a particularly biblical distinction. The word Jesus uses for lust
in Matthew 5:28 (epithumeō) is used elsewhere in neutral and even positive
ways.[7] For example, Jesus says that “many prophets and righteous men desired
(epithumeō) to see what you see, and did not see it” (Matthew 13:17). The word
clearly means “desire,” and in this case the desire is a good thing. Whether
the desire is good (as in Matt. 13:17) or evil (as in Matt. 5:28) depends
entirely on what it is a person desires. That is why the same Greek term is
rendered “desire” in some texts and “lust” in others. If you desire something
good, then the desire itself is good. If you desire something evil, then the
desire itself is evil. Same-sex attraction is clearly a desire that God
forbids. How then can we possibly treat a persistent and enduring desire for
the same-sex as morally neutral? Biblically, we cannot.
The
apostle Paul also addresses the propriety of same-sex desires in Romans
1:26-27. To be sure, Paul says that homosexual behavior is sinful:
Romans
1:26-27 “Women exchanged the natural function for that which is unnatural, and
in the same way also the men abandoned the natural function of the woman… men
with men committing indecent acts.”
But
he also says that the desires themselves are equally morally blameworthy and
stand as evidence of God’s wrath against sin: “For this reason God gave them
over to degrading passions… and [they] burned in their desire toward one
another” (Rom 1:26-27). Sexual desire that fixates on the same-sex is sinful,
and that is why God’s judgment rightly falls on both desires and actions.
Again, the issue is not merely sexual behavior but also one’s enduring pattern
of sexual attraction.
Answering
an Objection
A
common objection to the foregoing goes like this: “If a person cannot control
whether they have same-sex attraction, how can that attraction be considered
sinful?” This objection bases moral accountability upon whether one has the
ability to choose his proclivities. But this is not how the Bible speaks of sin
and judgment. There are all manner of predispositions that we are born with
that the Bible nevertheless characterizes as sin: pride, anger, anxiousness,
just to name a few. Why would we put same-sex attraction in a different
category than those other predispositions that we groan to be delivered from
and that we are morally accountable for? As we mentioned above, Jesus says that
all such sins proceed from the heart and that we are therefore morally
accountable for them (Mark 7:21). And this assessment is in no way mitigated by
the fact that we come by it naturally or were born that way. As
Richard Hays
writes,
The
Bible’s sober anthropology rejects the apparently commonsense assumption that
only freely chosen acts are morally culpable. Quite the reverse: the very nature
of sin is that it is not freely chosen. That is what it means to live “in the
flesh” in a fallen creation. We are in bondage to sin but still accountable to
God’s righteous judgment of our actions. In light of this theological
anthropology, it cannot be maintained that a homosexual orientation is morally
neutral because it is involuntary.[8]
8 comments:
I agree with this perspective and would re-iterate what was said in the second comment to Part one - that to entertain inappropriate thoughts repeatedly or to allow one's thoughts/desires to fixate on inappropriate things is to sin just as much as acting out on those desires.
Indeed the morality of our thoughts/desires is based on the content of what we are thinking about or desiring. Does the content of our thoughts match what scripture teaches about moral behaviour.
I have recently been thinking that traditionally holiness teaching has included cleansing from inbred sin. "Inbred" sin - I agree with this blogger that it includes all those predispositions we are born with and which in this life we may always struggle against. It appears many Christian LGBT people have given up on that struggle, but others have not and are claiming victory in Christ over their inbred sin, much as people who are born with bad nerves, struggle with anxiety disorder their whole life but are claiming victory in Christ, or much as heterosexual singles who have never had opportunity to marry, struggle with celibacy but claim victory in Christ.
Well said, Denny Burk. The main issue in this ongoing debate is the fact that LGBT people cannot see either their LGBT proclivities or their LGBT actions as being sinful, and they refuse to 'take it to the Lord in prayer' because they see no wrong in it - because they don't WANT to see any wrong in it. Pleasurable sins are much more difficult to deal with than others, and many people affected by them don't bother dealing with them - they place them under an umbrella of 'acceptance', and those of us who disagree with this are classed as homophobic, which is far from the truth. The Bible has but one set of rules for us all - but in these days of great self-indulgence, we cherry pick the bits we like and ignore, or reason away, the ones we find tricky.
God help us.
It's good that we are having this discussion. If there is to be a discussion, then both sides have to be heard and allowed to speak. I may not agree with what is said, but I fully support that it needs to be said.
One of the problems I have with the line of argument expressed in this article is that it's very Calvinistic, with a very strong emphasis on predestination. You see, as much as you might want to intellectualise the subject, the reality is that the kinds of 'struggles' that are being compared to LGBT 'desires' are VERY different. One can (and often does) have victory over those other desires. Many in the LGBT camp teach the same kind of holiness where we seek to bring under submission such things - including celibacy for those not in a committed, monogamous relationship. To say that LGBT desires come under the same umbrella when such desires have never in anyone (to my knowledge - believe me) been squashed reeks of predestination. Do you honestly think that those who are LGBT haven't earnestly tried to be rid of their desires? Unlike other 'battles', trying to 'battle' LGBT desires ALWAYS leads to depression, suicide, hatred, and violence. If that is the fruit born from such battle, then one has to question where the fruit comes from. If that is the result of following God, then that is no god worth following. The Bible tells us that the fruit of the Spirit is Love (etc etc etc).
I suppose I can't accept such teaching in this article because it is based in predestination more than anything, and that means that no matter what we teach or try to do, no-one in the LGBT community will ever be saved, and are all predestined to damnation. I know that there are many Christians who do believe in predestination, but it is not TSA position.
Yours in Christ,
Graeme Randall - former Australian East
Ignorant (and yes, homophobic) comments like the first two above are never going to do anything other than keep getting the Army in hot water----and it's not about a matter of differences of opinion either. There are also racial "differences of opinion" and people who belong to the Flat Earth Society who have a difference of opinion too---people who think blacks are inferior to whites and people who think the earth is flat and/or think that the world was made in six days and is only 6500 years old and justify their opinions Biblically/religiously with the Ham and Creation stories in Genesis.
Yet no organization that's credible would ever allow them to keep on expressing their views in a public forum as to give the public the impression that a great many of their members actually still believed such things.
When it comes to sexual orientation people are what they are and they do not change no matter what the religious right mistakenly claims. Exodus Global Alliance even disbanded because after nearly 40 years of rolling out the stories of supposed "homos no mo'" they realized that the stories were rarely ever complete and that in the end the "success stories" usually turned sour.
As far as the comment about fixating on "inappropriate" thoughts and behaviors go, I still don't understand why in the minds of fundamentalist types "inappropriate" always seems to revolve only around sex and sexual orientation? Such comments are downright disingenuous.
The sex drive is one of the strongest of all human drives and it's never going to leave anyone's mind until their last breath, with the possible exception of someone who is either in a coma or deadly, deadly sick with electrolyte imbalances or in unbearable pain.
Back in 1969 when I was a young Corpsman working a ward in a Naval Hospital, a retired LCDR who was dying of cancer motioned me over to his bed. He had his hands under the sheets and asked if I'd put curtains up around his bed. I did and when I went back a half hour later to remove the curtains he was dead with a big smile on his face.
The sex drive and sexual orientation is just that; the sex drive and sexual orientation and has nothing to do with sin. Promiscuity, pedophilia, prostitution, human trafficking, rape,adultery, making out in the back seats of automobiles, gang bangs in slings or any other aberrations people who claim to be saved and sanctified should not be engaging in are a whole different set of issues. When will some religious types ever get this through their demented heads?
Daryl Lach
USA Central
"You Must Go Home By the Way of the Cross, To Stand With Jesus In the Morning!"
Well fortunately this is all a non-issue now, because our LGBT brothers and sisters can now love each other and enjoy these God given desires within the confines of a healthy, sanctified union.
I officially nominate Southern Baptist Professor Denny Burk for the 2014 Southern Baptist Thornton Stringfellow Memorial Award for Backward Thinking Propped Up with Biblical Exegesis, if there be such a thing.
And while we're at it, don't ever be a bit surprised if some time in the future you wind up reading a story in the newspaper, about someone with the exact same name being caught in an embarrassing situation, at some raunchy place during a police sting operation. I'm not saying that it will happen, just don't be too terribly surprised if it does.
It won't be anything new, as several well known anti-gay clergy, including some SA officers I've known and read about through the years can personally attest to, what with their mug shots and stories plastered all over the internet and other sources.
In the small possibility of any legal repercussions, I'll just sign myself on this one as:
Anonymous USA.
I'm afraid that science is going to overwhelm the view of the writer in this piece. Just like Earth is not the centre of the universe innate sexual orientation is not something a person can overcome. It's vilification over the centuries, millenia, have damaged this small percentage of people born into a sinful world. Just as a baby born without a limb can't grow one back, so a person with same gender orientation can't change. This is the positional statement of The Salvation Army in Canada and I believe at IHQ, that we do not find same gender orientation as blameworthy. For the writer to liken it to "desire" rather than an orientation is an insult to people who struggle every day.
It is time we stop looking for a reason to be against this and stop being so defensive about it, and accept that it is something we are going to have to grapple with - just like divorce, unwed mothers, inter-racial marriages and slavery - we need to find a way to embrace the LGBT community and include them in the family of God.
I'm sorry Graeme, but only qualified biblical scholarship from a Wesleyan/Arminian source, will be acceptable for me. What was presented in this article had nothing to do with in depth study, scholarship or good theology. And I would like proper scholarship from both sides of the debate - not opinions on the already translated and then changed word.
Remember the words of Jesus - love. Love others as yourself. We need to stop pouring judgement on people who are different and learn to love them. How that will look in The Salvation Army internationally will be determined, but certainly, we need to grow in our understanding and we need to grow in holiness and love.
Jesus didn't just 'love' - he got angry as well, especially when he saw corruption in the temple. He actually threw the corrupt people out of the temple, because it was His Father's house and what they were doing there was unacceptable. There must be a lesson in there for us today.
Post a Comment