Sunday, May 11, 2014

LGBT ORIENTATION IS SINFUL - A SIN - THAT REQUIRES FORGIVENESS PART 2


Posted by request from a long time FSAOF member, USA Central

By Denny Burk - February 18

Part TWO

Is there a difference between desire and lust?

Sometimes it is claimed that we must make a moral distinction between mere desire and active lust—the former being morally neutral and the latter being sinful. But this is not a particularly biblical distinction. The word Jesus uses for lust in Matthew 5:28 (epithumeō) is used elsewhere in neutral and even positive ways.[7] For example, Jesus says that “many prophets and righteous men desired (epithumeō) to see what you see, and did not see it” (Matthew 13:17). The word clearly means “desire,” and in this case the desire is a good thing. Whether the desire is good (as in Matt. 13:17) or evil (as in Matt. 5:28) depends entirely on what it is a person desires. That is why the same Greek term is rendered “desire” in some texts and “lust” in others. If you desire something good, then the desire itself is good. If you desire something evil, then the desire itself is evil. Same-sex attraction is clearly a desire that God forbids. How then can we possibly treat a persistent and enduring desire for the same-sex as morally neutral? Biblically, we cannot.

The apostle Paul also addresses the propriety of same-sex desires in Romans 1:26-27. To be sure, Paul says that homosexual behavior is sinful:
Romans 1:26-27 “Women exchanged the natural function for that which is unnatural, and in the same way also the men abandoned the natural function of the woman… men with men committing indecent acts.”
But he also says that the desires themselves are equally morally blameworthy and stand as evidence of God’s wrath against sin: “For this reason God gave them over to degrading passions… and [they] burned in their desire toward one another” (Rom 1:26-27). Sexual desire that fixates on the same-sex is sinful, and that is why God’s judgment rightly falls on both desires and actions. Again, the issue is not merely sexual behavior but also one’s enduring pattern of sexual attraction.

Answering an Objection
A common objection to the foregoing goes like this: “If a person cannot control whether they have same-sex attraction, how can that attraction be considered sinful?” This objection bases moral accountability upon whether one has the ability to choose his proclivities. But this is not how the Bible speaks of sin and judgment. There are all manner of predispositions that we are born with that the Bible nevertheless characterizes as sin: pride, anger, anxiousness, just to name a few. Why would we put same-sex attraction in a different category than those other predispositions that we groan to be delivered from and that we are morally accountable for? As we mentioned above, Jesus says that all such sins proceed from the heart and that we are therefore morally accountable for them (Mark 7:21). And this assessment is in no way mitigated by the fact that we come by it naturally or were born that way. As 

Richard Hays writes,
The Bible’s sober anthropology rejects the apparently commonsense assumption that only freely chosen acts are morally culpable. Quite the reverse: the very nature of sin is that it is not freely chosen. That is what it means to live “in the flesh” in a fallen creation. We are in bondage to sin but still accountable to God’s righteous judgment of our actions. In light of this theological anthropology, it cannot be maintained that a homosexual orientation is morally neutral because it is involuntary.[8]

Saturday, May 10, 2014

LGBT ORIENTATION IS SINFUL - A SIN - THAT REQUIRES FORGIVENESS


Posted by request from a long time FSAOF member, USA Central

Part One

By Denny Burk - February 18
In contemporary discussions of homosexuality, it is commonplace to distinguish homosexual orientation from homosexual behavior. Usually, the distinction goes something like this: Orientation refers to one’s inner disposition while behavior addresses one’s moral choices. John and Paul Feinberg state it this way:
Homosexuality as a sexual orientation means that a person has a strong and abiding preference for members of the same sex and desires to act on that sexual preference… Homosexual behavior refers to specific sex acts between members of the same sex.[1]
Some Christian ethicists take this observation a step further and argue that we must make a moral distinction between orientation and behavior. On this view, homosexual behavior is a choice and thus morally blameworthy. Homosexual orientation is not a choice and thus not morally blameworthy. This point of view has become routine even among some who identify themselves as evangelical. A couple examples to illustrate the point. Dennis Hollinger writes:
I would suggest that orientation is not the primary ethical issue. From a theological perspective, it is a result of the fallenness of our world… But orientation is not usually a result of a person’s willful, sinful choice. Hence, the ethical judgment on homosexuality is not about orientation or homoerotic impulses.[2]
Likewise, Joe Dallas and Nancy Heche write:
If a person’s primary sexual attractions are toward the same sex, the person’s orientation is homosexual… If a person’s sexual attractions are toward both sexes, the person’s orientation is bisexual… The Bible does not condemn homosexual or bisexual orientation as a deliberate sin, but any deliberate expression of homosexuality, through actions, sexual fantasy, or lust, is biblically prohibited.[3]
I do not dispute that there is a legitimate distinction to be made between orientation and behavior. I do question, however, whether the Bible supports the notion that only homosexual behavior is sinful while homosexual orientation is not. Evangelicals would generally agree with Hollinger that homosexual orientation in some way stems from the Fall. But in what way? Does homosexual orientation comprise a natural evil only? Or is it also a moral evil? Is it something that primarily requires healing (like cancer), or is it something that requires vigilant repentance (like pride)? How we answer these questions has enormous pastoral implications for those brothers and sisters who experience same-sex attraction. What follows is my attempt to answer these questions biblically and to suggest some pastoral implications.
Does the Bible address sexual orientation?
It is sometimes claimed that sexual orientation is a modern concept that would have been completely foreign to the writers of scripture.[4] But is that really true? It depends entirely on how one defines the term “orientation.” The American Psychological Association defines sexual orientation in this way: “Sexual orientation refers to an enduring pattern of emotional, romantic and/or sexual attractions to men, women or both sexes.”[5] Notice that orientation involves a person’s enduring sexual attractions and that sexual attraction is a virtual synonym for sexual desire.[6] Thus sexual orientation is one’s persistent pattern of sexual desire/attraction toward either or both sexes.
If that is the definition, then the term “orientation” does not somehow take us to a category that the Bible doesn’t address. The Bible says that our sexual desires/attractions have a moral component and that we are held accountable for them. Jesus’ remarks on the nature of heterosexual desire are a case in point:
Mathew 5:27-28 “You have heard that it was said, ‘You shall not commit adultery’; but I say to you, that everyone who looks on a woman to lust for her has committed adultery with her already in his heart.”
The word that Jesus uses for “lust” is the exact same term used in the tenth commandment’s prohibition on coveting: “You shall not desire/covet your neighbor’s wife” (Ex. 20:17; Deut. 5:21 LXX).  Thus both Jesus and the tenth commandment censure not merely adulterous behavior but also the desire that precedes the behavior. The locus of such desire is the “heart.” As Jesus confirms elsewhere, adultery and every other kind of sexual immorality proceed from the heart (Mark 7:21).
The married man who experiences an adulterous lust for another woman is a man who experiences unwholesome attractions. His attraction may indeed be spontaneous and uninvited. It may indeed reflect his sexual orientation to be attracted to the opposite sex. But that married man may not appeal to his heterosexual “orientation” to absolve him of having feelings that he ought not feel. Jesus says such feelings are adultery within the heart. Likewise, a man who experiences a sexual attraction to another man may be experiencing feelings that are spontaneous and uninvited. His attraction may well reflect what he perceives to be his natural “orientation.” But that does not absolve him of having sexual feelings he ought not feel. The Bible judges such attractions as sinful lust—as coveting someone sexually. Thus the scripture does in fact speak to one’s enduring pattern of sexual attractions.

END PART ONE

Wednesday, May 7, 2014

A Christian view of reality means that the body is a temple, set apart to be a dwelling place for the Holy Spirit.


The Gospel Coalition Blog

MAY 06 2014
RUSSELL MOORE Can We Trade Sexual Morality for Church Growth?

From time to time we hear some telling us that evangelical Christianity must
re-tool our sexual ethic if we're ever going to reach the next generation. Some say that Millennials, particularly, are leaving the church because of our "obsession" with sexual morality. The next generation needs a more flexible ethic, they say, on premarital sex, homosexuality, and so on. We'll either adapt, the line goes, or we'll die.

This argument is hardly new. In the early 20th century, this was precisely the
rhetoric used by liberal Protestant Harry Emerson Fosdick and his co-laborers. Fosdick was concerned, he said, for the future of Christianity, and if the church was to have a future we would have to get over our obsession with virginity. By that, Fosdick didn't mean the virginity of single Christians but the virginity of our Lord's mother.

The younger generation wanted to be Christian, the progressives told their
contemporaries, but they couldn't accept outmoded ideas of the miraculous, such as the virgin birth of Christ. What the liberals missed is that such miracles didn't become hard to believe with the onset of the modern age. They always had been hard to believe from the beginning.

Joseph's reaction to Mary's announcement of her pregnancy, after all, wasn't,
"Well, it's beginning to look a lot like Christmas." He assumed that she had
been sexually unfaithful. Why? Because he and his contemporaries knew how people get pregnant.

But the Christian message isn't burdened down by the miraculous. It's
inextricably linked to it. A virgin woman conceives. The lame walk. The blind see. A dead man is resurrected, ascends to heaven, and sends the Spirit. The universe's ruler is on his way to judge the living and the dead. Those who do away with such things are left with what J. Gresham Machen rightly identified as a different religion, a religion as disconnected from global Christianity as the made-up religion of Wicca is from the actual Druids of old.

Always Difficult

The same is true with a Christian sexual ethic. Sexual morality didn't become difficult with the onset of the sexual revolution. It always has been. Walking away from our own lordship, or from the tyranny of our desires, has always been a narrow way. The rich young ruler wanted a religion that would promise him his best life now, extended out into eternity. But Jesus knew that such an existence isn't life at all, just the zombie corpse of the way of the flesh. He came to give us something else, to join us to his own life.

If we withhold what our faith teaches about a theology of the body, of marriage, of what it means to be created male and female, we will breed nothing but cynicism from those who will rightly conclude that we see them not as sinners in need of good news but as a marketing niche to be exploited by telling them what they want to hear.

You can't grow a Christian church by being sub-Christian. That's why there are no booming Arian or Unitarian or Episcopal Church (USA) church-planting movements. But even if it "worked" to negotiate away sexual morality for church growth, we wouldn't do it. We can only reach Millennials, and anyone else, by reaching them with the gospel, good news for repentant sinners through the shed blood and empty tomb of Jesus Christ.

If we have to choose between Millennials and Jesus, we choose Jesus.

No Amendment

Some think the Christian sexual ethic is akin to our congregation's constitution and by-laws, that it can be amended by a two-thirds vote. But this isn't the case. Sexuality isn't ancillary to the gospel but is itself an embodied icon of the gospel, pointing us to the union of Christ and his church (Eph. 5:29-32).

This is why the Bible speaks of sexual immorality as having profound spiritual consequences (1 Cor. 6:17-20), ultimately leading, if not repented of, to exile from the kingdom of God (1 Cor. 6:9-10).

Sexual immorality isn't simply a matter of neurons firing. A Christian view of reality means that the body is a temple, set apart to be a dwelling place for
the Holy Spirit. Sexual immorality isn't just bad for us (although it is); it's
also an act of desecrating a holy place.

There's little surprise then that the Jerusalem Council, while not placing the
burden of the Mosaic ceremonial law on the new Gentile believers, did decree that the new brothers and sisters in Christ must flee sexual immorality (Acts 17:20). In a world of concubines and temple prostitutes and public pornography, a Christian sexual ethic was just as freakish and counter-cultural in the first-century Greco-Roman world as it is today, if not more so.

But the apostles maintained the pattern of sound words they were given because to do anything else would be to replace King Jesus with another lord, and to preach "peace" where there is still war, "Spirit" where there is still flesh.

They wouldn't do it, and neither should we.

Virgin births and empty tombs are hard to believe. Fidelity and chastity are
hard to live. That's why we don't have a natural gospel but a supernatural one.

And that's why Jesus isn't a means to where we want to go. He's a voice calling us to where we don't, left to ourselves, want to go: the way of the cross.

If we want to reach the next generation, they must hear from us a Galilean voice saying, "Come, follow me." Anything less is just more marketing for an already well-marketed Broad Way. And the end thereof is death.

Russell D. Moore is the president of the Ethics and Religious Liberty Commission of the Southern Baptist Convention.


Copyright © 2014 The Gospel Coalition, Inc. All rights reserved.

Sunday, May 4, 2014

Burning bright at sea...

Due to a very poor internet connection these next 8-10 days as we sail across the North Atlantic, the FSAOF Posts may be infrequent. We will resume our regular daily postings on May 15.

And our LGBT series will not be dampened by comments that we burn our books on this critical issue!

Blessings, Sven





THIS WILL BE OUR VIEW TONIGHT - NOT!




Friday, May 2, 2014

GO YE INTO HALF THE WORLD… Part One


2014 has been heralded as the year that presents a turning point in a global struggle for the right of as many as 600 million people around the world to be openly homosexual without fear of humiliation or violence. (Many suggest that a more accurate figure is as low as 2.4 Million)

An international community of human rights activists have made hard-won gains for LGBT (lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender) rights in traditionally conservative countries such as Spain and Argentina and rapidly changing societies like India. Absent from their list are the many Southern hemisphere countries where more than three quarters of the world’s Salvationists are enslaved, along with their countrymen, to a culture where discrimination, humiliation, violence and death are constant threats.  Salvationists are swept up in a society where politics dictate culture and where religious beliefs are twisted, thwarted or simply dismissed.

A well-mobilized counterassault from evangelical Christians and conservative Catholics across Africa dispelling the belief that homosexual orientation is a mortal sin has yet to be mounted, one that society could embrace, dispel and help control. A change and commitment to this new and credible position on the theological significance and enormity will require a sizeable, credible and influential commitment by an honest and intellectually credible Christian movement. Is the Army God’s choice to head up this initiative in partnership with other denominations? The Salvation Army has a long tradition and rich history of effecting social change.

On what authority do we go dorward.

The Reformation in the 1500s had several slogans.  The two best known are the " sola scriptura "and" sola fide. In my native Swedish language it translates simply as "Scripture alone" and "faith alone ". The concept of ‘Scripture alone’ is today debated and questioned and by many as being solely the highest authority on Christian beliefs and lifestyle. And few things in today’s world divide churches and Christian communities more deeply than the issue of homosexuality. What lies at the very heart of the matter is the Bible and its interpretation. I’ll return to this debate in the next article.

For Luther, it was about whether it was synods and the pope, or Scripture that had the highest authority, and his conclusion was that it was Scripture. Hence came the term ‘Scripture alone’ as the credible authority on how we Christians act clearly and consistently on the basis of our beliefs, including, matters of sexuality and what it means to follow Jesus with wisdom, humility, and grace.

Martin Thielen, Senior Pastor of Lebanon First United Methodist Church, Lebanon, Tennessee shares in his What’s the Least I can believe and Still be a Christian?, his church’s mission statement: “OPEN HEARTS, OPEN MINDS, AND OPEN DOORS’.  The FSAOF would not have been far from that same vision if we’d introduces our three LGBT Series similarly: Read with an open heart and mind, and you are bound to be changed. Positive and fundamental change comes not only from a 180 degree turn-around in one’s long-held or traditional position on the LGBT controversy, but more importantly in recognizing the integrity of the views of those holding contrary or a somewhat differing position. We have witnessed and been commended for contributing to those with open minds and open hearts, recognizing too that for some, it’s taken months or even several years. Change in one’s long-held commitment to a theological ‘truth’ is often long in coming. The very few biblical verses that touch upon same-sex-related matters and those that fuel the divide say nothing about love and enduring relationships between people of the same sex. This has led theologically conservative Christians to condemn altogether what is today called ‘homosexuality.’

Some LGBT folks within the FSAOF community have offered both a scholarly and profoundly personal reconciliation of a duality often depicted as hopelessly at odds. And as we embrace the LGBT folk in our ‘family’ we recognize that we are doing nothing more than exhibiting the same love and grace that Jesus extends to all.

Did we leave the third world Army behind as we Europeans and North Americans debated the three views represented by the Christian Right, Left and Center, leaving the rest of the SA world to move forward at their own pace. Were we aware of how splintered our fundamentally ‘cohesive’ SA theology was being developed?

Candidates at the High Councils are expected to give a speech outlining their expectations of the worldwide Army and their own effectiveness in moving their vision forward.

1977 Arnold Brown, point 6,  he (the General) must speed the progress of the Army in the developing countries.

1981  Jarl Wahlstrom … he (the General)must strike a balance between some cornservatism and courageous new thinking.

1993 Bramwell Tillsley … I long for an Army that is International in its outlook and recognizes its responsibility to the whole world.

1994 Paul Rader … we must go forward in finding cost effective, supportable means for entering new areas of ministry; … forward in compassionate and creative response to the Aids pandemic … We must move forward together in all our rich cultural diversity …We must share a common strategic vision as we move aggressively forward to the 21st century.

1999 John Gowans … I will do what you tell me to do.

2002 John Larsson … I will need to encourage the renewal of confidence in the unique contribution that the Army was raised up to make … The Army is a force … it is a force that is visible … a force with a mission to the whole person … a force with a genius for inclusion and releasing of potential.

2006 Shaw Clifton … He (God) wants us to be a truthful Army, an honest Army, never pretending that all is well, never wanting ourselves or seeking plaudits of men … He wants us to be a united, International Army.

2011 Linda Bond … It is vital that we are convinced of why we exist, when we have such certainty, this one mission will bring us together as one Army, every nation, every generation, every Salvationist totally sold out to our calling by God.

2013 Andre’ Cox … In conclusion, my dream for this great organization is that the SA will be characterized as being a force for good, a force for change and a force that lives by the values it proclaims.

To be continued…

Sven Ljungholm
Former Officer
Liverpool