Saturday, June 8, 2013

Life on the Front Line Part One of Three


Life on the Front Line

After this the Lord appointed seventy-two others and sent them on ahead of him, two by two, into every town and place where he himself was about to go. And he said to them, “The harvest is plentiful, but the labourers are few. Therefore pray earnestly to the Lord of the harvest to send out labourers into his harvest. Go your way; behold, I am sending you out as lambs in the midst of wolves.’ (Luke 10:1-3 ESV)

There is certainly something uniquely special about being sent out by God to work as an Officer in The Salvation Army. Officership, in and of itself, presents a set of unique challenges.  There are many factors to be considered when serving as an officer, in part because of the unique calling but also because of the challenging context – both within the Army and outside in the complex world we operate in. The following are the points I raised previously (some time ago), and I now offer a reflection on the cultural context.


1. Officership is unlike any job, and is a vocational calling. As such, achieving a work-life balance is much more difficult as the line between is mostly blurry.

2. Officership, like many vocational roles, is poorly paid and leaves little scope for well-deserved holidays. We also need to remember that officers kids were not called (in most cases) to a life of austerity, and are often disadvantaged (compared to their peers) by the calling of their parents.

3. DHQs are run by officers who are often burnt out themselves. There's a sense of being in the same boat, but rather than feeling that sense of sameness it is often the case that DHQ staff feel corps officers should suffer because they are suffering. On asking for support because we were struggling, we were told 'you are Salvation Army officers...you should just get on with it!' on another occasion, when our eldest son was being treated for cancer and we asked for practical support, we were told that staff at DHQ were 'running out of sympathy!' the compassion that the Army shows to the homeless, the poor, trafficking victims, the elderly, etc. needs to be shown more visibly and more actively to the officers offering that compassion.

4. In the olden days (when my parents were divisional leaders) their priority was the pastoral care of the corps officers in their care. If a corps officer was in distress, they would get in the car (no matter what time of day of night) and reach out to them. Legislation has, in recent years, changed the priorities of DHQs towards micro-bureaucracies, wrapped up in health & safety, legionella, child protection and finance. Rather than establishing a highly effective systems approach, the Army appears to have pursued a labour (or labor, for my American friends) intensive strategy, making Officership less vocation and more administration. This has to change!

Officers are the Army's greatest asset and, as they are not regular employees as such, they need to be affirmed, protected, nurtured, cared for, and loved beyond imagination.

Unlike the business world, you can't 'sweat the assets' without doing serious damage!

The Culture Within


It is said (by Dave Logan, Co-author of Tribal Leadership) that ‘culture eats strategy for breakfast!’ In other words, no matter how good the strategy is, if the culture is wrong then all striving is in vain.

The Salvation Army is a blessing from God. I feel I need to say that because, despite its problems, it has been raised up to do God’s work and fulfils this calling faithfully. That doesn’t mean it couldn’t be more effective at times. Indeed no organisation is perfect and none can claim to be without problems. But what are the big cultural challenges for the Army today? I believe there are a few areas that desperately need cultural change.

Considering the reasons that Officers resign their commissions, it is clear that many leave because of irretrievable breakdown in the relationship. This can be for many different reasons, but the result is a broken relationship. For Corps Officers – the front line troops – there appears to be an increasing feeling of isolation and hopelessness. There is a growing feeling that the ivory towers of DHQs and THQ are compromising the front line mission in order to pursue a divisional or territorial strategy. In a military context this could situation might be regarded by the higher officer classes as justified use of cannon fodder.

Cannon fodder is an informal, derogatory term for military personnel who are regarded or treated as expendable in the face of enemy fire. The term is generally used in situations where 
soldiers are forced to deliberately fight against hopeless odds (with the foreknowledge that they will suffer extremely high casualties) in an effort to achieve a strategic goal. An example is the trench warfare in World War I. (Source: Wikipedia)




Stuart Rivers
Former Officer
UKTI

8 comments:

Joseph Smith (Major) UKIT said...

Stuart Rivers, thanks for your post.

I am shocked and ashamed that you and your family were treated in such a disgraceful, insensitive way.

In the past, I also experienced that people skills were not at the top of the list of requirements for DC's.

You will be pleased to know that Divisional Leaders are chosen for their people skills now. This has made a difference. But there is a cost; motivational leadership and platform ministry, may have suffered.

On reflection would you not agree that our soldiers are our greatest asset? They are the ones on the real frontline everyday.

Respect and regards, Joseph

Anonymous said...

DCs with people skills?

I was out ill for three weeks - not one visit or telephone call. In my last appointment I was blessed by both and even received a card and flowers. And when my mother passed in the same city as they live neither turned up for the funeral at the hall. She'd been a life long soldier. I could go on but to what end?

Active Office UK

Joseph Smith (Major) UKIT said...

Active officer, your DC must change or others will suffer in the same way.

Please give him/her/them another chance by letting them know how you feel. If they do not respond, let THQ know. I know this is not easy to do but it may be the only way they will learn about how to prioritise pastoral care of officers over other responsibilities.

Joseph

Anonymous said...

Amen and amen!! What you describe could have very easily written to describe the events surrounding our exodus. The "ivory tower mentality" you describe perfectly captures what we encountered in a very dehumanizing process. We had to deal with a divisional commander who couldn't seem to distinguish between being God's representative and being God Himself.

Former
USA Central

Anonymous said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
Anonymous said...

Use this tips you've obtained here and get started on your organic garden today. Living in fact this is a really wrong vision.

Also visit my website - homepage

Anonymous said...

Joseph. I would love your assurances over the skills of current divisional commanders to be true. It may be true in some cases but certainly not all.
Cannon fodder certainly describes how it feels to many. Gone and forgotten.

Joseph Smith (Major) UKIT said...

Anonymous, it is clear that sometimes DC's fail to love the officers entrusted to their care.

I fear that corps and centre based officers also sometimes fail to love the salvationists and others entrusted to their care.

I think that the important question is "how do we minimise these failures?", and redeem these painful experiences?

It may help to remember that we are all sinners needing forgiveness and a second or even a tenth chance to become all we aught to be. This does not excuse persistent insensitivity, or misuse of power, but surely we need to address our concern privately with the person concerned, and then with their leader if they persist in the failure...

What is the alternative? That we build up resentment which damages our peace and emotional life, but allows the offender to continue in error, perhaps hurting other people too?

I know from experience that this is not easy to do, especially for a junior officer. But the exercise of integrity in this way prepares us for greater responsibilities and provides a path for our own spiritual maturity.

Respect and regards, Joseph.