Tuesday, June 11, 2013

Operation Nose Lift


Henry:      Cosmetic Surgery is against army regulations.

Hawkeye:    Another good reason to do it.

Trapper:    Henry, do you know who’s a major down at Tokyo General?  You ever hear of Stanley Robbins?

Henry:     Yeah, sure, the plastic surgeon.  He does all those Hollywood people.

Trapper:    We could have him here in an hour working on Baker’s beak.

Henry:     Don’t tell me.  I don’t want to know about it.  You guys have my full permission, and I never said that.  I mean, I’m not even here, so how could I?

An enlisted man come to Hawkeye and Trapper for a nose job, however, plastic surgery is against regulations in the army.  Not deterred by regulations, Hawkeye and Trapper covertly arrange for the surgery to help out the troubled soldier.
________________________________

Is there ever an occasion when it is okay to break the rules?  What happens when rules and regulations get in the way of progress?  Is there a difference between appropriate legislation and inhibitive legalism?  What about the ethics of the philosophy “It’s easier to ask for forgiveness than permission?”  These are challenging questions to wrestle with while trying to effectively lead when the system seems to get in the way of getting things done. 

Thomas Edison once said, “There ain’t no rules here. We’re trying to accomplish something.”  I don’t think I would want to live or lead in a society that isn’t governed by rules, but I do pray for wisdom and courage to lead in such a way that I can influence those who make the rules.  Leaders have a responsibility to lead up as well as leading down and to appropriately challenge anything that gets in the way of accomplishing something of significance.

Capt. Robert Evans
Australia
   

10 comments:

Anonymous said...

One of the final straws in my decision to resign was when I asked my DC directly "So are you saying that policy is more important than people?" and he leaned forward and responded "Yes". I was done.

Former
USA Central

Joseph Smith (Major) UKTI said...

"We believe that the Scriptures of the Old and New Testaments were given by inspiration of God, and that they only constitute the Divine rule of Christian faith and Practice."

The safest course is to ask "is the rule in line with Scriptures?"

If this is not clear "is the rule in line with Kingdom values?"

If still not clear, "Can you imagine Jesus obeying this rule in this circumstance?"

If the rule is not acceptable be prepared to honestly, and in love, explain why you cannot obey it, and be prepared to accept the consequence's without resentment or bitterness, because resentment and bitterness can do more harm to you and the kingdom than obeying an unreasonable rule.

Joseph.




Anonymous said...

We once had a Commissioner tell us to go for it with innovative ideas. He acknowledged the pencil pushing middle management wouldn't like it, but go for it anyway. So he essentially gave us permission to be a bit sneaky and bend the rules!

I'm not sure if he's ever done this himself, he's a straight laced guy, but seriously, those pencil pushing middle managers are a tough group to go up against!! Mostly non-officer personnel, they hold tighter to legalism than I've EVER seen! It's seriously CRAZY!

I've now resigned, but I still hear some of the struggle from my officer friends. Same old same old.

So essentially, I'm not sure it's possible in TSA world, when rules and regulations are the heartbeat of the organization, or at least seem to be.

Former officer
Australian Eastern Territory

NAME ON FILE

Joseph Smith (Major) UKTI. said...

Anonymous Former officer Australian Eastern Territory, (name on file),

Brits call these people 'jobs worths' They claim that to allow you to break the rule is 'more than their job is worth'. I would just tell them you understand, and respect their position, then go over their head. DC's can use such people as a shield to avoid difficult questions or maintain the status quo...

If the rule impairs you mission effectiveness you must challenge it. You never know, the DC may have wanted someone to challenge this rule so that he can tell his superiors that it is time it was scrapped.

If challenging the offending rule is done graciously it will gain you respect. Even though you may have to bow to it until you are in a position to get rid of it.

Just an observation from the trenches! Joseph.

Joseph.

Anonymous said...

A few articles down an "anonymous" commenter wrote about just finishing Albert Orsborn's autobiography "The House of My Pilgrimage" which was written in the 1950s.

Well, I read it years ago and I can still remember General Orsborn writing about the myriad of defections amongst officers in the UK during the first decade of the 1900s and up until the first World War. It turns out that even his father, mother and older sister were among those who left the work.

Reflecting back on that earlier time period he remembered that someone (his father?) said, "Son, you'll find it very difficult to retain your evangelical zeal within the SA system." Orsborn basically wrote that there was nothing new under the sun because people who were disillusioned were still saying the same thing in the 1950s!

His reply to the naysayers was something to the effect that an organization of any type that is going to survive and maintain its integrity can't just let people do anything they want to do, whenever they want to do it and however they want to do it at any time! He also concluded that yes, it may be difficult to maintain one's evangelical zeal within the Army system BUT IT'S NOT IMPOSSIBLE!

I also remember reading one of the appendices of a major biography on either William or Evangeline Booth written in the 1930s in which the author was describing a scene in an office at NHQ USA where the office workers though dedicated to the cause were when pressed for a comment were pretty darn sure that the Army was on its last leg and that they were living smack dab in the middle of its twilight years.

In either the same book or a similar one there was an appendices where in 1894 the atheist Thomas Huxley who was no friend of William Booth or TSA and of whom when he died, the War Cry (in of course the most Christ-like way possible) suggested that he was finally done in by God, told the story of a former officer couple who sold their small business in the 1880s to cast their lot with the Army only to then complain that William Booth and the Army personally screwed them over and that they eventually wound up out of the ranks, living in dire straits on almost nothing. Huxley also interviewed another ex-officer in 1894 who claimed that the Army was not the same Army it was in the 1880s and that by 1894 it had lost all of its power as an agent for evangelizing anyone and was no longer of any consequence to anyone, anywhere in the world.

Add to this that in 1969 Commissioner A.J. Gilliard wrote me a personal letter telling me that in 1920 he almost didn't go to training because he was working at IHQ and found himself thrown into the middle of a bunch of "tired, worn out, sick old men and women who shocked him by their attitudes toward people and the Army" and I guess after reading the articles and correspondence on this site in the last week or so, the writer of Ecclesiastes (and later General Orsborn) hit it right on the nail. There really is nothing new going on under the sun! Just some Food for Thought:

Daryl Lach
USA Central

P.S. I've got one more short story to share but because of the word limit I'll need to do one more posting....

Anonymous said...

continuing.....

How's this for a "Boy, You really screwed me over one good, TSA!" story? Do any of you remember a man in Army history named Tom McKee? He was as a young man supposedly the love of Evangeline Booth's life. They wanted to get married but William Booth forbade it. He and Catherine had both predicted and told Eva that if she stayed on as an officer and did not marry that one day she would become the General!

As a consolation prize Booth (who according to TSA folklore was always wise and seldom ever got anything wrong, great prophet/preacher that he was) introduced McKee to a German officer who was at the time the editor of the German War Cry and suggested that he marry her instead. Well, McKee did as his General told him and together he and his new blond German wife climbed the dizzying heights of officership to become Commissioners by the time of Booth's PtG. McKee was also considered one of WB's inner circle and was among the very few upper eschelon officers who were allowed to be present at Booth's death bed. (which is pretty darn good considering that Kate Booth-Clibborn who travelled to London all the way from Zion, Illinois, just to see her dear old dad for one last time, wasn't even allowed to speak to him because someone at HQ decided it was inappropriate and might upset him!)

Anyway, within two years after Booth's PtG Commissioner McKee and his darling, hand picked blond German wife were booted right out of the Army on their keisters because the Mrs. turned out to be a drug addict! (If I'm not mistaken word on the street had it she was on Horse.)

In the late 1900s and early 20th Century a lot of people took drugs that today would be considered illegal but at the time could be bought over the counter. In the beginning no one would think anything of it because the people taking them were really happy-go-lucky, full of enthusiasm for any task at hand and generally chirpy and jazzed up all the time---just the sort of person Booth hoped would show up on the Training College's doorstep every September.

The problem was that after about 20years on the garbage (whatever garbage it was that they were on) these same people turned out to be more buzzed than jazzed up and the various world governments started to put restrictions on what are now illegal drugs after scientists began to understand addiction better and what these substances were doing to people.

Oh well, so there you have it. Tom McKee at the age of 54 during a time when there were no old age pensions/social security benefits, etc. found himself out on the street with a strung out wife (hand picked by Booth himself) after years of service to the Army---and all because he listened to his General!

To make matters worse the poor thing didn't die until 1936, the last year the Army was in a statistical growth mode in the UK, so he didn't even have the luxury/satisfaction as so many dumped upon people since have had, to gloat over the supposed "impending death of the Army." Every time he went to the corner market he probably couldn't even get in without first passing an Army band or someone peddling the latest copy of the War Cry.

Now that's a story to weep and blow one's nose over-----

Daryl Lach
USA Central

"You Must Go Home By the Way of the Cross, To Stand With Jesus In the Morning!"

Joseph Smith (Major) UKTI said...

Dear Daryll, you seem to gloat in the tales of failure and falleness that you record. I cannot see anything edifying in what you have written, only a warning that we are all sinners needing forgiveness and the power of the Holy Spirit. But we already knew that, didn't we?

Respect and regards, Joseph.


Anonymous said...

Oh get off your high horse Major. Have you ever heard of comedy? It's related very much to tragedy and often times make tragedy bearable. That's what's edifying about it. It also puts into perspective the rantings of people who think in such microcosms of time and space that they believe they're the only ones who've ever suffered or had doubts and fears and are sure the old ship of Zion is sinking fast when it isn't.

Also, have you noticed that the people I write about in these scenarios are all long gone and dead? My stories on this blog hurt no one and hopefully help people living today see reality a little more clearly instead of through some religiously imposed SA cultural prism where people are taught to believe their forbearers were more wonderfully Christ-like years ago then people are today when that's clearly not, never was and never will be the case. Human nature does not change. That's the other thing that's edifying about it!

Daryl Lach
USA Central

Joseph Smith (Major) UKTI said...

Dear Daryll, I am sure you do not intend to cause harm to others. Perhaps you have been deeply disappointed because showed too much trust, and you want help others avoid the same kind of disappointment?

My concern is that the skeptism created by the failure and falleness you write about has a hardening effect on our hearts and result in cynicism, when what most of us need is a softening of our hearts combined with discernment which is a product of the Holy Spirit working within us.

Yes, officership includes being hurt and disappointed. This was the experience of Jesus before us.

Sometimes we may have to review our opinion of a person, but we must retain our vulnerability and hopefulness if we are to demonstrate real empathy with the hurt people we are called to reach for Jesus.

With respect and warm regards, Joseph.

Anonymous said...

hi