Tuesday, March 19, 2013

If there's no hell, why the need for the Cross?



In the course of the last 18 months we've featured Rob Bell and Brian McLaren a number of times in our articles. Both are well-known pastors and outspoken leaders of the controversial emergent church movement. It's surprising to me that a great many salvationists, including Salvation Army officers in the Western world, have found the emergent church theories compelling enough to attend lectures conducted by Bell and McLaren and included their books and material in their SA study and  worship material.
On Sunday we will begin a one week series focusing on Easter, and all of the articles are written by former Salvation Army officers. I invite you to read the series and compare our theology with that of Bell and McLaren.  Here are some thoughts from one of my favorite theologians.
Within days of its release, Dr. John Stott's, The Cross of Christ was heralded as a classic work on Christianity's main stay. 
“I could never myself believe in God, if it were not for the cross. The only God I believe in is the One Nietzsche ridiculed as 'God on the cross.' ...The universal symbol of the Christian faith is neither a crib nor a manger, but a gruesome cross. Yet many people are unclear about its meaning, and cannot understand why Christ had to die". 
 Indeed, many theologians, those wishing to side-step the concept of God's willingness to watch His son being spurned by the crowd of witnesses and by the Father himself, opt for a kinder, less gruesome, punishing version of God; a Watchtower pastel of the white bearded Grandfather.


In John Piper's tweet of last Easter we're given a brief insight into post-modernist theology. Friends ask if they should read Bell and McLaren, and to which I respond in the affirmative. But with this caveat - line up material that has been time tested, ancient truths by church fathers - New Testament commentaries by respected theologians, historians and philosophers... against the 'new age' universalist material.



Farewell Rob Bell?
 To my knowledge, until now John Piper has not publicly addressed the controversy that erupted over his infamous tweet, “Farewell Rob Bell“, on February 26, 2011.  The only thing he has said, via Twitter, is that Michael Krahn’s article was “pretty close.”

In a new interview with Christianity Today‘s Christine Scheller, ranging over a variety of issues like Trayvon Martin and why he doesn’t give more application in his sermons and excommunication, he was asked about what he meant and why he said it.
* * *
You famously tweeted, “Farewell Rob Bell” in response to his promotional video for his book Love Wins. Is there a place for theological reconciliation in the body of Christ?
To say yes to that—and you should say yes—would require serious definition. When you say theological reconciliation, you can mean two people with two different theologies working their way through to a common theology. That is their way of being reconciled. That’s what I give most of my energies to. I want to persuade people of what I see in the Bible, and work towards unity in truth. Probably what would be thought when [people] ask that question is: Can two people who maintain their differences in theology then be more reconciled? So, you wouldn’t say farewell; you would say hello. The answer is that it depends on the issues.
I don’t mind addressing the Rob Bell issue. When I watched the video of Rob Bell that was put up on Justin Taylor’s website, which was, I think, a link to his book on hell, my issue there was not primarily his view of hell. It was his cynicism concerning the Cross of Jesus Christ as a place where the Father atoned for the sins of his children and dealt with his own wrath by punishing me in his son. Rob Bell does not admire that. He doesn’t view the Cross that way, as a penal substitution. I consider that the essence of the Cross and my salvation, and the heart of God for me, and that ticked me off royally. I didn’t say all that, so probably everybody thought “Farewell Rob Bell” was kind of like “I don’t like his view of hell, so there.” Well, I don’t like John Stott’s view of hell either, and I never said anything about John Stott. I kept learning from John Stott. I would have sat at John Stott’s feet until the day he died.
There are some views that push people away farther and there are other views that don’t push them away farther. I want to learn from everybody. Francis Schaeffer said our differences in the church are a golden opportunity to show love, and instead of throwing hate bombs over the walls that we’ve got between ourselves, we throw love bombs over. In other words, differences can be an occasion for courtesy, kindness, gentleness, listening, and respect—all of which, the world would then look at and say, “They don’t have theological unity, but they do talk to each other in a certain way.” Now, Paul was pretty hard on certain theological differences and Jesus was really hard on certain differences. And so, there’s a point for “Thus far, no further, farewell.” There are other points where we ought to be cultivating all those courtesies.
Sven Ljungholm
Overton Hill, Cheshire



6 comments:

Anonymous said...

Am I correct in thinking that TSA does not come down on any one specific theory of the atonement, but sees them all as analogies?

If that is the case, just because Bell does not agree with the "penal" theory of the atonement, does not mean he should be rejected for that should it?

There are many evangelicals across the denominational spectrum, who at least think that it alone does not sufficiently describe the atonement.

If I am correct about TSA position it would seem to be a more viable one, than excluding all the other theories as heretical. Just an observation,

Former C&B

Anonymous said...

To link the coming of Jesus to hell is to minimise the work and ministry of Jesus. Jesus came to reconcile us to God, regardless of whether there is a literal hell or not. Former C and B is right that TSA does not subscribe to only one theory of the atonement,a nd the penal theory of the atonment, along with teh substitutionarytheory of the atonment has logical fallcies which can only be reconciled if they are PART of the answer rather than the whole answer.

Former
Australia Eastern

FORMER SALVATION ARMY OFFICERS FELLOWSHIP said...

From Adrian Warnock:

“. . . the Bible surely causes us to say that at the cross, God is saving us from himself by himself. The Cross is a Trinitarian endeavour driven by God the Trinity’s righteousness and justice, and his merciful desire to justify (cf Romans 3:25-26).

To paraphrase John Stott, the cross is God’s self-satisfaction by his self-substitution. Consequently, as Stott also notes: ‘We must never make Christ the object of God’s punishment or God the object of Christ’s persuasion, for both God and Christ were subjects not objects, taking the initiative together to save sinners.’”

Strikingly, in the current debate many would take issue with John Stott’s comment. When I read the book from which it is taken, I didn’t take it as a denial of the idea of God punishing sin in Jesus, just a desire to stress the fact that both God the Father and God the Son were united in the act of the atonement.

I think that this paragraph certainly hits on the heart of the disagreements that many have with penal substitution as we often explain it. Should we, in fact, be saying that Jesus was punished by God as we often do? Was Stott wrong to say what he did? Or are we missing a nuance in our popular presentation of this doctrine?

Anonymous said...

“The Third ‘Jesus’ of the Emerging Church”

In A Generous Orthodoxy, Brian McLaren describes his spiritual journey, which took him from a conservative Christian upbringing to a Pentecostal Jesus and eventually led him to say, “About that time, quite by accident, I met a third Jesus.”1 This following account gives important insight that we should pay attention to–because many are following this same path.

McLaren describes:
By my mid-20s, I had met the conservative Protestant Jesus, the Pentecostal Jesus, and the Roman Catholic Jesus.
2 McLaren found that the Protestant Jesus was too limiting. His dissatisfaction led him on a quest for something more. McLaren found what he was looking for in the mystics: I discovered other Roman Catholic writers ”twentieth-century writers such as Flannery O’Connor, Thomas Merton, Henri Nouwen, Romano Guardini, and Gabriel Marcel, as well as the medieval mystics and others.3
From these mystics, McLaren’s whole attitude toward salvation and spirituality changed. He began to emulate Thomas Merton and Henri Nouwen as illustrated when he states: I didn’t think of them as different saviors … But I was still unsatisfied, especially because I sensed that if Jesus were truly the Savior, he wasn’t just my personal Savior, but was the Savior of the whole cosmos.
4 This third Jesus McLaren discovered was the same Jesus Thomas Merton and Henri Nouwen had found, who both came to believe that God dwells in all persons and that all paths lead to God.
This third mystical Jesus is very much in tune with the New Age version of Jesus.

Active officer UKIT

Mark Ferreira said...

Part of the issue with substitution is what it means for forgiveness: is sin truly forgiven if there is still punishment served? Doesn't forgiveness imply that punishment is waived rather than served by someone else (or paid by someone else when we talk about the atonement as paying our debt). So we need to look at more in order to have a better understanding. The atonement is so singular and unlike any human system that we look at it from a few angles to get it the best we can. Substitution. Paying the debt. Demonstration (God demonstrates his love for us...). Sacrifice. We start to grasp the fullness of the atonement when we look at all of these ideas.

Anonymous said...

It is interesting to note that the same John Stott, who defends the penal theory of the atonement, is the same man, who along with the Clark Pinnock, and Pope Benedict, have moved away from the position of the eternal punishment of the wicked in the literal fires of Hell. For Stott and Pinnock, the move was toward the concept of annihilation, and for Benedict, separation from God.

Then there is the bogeyman that seems to scare the Hell out of we evangelicals whenever the word universalism is even whispered in public. I have been surprised to discover the large number of my colleagues who now confess they believe in it, but could never say so in public. But if one is going to mount a campaign against these people we will no longer be able to neglect the texts that support their position. Here are a few to consider:

1. The purpose of God is the restoration of all things to their original excellence. (Acts 3:21)
2. The means of restoration: through Christ (Romans 5:18; Hebrews 2:9)
3. The nature of the restoration: union of every soul with God (1 Corinthians 15:24-28)

And that brings me to the post by active UKI, who has interpreted McLaren accurately. It is Karl Rahner, the brilliant Catholic theologian who is often quoted as saying: "The devout Christian of the future will either be a 'mystic' or he (or she) will cease to be anything at all".

However as soon as one mentions this to those who are convinced that believing in Jesus, means swallowing the whole history of theology kit and caboodle one cannot be a Christian, they are threatened. But surely this should not be the case for Salvationists who have always put great stock in personal experience that proceeds in action, which is what being a 'mystic' is about.

Richard Rohr, the Franciscan priest and theologian puts it this way: "Too often religion offers more doctrinal conclusions, more competing truth claims in the increasingly large marketplace of religious claims, but seldom gives people a vision, process, and practices whereby they can legitimate those truth claims for themselves - by inner experience and actual practices."

And isn't true that even in The Salvation Army, the official organization honours the administrative types above all others, and has invariably kept the mystics, charismatic types and prayer people at arms' length - my officer Dad being one of them - but now that he has been dead for over fifty years, people who knew him are now telling me that he was one of the "Army's saints, larger than life in more ways than one!"

Hello Thomas Merton and Henri Nouwen, now that you have been Promoted to Glory even Salvationists are reading you as once they read C.S. Lewis. You Richard Rohr, are going to have to wait your turn until you kick the bucket. And for you Bell and McLaren you are assigned for the time being at least to the garbage dump outside of Jerusalem, alias Gehenna, Hades, and now better known as Hell. Pray pardon my humour!

Former Canada and Bermuda