First let me say thank you for accepting me into your Facebook fellowship. I have read many of the (more than 600) posts and have been blessed to know that I am not alone and God still loves and uses us even when ignored by TSA.
My husband and I were commissioned in 1987 (Messengers of Peace) in Los Angeles, CA. We were always assigned to corps that were struggling and God worked greatly in turning those corps around. We sensed God’s leading and blessing as He moved and challenged us to explore our ministry; to move outside the familiar SA paradigm.
We were stationed in an Oregon SA corps in 1999 to yet another struggling corps: again God worked in mysterious ways and within a short period a few people from the community began coming to our services. Most of these people were ex Seventh Day Adventists and expressed their interest in worshiping on their accepted Sabbath, Saturday. As corps officers wishing to follow SA procedure we asked DHQ if we initiate Saturday Worship services and were given the go ahead. The Sabbath worship group grew from a handful of people to a good number.
Some weeks later God led us to initiate Hebrew lessons with a Messianic Jew doing the teaching. Everything was going great and God blessed our new initiatives for four years until officers councils in 2003 when the then Commissioner in the Western Territory spoke to us after one of the meetings and told us we were to stop all Saturday meetings and Hebrew classes immediately. Naively perhaps, I asked why and was told, ”we are a New Testament church and the Old Testament was not to be used in guiding us in our ministry forms”.
A few days after councils we received a phone call from our DC (now a active Commissioner) to say that he had just spoke to the Territorial Commander and we were to definitely cease all programs that focused on messianic Judaism or we would be terminated (the DC was quite upset as he knew we had a very active corps fellowship, and these people also came to our Sunday services). We asked what our options were and he informed us that there were no options.
After a week of prayer we wrote a letter of resignation, which the TC accepted immediately. We have never heard from any of the officers we worked since our departure.
I found it quite incredible when that very TC was elected General, and often wonder how can a woman that obviously doesn’t believe or respect the lessons foundin the whole Word of God be elected to such a position.
I believe the Jews are God’s chosen people and they deserve the right to know Jesus perhaps more than anyone else.
That small Saturday group moved to another venue and left the army altogether, but God has blessed their group beyond all expectations. They have many new people attending regularly and are truly committed to God and the whole Word of God. Should I say that my husband is the leader of this group?
By the way, most of our present congregation are messianic Jews and God is doing a mighty work among them.
At first we were deeply hurt but after almost 8 years God has healed our hearts.
Just thought I would share my story with you.
Thanks again for your wonderful fellowship and the blessings I have received from reading the posts.
Yours in Christ
(Name on file)
USA West



12 comments:
Too bad that you were treated unfairly.Many churches today worship on Saturday and Sunday.Biblically no day is holier than any other. Every day can be a holy day or a day set aside for worship according to NT teaching.It is not like you were only following OT law. As Christians you were opening up opportunities for service and worship. I do not know all the circumstances but the General sounded harsh and very opinionated back then.The Salvation Army does not have sole rights to God.If the truth came out over half of the officers in the world would probably be dismissed for not being 100% Army.
I am glad that you found healing. God does that in spite of those that hurt us.
USA former
I have some understanding of where you are coming from. I have an absolute passion for bringing together much of the Jewish faith with Christianity. When I was in College (Messengers of the Truth - 95-96) we had two lecturers/training officers who were in fact converted Jews - and they never stopped being Jews. One was Major Stelstra (since PTG) who was a very highly respected Rabbi before converting, and Major Graham Harris (I think he might have been promted since then). They showed us how understanding the Jewish faith as a Jew can so much more greatly enrich our understanding of NT Christianity, and give it a completely different meaning. Major Stelstra would take us on tours of the Great Synagogue in Sydney, and he would wear his scull cap with his uniform and be respected as a great Rabbi by all the other Rabbis there.
Every year during Easter, I would conduct a 'Seydar' celebration - saying it in Hebrew and then in English, explaining the significance of it to us as Christians. I would open it up to other denominations. One year, an Anglican Priest came up to me afterwards and said 'I have been partaking in 'The Lord's Supper' for years, and administering it for years as a Priest. But the full significance of it never hit me until tonight. I will never partake of it the same way again.' In one of my Corps, the wife of my CSM was a practicing Jewess and a Soldier - she also enriched our fellowship - and taught me Jewish cooking.
It's not just the current General that has those views. Shaw Clifton was extremely anti- anything like that.
My prayer is that one day, things will change. But until then, we just have to keep the faith, and pray for change, and know in our hearts the path that God is leading us in.
Yours in Christ,
Graeme Randall
Former Australian East.
I would have to agree with Graeme on this one.Also change is bound to come around. It just will take some time. Jesus made many "changes" and he was hung on a cross. Evidently for some (former officers) it was too late.
USA former
This is quite an interesting story that will have many facets. Only you know the full dynamics that led to your ultimate resignation and immediate acceptance of same by the then TC.
I would like to think that SA principles were being adhered to in your Saturday and Sunday congregations, that these believers were invited to become active uniformed soldiers who could sign the Soldiers Covenant with honest intent and then ultimately identify with a larger Salvation Army beyond their limited local Corps fellowship.
Somehow I have the feeling that, wittingly or unwittingly the Saturday Sabbath keeping may have become the predominant and more important one with the Sunday meeting added as an extra because it was expected as officers in the SA.
I think the SA as an organisation is quite within its right to demand loyalty and adherence to denominational policies and practices - any other denomination would expect exactly the same and would have acted in the same way. Especially when it provides people with a ministry and a living in the first place.
From my very limited perspective (only your side of the story of course)you could have been increasingly torn apart as you sought to walk on a knife's edge to accommodate everybody. including the soldiery who may have felt inferior or maybe even excluded. Add to this that it could have looked as a separate and distinct SDA style congregation on SA premises being established, this would have been beyond the authority and control of the SA DHQ/THQ.
It is always good to remember that no corps is an autonomous unit in its own right. The corps itself has got no assets in capital nor property and officer leadership and local leadership is appointed by higher authority.
From reading your story it seems that all has worked out very well for you both and that God is blessing you mightely in your new ministries - this is good for you and the people you serve but especially for the Kingdom!
Every blessing to you personally and your powerful ministry outside the restrictions of the SA
ACTIVE UK
Active UK summed it up correctly....restrictions. It was the way that it was handled that was most disturbing.
USA former
One more thing. The Mercy Seat is an OT ministry form.Maybe it should be removed immediately.No options. You see, things do not always add up and are not always true to the Word. It just happens to be who is in charge...General , TC , DC...
USA former
Two further thoughts -
Given the time frame this happened, I wonder if it was the then TC instructing this to happen, or the then General (Shaw Clifton). I had resigned by that time, but my parents are still Officers, and my home Territory is very pro- looking at Jewish tradition to inform our Christian thought and Theology - and so was our TC. About that time, the then TC circulated a directive from the General instructing that all such activities were to cease immediately, and that any Officer - anywhere in the world - found to be doing such things, would be stood down effective immediately - no questions (for the same reasons you gave). Many other TC's reworded the directive and made it look like it came from THQ in an attempt to show loyalty to the General, but not ours. As a result, in my home Territory, there were those who nick-named Shaw Clifton 'Mien Furhror General' as it came accross that he was anti-semetic.
The other thing to bear in mind (for Active UK) is to remember the early days of TSA. Remember, in the early days, the main Holiness meeting was usually held on a Wednesday evening - and was usually by ticket only. The Salvation meeting happened whenever it was appropriate to witness/preach to a crowd of unsaved people - whether that was in a pub on Friday night, or in a hall on Sunday, or in the street at some other time. So what's the difference between having a meeting on Saturday or Wednesday? Neither is on a Sunday, and both are true to the practices/traditions of the early TSA.
Something to bear in mind.
Yours in Christ,
Graeme Randall
Former Australian East.
Grame,
When I read this posting (after having the privilege of talking to you in London earlier this year)I just knew you were going to weigh in on it---and also knew just about what you were going to write. lol!
USA Former,
You make an excellent point about the Mercy Seat being a Hebrew Testament holdover into Xianity but I don't think it quite fits in with what happened in Oregon.
Even though you're no longer attending the Army there's an excellent book by Major Nigel Bovey(in paperback)that came out this last year that deals with how the Mercy Seat has evolved in its usage, meanings, etc. to Salvationists (and other Xian groups who used it) over the years.
It's an excellent account and seems to me to be something you might still be interested in reading. (and I'm not just saying that it's excellent just because Major Bovey used an excerpt in it of one of my stories in Priority!Magazine.lol! Btw, he used stories and comments from Salvationists from all around the world. Try it USA Former, you'll like it!)
UK Active,
You ALWAYS seem to hit everything right on the nail! Yet unlike so many other commenters and writers on this and other unofficial SA blogs you never go negative! You always show the Army's side of things and the reasonableness of official positions which isn't always an easy thing to do when so many people claim to have been hurt by official positions! (usually because the positions were rarely ever explained to them!)
I really like your responses. In many ways you're a man after my own heart. I only wish I had the likes of you for a corps officer when I was kid growing up instead of some of the ding-a-lings we actually did have. lol!
One last comment: Several years ago I remember reading a theologian (can't remember for sure but I think it may have been Helmut Thielicke (?)the German) who stated that one of the major reasons why the Holocaust was able to take place during the Third Reich was because most Xians in Europe had forgotten the the Hebrew roots and underpinnings of the Xian faith. Certainly food for thought for Xians today!
Daryl Lach
USA Central
"You Must Go Home by the Way of the Cross, To Stand with Jesus in the Morning!"
I think we need to be very careful and factual here. Shaw Clifton has been mentioned a couple of times in a very negative way, whatever our personal opinion of that guy may be....he was not the General in 2003 (John Larsson was from 2002 - 2006)
Graeme:
We are not in the early, first generational infant SA anymore!
The earliest SA history shows a mish mash of all sorts of practices, much of it being real or perceived legend, by mavericks. Yet by the late 1890’s a clear structure of Sunday pattern began to emerge: Holiness, Praise, Salvation, each with their own meeting times - eg morning, afternoon, evening. Add to these the three open air meetings meant to recruit and introduce people to salvation (including a drum or double B as mercy seat)..... add to that the area mid-weekly holiness meeting to supplement the Sunday morning holiness teaching and provide regional fellowship, and you can see a highly formalised and tested structure that lasted for most UK corps well into the 1970's ( already 35-40 years ago). How things have changed since then!;);)
What I am trying to say is that there is of course no difference between having meetings on a Saturday or Wednesday or Sunday but when it becomes a superior, legalistic OT approach ‘outside the SA paradigm’, to the detriment of established SA practices and procedures, then one should not be surprised that a huge inter-relational confrontation is likely with the organisation always holding the trump cards.
Hope you are keeping well in London
Kind regards
ACTIVE UK
(name on file)
I would agree that Army leadership has the right to have officers follow standards.Certain teaching and practices should be frowned upon. My problem may be in the way that the situations are handled.
USA former
testing
Could it be that these are not easy situations to handle in the first place? However sensitively these are handled, there will be disappointed and disgruntled people who feel they have not got it their way or feel they have not been listened to.
As a CO I have to constanly balance and be consistent. Often I have to compromise in order to maintain integrity and unity among my people.
Do I always succeed? No! Do I always get it right? No! Do people feel at times that they have been let down? sometimes - yes. The importance of maintaining personal and spiritual integrity should be paramount as we can not please people all the time with some people who can never be pleased. Also the importance of providing a factual paper trail will allow for an objective independent audit to distinquish fact from fiction.
ACTIVE UK
Post a Comment