I continue my interaction with Rob Bell’s book. Today we
come to the third chapter and the topic of hell.
The central point of this chapter is to argue that hell is a
real place. But, and most importantly, the reality of hell is not only or even
primarily a future place. Hell is present in the world today. Hell is the
outcome of people’s choices when they reject “the good and true and beautiful
life” God has for them.
Here’s a statement of summary:
And that’s what we find in Jesus’ teaching about hell—a
volatile mixture of images, pictures, and metaphors that describe the very real
experiences and consequences of rejecting our God-given goodness and humanity.
Something we are all free to do, anytime, anywhere, with anyone (73).
Before reading my bullet point comments, think about the
idea:
Aside from the Bible’s teaching on the subject, do you think
this idea of hell is a sufficient answer to humanity’s universal longing for
justice?
Now for my quick hits.
1. Hell is not for the victims; what a victim of a hate
crime or a rape or genocide has had to endure can be absolutely called “hellish”,
but hell is not for them. Hell’s purpose is the final judgment of evil in any
form: human and non-human—angels and people.
2. Jewish people at the time of Jesus, and Jesus himself,
had no problem believing in eternal punishment. I suspect that most oppressed
people don’t.
3. There is plenty of ancient Jewish evidence about hell
that would make the most graphic images of hell in the New Testament look like
watercolor paintings. I could give references if you want them.
4. Gehenna, to the best of our knowledge, was not a “trash
dump”. There’s not one shred of evidence to support this idea that has become
self-evident.
5. In the Bible, restorative punishment, punishment whose
purpose is to restore, is generally corporate and only for Israel in the OT. What
I mean here is that individuals are not the objects of restorative punishment
in the OT. Much is made of Ezekiel’s vision of the restoration of Sodom (Ezek
16:44-58) in the chapter. Rob overreaches to make his point. A careful reading
of the passage reveals that Ezekiel is speaking of Sodom corporately. The city
will be restored with Samaria and with Jerusalem. In the NT, members of the
church are chastised in order that they might be restored. There’s no scenario
presented that gives even the hint that the unrighteous suffer divine judgment
in order to bring them to faith and salvation. See Romans 1:18-32.
6. As the presence of heaven has broken in to the present
the present age in the coming of Jesus, so too has the presence of hell. God’s
wrath, indeed, is presently being poured out in the present (Rom 1:18-32). But
this is not hell.
7. The warnings of judgment on the lips of Jesus transcend
the Jewish War of 68-70 and the destruction of Jerusalem and the temple. I am
in no way suggesting that these were not within the scope of the judgment, but
they do not exhaust the reality of the judgment Jesus predicted.
8. The interpretation of the parable of the Rich Man and
Lazarus told in Luke 16 is formative for the teaching on hell espoused in the
chapter. Rob's reading just doesn't stand up under scrutiny. You can look it
over for yourself. In the parable Jesus is teaching that deeds of mercy or lack
there of in this life are determinative for the life to come. What one does in
this life determines where one will spend the life to come and that final state
is unalterable.
In addition, a brief word is required on the interpretation
of the phrase “aion kolazo” (“eternal punishment”) in Matthew 25:46. First, the
word “kolazo”. The term in Matt 25:46 is the noun not the verb, but both are
only used twice in the NT (verb Acts 4:21; 2 Pet 2:9; noun 1 Jn 4:18; Matt
25:46). In none of its uses either in the verb or noun form does it speak of
“pruning” or does it refer to a restorative punishment. Second, Rob again, as
in the chapter on heaven, insists that Jews didn’t have a category for the idea
of forever. This is just wrong. Let me show you a passage where the concept of
forever is meant in a context of divine punishment: Revelation 20:10 and 14-15.
Rev. 20:10
And the devil, who deceived them, was thrown into the lake
of burning sulfur, where the beast and the false prophet had been thrown. They
will be tormented day and night for ever and ever.
Rev. 20:14-15
Then death and Hades were thrown into the lake of fire. The
lake of fire is the second death. 15 All whose names were not found written in
the book of life were thrown into the lake of fire.
These two texts are related and express a vision of the
final fate of God’s enemies. In the first text were told that the devil, the
beast and the false prophet will be “thrown” into the “lake of burning sulfur”
to be “tormented day and night. This torment according to John will be “for
ever and ever”. This phrase is created by repeating the word aion twice. It
means something like “for ages upon ages”. In this way John is expressing the
idea behind our term “forever”. While the term aion may mean a distinct period
of time with a beginning and an end, it can be and is used by biblical authors
to express an unending period or set of periods.
Another observation about these passages is the assumption
that the lake of fire is not only for God’s explicit enemies. Anyone whose name
is not written in the “book of life” will suffer the same fate with the devil,
the beast and the false prophet. A so-called neutral position (even giving
someone the benefit of the doubt) for John is implicit support for God’s
enemies. As someone said once, “You’re either with us, or with them”.
Finally, it appears that Hades, hell that is, is not the
same thing as the “lake of fire”. If we harmonize Jesus’ parable about the Rich
Man and Lazarus in Luke 16 with the teaching of Revelation here, we would have
to say that the Rich man who died and was in Hades in his first death, will be
thrown into the lake of fire in the “second death”.
No comments:
Post a Comment