Friday, September 9, 2011

ROB BELL a UNIVERSALIST? WHO KNOWS...


Then in Part Two Freswick further reinforces this for us as he turns over a few more rocks revealing Bell’s reimagined postliberalism:

Rob Bell repaints the attacks on the Christian faith by German liberal theologians and their subsequent followers. He embraces a liberal world-view that denied the virgin birth because of a faulty view of the relationship between science and scripture. Rudolph Bultmann was the one of the most famous of these men. Bultmann claimed the job of modern (late 19th, early 20thcentury) theologians was to demythologizethe gospels so the Christian faith could be relevant to our culture and learn how to live like Jesus. Living like Christ was important but doctrine was not.

Rob Bell repaints these false teachings of historic liberal theology. He consciously uses liberal theologians’ own words. He declares historic liberal theology to be a part of the Christian tradition he embraces. He is certainly aware of this historic attack on the Christian faith. His response is to accept liberalism as a part of the historic Christian faithrather than expose and condemn its errors. Rob Bell is a part of the historic liberal tradition rather than the historic tradition of the Christian faith.
One key aspect of liberalism embraced by Rob Bell is the false view of the life of Jesus replacing faith in Jesus. For Bell “Christian” describes those devoted “to living the way of the Messiah, who they believed was Jesus. A person who follows Jesus. .. .A way of life centered around a person who lives.” He writes, “I am far more interested in jumping than I am in arguing about whose trampoline is better.” What we do is essential, not what we believe.

Bell continues with the thought that we follow the rabbi Jesus to be like Him. Jesus the rabbi chooses us because He has faith in us. “I have been told that I need to believe in Jesus. Which is a good thing. But what I am learning is Jesus believes in me. I have been told that I to have faith in God. Which is a good thing. But what I am learning is that God has faith in me. The rabbi (Jesus) thinks we can be like him.” This is a postmodern liberal repainting of “modern liberalism”.                                 

So Apprising Ministries has been giving you peeks at its bleak future of division and compromise of God’s Word; and for nearly six years now, in articles like Is Rob Bell Evangelical? and Rob Bell Is Definitely Not Like Jesus, I’ve been warning you that Bell’s doctrine is not at all in line with the historic orthodox Christian faith. Take for example Rob Bell On His Practice Of “Militant Mysticism”.

Mysticism was not taught or practiced by Jesus of And His Apostles, which is why we don’t find it in the Bible. Here I’m going to point you to another review of Bell’s new book; this one by heretical Open Theist Greg Boyd, who not surprisingly is supportive of Bell’s latest work. And this gets me to my serious questions concerning Rob Bell.

Boyd tells us:
I have actually read the book (I received an advanced copy)… Rob is first and foremost a poet/artist/dramatist who has a fantastic gift for communicating… Putting his formidable communicating skills to full use… As I interpret Rob’s work,… I know many readers will want my opinion on whether or not Rob is in fact a Universalist.  I’m tempted to say — and probably should say —” I’m not sure;…

I strongly doubt Rob would describe himself as a “Universalist.”…even if one ends up disagreeing with some of Rob’s conclusions (which, as I said, are at most alluded to rather than dogmatically defended)… I would argue that Rob cannot hold to Universalism as a doctrine: he cannot be, in the classic sense of the word, a Universalist. Then again, I could be wrong… (Online source, emphasis his)
Here’s my first question: If Rob Bell has such “a fantastic gift for communicating, with “formidable communicating skills,” then why is it even people who are friends and supporters of Bell’s like Greg Boyd are “not sure” and “could be wrong” about what he believes, teaches, and confesses? For six years now I’ve talked with thousands of Rob Bell disciples and even they disagree about what Bell believes.
If you really want to see someone with formidable communicating skills pick up e.g. a copy of The Kingdom of the Cults by the actual Bible Answer Man, the late Dr. Walter Martin; I’ll guarantee that you’ll have no trouble figuring out what he believed about what he so often referred to as “the historic orthodox Christian faith.” This is how it should be; the Christian is to declare the Word of God as Jesus did, not raise questions about it.

According to Jesus His pastors are commissioned to:
Have nothing to do with foolish, ignorant controversies; you know that they breed quarrels…preach the word; be ready in season and out of season; reprove, rebuke, and exhort, with complete patience and teaching… He must hold firm to the trustworthy word as taught, so that he may be able to give instruction in sound doctrine and also to rebuke those who contradict it. (2 Timothy 2:23; 4:2; Titus 1:9) 

Which brings me to my other question: How do the nebulous teachings of Rob Bell fit that instruction?

Eric Marrapodi, CNN Belief Blog Co-Editor

2 comments:

Anonymous said...

Ever since joining the FB FSAOF group 2 years ago I have become a regular visitor to this site and commend you for posting such a wide and varied selection of views and comments. It's without doubt the most truly catholic of all of the SA websites or blogs. Regular visitors can't help but be informed, educated, challenged and blessed, all essential characteristics in a vibrant spiritual life.

Thank you for revisiting some issues on a regular basis, including the Rob Bell controversy.

Former Officer
USA East

Anonymous said...

I can only agree that Rob causes doubt and wonder,about what he believes. If he is that great of a communicator I would rather see him state things in a plain manor and not attempt to dazzle and tickle the reader or listener.

I think Rob is after a much larger audience.Hitler had a large audience. People need to guard their hearts and minds and yet be informed. I find all of this interesting but somewhat dangerous.

USA former