
When All Doesn’t Go Well
While both officers remain active and healthy, the social security question doesn’t have immediate impact as they have no need to draw upon those benefits. However, the following scenarios are examples of when this becomes problematic:
The death of the married female officer leaves the husband without social security benefits for their minor children, while if the husband dies, the wife does receive those benefits. While it might be argued that if the officer remains active, they are taken care of through the allowance system, a widower with young children may determine that active officership is not possible, and is left with fewer resources based sorely upon his gender.
The disability of a married female officer leaves the family without any income from social security for her, as well as potentially without medical coverage, again of particular importance if the couple needs to leave officership. In similar situations where early retirement is necessary, if it is due to the wife’s disability, no social security income is available to the household, but in the reverse case, the family can receive social security income. (It’s my understanding that a recent test case has allowed for social security payments to the woman officer).
A recent case in another territory involved a married woman officer who needed a kidney transplant. Because she had not worked, she was not eligible for a medical program that provided full coverage for medications. A male officer with the same situation was able to take advantage of that program.
It also raises the question as to whether any income is accessible to the married woman in retirement, either pension or social security payments.
The lack of income and work history can make employment, home ownership, and credit rating difficult for a woman who leaves officership, especially if the marriage does not remain intact.
Couples who would like to retire based on the age of the older spouse are unable to do so financially (at least prior to the husband reaching 62), if the older spouse is a woman. Therefore, Salvation Army officer women are serving past retirement age, to the age of 68 or 70. This has many implications, including struggling with poor health, stress-related illness and death, and one as simple as giving up precious years being near grandchildren.
On Shaky Ground
The current social security policy is based partly upon an opinion by the US Treasury Department (1957) that restates the Salvation Army’s information to the IRS that the service of the wife of a Salvation Army officer is gratuitous, and that she is considered to be a volunteer worker. It also affirms the position that she may render little or no service, or may devote full time to the religious and charitable work. “Like wives of ministers of other denominations, wives of Salvation Army officers are expected to assist their husbands in their religious and charitable work.” It is clear that in this decade, that statement is no longer valid, just as the expectations of clergy spouses is quite different than it was fifty years ago.
It is unlikely that this written statement could be used by a woman in conversation with divisional leadership to support her decision to volunteer in other ways, to choose not to participate in divisional activities, or to attend a different church. In fact, in contrast to this written description, there are many married women officers who have an assigned appointment, and the expectation is that they fulfill that role as is publicly posted in the Changes of Appointment.
-PART 2 of 3-
Major JoAnn Shade ministers with her husband Larry as the corps officers and Directors of the Ray and Joan Kroc Corps Community Center. She received a B.A. in sociology from S.U.N.Y. at Binghamton, a M.A. in Pastoral Counseling, and a Doctor of Ministry degree from Ashland Theological Seminary in June, 2006. She is a prolific writer, lecturer, and busy counselor and has contributed to this blog since its inception.
5 comments:
I would dare to say that if The Salvation Army was more concerned in general, that my wife and I may have remained as officers. We served in many appointments that were generally tough ones and it was very draining and even caused physical ailments. After nearly thirty years we had enough. I think that I came through the stress a bit better then she did but she often felt that she was taken advantage of without receiving any compensation in her name. That seemed to nag at her and I know that it does other married officers also. It is a very unfair system that will probably change in 5 years or so when the tax man decides that there has been a long time of border-line fraud or deception.
I hope and pray for change. It is too late for my wife and I but for those that continue in officership, they may see a forced change one day. You know. Lawyers,fines class-action court room scenes.Thing like that.Why would it even have to come to this? Salvation Army leadership should do the right thing and treat female officers with fairness , love and dignity.
Former officer in the USA East
JoAnn:
Thank you for this well thought out relevant article.
My first response after reading about this subject is to apologize to my wife and every women officer I ever served with for not being sensitive and aware of the implications surrounding allowance.
I sit at my computer recalling the impact women (married women in particular) have made on the ministry of the Army around the world.
There is no doubt that my wife, mother, aunt, and grandmother were fully engaged and actually if an honest assessment were made worked harder than their husbands. Following is an excerpt from the final sermon I preached as a Salvation Army Officer making my remorse for not being aware even more acute…
“One of the greatest blessings along my journey has been the marriage partnership and love of my life Jessica Ann. She has been a faithful partner both at the home and in every ministry we have been privileged to serve.
Proverbs 31:10, 11, 29 says, “An excellent wife, who can find? For her worth is far above jewels. The heart of her husband trusts in her, and he will have no lack of gain. Her children rise up and bless her; her husband also, and he praises her saying, ‘Many daughters have done nobly, but you excel them all.’”
Shortly after we were married we sensed a definite call from God to offer ourselves up to become ministers of the Gospel through the service and ministry of The Salvation Army. It was during these two years of instruction and Christian fellowship that we began to understand and sense the awesomeness of God, and the responsibilities that we would carry as Salvation Army Officers.”
There is much more to be said about the specific ministry responsibilities carried out by Jessica but I am sure every officer couple has their own unique stories.
All this to say that you are on the right path, and I salute you for your willingness to speak out and make a difference! God Bless!
Former US East
At times I think, in the scope of eternity, perhaps it really doesn't matter. But here's another example. In our county, there are about 100 churches, and around 20 of them are led by women. However, I am the only one of those women who comes regularly to the ministerial association, and that's because I make a deliberate effort to do so. Is it because they are getting their kids off to school at 7:30 a.m, they don't see the need to gather in that way, or perhaps because nearly every month, one or more of the pastors consistently refers to those gathered as brothers (and not when they're reading from the scriptures). Probably all of the above, but would a few of them participate regularly if they felt included?
The Kingdom loses, both now in lost fellowship and in the future when women realize they can use their gifts where they are fully welcomed.
JoAnn
US East active
Thank you JoAnn and others for sharing your valuable insights.
JoAnn shared information with me about an article written by a colleague with whom I served in Russia, Danielle Court. It's in the same critical and positive spirit as JoAnn's and I've received approval from the author, an active Canadian officer serving in Australia, to post it. It will be posted in a few days following JoAnn's part -3-.
On another note, readers will be interested to know that I received a private message today sharing that married female SA officers serving in the Benelux countries are termed 'volunteers', and consequently do not receive any allowance/compensation.
I think the issue is country dependent to an extent. In Australia, for a few decades now, married officers have had their allowance split 60/40. A couple of years before I resigned, they changed the rule so that marrieds could choose how they split the allowance. There were some extremely conservative couples who took the attitude 'men are the spiritual head, so they do all the ministry, and the wife just offers support', so they split it 100% to the husband. Others kept the 60/40 split as the wife tended to do more 'housework' and that was their decision. Others (like my parents) split it 50/50.
In Australia, the issues are slightly different. The social considerations (pensions, what happens after you leave officership etc.) have nothing to do with pay you received, but 'were you employed?'. In Australia, ALL clergy are not considered to be employed. When I as a single officer left officership, the biggest problem I had was that I officially had been unemployed all my life (I went into Officership from University). Income tax has little to do with whether you receive an allowance, or whether you are employed etc. You can be unemployed, but still be required to pay income tax. So many of the social implications raised in these articles are a moot point in Australia. The main issue is that of equal pay for equal work.
This raises the other issue that is often debated in Australia - that of the pay given to single officers. In my three corps appointments, I followed work-a-hollic married couples with no dependents (we call them 'single-marrieds' in Australia). The point is, I, a single officer (it is extremely rare for two singles to be appointed to the same corps in Oz), was expected to maintain the worlkload of two work-a-hollics, yet I received less pay then they did. The debate for many singles is that officers should be paid according to the demands of the appointment. If the appointment requires two people, pay two people. If only one person goes there but they do the work of two people, they get the pay. If a married couple go there, pay for two people.
I also think that officers should be paid from THQ rather than from the appointment (as they do in Australia). Appointmens all contribute what they can afford to THQ for paying officers, THQ then pays each officer according to their appointment, allowing marrieds to decide how they want their allowance split.
When considering the level of pay in relation to things like social security etc., we need to realise that in order to maintain the same level of lifestyle, many officers in the western world are comparatively on an extremely high income (when you consider the house, the car etc.). In Australia, given the rental situation etc., to maintain the same lifestyle one enjoys in officership, an average family would need to be on a total Gross salary of $150,000 to $200,000 p.a.
There are lots of considerations and arguments in this subject. But one that does need discussing.
Yours in Christ,
Graeme Randall
Former Australian East
Post a Comment