Thursday, November 12, 2009

Just Thinking | THE GHETTO RANT -2-


High Council 2006

Sure, a married woman might one day aspire to be married to a man that can take her to higher positions on the totem pole of the women’s ghetto. It may be a nice place for her - but it does not matter if she is qualified, able or even gifted for the appointment. Indeed, all the women ghetto positions in the world cannot offer a reasonable opportunity for women to learn, cultivate, or prove leadership qualities enough to get out of the ghetto.

I realize that I’m on dangerous ground. To even speak about these things so plainly will cause some leaders to consider me a whiner; will permit unsympathetic male officers to disdain me as a “femi-nazi”; and might persuade women who have bought into the ghetto and find comfort in it to treat me as a threat. But I think it’s time we, at least, spoke plainly.

Consider life as a married-woman corps officer, celebrated in our system as a front-line leadership position. She is free to teach, preach, lead and learn. She can sort out all her leadership skills alongside her husband and can “share the load” and work it out together. This is likely the most extreme freedom she will ever experience in her officership. This is, in actuality, the promise realized… but it’s all downhill from there. It is true that the organization chants in response to this rant: “See, look at the front line… look at the trenches - corps officers are married women. They are leaders. They are free.”

Here enters the illusion that eventually gives birth to the anger. Every successful corps officer has proved his/her leadership abilities on the ground and is thus considered able to offer leadership to larger areas of command. The problem is that the leadership at a corps level is only credited to the male officer.

“Oh, that can’t be!” you lament. “That’s not true - surely a shared leadership command would be credited to team leadership not just the male.”

But alas, it is true. Women leaders, even after proving themselves in front-line appointments as fully functioning, fully able, fully contributing corps officers - active in leading the corps council, community PR, corps structure and systems, leadership training, preaching and teaching and training - are most often sent to the women’s ghetto when their corresponding husbands are given a job that is directly related to their success as leaders on the corps level.

Then you never hear from married women leaders again - unless you head to a women’s retreat. It seems we can’t match our walk with our talk.

The cause of this current system of imprisoning effective women leaders for generations is unknown. Booth was known to promote married women according to their giftedness, not their married-ness. But even Booth ran into problems from the mainstream-informed officers in his ranks. In 1888, addressing a meeting in Exeter Hall, William Booth said, “We have a problem. When two officers marry, by some strange mistake in our organization, the woman doesn’t count.”

From what I can piece together, it has been a subtle yet increasing theological and systemic shift that has managed to render a huge section of the Army’s leaders unusable and at best very limited to the larger war front. The Army has hamstrung itself, fighting a war against a well-armed enemy with an arm and a leg tied behind its back.

Now, there are officers who believe that “headship” is a scriptural principle and as a direct result keep married women in submissive positions as leaders. Married women officers themselves often have been taught and continue to believe this lie. When I have challenged it, I realize that not only does the Army perpetuate it by its current system but has probably even taught it by previous practice.

I don’t have the space to dissect the necessary principles on women in leadership here. Suffice it to say, Catherine Booth did it a hundred and thirty years ago in a book entitled Female Ministry (which no recently commissioned officer, male or female, seems to have read), and recently Loren Cunningham (founder and president of YWAM) along with David Hamilton (Biblical scholar) offers a great overview of the new world-winning strategy called Why Not Women? Good question.

I’ve met many capable married women officers - and an alarming number of them are on anti-depressants. I’ve got a hunch they wouldn’t be if they weren’t so frustrated with their seeming ineffectiveness. The Apostle Paul offers that health in the body is in part due to letting people use their gifts. If someone has the gift of leadership, Paul suggests a good, godly idea - let them lead (Romans 12). I think he’s on to something.

Captain Danielle Strickland

Writer: Capt. Danielle Strickland is currently the Social Justice Director of the Southern Australia Territory. She digs traveling, reading, running, speaking, basketball and movies. Her passion is grace, mercy and justice… and all the stuff in between. Her favourite question is ‘how hard can it be?’ and most of her days are spent answering it. (While waiting to enter Training College as an accepted Candidate, Canada, she helped pioneer the work in Moscow, Russia.)

4 comments:

Anonymous said...

best thing I've heard coming from an army officer in years!

former,
GNY USA East

FloridaFlamingo said...

This also ties directly into Major Slade's series on married women (in the USA at least) to not receive pay. How can you feel fulfilled if you are working your butt off so your husband can collect the paycheck. Talk about repressed realities.

Anonymous said...

Deb,

I agree with what you stated. My wife was humiliated over the years and one area was no
compensation in her name. That does have an ill effect on female married officers. When will the Army wise up? Do many more need to resign because of deaf ears?

Former USA East

Anonymous said...

I am the daughter of a third generation officer. I left the SA when I left home, but I honor my heritage. I continue to be perplexed, though, at the discrimination (there is no other way to describe it) against females. Female officers receive orders and have mandatory job expectations in each appointment. But they are not compensated. Clearly discriminated against and treated differently due to their gender and marital status, and treated differently from single female officers. The Civil Rights Act of 1964 makes this type of discrimination unlawful, and I cannot believe that there has not been a class action lawsuit in this regard. The Army is putting themselve at risk by not addressing this. However, addressing it puts them in a position of admitting guilt as well. That could be their conundrum.