Saturday, July 6, 2013

THREE DOCTORS: HIV, snake bites, 4,000 operations a year and no quitting whistle!


YEAR 2012  REPORT – Dr. Paul Thistle shared the below report with a Rotary Club in his native Canada.

Here’s the story of a (hospital) place named Howard. It began in 1923.  The school commenced first, in recognition of the need for education among the native population in rural Zimbabwe.  A clinic was attached to the school which grew into a hospital, ward by ward, wing by wing.  Today, Howard Hospital is well known across the nation having served, schooled and saved hundreds of thousands, perhaps millions of Zimbabweans.

Sub Saharan Africa has always had a lions’ share of poverty, pestilence and political unrest, but for Zimbabwe in the last dozen years it has been something different again.  We still fight inflation, 80 percent  unemployment  and a scarcity of health care professionals, medicines and surgical supplies. Old Mother Howard’s cupboards are often bare.  The escalating costs of transportation alone make travel to Howard prohibitive especially for the disadvantaged, the widows, orphans and child headed families in our villages.  Many will travel 18-20 miles by foot to seek medical attention ….  if they can walk.  Others will use wheelbarrows and ox driven carts.  On the other hand, half of our patients are from the cities and towns of Zimbabwe, in search of affordable care in a privatized system. Public health care in Zimbabwe remains underfunded, semi-privatized, a pay as you play. This has been exacerbated by the political stalemate in the unity government.  June is winter in Zimbabwe with shorter days, but when you are poor and sick, the nights are a little longer all year round.

We are a 144 bed general hospital with 3 doctors, 50 nurses, 100 general staff serving a catchment of 270,000 people on an annual government grant of $7,000 US.  Our outpatient services had 110,000 total attendances in 2011. That’s more than a mouthful of stats. The number of operations have tripled to 4,000 a year in the last decade due to the unmet demand for affordable surgical care in Zimbabwe. 

I am a Salvation Army officer and gynaecologist by training, not an orthopedic surgeon but I still need to set bones and reduce fractures; in the operating room they call me ‘Captain Crunch’.  

There is nothing sensational about treating the poor in rural Africa - just hard work day and night - and the following day. We are Club Med without the Club.

By the grace of God, our doors remain open to welcome the sick, and in turn, for us to reach out into the community with our messages of prevention, treatment and care.   It is HIV and AIDS that still places the single largest demand on our scarce resources  at Howard.  The good news here is that we know what works. Our HIV prevalence has dropped from 29 percent in 1999 to 5.7 percent in April 2012. We have our HIV clinic called Hope Clinic in Shona translation. With 3,000 people on treatment and 4, 000 more decentralized to our district clinics AIDS has changed from being a byword of shame and suffering to become a chronic disease to live with, like diabetes or hypertension. 

Talk is cheap. To the thousands in our community accessing lifesaving antiretroviral therapy they would agree with Benjamin Franklin, ‘Well done is always better than well said.’

HIV, pregnancy and poverty is a triple whammy.  There is the story of Unity, a 30 year old, HIV positive mother of three from a village 15 miles away, who has no antenatal care, and therefore no access to life saving ARVs. She presents in a coma secondary to fits at home for several days. We call this condition eclampsia. There was no affordable means of transport.  Her twins have already died in the womb. And Unity dies a few hours after arrival.  To top it off, it is the middle of the night and the hospital has no oxygen, and there is no money in the bank to purchase oxygen. 

It is the straw that breaks the camel’s back.  But when your back is broken from a night of broken rest, you still have to get up for work the next morning with a 100 more in the queue.   
And when your get up and go just got up and left what motivates you to continue on: professionalism, a sense of duty, compassion, and a glimmer of vision. 

A glimmer of vision. As Proverbs (29 v18) reads, ‘Where there is no vision the people perish.’  However, vision can be clouded by indifference. To quote Elie Wiesel, Holocaust survivor, it is indifference to suffering that makes the human being inhuman. At Howard we have to counter this indifference, apathy and despair with a message of hope and healing.  For we are not talking politics here but people.  At Howard and elsewhere, people are more important than programs.

There is nothing more liberating to serve people irrespective of race, colour, religion, and social status, …. simply because they are human, created in the image of God. 

A vision that sees a better world tomorrow than today, and a plan to bring it into place. 

I am privileged to report that Howard Hospital has captured this vision thanks in a big part to our network of international supporters, particularly Canadians. 

At a time in history when there is increasing skepticism over large NGOs and government to government aid, our friends have rallied to provide holistic care to the underprivileged in our corner of the country.  We stretch dollars on a shoestring budget (even when we have no shoes) and deliver the assistance to the community on the ground.  Rotarians are part and parcel of the community and know and apply this concept well.  In the past few years, Rotarians working together within their districts across Canada, with Rotary International and Rotary Foundation Matching Grants have improved the short and long term health of men, women and children at Howard through the support of laboratory services, the provision of antiretroviral drugs to pregnant women, and general medical and surgical supplies to our hospital and neighbouring clinics.

Bicycles have been provided for home based care volunteers.
Nurses have been able to complete their degrees at Howard by long distance learning. A cervical cancer screening program has been set up. Cancer of the cervix is the number one cancer of women in Zimbabwe .. and it is preventable. Diesel fuel has been purchased to fire up the generator when the national power grid fails day and night.   A four wheel drive vehicle was provided for our community care program and now an ambulance for our patients in distress out in the village. 

Vision without action is but a daydream. And Rotarians did not need skype or twitter to do all of this, but patience, perseverance and a personal touch.    Maita basa!  You have done work.
 
I am most grateful for my parents who taught me the value of a day’s hard work, my loving wife, Pedrinah, who holds down the fort at home, and our two boys, James and Alexander who have taught me on numerous occasions how to pick up the broken pieces of our lives and move forward … in grace.

At Howard, we must remain focused on our purpose, not our problems to providing quality affordable health care to an underprivileged corner of rural Africa.

Theodore Roosevelt  said ‘Do what you can, with what you have, where you are’ 

 Some believe we cannot, at least not in Zimbabwe, not at this time.  I believe we can, … or else I would not be standing in front of you today. 


Friday, July 5, 2013

Are SA Medical Officer Missionaries routinely Shuffled across Territories? Part One


THE SALVATION ARMY - HOWARD HOSPITAL - ZIMBABWE
Opened 1923
Forty years ago, Zimbabwe (then Rhodesia), was considered to have had a model health care program and educational system.  The World Health Organization’s reports consistently showed that it was one of the leading countries in Africa, the only major exception being the Republic of South Africa.  However, since the 1990s, participation in the Congo war, rampant 1,000% inflation and a lack of foreign investment has left the country economically ravaged.  In 2008, Zimbabwe’s health care system was in a state of collapse, unable to provide basic health services or protect its people from ongoing HIV epidemics and sporadic outbreaks of infectious diseases, and calls for urgent intervention from humanitarian organizations around the world were growing by the day.
In this environment, Captain Dr. Paul Thistle had been serving at The Salvation Army’s Howard Hospital, Chiweshe, Mazowe district of Mashonaland since 1995; and as Chief Medical Officer since 1999.

Thistle is from Scarborough Ontario, and received his medical degrees from the University of Toronto.  Besides being a specialist in gynecology and obstetrics, he was honoured by the Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons of Canada as the first recipient of the Teasdale-Corti Humanitarian award; the Paul Harris Rotary Fellow award; and a Doctor of Laws degree by the University of Windsor. His clinical and research interests at the Howard, included prevention of mother to child transmission of HIV, AIDS prevention and treatment, cervical cancer screening and long-term methods of family planning.  Many of his colleagues have referred to him as “the best bush surgeon in the world”.

During his tenure patients came from the 100,000 peasant farmers, commercial farm and mine workers in the immediate area.  Others were referred from hospitals in a larger area encompassing a population of over 270,000.  Minor procedures were done on the spot by doctors, and often, by trained paramedics and nurses.  More difficult surgical cases were done on Tuesdays and Thursdays, and if there was an excess of cases, on other days as well.  The hospital welcomed 300 patients a day via the large adult outpatient and separate maternal child health clinics.  The majority were seen and treated by nurses who then referred some one hundred a day to the remaining doctors.  The nurse’s training school offered education for medical assistants of primary care. Likewise, there was a school for midwifery soon to be headed by Paul’s wife Pedrinah, providing both upgrading and complete training.
In the department of obstetrics, also known as Family Child Health (FCH), there were 2500 deliveries each year.  Within the hospital premises an ante-natal shelter offered accommodation to expectant mothers to prevent problems arising from delays in transportation.  A home care program was established for chronic and palliative care, including patients with AIDS related diseases, under the supervision of chaplains and nurses.  A supplemental feeding program was provided for children with malnutrition.  Child sponsorship was available for orphans whose parents died from AIDS and who could otherwise not afford to go to school.   A comprehensive HIV counseling and treatment center was launched in conjunction with an expanded effort to diagnose and manage tuberculosis.  An education team provided outreach to the schools, churches and community centres, with the message of AIDS prevention using the means of song, art and puppetry.  Much of this innovative ministry came to an abrupt halt in August 2012, when the Thistles were dismissed, and given twenty four hours to leave the Hospital grounds and forty eight hours to leave the country, by the then Territorial Commander Commissioner Vinece Chigariro, who has since been transferred to the East Kenya territory.

In late summer 2012, the FSAOF was asked to intervene in the seemingly unfair dismissal and repatriation of Captain Dr. Paul Thistle. The alert reached us too late for our fellowship’s involvement. We were however, made to realize that the dismissal was unethical (against Zimbabwe government standards of medical ethics) and subsequently the cause of much suffering and even deaths of patients.


This tragic story surfaced again last week when we were made more fully aware of the troubling circumstances that led to the dismissal of Dr. Paul Thistle. He is presently in Canada where he returns and undergoes regular training. He’ll soon return to Zimbabwe with his family to begin his 18th year as a surgeon, however, not in the SA’s 90 year old Howard Hospital, but at a neighboring mission hospital where he is presently a volunteer.
Dr. Thistle shared earlier this week with FSAOF: “Pedrinah and I remain deeply disappointed, that in official correspondence from IHQ, and in official Salvation Army press releases, no one ever wondered if people might be suffering. When you abruptly reduce the physician staff from 3 to 2 including removal of the only surgeon, it doesn’t take a rocket scientist or any health care experience to deduce that people will suffer.  Surgeries booked weeks and month in advance were cancelled.  When you receive phone calls from relatives stating that their mother or sister has died for lack of medical care at Howard, it is devastating.  The people, poor and disempowered, have had a basic human right withdrawn over a ‘routine transfer’ without stated reason. There has been no hint of an apology from the Salvation Army and very little has changed on the ground since August 2012 in regards to the delivery of health care services.” 


According to the latest reports from the Zimbabwean government the lack of trained medical staff continues to be a problem. 
In 2010, the World Health Organization reported that there were fewer than two doctors for every ten thousand people and that approximately 80% of the positions available for midwives remained unfilled. 

Doctors, pharmacists, laboratory technicians and nurses continue to leave the country to find better working conditions and salaries in South Africa, Canada, and the United Kingdom.  Basic health care services are uneven and some medical facilities suffer from a shortage of drugs.



Paul’s predecessor as the CMO, Major Dr. James Watt, former CMO of the Hospital, now retired in Canada, said the same day: “This is what I would prefer the FSAOF blog to focus on… that you would place the humanitarian crisis at Howard back into the public forum… it should be discussed urgently, i.e. before the High Council. Whether the Thistles are part of the solution to the restoration of Howard Hospital … that is a different question.


Nearly a year has passed since he (Dr. Paul Thistle) was removed from Howard Hospital; no suitable replacement has been found, and the hospital is in financial difficulty.  Furthermore, patients continue to die at Howard (over 10% mortality), among those referred to Harare, the capital two hours distant, for care (no money, no treatment), and at home, seeing the uselessness of coming to hospital. 

Many of these are Salvationists.  Many of them are known to me by name. My chief concern has always been the welfare of the people of Chiweshe. From my perspective, the health and well-being of the patient in the community is paramount."


Less than half the population has proper sanitation with the result that there are outbreaks of cholera from time to time.

UNAID reports that about one million people over the age of fifteen are infected with HIV/AIDS and that life-expectancy had dropped to forty nine years in 2009. The United Nations Children’s Agency believes that one in three children suffer from chronic malnutrition..  At one time the United Nations World Food Program was feeding half of the population, and the 2011 Famine Early Warning Systems Network warns that millions may again require food assistance.

In the light of the ethical concerns and responsibilities associated with the above information, the FSAOF seeks answers as to whether TSA IHQ, Zimbabwean THQ and Canada and Bermuda THQ officials sought to address the legitimate concerns of the HH donors and stakeholders, or simply made empty assurances in an effort to distract and dismiss them? 

For example, in making its decision to order Captain Dr. Thistle out of the country within a forty-eight hour time ultimatum;

  • Was attention given to the ethical breaches, those forced on or committed against Dr. Thistle and his wife, and the SA?


  • Were potential ramifications given even superficial consideration?

  • Did they consider how this might affect the availability of quality health care in general or focus instead on international flight departure times out of Harare?

  • Did they realize the negative impact that the removal of one of three Howard Hospital doctors and the only surgeon would have on the region? 

  • Was the decision made before being able to provide an immediate replacement even though assurances had been given by the SA? 

  • How great was the time lapse before a Chief Medical Officer was in place, and what are the qualifications-certifications of the person so employed? 

  • Was The Salvation Army correct in its statement that its medical missionaries are routinely shuffled?

  • What is the average duration of a SA medical officer’s overseas appointment? 

We would like answers from those responsible for making the decision.

End Part One  (This is part One in a series - Part Two will follow on or about July 11, 2013)

Dr. Sven Ljungholm Liverpool, UK - Former Officer
Dr. John Sullivan Oshawa, Ontario - Former Officer



Wednesday, July 3, 2013

Same Sex Attraction, Inclusivity and Acceptance Part Two


Inclusivity and Acceptance

Whatever our sexual orientation we are called to love one another, to accept and not reject one another. However, the acceptance and inclusivity must not ignore those areas of our lives which are not in accordance with God's will. Same sex attraction, together with any other tendency to express our sexuality outside of God's will, is to be challenged and resisted. However, for me, the words of Jesus to the woman caught in adultery encapsulates what our ongoing approach and attitude to each other should be. Neither do I condemn you . . . go and sin no more. 

I recognise that the practical and pastoral outworking of these issues for individuals and churches is massive, and there is insufficient space in this article to even begin discussing what this should look like. However, our churches need to be places where we are accepted for who we are as persons, but our sin, including sexual sin, is challenged, and patience and wisdom exercised as we each stumble our way forward in the grace of God towards a closer affinity with his will.

Conclusion

Nothing I have said above is going to bring immediate resolution to this very difficult area. All I have tried to do is to clearly, but hopefully sensitively, state where I, and perhaps a number of others, stand on this perplexing issue. However, as there are a number of different perspectives, some of which are held extremely and understandably passionately, this will mean that that which we each believe the church should be, will not happen in the near future. And we need to accept that this is so. However, if we can continue to be honest with one another, patient and loving, and accept that it's not my will or your will which is to be done but God's, I'm sure progress can be made. 

But I think it will be through a valley of tears of pain. And the valley may be a long one. 

In the meantime I would urge that we continue talking and never give up on one another, and respectfully suggest that we resist the temptation to sometimes think the worst of one another but try to understand where we are each coming from, and then present our challenges to each other in love. It's certainly not easy to do so, but essential.

Whilst writing this article I have been listening to this Gowans/Larsson song from the musical Glory (I may have mis-heard some of the words so feel free to correct my mistakes):-

We're all seeking the same Saviour, we're all seeking the self same Lord.
We're all claiming the same cleansing, we're all finding our peace restored.

Varied are the ones we name, the prayers we plead,
Yet essentially the same the grace we need.
Different in a thousand ways, in this the same.
Side by side in prayer and praise that grace we claim.

Every seeker comes alone to make his prayers,
But before one common throne we bring our cares.
Coming with an inward open Lord to meet.
We are not alone before the mercy seat.

You can listen too at:-



Bernard Martin
Former Officer UKT

Tuesday, July 2, 2013

Same Sex Attraction, Inclusivity and Acceptance Part One



Same Sex Attraction, Inclusivity and Acceptance - one Conservative Evangelical View

Introduction

I am very conscious that within the constraints of a blog article such as this there is much scope for misunderstanding to occur, due to a host of reasons, such as the inability to fully unpack the meaning of words used, the lack of space to explain and support all one says, and particularly the very sensitive nature of the topic. I recognise that before I begin, even the words of the title could be understood differently to that which I intend. However having highlighted that very real factor, I will proceed and try to be as clear as I can within the constraints present.

I would first say that in describing myself as 'Conservative Evangelical',  I mean that I try to use Scripture, Reason, Tradition and Experience to reach conclusions about how I should believe and behave, with Scripture holding the preeminent position among the four. I would also say that I recognise my total dependence on the Holy Spirit to guide my deliberations and conclusions, but I do not therefore believe that all I hold is affirmed by him. I trust him to continue leading me onwards.

By 'one ... View', I mean that it is the view that I have come to hold, and it may or may not coincide partly or exactly with that held by other Conservative Evangelicals.

My Framework


The basic framework I work with is as follows:-

1    God made human beings male and female, and his intention was that sexual intercourse was only to occur within the bounds of a marriage relationship between one man and one woman.

2    Due to the entrance of sin however, we are all born damaged, in some way shape or form, in every area of our lives, and so we are far from his originally perfect creation, and in need of salvation.

3    When we receive the salvation purchased and provided by our glorious Triune God, we commence traveling the road of recovery, and though we make progress in this life, return to perfection awaits the coming of the new age in its fullness.

4    The damage caused by sin has damaged us all sexually, though our individual experience of the nature and extent of damage will vary.

5    The fact that we are damaged will mean that our present natural tendency will be to act in accordance with our damage.

6    Same sex attraction is one amongst a number of 'types' of damage, but I would again stress that we are all damaged in some way or another. And let only him who is without sin, throw the first stone.

7    Whatever our particular expression and experience of damage regarding the sexual aspect of our being, God's call to all is receive his grace so that we can increasingly grow in conformity to his will regarding our sexuality.

Consequences of the framework

The outworking of my framework means that sexual expression should only occur within the bounds of a marriage relationship between one man and one woman. This presents a challenge to every human being, but for those who know same sex attraction, the challenges are of a particular type. 

However, I would again stress that the challenge to live in a way pleasing to God regarding sexual expression applies to us all, and whether heterosexual or homosexual, some will experience greater challenge, pain and difficulty than others. Also, we can all fail in the damaged area that is particular to us, but we can also all know ongoing forgiveness.


End Part One

Bernard Martin
Former UKT

Monday, July 1, 2013

We need to focus more on loving the sinner, and less on protesting his sin.


I thought we just needed to try harder. Maybe we needed to focus more on loving the sinner, and less on protesting his sin.

But I’m done. I can’t look my gay brother in the eye anymore and say “I love the sinner but hate the sin.”

I can’t keep drawing circles in the sand.

Even if I was able to fully live up to that ideal, I’d still be wrong. I’d still be assigning him an identity, viewing him as something other, something different. - Not human. Not friend. Not Christian. Not brother.
Sinner.

And despite all my theological disclaimers about how I’m just as much a sinner too, it’s not the same. We don’t use that phrase for everybody else. Only them. Only “the gays”. That’s the only place where we make “sinner” the all-encompassing identity.

Then we try to reach them, to evangelize them. We speak of “the gays” in words reminiscent of the “uncivilized headhunters” from those epic missionary stories – foreign and different and far away, the ultimate conquest for the church to tame and colonize and save. Maybe we accept them in our midst. But even then, it’s sinners in our midst – branded with a rainbow-colored scarlet letter. They aren’t truly part of us.

Even that word “them” makes me cringe as I speak it, as if my brothers and sisters are somehow other, different from me.

It’s a special sort of condescending love we’ve reserved for the gay community. We’ll agree to love them, accept them, welcome them – but we reserve the right to see them as different. We reserve the right to say “them” instead of “us”. We embrace them with arms full of disclaimers about how all the sinners are welcome here. And yet, they’re the only ones we constantly remind of their status as sinners, welcome sinners.

In all this, we turn our backs on all the gay brothers and sisters already in our church, already saved, already following Jesus. Our us vs. them narrative leaves little space for those who didn’t choose to be gay but did choose to follow Jesus. Using “gay” and “sinner” interchangeably, we force them away from the Table and into the shadows.
__________________________

They say Jesus was a friend of sinners, but he didn’t describe himself that
way. His motto wasn’t “eating and drinking with prostitutes and tax collectors.” Those were the labels used by the religious community, by the disapproving onlookers. What’s amazing about Jesus is that when he hung out with sinners, he didn’t act like they were sinners. They were just his friends. People with names. Defined as beloved children of the Creator, not defined by their sins. Icons of God’s image. His brothers and sisters.

It was the Pharisees who looked at them and scrawled “sinner” on their foreheads. It was the accusers who drew circles in the sand with themselves on the inside and “those sinners” on the outside.

Those words, “a friend of sinners”, were spoken with an upturned nose and a self-righteous sneer. And that’s the same phrase the church has adopted to speak of our own brothers and sisters – “Love the sinner, hate the sin.”

It’s the same self-righteous sneer heard in the words of those who dragged the woman caught in adultery to Jesus: “What should we do with such a woman?” They defined her by a moment. She was “one of those”. Not a sister. Not a human. Just a pawn in a political debate. A sinner.

But Jesus knelt with her in the sand. Unafraid to get dirty. Unafraid to affirm her humanity. “Neither do I condemn you, go and sin no more.”

He could have said “You’re a sinner, but I love you anyways.” But she knew she was a sinner. Those voices were loud and near and they held rocks above her head.

Jesus refused to let his voice join theirs. By telling her “go and sin no more”, he affirmed that sin is not her deepest identity. It’s not how he saw her. It’s not who she was at the core of the being.
__________________________
I am a sinner.

But before I was a sinner, I was created in the image of God. While sin has twisted and smudged that image, it can’t erase it. Sin, my sin, is so terrible that it killed Jesus. But it doesn’t define me any longer. I am a new creation.
Because of Jesus, “sinner” is not how God sees me. It’s not how I see myself. And it shouldn’t be how I see my brothers and sisters in the church.
There is no condemnation for those who are in Jesus. To look at my gay Christian brother and say “God loves the sinner” is to set myself against Jesus and bring condemnation again to those he’s already redeemed.

So I’m done.

I’m done with “Love the sinner, but hate the sin.”

I won’t say it anymore.

I’m done with speaking as if I’m different, better than you.

I’m not going to define anyone by their sin. That’s not my identity. It’s not yours.

We are icons. We are children of the Creator, redeemed by Jesus. We are brothers and sisters. And today, that’s enough.

 I’m indebted to Pastor Jonathan at Renovatus for his teachings on Jesus and the women of the Bible. See “Everything I’ve Ever Done.”

Micah J. Murray

6 Lessons From the Collapse of Exodus International july3


6 Lessons From the Collapse of Exodus International
11:30AM EDT 6/24/2013 MICHAEL BROWN

While the secular media is celebrating the demise of Exodus International and gay activists are hoping this will be the nail in the coffin of ex-gay ministries, Jesus continues to save, transform and liberate homosexual men and women all around the world.

Still, there are some important lessons we can learn from the closing of Exodus:

1. When a ministry or church or organization departs from its calling and purpose, it will no longer be backed by God. In the words of Jesus, “If the salt loses its saltiness ... it is no longer good for anything, except to be thrown out and trampled underfoot” (Matt. 5:13, NIV).
Right now, the world is mocking the idea that homosexuals can change, either by the gospel or by professional counseling or both, while many in the church are even questioning whether change is possible.
But Exodus is not closing because God no longer transforms homosexual men and women. It is closing because it has lost sight of its original mission and vision.

Alan Chambers, the current leader of Exodus, has stated publicly that he does not believe change in sexual orientation is possible, also claiming that practicing, unrepentant homosexuals who profess faith in Jesus are heaven-bound and saved. This means that Exodus stopped offering hope to struggling homosexuals and even stopped effectively calling them to holiness.

In that light, while the announcement of the closing of Exodus is bad news because of the reproach it brings to the gospel and the discouragement it brings to gay strugglers, it is good news because Exodus was no longer serving its God-ordained purposes. (For better news still, see No. 6 below.)

2. There is always a danger when one person becomes the face of a movement or denomination. When Alan Chambers offered an apology to the LGBT community for alleged harm done to them through Exodus International, he was not speaking for thousands of ex-gays or for hundreds of churches and ministries that are involved in ministering to homosexual men and women. He was speaking for himself (and perhaps for members of his board, some staff and some Exodus-affiliated ministries).

Of course, the secular and gay media are presenting this as far more than the apology of one man—first, because it helps discredit the entire ex-gay movement, and second, because in recent years, Alan has increasingly become the face of Exodus and, by extension, of a vast and diverse movement.
This is a real shame, and we need to guard against the “one man (or one woman) speaks for us all” mindset.

3. There is intense pressure on those offering hope and transformation to the homosexual community. We need to pray for Alan and his wife and family, along with those who have served with him in recent years, since there is a massive spiritual attack on those who stand on the front lines of ministry to homosexual men and women.

On the one hand, if you are an ex-gay leader, both the church and the world are watching your every move, the former wanting to be sure you are preserving your testimony, the latter wanting to discredit you. On the other hand, many in the church mistake compassion for compromise while the world mistakes conviction for bigotry. The pressure from both sides (and all the more from the spiritual realm) can be intense.

4. There is no way to appease gay activists without departing from the truth of the Word. When I am asked by church leaders what we can do to minister more effectively to the LGBT community, I state that we must first repent of our own sins—including rampant no-fault divorce, pornography and immorality in the church—and then we must ask God to break our hearts with His love for homosexual men and women.
At the same time, I fully realize that unless we celebrate homosexuality, embracing it as morally and socially equivalent to heterosexuality, and unless we tell “gay Christians” that they can follow Jesus and practice homosexuality at the same time, we have not gone far enough in their eyes.

The written apology issued by Alan Chambers leans in the dangerous direction of complete moral capitulation and should serve as a strong warning for the rest of us who want to stand for compassion without compromise.

5. The collapse of Exodus is closely connected to hypergrace theology. It is no secret that Alan Chambers is a member of a church that actively promotes hypergrace theology, with the pastor of that church serving as the chairman of the board of Exodus. This is reflected in Alan’s apology, where he stated, “My beliefs center around grace, the finished work of Christ on the cross and His offer of eternal relationship to any and all that believe,” by which he actually means there is nothing you can do to sever your relationship with God, nor is change in your lifestyle required in order to have a relationship with God.

He also stated, “Our beliefs do not center on ‘sin’ because ‘sin’ isn’t at the center of our faith,” but in effect this means he will not clearly and strongly preach against sin, another byproduct of hypergrace theology.

6. People and organizations may fail, but nothing can stop the goodness and compassion of the Lord. Over the last two years, as Exodus began to depart from its mission and change its theology, some of the key Exodus ministries withdrew from the organization when their concerns were not heard. They have now formed the Restored Hope Network, and I am privileged to serve on their board of advisers as they unashamedly “proclaim that Jesus Christ has life-changing power for all who submit to Christ as Lord” and as they “also seek to equip His church to impart that transformation.”

God’s hope goes marching on!

Michael Brown is author of The Real Kosher Jesus and host of the nationally syndicated talk radio show The Line of Fire on the Salem Radio Network. He is also president of FIRE School of Ministry and director of the Coalition of Conscience. Follow him at AskDrBrown on Facebook or @drmichaellbrown