Wednesday, November 18, 2009

A LIBERAL RESPONSE -1-

This week (beginning 9th of November) in the UK has been designated ‘National Families Week’. There has been an emphasis on the diversity of the modern family, highlighting same-sex adoptions. This, as one can imagine, is highly controversial. Religious based adoption agencies are being threatened with de-registration if they do not allow same-sex couples to adopt, while conservatives are taking the opportunity to highlight the fundamental nature of the traditional nuclear family. Much of the controversy still rages around the ‘morality’ and ‘legitimacy’ of same-sex relationships and homosexuality in general. With this in mind, this article will attempt to outline – extremely briefly – my ‘liberal’ response to the question of homosexuality. It will touch on theology, statistics, science, and testimony. At no point will it attempt to be a definitive answer. The purpose is simply to point discussions in a particular direction, encouraging the serious enquirer to research themselves in the directions pointed.

Theology
As with all things relating to the church and Christian living, the best place to begin a discussion is from the Bible. The Bible has long been used to condemn homosexuality. But is it the Bible that is condemning it, or is it men and women’s desire to condemn it that they interpret the Bible in such a way?

We must first realise that the Bible was written many years ago, in languages that have been dead for many years. The culture in which it was written is as foreign to us today as that of the culture of space aliens if they were to reveal themselves to us. It is something that we gradually come to learn more and more about. As we come to understand the language, we realise that many traditionally translated documents were grossly mistranslated. Academics are constantly re-translating the classics, realising that previous translations were completely wrong. With this in mind, the same must be done with the Bible. There is no such language as Biblical Greek or Biblical Hebrew. There is Ancient Greek and Ancient Hebrew, and the Bible was largely written in these languages. As our knowledge of these languages increases, we need to re-translate the Bible. This is terrifying as it will inevitably lead to a major re-write of much of our theology.

When such a task is applied to passages which traditionally condemn homosexuality, we find they do not refer to homosexuality at all. Let me give two examples:

Leviticus 18:22 “Do not lie with a man as one lies with a woman; that is detestable.” The word here ‘man’ is better translated as ‘Temple Prostitute’ (in the Hebrew tradition) or ‘Temple Priests’ if one were to use the template of Ancient Hebrew. The ‘Temple Priests’ were priests (men) who served the fertility god Ba’al. It was believed that by having sexual relations with them, one would be imbued with the fertility powers of Ba’al. If one wanted fertile crops, or a large family etc., or to remedy lack of crops or lack of children, one would ‘lie with’ one of these priests. In this context, we realise that Leviticus 18:22 has nothing to do with homosexuality, but everything to do with Idolatry.

1 Corinthians 6:9-10 “9Do you not know that the wicked will not inherit the kingdom of God? Do not be deceived: Neither the sexually immoral ...... nor male prostitutes nor homosexual offenders 10...... will inherit the kingdom of God.” The phrase translated here as ‘male prostitutes nor homosexual offenders’ is ‘malakoi aresenekoine’. Literally translated (according to Ancient Greek – not Biblical Greek) it says ‘soft compassionate/effeminate men’. This makes no sense, until one realises that Paul was using common ‘slang’. In Pauls’ day, there had been a long tradition of what we today might refer to as ‘pederasty’ (although this doesn’t fully convey the full meaning). The practice was for older men to take young, pre-pubescent males from disadvantaged backgrounds, give them their name (backing), and financial support, so that they could escape their plebeian life and enter into public life. In return, the youths would provide sexual favours for the men. We know from the wealth of other ancient documents that ‘malakoi’ was a derogative term used to describe a male who dressed as a child, and made themselves look like a child, in order to maintain that ‘lifestyle’ of being ‘pampered’ by older men. In essence, a ‘malkos’ was a male who refused to grow up and take their place in society. They essentially ‘robbed’ the rest of society from the potential income they could generate and contribution they could make etc. This understanding makes far more sense given the context of the verse. Aresenekoine was the term given to men who encouraged such behaviour, and so encouraged men to be lazy and not contribute to society. To translate such passages as ‘homosexual’ is as offensive to homosexuals as it would be to women to use the word ‘wife’ interchangeably with ‘prostitute’. They are equally as far removed from each other.
The traditional translation of such passages is wrong. It feeds prejudice, and perhaps was willingly translated as such because it would seem to lend weight to a misunderstood expression of personhood. The important point here is that there are no verses that condemn homosexuality. Equally, there are no verses that support it either. But then again, there are no verses that condemn paedophilia, yet we do. One could in fact find passages that support paedophilia, or slavery, or genocide, yet we condemn them. The reality is that God gave us an intellect to enquire ourselves as to what is right and wrong, and to change our understanding as we mature.

Graeme Randall
Former
Australia

Links:

This is a religious website devoted to ‘religious tolerance’. It provides information and essays on various religious subjects from a liberal perspective. Very balanced, and not preachy.
http://www.religioustolerance.org/hom_fixe.htm


This is a secular website giving up-to-date media articles, scientific research, and support information on gender development. Specifically aimed at the layman. A good resource for a basic, background introduction to the subject.
http://www.gender.org.uk/

Just Thinking | THE GHETTO RANT -4-

Here are a few ideas:

Teach good theology. Make every officer read Why Not Women? by Loren Cunningham to start. Not just the women - all officers. We must teach on this subject. If we don’t give proper theology, our officers will get it somewhere else. Most likely it will be the Baptists and most mainline Evangelicals teaching their own theology on women. This is important. What we think affects what we do. So this is not just a method problem; it’s a thinking one.

Use separate appointments/or separate tracking early. Follow the gifts and skills of officers. Do something easy to make this happen. Please don’t make another committee to discuss it. Just have married couples give a report of how they divide up the command and what their gifts are. It’s not rocket science. Get to know your leaders.

Dismantle the women’s ghetto. Put the women’s department where it belongs, in Program. Give officers appointments that match their giftedness and/or capabilities.

Dismiss officers who don’t work. Get on it. They are a drag on our system, our culture and our potential. It doesn’t matter their gender. Incompetence should be rewarded with a new job (just not with us).

Make it a must. Imbalance cannot be corrected without a counterweight. Create a reasonable minimum requirement of married women department heads in each territory. Do this for a minimum of five years to correct the initial imbalance. Whole countries do this in the workforce to create an equal setting from which the “best man for the job” becomes more than a literal description of what’s happening. We should be leading the world, transforming the culture, and this will only happen by intention.

Invite good married women officers to actually speak at non-women events. I know a few if you need some suggestions.

Most of all, let’s stop making excuses. Let’s stop pretending. Let’s be honest, real and practical about what to do. I know I sound passionate, but it is our whole future we are talking about here. Do I think God can’t use me outside of structure and system, promotions and process? Of course not!

But these days, it would appear that he simply can’t use me as General of The Salvation Army or any kind of department head, or anything that might insult my husband’s ego.

Let’s start partnering with God in His great design for The Salvation Army. Let’s really allow our workforce to grow in big proportions overnight and engage the enemy in a fight he hasn’t had to bear or to lose for a hundred years now. We did have him scared; now we have him sleeping. But I think if we started marching full strength, we could wake him with a fright. And he just might meet his end at last. Read Psalm 68:11 for details.
Writer: Capt. Danielle Strickland is currently the Social Justice Director of the Southern Australia Territory. She digs traveling, reading, running, speaking, basketball and movies. Her passion is grace, mercy and justice… and all the stuff in between. Her favourite question is ‘how hard can it be?’ and most of her days are spent answering it. (While waiting to enter Training College as an accepted Candidate, Canada, she helped pioneer the work in Moscow, Russia.)

Saturday, November 14, 2009

Just Thinking | THE GHETTO RANT -3-

I recently saw a movie that reminds me of the situation. It was called Jarhead. I don’t recommend the movie, but it may offer us some advice. It was about some soldiers trained, equipped and sent to the front to fight in a war. The problem was that they were never deployed. The government that sent them wouldn’t give them permission to engage the enemy (they were caught up in political talks) and so the soldiers sat on the ground - trained, equipped and stuck.

Not able to engage the enemy - not able to shoot, fight or even die - they started doing other things. Trying to keep in shape, wasting time on the decorations in their bunkers, learning to cook in different ways and getting angry at each other. It was a picture of soldiers stuck. And every married women officer-leader lives the same reality. So we busy ourselves on the ground… taking courses, watching our weight, picking on each other, over-organizing every women’s event and project… all the while simply trying to create some meaningful existence for ourselves, convincing ourselves that it isn’t our fault that we can’t lead, but having no way to prove it.

Now I’ve had this conversation enough times with enough people to tell you the responses:

Why do you need to lead on a positional level… are you hungry for power? This suggests that every leader wanting to stretch her ability to lead is hungry for power. It is an argument already lost by the practice of many godly men who long to lead well and lead bigger to mobilize forces and take more ground for God. Stop insulting us by considering any godly ambition for women leadership to be a Jezebel-inspired desire for control. It’s embarrassing.

The women’s ministry department is a valid leadership area. Good one. If that’s valid, then why can’t even the top dogs in the ghetto qualify to lead the Army? And considering that any single woman General can simply add the duties of World President of Women’s Organizations to her other responsibilities as international leader of The Salvation Army, this hardly seems like a division that needs to stand on its own.

The Army’s great strength is in “team leadership.” Married couples should work together and the women shouldn’t need a position to be able to lead with her husband. Yeah, this one really works, except when it comes to any administrative position where there is only one head, and except when it comes to an organizational culture that dismisses women from the boardroom and power positions. It’s such a nice offer to let us women “influence” the final decision made by men anyway, but let’s be honest: no signing authority, no positional authority, and no real authority means no authority.

Don’t get me started on headship. Anyone who still holds to this view needs to read the Bible again. Here’s a hint: look deeper. Not only that, but our movement has already established Army theology (even if it remains unimplemented), so if you believe in headship limiting women leaders, join another movement.

It has the potential to wreck marriages. Nice marriage. There is nothing like a union that insists on one of the members stuffing her gifts and abilities down inside of her for fear of her partner looking smaller in light of them. This behaviour insults the purpose of marriage and makes men look bad. Grow up and get a healthy ego. Stop needing your women to be smaller than you to feel good about yourselves. Actually, to take a more pastoral note: get some counselling.

I’ve heard that there were once attempts to make some married women officers department heads, and one couple was called in to see if they would accept. This is insulting. I’ve never heard of a couple being called in to see if it was okay to offer promotions to men. Never. Ever. The marriage is never considered and often is compromised when it comes to promotions. Think about it. The Commissioner calls me up and says, “We’ve been thinking about promoting your husband but were concerned about how that would affect your marriage. Would it be okay with you?” Yeah, that’ll happen. But when it has potential to work the other way, we ask first and then call it off! What happened to equality… what happened to the greater work of the war trumping our personal preference? Come on.

Women don’t want to lead. To that, I would point out that the women’s ministry department in many territories have the most success at getting converts and then building disciples by making soldiers. This means that even from the ghetto, women are leading and leading well. Perhaps the shrinking program departments around the western world should take note. There might just be a married woman who could grow a whole programme department… imagine!

While I’m on this one… does it matter if a male officer doesn’t want to lead? Don’t sign up. Kick women out who don’t pull their weight. Don’t use lame women leaders as an excuse to paint us all with the same brush. It’s pathetic. Honestly, I’ve known some male officers who lack the muster to work hard… it doesn’t seem to make a difference on the ones who do.

Here’s the best one of them all: In many cultures and situations this is not culturally acceptable. I can’t help but chuckle as I imagine Catherine Booth in Victorian England scandalizing the country and even herself as she spoke the scriptures publicly for the first time. It was as counter-England in her century as you could find. Now come with me to America as 16-year-old Eliza Shirley leads the charge, or how about the Marechale opening the Army as a young woman in France. And on and on I could go. We have never been a culturally relevant movement; we’ve been the very opposite. We were a threat to the established church culture, we were a circus to the thinking class, and we were a sign and a wonder for the average person on the scene. When did we start thinking cultural sensitivity was our calling? If there is an evil part of culture, let’s do everything we can to offend it. I suggest that subjecting women to unequal treatment and opportunity is an evil to be challenged, not a relevancy to be followed. Let’s go buy ourselves some courage and return to the war ready to actually fight!

How do we change it? With so many women of bad theology and bad practice, how do we turn the tide now?

Writer: Capt. Danielle Strickland is currently the Social Justice Director of the Southern Australia Territory. She digs traveling, reading, running, speaking, basketball and movies. Her passion is grace, mercy and justice… and all the stuff in between. Her favourite question is ‘how hard can it be?’ and most of her days are spent answering it. (While waiting to enter Training College as an accepted Candidate, Canada, she helped pioneer the work in Moscow, Russia.)

Thursday, November 12, 2009

Just Thinking | THE GHETTO RANT -2-


High Council 2006

Sure, a married woman might one day aspire to be married to a man that can take her to higher positions on the totem pole of the women’s ghetto. It may be a nice place for her - but it does not matter if she is qualified, able or even gifted for the appointment. Indeed, all the women ghetto positions in the world cannot offer a reasonable opportunity for women to learn, cultivate, or prove leadership qualities enough to get out of the ghetto.

I realize that I’m on dangerous ground. To even speak about these things so plainly will cause some leaders to consider me a whiner; will permit unsympathetic male officers to disdain me as a “femi-nazi”; and might persuade women who have bought into the ghetto and find comfort in it to treat me as a threat. But I think it’s time we, at least, spoke plainly.

Consider life as a married-woman corps officer, celebrated in our system as a front-line leadership position. She is free to teach, preach, lead and learn. She can sort out all her leadership skills alongside her husband and can “share the load” and work it out together. This is likely the most extreme freedom she will ever experience in her officership. This is, in actuality, the promise realized… but it’s all downhill from there. It is true that the organization chants in response to this rant: “See, look at the front line… look at the trenches - corps officers are married women. They are leaders. They are free.”

Here enters the illusion that eventually gives birth to the anger. Every successful corps officer has proved his/her leadership abilities on the ground and is thus considered able to offer leadership to larger areas of command. The problem is that the leadership at a corps level is only credited to the male officer.

“Oh, that can’t be!” you lament. “That’s not true - surely a shared leadership command would be credited to team leadership not just the male.”

But alas, it is true. Women leaders, even after proving themselves in front-line appointments as fully functioning, fully able, fully contributing corps officers - active in leading the corps council, community PR, corps structure and systems, leadership training, preaching and teaching and training - are most often sent to the women’s ghetto when their corresponding husbands are given a job that is directly related to their success as leaders on the corps level.

Then you never hear from married women leaders again - unless you head to a women’s retreat. It seems we can’t match our walk with our talk.

The cause of this current system of imprisoning effective women leaders for generations is unknown. Booth was known to promote married women according to their giftedness, not their married-ness. But even Booth ran into problems from the mainstream-informed officers in his ranks. In 1888, addressing a meeting in Exeter Hall, William Booth said, “We have a problem. When two officers marry, by some strange mistake in our organization, the woman doesn’t count.”

From what I can piece together, it has been a subtle yet increasing theological and systemic shift that has managed to render a huge section of the Army’s leaders unusable and at best very limited to the larger war front. The Army has hamstrung itself, fighting a war against a well-armed enemy with an arm and a leg tied behind its back.

Now, there are officers who believe that “headship” is a scriptural principle and as a direct result keep married women in submissive positions as leaders. Married women officers themselves often have been taught and continue to believe this lie. When I have challenged it, I realize that not only does the Army perpetuate it by its current system but has probably even taught it by previous practice.

I don’t have the space to dissect the necessary principles on women in leadership here. Suffice it to say, Catherine Booth did it a hundred and thirty years ago in a book entitled Female Ministry (which no recently commissioned officer, male or female, seems to have read), and recently Loren Cunningham (founder and president of YWAM) along with David Hamilton (Biblical scholar) offers a great overview of the new world-winning strategy called Why Not Women? Good question.

I’ve met many capable married women officers - and an alarming number of them are on anti-depressants. I’ve got a hunch they wouldn’t be if they weren’t so frustrated with their seeming ineffectiveness. The Apostle Paul offers that health in the body is in part due to letting people use their gifts. If someone has the gift of leadership, Paul suggests a good, godly idea - let them lead (Romans 12). I think he’s on to something.

Captain Danielle Strickland

Writer: Capt. Danielle Strickland is currently the Social Justice Director of the Southern Australia Territory. She digs traveling, reading, running, speaking, basketball and movies. Her passion is grace, mercy and justice… and all the stuff in between. Her favourite question is ‘how hard can it be?’ and most of her days are spent answering it. (While waiting to enter Training College as an accepted Candidate, Canada, she helped pioneer the work in Moscow, Russia.)

Just Thinking | THE GHETTO RANT

The Married Women’s Ghetto

So here’s the rub. There were many married women officers at the most recent High Council, and not one of them was nominated to be General. Do we think that out of all the women officers represented at the High Council, only single women have the gift of leadership? Are married women less capable, less inspiring, less able? Most would insist, with some trepidation, that no married women possess the experience necessary for the office of General. The rough part is this: they would be right. This problem is the result of what might be called “the women’s ghetto of The Salvation Army”.

When Martin Luther King, Jr. was trying to stand up for the rights of the urban poor in the northern part of the United States, he ran into a movement of young black ghettoized youth that had assembled themselves into an organization known as the Black Panthers. They were a group of militant young people so jaded and cynical that they scoffed at King’s non-violent protest methods. They wanted something extreme to be done about the injustice they endured - and they wanted it done now.

The injustice they experienced was somehow more humiliating than that of the black man in the south because it occurred in what was supposed to be the “land of freedom” - the north. Yet they found that, while they were technically free, they were still trapped and bound by their circumstances - stuck in a ghetto. Even though they could hear about the freedom and see the freedom and even sometimes taste the freedom, they couldn’t live it. This infuriated them.

Today, the outlook of married female officers bears resemblance to that of the black ghettoized youth in the north. They are told they are free - and indeed they are free in many respects. They are free to learn, to grow, and to lead on a basic level (especially as corps officers). But they cannot have the freedom to truly lead in the full potential or capacity they offer in the current system of The Army because of the “women’s ghetto.”

By women’s ghetto, I mean that part of The Salvation Army’s infrastructure that allows men to exercise leadership within the formal system while deploying their wives into corresponding positions over other women in a weird parallel universe. In this corporate structure, a woman’s end goal is to be married to a Commissioner - and to ultimately be the wife of the General.

It has no bearing on the election of a General whether or not his wife is even good at her job - as the position is not functional, but positional. By this I mean that it is not a merited position and is not considered an appointment providing leadership experience to become General (in fact, the wife of the General is the only Commissioner not allowed to attend High Council!).
High Council 2006

Captain Danielle Strickland

Writer: Capt. Danielle Strickland is currently the Social Justice Director of the Southern Australia Territory. She digs traveling, reading, running, speaking, basketball and movies. Her passion is grace, mercy and justice… and all the stuff in between. Her favourite question is ‘how hard can it be?’ and most of her days are spent answering it. (While waiting to enter Training College as an accepted Candidate, Canada, she helped pioneer the work in Moscow, Russia.)

Abortions on the basis of gender

MINISTER FOR HEALTH AND SOCIAL AFFAIRS, SWEDEN

On Wednesday the opening speech was by Health and Social Affairs Minister Göran Hägglund at the Midwives Association's annual conference.

- If man were a utility creature, one who constantly calculated every little move, weighed it against other features solely based on how it serves a self, considering each neighbor based on what he can bring in benefits, then society would be in trouble, "said Göran Hägglund and continued.

- If she were a creature of each of these so-called useless spiritual, social and cultural values all the time would be taken apart to see what was the most logical and practical, then it does not matter how technologically advanced we were. We would not be much more than intelligent animals

- "There are values that are universal in all countries. Or rather, should be. In China, it has for many years been the system to eliminate fetuses that are known to be girls, preferring to have boys as children. That is nothing more than a mockery of the idea of equal value. We should be very careful to take a stand against this trend in Sweden," he said.

In his speech Göran Hägglund highlighted the importance of the midwives' important role as team leaders in a number of open parenting courses offered in maternal and child health centers. In addition, he highlighted the government's extra investment in developing countries, maternal health and reducing maternal mortality. SEK 100 million from the aid budget for 2009 is earmarked for accelerating the development. A large part of the speech however, was devoted by Hagglund to criticize gender-selective abortions and the commercial philosophy, or utilitarianism - that people are valued based on the benefits they bring to society - as Thursday's speaker, Professor Torbjorn Tännsjö will cover.

Hägglund grew up in the Pentecostal movement, but is now a member of the Church of Sweden. He is married and has two children.

Jacob Rudolfsson (translated: s. ljungholm)

jacob.rudolfsson @ varldenidag.se

New Chief of the Staff Announced by General



General Shaw Clifton appoints Commissioners Barry and Sue Swanson respectively as Chief of the Staff and World Secretary for

I am pleased to advise that, following extensive consultation with senior Army leaders, both here at International Headquarters and further afield, I have decided to appoint Commissioners Barry and Sue Swanson respectively as Chief of the Staff and World Secretary for Women’s Ministries. These appointments are effective from Saturday 1 May 2010. Commissioners Swanson are officers of the USA Central Territory, currently serving as territorial leaders of that territory.

Commissioner Barry Swanson takes up his appointment as Chief of the Staff in succession to Commissioner Robin Dunster who, at the time of her retirement in May 2010, will have served as Chief of the Staff for four years, and as a Salvation Army officer for forty years. Tribute will be paid to the commissioner’s service in separate correspondence.

Commissioner Sue Swanson takes up her responsibilities as World Secretary for Women’s Ministries in succession to Commissioner Lyn Pearce, who will enter retirement. We thank Commissioner Pearce for her valuable contribution to the work of the Army’s women’s ministries, and a more detailed expression of thanks will be recorded in separate correspondence.
Commissioners Barry and Sue Swanson became officers in 1978 and served in corps and divisional appointments in their home territory for the next twenty-one years until, in 1999, they were appointed to lead the work of the programme department at territorial headquarters. Four years later they became Chief Secretary and Territorial Secretary for Women’s Ministries in the USA Central Territory – followed, in 2006, by appointment to National Headquarters as National Chief Secretary and National Secretary for Women’s Ministries. In 2007 Commissioners Swanson came to International Headquarters as International Secretary and Zonal Secretary for Women’s Ministries, the Americas and Caribbean zone, prior to being appointed to their present responsibilities as territorial leaders in the USA Central Territory.

Commissioners Swanson return to IHQ with a commendable record of commitment to Salvation Army service and ministry, and I believe their contribution on the international scene will enrich the Army world and thereby the cause of Christ.
May God bless the Chief of the Staff-designate and Commissioner Sue Swanson.

Shaw Clifton
General

Wednesday, November 11, 2009

FIRST EVER FSAOF TEA FELLOWSHIP; AT THE CONGRESS !!!

All Former SA officers are invited to join for fellowship at the Cafe' in Colston Hall, Bristol, at 4:00 PM on Saturday Nov. 14. Refreshments are courtesy of the FSAOF... feel free to contribute a few pennies.

Please RSVP to Sven Ljungholm; selmoscow@sel.com in order that we can reserve space. Please feel free to bring a friend and family. Kindly share your name and the total number in your party. Sven, 6'6" and his wife Glad (much shorter; normal height and weight), both in uniform will be at the Cafe' door to greet you. Please share this information with all former officers- invite them even if they don't have time to RSVP.

Welcome !

Tuesday, November 10, 2009

LETTER FROM LATVIA; FSAOF PROJECT !

Nov 10, 2009

Dear, Brothers and Sisters in the Former SA Officers Fellowship,

We have completed calculating our needs against your donation. I would suggest that the generous contribution is earmarked for school lunches for children living in; -Sarkani -Seda -Drusti, LATVIA.

Seda is north of Skangale and it's the same SA officers and the same activity as in the town of Sarkani.
Drusti is also in the same area, about 1.5 hours northeast of Riga, the capitol.

We expect that the FSAOF contribution will cover the cost of all school meals for these children until school ends in May, 2010, six months from December 1 this year.


Blessings,
Peter Baronowsky
Regional Commander


------------------------
FSAOF Colleagues,

An additional donation will be sent in the days ahead of $1,000.00 to provide each child with a warm winter coat, and a SA sponsored Christmas party in each town. Any assistance in meeting our donation target is welcome !

Happy Thanksgiving...

AN ALL TOO COMMON SIGHT WELCOMING CHILDREN HOME FROM SCHOOL...

Monday, November 9, 2009

MRS. MAJOR N.O. ALLOWANCE - PART 3-

It t is unlikely that the above statement regarding status would be repeated publicly, as it is not one that current leadership would be able to defend. Yet this foundational position, built upon an unequal view of officers based simply on the marital status of a woman, leads to a sense of cognitive dissonance (an inconsistency between attitudes or behaviors), so that something must change to eliminate the dissonance. To resolve this dissonance, a woman can decide to ignore the lack of compensation, accepting it as ‘just the way it is,’ one of the quirks of the organization that simply has to be accepted. Or, she can receive the message that she is not equal to her husband, and begin to live that out as a self-fulfilling prophecy that keeps her from reaching her full potential in ministry.

While transcribing interviews done with women clergy in a variety of settings, a young woman noted her reaction:
I was struck most by the oppressive silence of the promising, bright voices who had left local church ministry. I thought of the gifts and graces the church was losing out on because of its fear of change. One phrase kept coming to my mind when I would think of women leaving: the gifts of God for the people of God are being rejected.

Because of the dual clergy requirement, the Salvation Army may not see an exodus of women as a result of this factor, but it is likely that their commitment to the ministry may not be as whole-hearted and healthy as possible. The Salvation Army is sending a message to its married women officers through this policy, and, at least in some cases, the church is losing out on the gifts and graces they bring to the table.

Implications for the Future

In regards to the growing emphasis on social justice within the Army, it is difficult to fathom that organizationally the Salvation Army would work for the rights of women, and yet within its own camp, this unjust policy continues to be practiced. Is this one of the “sin in the camp” concerns that General Clifton alluded to in his comments early in his role as General?

Change
S
o how to address this? Changing a policy that has seemingly served the organization well for many years is difficult, but not impossible. It begins with an understanding of how the policy affects the families of married officers. This matters far beyond the issue of money.

It starts with an acknowledgement that both the husband and wife are officers. They both sign the Undertakings of an Officer, with its language about an allowance that is provided to officers. They both are subject to assignment, and they both are expected to fulfill certain obligations in regards to their appointments. Although the woman is theoretically a volunteer (IRS), she is expected to abide by the regulation that forbids remunerative employment. As such, they both should receive an allowance as compensation for their service.

It appears as though the financial differential of having the allowance in one name, versus being distributed between the spouses, is minimal upon retirement (one example indicates, less than $30 per month). If the largest financial loss is at the time of the death of one spouse, is that simply reflective of what people in the United States face? If the Salvation Army has a married couple who works for the organization as employees, that is what they would experience. And, within the mindset that what is being provided is a living allowance, it would seem as though a single person would need less income than two people. Currently, it appears as though compensation in retirement is more than adequate in the US, and if it is not, provision could be made in individual situations in the same way that this has been done in the past for those who were receiving less than a minimum standard.

As a personal response, I have been an officer for thirty years. I work at least 60 hours a week. I handle our family’s finances. Yet I report no income on our income tax form, and receive a statement from the Social Security Administration yearly indicating that I haven’t worked over the last thirty years. I am a strong, confident woman who is fully involved in ministry, and I haven’t allowed the lack of financial compensation or the perceived stained glass ceiling to keep me from doing what I feel called to do.

Yet I also listen to the voices of women officers across the county, and this topic is seen again and again as one large piece in the puzzle of their role within the Army that needs to be solved and resolved. While women have not (yet) followed in the footsteps of the suffragettes and chained themselves to the gates of the Centennial Memorial Temple in New York, the undercurrent of restlessness and sorrow is stirring among many officer women. The compensation issue is seen as symbolic of the lack of leadership opportunity, and a sense of being second-class citizens within the Army. These women are products of their culture. They have been raised in a world that has been changed by the work of civil rights and feminism, and they see themselves as equal partners in ministry, only to bump up against this policy.

Upon entering SFOT in 1976, I was aware of this policy to some extent, but I thought, perhaps naively, that it was only a matter of time until it was corrected. I had no idea that more than thirty years later, it would still be in place. We cannot allow this to be a money decision. We cannot allow this to be a legal decision or one of personal preference. It is time to do what is right, what is ethical, and what reflects the biblical call to social justice.

Postscript: Since this essay was written, I have had personal conversation with Salvation Army leadership that indicates that this policy is being reviewed and will be changed at some time in the future. However, I’ve seen no verification of that information in writing or how it will be accomplished.

Major JoAnn Shade ministers with her husband Larry as the corps officers and Directors of the Ray and Joan Kroc Corps Community Center. She received a B.A. in sociology from S.U.N.Y. at Binghamton, a M.A. in Pastoral Counseling, and a Doctor of Ministry degree from Ashland Theological Seminary in June, 2006. She is a prolific writer, lecturer, and busy counselor and has contributed to this blog since its inception.