A
sleek campus in a suburban area outside of Chicago once served as the center of
operations for an oil company, but now houses The Salvation Army’s Central
Territorial Headquarters. Each morning, Carol Seiler drives into the underground
parking lot and takes the stairs, passing the women’s ministries department and
heading for the floor reserved for territorial leadership. Her office, a small
space once used for traveling officers, is around the corner from the
territorial commander.
Just
over 5-feet-tall, Seiler is not an intimidating figure, but has a commanding
presence that fits the self-selected location of her office. As we sit, she
straightens the fitted blazer of her navy polyester pantsuit, her shoulders
adorned with maroon velvet epaulets and a silver Salvation Army
crest—designating her as one of 10 commissioners, the rank just below the
General, in the United States. By regulation, the wife of the territorial
commander is appointed to lead the women’s ministries department, but Seiler
brought a different background to the role. While she still holds that title by
international regulation, she created a position of her own: strategic mission
planning to keep the Army agile yet analytical in the Midwest.
“We
have inherited a paradox in an organization that cares about empowering women
in our programs, but uses gender and marital status to actually discriminate
against officers who are married women,” Seiler said. “Even if it
unintentionally happens, having one spouse be an attachment to the other, even
though both complete training college and hold a rank, devalues the
individuals.”
The
Salvation Army began with a desire to treat women equally, allowing them to
teach, preach and minister just like men. In its first 50 years in the United
States, the Army often had women leaders. Yet that equality had some
reservations, which William Booth, who started the Army with his wife,
Catherine, told listeners at an 1888 meeting, as recorded in a May 1888 edition
of The War Cry [ “In the way of our salaried officers we have a great
difficulty to meet…the male officers are joined with the female officers, and
then, by some strange mistake in our organization, the woman doesn’t count.”
Now, some men and women of The Salvation Army are trying to return the
organization to its intended egalitarian roots—for all officers, married and
single.
How
did The Salvation Army get sidetracked?
The
1900 edition of Orders and Regulations for Officers—“a manual of operations for
furthering the mission”—named gender equality as “one of the leading principles
upon which the Army is based.” This evangelical church ordains women and
appoints them into positions throughout the nonprofit organization, including
the April 2011 election of General Linda Bond as the international leader, but
the foundational progressive perspective was sidestepped along the way. The
1987 edition of officer regulations stated, “the nature of such service [for an
‘officer-wife’] will depend largely upon her husband’s appointment. In most
appointments…an officer-wife should assist her husband. He is of course,
responsible.” Not until the 1997 edition did the idea of “individual vocation
and mutual support” recognize instead the distinctive role of each officer.
Finding
a niche to fit her skills was part of Seiler’s strategy as a young officer.
Soon after receiving a master’s degree in public health, her husband became a
finance trainee and she was tasked with corps cadets, a young adult Bible study
program. “My previous work and education weren’t even factored into my role,”
said Seiler, who is largely responsible at that time for starting Bethesda
House, a shelter for homeless families affected by HIV/AIDS. “I found ways to
be fulfilled without fussing about it, but when I became a divisional
leader—and the divisional commander’s wife—I realized I needed to do more to
help other women,” she said. “Once you get into a position of authority, you
have to keep being a voice.”
In
a 2011 Pew Forum on Religion and Public Life global survey of evangelical Protestant
leaders, a third of worldwide leaders surveyed (33 percent) say they agree that
“women should stay at home and raise the children in the family;” the number is
higher among U.S. leaders with 44 percent agreeing women should stay at home.
The
Salvation Army—an evangelical Protestant church and international humanitarian
organization currently operating in 125 countries and 175 languages—is rooted
in Methodism. The Christian Mission, later re-named The Salvation Army,
originated in England in 1865 with a Methodist minister and his wife—William
and Catherine Booth. Though Catherine was never ordained nor commissioned, in
the Mission’s Foundation Deed the Booths included a provision that women have
the same rights to preach as men, and the organization has made women ministers
ever since—a remarkable advancement even today as just over half of American
Protestant denominations ordain women.
Yet
some see the opportunity given to married women officers as less than what is
offered to single women and male officers. “I was basically dismissed when I
married,” said one female officer with roughly 30 years of experience as both a
single and a married officer, who asked that her name not be used. “As a single
officer I was valued and people knew I could think and contribute, but as a
married officer I’m expected to coordinate parties and place uniform orders.
I’m an expansive thinker, and I feel boxed into a role that I don’t fit into.”
Despite
this, it is women officers who are largely essential to the Army’s legacy,
starting with its co-founder. Emerging from England’s working class, Catherine
Mumford grew up in a world where all women worked and religion, specifically
the local Wesleyan Methodist chapel, was at the center of the family. Women
could not participate in decision-making bodies nor be ordained, but the
theology did support women’s public ministry, according to Dr. Pamela Walker, a
professor of history at Carleton University in Ottawa and the author of Pulling
the Devil’s Kingdom Down on The Salvation Army in Victorian Britain.
“The
Army is a patriarchal organization, but it also endorses women’s authority,”
Walker said of the Army at its beginning. “In that tension is the root of
women’s position within the Army over the next hundred years.”
In
Victorian Britain, most evangelicals understood women to be “domestic,
dependent, and submissive, which necessarily precluded them from preaching or
assuming positions of authority,” Walker said. When the minister of the
Bethesda Free Church in Sunderland, Rev. A. A. Rees, published a pamphlet
arguing that Paul specifically and unequivocally forbade women to speak in
church, and because of Eve’s sin women were “under a denser cloud of suffering
and humiliation” and must remain in subjection to men, Catherine Booth was
enraged. She published her own pamphlet, “Female Teaching,” arguing that God
made man and woman together, and subordination occurred as a punishment for
Eve’s transgressions; the subjection was “neither natural nor eternal.”
She
wrote: “Will he inform us why women should be confined exclusively to the
kitchen or the distaff, any more than man to the field and the workshop? Did
not God, and has not nature, assigned to man his sphere of labor, ‘to till the
ground, and to dress it?’ And, if Mr. Rees claims exemption from this kind of
toil for one portion of his sex, on the ground of their possessing ability for
intellectual pursuits, he must allow us the same privilege for women.”
Because
19th-century British and American Protestants regarded women as passive and
receptive by nature, Walker said the most innovative and ultimately significant
aspect of Catherine Booth’s thinking was her assertion—radical at the time—that
women could possess spiritual authority as women and could preach as a part of
the natural order. She wrote to her mother, “I felt quite at home on the
platform—far more than I do in the kitchen.” When William Booth became ill in
1860, Catherine Booth took his place in the Methodist New Connexion preaching
circuit. The minutes contained no reference to her preaching, but the press
did, including a Wesleyan Times article titled “A Minister’s Wife Preaching for
Him!” She became well known for speaking and received many invitations to do
so, often before wealthy crowds where she gained financial support for the
ministry.
When
Catherine Booth—the “Army Mother”—died in 1890, 30,000 people lined the streets
of East London to watch her funeral procession. She was called the “most famous
and influential Christian woman of the generation.”
The
present tension
In
the United States today, women account for roughly 53 percent of entry-level
professional employees in the largest industrial corporations, yet they hold
only 37 percent of middle-management positions, 28 percent of vice-president
and senior-managerial roles, and 14 percent of seats on executive committees.
According to McKinsey & Company analysis, the chances of women advancing
are half of those for men.
This
is further complicated in The Salvation Army because for the most part a wife
seems to have opportunities only as far as they relate to her husband’s
appointments. All officers complete two years of training at one of four
colleges across the nation; each fulfills the requirements, and is ordained and
commissioned individually. Territorial leaders and personnel departments then
appoint officers to positions in Salvation Army corps (churches) and divisional
and territorial headquarters. A newly commissioned officer lieutenant is
individually promoted in rank to captain after five years of service and to
major after 15 years of service. Any rank beyond major, which couples then take
together, is given with elevated position.
For
married women officers, the dilemma is not found as often at the corps level
but in headquarters positions. Many headquarters (i.e. leadership) positions
for a husband come with a “linked” appointment for his wife, generally in the
women’s ministries department or as his assistant/associate. Colonel Sharron
Hudson is the territorial secretary for women’s ministries in the West and wife
of the chief secretary. “It’s a Catch-22 really, because I feel valued in my
ministry to women and always have; women’s programs have been the lifeblood of The
Salvation Army,” she said. “But after 20 years of working together in a corps,
when my husband was appointed a divisional secretary and the linked appointment
for me was in League of Mercy I had a hard time at first. I joked with him—kind
of joked—about him being in an office with a couch next to the divisional
commander and me being down in a cubby hole.”
However,
Hudson, who is currently working toward a master’s in Christian leadership at
Fuller Seminary, stresses that The Salvation Army does give her a position. “In
most other churches, I would be a ‘pastor’s wife’ but in The Salvation Army I
have my own appointment and title,” she said. “Even with its foibles, the Army
is still radical in its use of women in leadership.”
Western
Territorial Commander Commissioner James Knaggs said a male-dominated way of
thinking leads to the husband generally having the more dominant role in
headquarters appointments. He believes it needs to change and appointed a
married woman officer as the property secretary in the West. Yet Knaggs noted
that a number of married women officers he has discussed promotions with said
they did not want a position over their husbands. “They pleaded, ‘Don’t do this
to our marriage,’” Knaggs said.
“The
Salvation Army’s early leaders stressed the creation account,” said Dr. Roger
Green, professor and chair of Biblical Studies and Christian Ministries at
Gordon College in Massachusetts and the son of Salvation Army officer parents,
referencing Genesis 1:27-28.
Green
said in this account, there is no gender distinction. “There is a oneness of
purpose and jobs,” he said. “Following redemption in Christ there is no male
nor female as we read in Galatians 3:28. Early Army leaders knew this applies
primarily to salvation, but also to how we are intended to be in life and
ministry—without gender hindrances.”
Bold
enough
Some
married women officers don’t see positions and titles as an issue at all,
perhaps subscribing to the 1950s ideal of womanhood. “I personally wouldn’t
want to be in charge,” said Major Sandra Turner, who served as a single officer
in the Southern Territory for nine years before marrying; she recently moved to
a corps appointment from the assistant secretary for program in the Central
Territory’s Metropolitan Division under her husband. “I’m fine with the title
of assistant. I had a big office when I was single and then when I got married
I didn’t have an office at all.” When Turner married as a captain, she took on
her husband’s title of lieutenant. “It didn’t bother me; I would much rather be
known as Mrs. Turner,” she said.
In
The Salvation Army, according to 2011 statistics from International
Headquarters, women account for 57 percent of 26,254 active and retired
officers around the world. The international leader (the General) is a single
woman (the third single woman of 19 Generals in Salvation Army history). Nine
of 61 territorial/regional commanders are female—all single and also appointed
the territorial president of women’s ministries. Of the 5,289 officers in the
United States, 56 percent are women. The vast majority of U.S. officers (82
percent) are married, 15 percent are single women and 3 percent are single men.
Just two of 40 divisional commanders in the U.S. are women—both single.
William
Booth wrote in a letter to Catherine before they married, “I would not stop a
woman preaching on any account. I would not encourage one to begin.” Seiler
says the same applies now. “[Catherine] was bold enough to take the first step;
the boldness to start had to be hers,” she said. “This is not uncommon today.
There are a lot of men who say they wouldn’t stop someone, but they also won’t
encourage it. It takes individual initiative and boldness.”
The
organization reportedly discussed appointments for married women officers at
the 2011 High Council, the closed-door meeting of international commissioners
that elects the Army’s worldwide leader. It was the largest ever High Council
with 109 members. For the first time, more attendees were women than men (57 to
52) due to a vote to include officers holding the appointment of territorial
president of women’s ministries—generally the wife of the territorial
commander.
“Some
worry about how it would work if the husband was subordinate; it’s curious
though that we don’t even think about it the other way around,” National
Commander Commissioner William Roberts said. “If I can have any influence on
[recognizing the place of married women in Army leadership], I will. We need to
explore it further.
One
facet of concern
For
those married women officers in the U.S. who feel devalued by the organization,
the method of compensation and its result on Social Security considerations is
a tangible illustration.
According
to Seiler’s monthly statement from the Social Security Administration, she has
no work history; a long list of zeros fills her income record for 31 years with
the organization. The Army utilizes its prerogative as a religious institution
to determine how it will compensate its workers. The officers are not employees
but are members of clergy, and as such fall under Social Security publication
517 that says “if a husband and wife are both duly ordained, commissioned or
licensed ministers of a church and have an agreement that each will perform
specific services for which they are paid jointly or separately, they must
divide the self-employment income according to the agreement.”
It
is this “ministerial exception” that protects the organization from the U.S.
Equal Employment Opportunity Commission’s Equal Pay Act that requires men and
women in the same workplace be given equal pay for equal work, as well as from
discrimination lawsuits. The Salvation Army won a case filed in 1972 by a
disgruntled ex-officer, who claimed she was discriminated against in
appointments on the basis of her sex, on the grounds that relations between a
church and its ministers were exempt from the relevant provisions of the Civil
Rights Act. This clause was affirmed with the January 2012 Supreme Court ruling
in the Hosanna-Tabor case that ministers may not bring employment
discrimination suits against their churches.
In
the Army’s case, the agreement for compensation is that the officer allowance
be paid jointly to the husband—the check is written in his name. Officially,
the wife is a “worker without expectation of remuneration,” and her husband
receives 40 percent more of an allowance as a married man than he would as a
single man. Social Security benefits following retirement include a non-worker
benefit of 50 percent of the working spouse’s income, but this is complicated
in times of divorce or early death.
If
the Army were to begin paying all officers individually, a couple’s Social
Security benefit would be reduced. Outside analysis determined that to make up
the difference in retirement, each territory would need to begin to set aside
$4 million annually.
“Do
I think my wife should be paid for her work? Absolutely,” said Colonel Dave
Hudson, chief secretary in the Western Territory. “But it’s not as easy to
answer when you explain that it will cost the Army significant dollars a year
to get what we are getting now. We have yet to come up with a format and price
tag that is manageable.”
From
separate pay to time spent on the job to the titles gained, the value an
individual feels is the core of the issue.
“Everything
comes down to that, and everybody receives value differently than others,”
Hudson said. “We need to look at what the best needs are for the organization,
the individual and the family and try to meld them all together. Every officer
should be utilized to the fullest extent of his or her abilities and skills.”
The
march forward
Despite
The Salvation Army’s obligations and structures—a maturity that Booth wasn’t
bound by—“We have to think about the issues of today and apply the elements of
Booth: creativity, willingness to take on new things, and care for mission,”
Seiler said.
Commissioner
Nancy Roberts, national president of women’s ministries, who holds a master’s
degree in counseling and guidance, agrees. “I’ll stand behind women who are
speaking up and support and encourage the use of an individual’s strengths and
gifts beyond just the traditional roles,” she said.
This
is happening internationally, specifically with the first appointment of a
married woman as chief secretary in June 2011. In the Germany and Lithuania
Territory, Major Marsha-Jean Bowles was promoted from personnel and candidates
secretary to chief secretary with the rank of Lt. Colonel. Her husband remained
in his position as territorial youth secretary but also received the rank of Lt.
Colonel.
“Women
officers—married or single—should not be ‘lost’ to the Army, but valued
equally,” Seiler said. “The Salvation Army was considered radical and
progressive in its early years. We’re in the aging stage of an organization now
and can affect how the future will look, but we have to break some old habits
and be intentional.”




2 comments:
A most interesting article. When I first came into contact with the Army in 1953, one of the things I was attracted by was that BOTH men and women could be ministers. I saw this as equality between the sexes, but there were other things of which I was not aware. This article has illuminated aspects of women as officers of which I was not aware. The Army needs to "shape up or ship out" in my opinion!
A word from the Poet General Albert Orsnon
Have I worked for hireling wages,
Or as one with vows to keep,
With a heart whose love engages
Life or death, to save the sheep?
All is known to thee, my Master,
All is known, and that is why
I can work and wait the verdict
Of thy kind but searching eye.
All my work is for the Master,
He is all my heart's desire;
O that he may find me faithful
In the day that tries by fire!
Post a Comment