A
review of Norman H. Murdoch's latest Salvation Army history which tells an
uncomfortable story.
Norman
Murdoch's book Christian Warfare in Rhodesia-Zimbabwe (Pickwick Publications)
is of much wider interest and importance than the title might suggest. Its
author, an Emeritus Professor of History in the University of Cincinnati, Ohio,
has, over a long career, made the development of The Salvation Army a special
research interest.
Due
to illness, Professor Murdoch was unable to give a final revision to this, his
last work, and the demanding task of editing the text, finding a publisher and
preparing the book for publication was undertaken by Major Dr. Harold Hill of
our own territory. New Zealand
The
book's main focus is on the degree of priority The Salvation Army gave to the
needs and aspirations of the indigenous peoples of Rhodesia, now Zimbabwe, in
the period 1891-1991.
It
was a surprise to read that 'Commissioner Thomas Estill, the Army's Southern
Africa commander, made it clear that he had not sent the Salvationists to
convert Africans to Christianity. Instead, his charge to the pioneer party was
to teach South African white men, who had gone to Mashonaland in northern
Zimbabwe as gold miners, to seek the "Pearl of Greatest Price".'
On
arrival in Mashonaland in November 1891, Major John Pascoe, the leader of the
Salvation Army pioneers, was granted by the British South Africa Company (BSAC)
3000 acres in the Mazowe Valley.
This was land that for centuries had been
lived on and provided the livelihood for numerous Mashona families. The
legality and moral status of BSAC's disposal of the land was in doubt from the
beginning, and was later violently contested during the first chimurenga
(rising) of 1896 -97 , during which a white Salvation Army officer was killed.
A
further complication was that General William Booth had,
in 1890, published his
book In Darkest England, and the Way Out, presenting a scheme to eliminate
poverty in Britain. An essential element of the General's plan was the
establishment of 'The Colony Over-Sea' to which thousands of the 'submerged
tenth' of the British population would be helped to emigrate.
But
where could this overseas colony be situated? 'lt is proposed', Booth wrote,
'to secure a large tract of land in some country suitable to our purpose. We
have thought of South Africa, to begin with ... Africa presents to us great
advantages for the moment. There is any amount of land suitable for our purpose
which can be obtained, we think, without difficulty.'
Booth
soon requested land for his 'colony' from Cecil Rhodes, whose BSAC had
established Fort Salisbury in 1890 and claimed possession of large swathes of
land in the area. However,by 1908 it was clear that neither Rhodes nor his
company would provide land for the Colony Over-Sea.
So,
initially the needs and aspirations, let alone the rights, of the Mashona were
not seen as a concern by The Salvation Army's founder or by the pioneers of his
Army in Rhodesia. Furthermore, the development of the Army in that land
required a dependence on the white government of the day that continued through
a number of regimes of varying degrees of oppression and exploitation until
majority rule was established in 1980.
Murdoch
presents a case study investigating how Salvation Army internationalism worked
in one Arrny territory.
Murdoch
does make it clear, however, that the development of educational and medical
work by the Army in Rhodesia led to there being, through the decades, always a
number of Army missionary officers with knowledge of and sympathy for the
Africans in their distress caused by the loss of lands and independence.
But
the August 1981 decision by General Arnold Brown to withdraw The Salvation Army
from the World Council of Churches because of its financial support of African
liberation struggles was made with no reference to the wishes of Salvationists
in Rhodesia, some of whom were deeply disturbed by the General's action, which
revealed that their needs and aspirations were still being ignored and
over-ridden by Western interests.
What
is the wider interest and importance that this book has for Salvationists
worldwide? The importance relates to the nature and quality of the
internationalism that we often so glibly claim as one of the great assets of
Salvation Army organisation. Murdoch's book presents us with a case
study-probably the first-investigating in detail and at depth how that
internationalism worked in one Army territory. And it is not a comfortable
story.
In
Rhodesia-Ztmbabwe, Salvation Army 'internationalism' seems to have differed
little from Western imperialism. Is this a unique instance? Or would the same
story emerge as histories of the Army in other territories are thoroughly
researched and critically investigated? Could it still be the case?
The War Cry, NZ
Colonel Laurence Hay
This valuable study
continues the methodological approach followed in Murdoch’s earlier works of
viewing the history of The Salvation Army not in a ‘providentialist’ way
(history as ‘His-story’) but rather by applying the discipline of history to
the Army in the same way as one might for any other organisation, even if the
results may be at times embarrassing for the Army.
Colonel Laurence Hay
A Candid Historical Account of a Troubled Relationship 22 May 2015
By Glen O'Brien - Published on Amazon.com
Format: Paperback
Norman Murdoch, Emeritus Professor at the University of
Cincinnati, has made a very valuable contribution to Salvation Army history
bringing with him a unique insider/outsider perspective. As a son of Salvation
Army officer parents, and a graduate of Asbury College and Asbury Seminary, who worked
in Salvation Army urban youth work, he may be seen as an insider. However,
instead of becoming an officer he chose instead a scholarly career and pursued
the study of American intellectual history with a special focus on the
Salvation Army in the nineteenth century. This provided him with an outsider’s
objectivity that has meant that he has avoided sanitised or triumphalist
accounts of the Army’s history. He has produced many important historical
studies on the Army (including The Origins of the Salvation Army, 1994) and,
given his Alzheimer’s disease, Christian Warfare in Rhodesia-Zimbabwe is likely
to be his last book.


3 comments:
Further reviews will follow next week!
More than 1,100 visitors have read this review - why so few comments? PLC? Difficult to admit that the SA was politically motivated, duplicitous and controlled by its own white led IHQ power base?
Of course IHQ controlled things in the days written about and yes it was a white led base when colonies such as that which were in Rhodesia happened. In many ways this white led power base is still controlling when the majority of Salvationists are non-white and very much fundamentalist in their theology.
John Stephenson
Canada and Bermuda
Post a Comment