What
is the difference between Catholicism and Protestantism? Authority.
Who
is your authority on interpreting the Bible?
For
the record, I’ve been both. I was born and raised Protestant and converted to
Catholicism half a lifetime ago. I respect both traditions, but believe the
Catholic Church offers the fullness of the Truth.
One
response (to a recent post) proposes that once you are SAVED
, you are always saved
. The
Quiner’s Diner reader quotes scripture, 1 Jn 5:11-13: “These things I have
written to you who believe in the Son of God, in order that you may know that
you have eternal life.”

. The
Quiner’s Diner reader quotes scripture, 1 Jn 5:11-13: “These things I have
written to you who believe in the Son of God, in order that you may know that
you have eternal life.”
On
the other hand, another scripture, Hebrews 3:14, says something a little
different: “For we have become
partakers of Christ, IF we hold fast the beginning of our assurance firm UNTIL THE END.” [emphasis mine].
This
suggests that we still have free will to reject Christ, after once accepting
Him.
How
do you square these two competing scripture passages? It makes me think of
Billy Graham’s good friend and original preaching partner, Charles Templeton.
He walked away from the faith, becoming an atheist. Is he saved, after spending
the last half of his life denying Christ?
Another
Quiner’s Diner reader weighed in with this view:
“There is one Body of Christ on earth. It is
composed of ALL believers, whether
Catholic, Orthodox, any of the numerous Protestant denominations, messianic
Jews, or anyone not even affiliated with a religious body, who know Jesus. To
claim that any one of these bodies has an exclusive option on the truth is to
be sadly mistaken.” [Emphasis mine.]
But
if there is no arbiter of Truth, there is no truth. Protestantism was built on
protest. There is no central authority. As a result, there are 40,000 flavors
of Protestantism, with wide-ranging dissent on wide-ranging theological
questions.
Christians
disagree on a wide range issues, such as authority, justification,
sacramentalism, Mary, the saints, purgatory, intercessions, to name but a few.
Who
is right?
Scripture
sometimes seems to contradict itself. To understand the inerrant Truth found in
the Bible, it is vital to have an infallible teaching authority led by the Holy
Spirit.
That
authority is only found in the Catholic Church.


6 comments:
I am sorry for Tom Quiner. He may wish to read the book entitled "Thirty Years in Hell"...or..."From Darkness to Light" by Ex-Priest, Bernard Fresenborg, who, in his Author's Note, says....
.....ex-priest Bernard Frasenborg, who for thirty long years tread the slippery and deceitful path of abhorrent Catholicism, but who to-day stands at the Vatican's door, with the torch of Protestant wisdom, and denounces Popery with a tongue livid with the power of a living God.
Author’s Announcement:
This great book has stirred America from center to circumference. About 400 Large Pages, And each Page a stinging rebuke to Roman Catholicism.
Roman Catholicism, as taught by our modern priests and inspired by the papal power at Rome is naught but the distant rumblings of an antiquated chariot of darkness, as the teachings of this MONARCHICAL creed has naught in view but the enslavement of reason for the financial gain and benefit of the "Robed" few who claim the right to think for the masses.
For thirty long years I was bound to this bewitching spirit of darkness by the chords of superstition and never dared to look above my blind superiors for wisdom, until a "something" which I will call "fate" broke the windows of my mental dungeon and permitted the light of "SPIRITUAL LIBERTY" to filter through my being which awoke "reason and common sense" from her long sleep of lethargy.
Now, what I once thought "Holy" I detest as abominable; What I once worshipped, I now hate.
It is not the glitter of gold nor the applaudits of the Protestant world that I crave, but it is the Master's approval, that I desire. Therefore I deem it my duty to both God and mankind to proclaim to the world what I know of the awfulness of Roman Catholicism, and I know enough to make my poor soul often wonder if I shall ever be permitted, to sing with the blest around that GREAT WHITE THRONE in the New Jerusalem.
As you peruse these pages, I pray that you may whisper a prayer to God in my behalf, as I am now fifty-six years old and only a child in wisdom.
With pity for the blind hosts of Catholicism and a prayer upon my lips for their deliverance from the trenches of paganism, I dedicate this book to the world as coming from a heart which poured out its youth's vitality upon the barren fields of superstition, and wasted its vigor in serving only the god of myths. With a feeling of brotherly love for the entire world, I am,
Yours in His name,
BERNARD FRESENBORG.
Stirring stuff, but I've read some of the book, and its contents are chilling. It's available as a free e-book for those who wish to question, and not accept blindly. Just type in the book's title as supplied above, and be prepared to be shocked.
Anonymous # 1.
You're obviously a fundamentalist Protestant but I sure do hope you're not a Salvationist! Anyone can find malcontents in any group and blow things up way out of proportion to whatever is really happening.
I also doubt that the ex-priest's book is taking America by storm. One(you), really shouldn't go around assuming that what floats your boat in microcosms of time, place and the type of people you may hang out with, is taking anyone else, in the larger population, by anything, let alone a storm! In fact, I can almost assure you that the larger population in America (or anywhere else for that matter) could care less about this book. After all, Harrison Ford was just involved in a small plane crash and Lindsey Lohan is still a mixed up, confused, rich, young, actor who use to go out drinking with her mother in bars when she was only 18, and still lacks a strong father figure to guide her! (lol!)
Years ago I remember a slew of talk shows on television, where the participants on stage, were once born again Xians who slowly went from preaching on street corners and college campuses to becoming atheists. I remember being scared and wondering if such a thing could happen to me since what I truly believed in my 40s, was starting to make me question whether or not, I was being a heretic to my once 18 year old Salvationist self.
With the help of a good Xian therapist (to whom I will forever be grateful)I came to realize that many of these people never really changed anything when it came to their basic thinking. They were living in the exact same house. They just re-arranged the furniture differently!
The catch is that some people may have a genetic component to their personalities where there can't be any room for ambiguity or paradox (which life is full of!)and where every system they adopt mentally, must work out perfectly or it is soon discarded for what appears to be the opposite position!
I suppose western culture, where the prevailing philosophy is Greek dualism, as opposed to eastern paradox, doesn't help matters either! The point is that just because some people jump ship because they can only find security in extreme positions, doesn't mean that where they're at psychologically, at any given moment, is now the whole truth and nothing but the truth.
I've known many catholic people in my own life who were wonderful Xian people and others who were probably sociopaths. The same can be said for fellow Salvationists and any other religious group I may have associated with over the years, such as the Nazarenes at whose colleges I was formally educated.
Sorry anonymous # 1 but the book you're promoting is not a classic. It's just another silly book that does a dis-service to Xianity as a whole----and btw, maybe this will freak you out and push you over the edge or maybe it won't---but SA theology, in some ways, being that it came out of Methodism which came out of Anglicanism, is actually closer to Roman Catholic theology than it is to Protestant Calvinism!
Daryl Lach
USA Central
"You Must Go Home By the Way of the Cross, To Stand With Jesus in the Morning!"
I am certain that no particular expression of Christianity has a corner on the truth. I am assuming that the term Catholic refers to Roman Catholic, itself a kind of protest breakaway. By the 1500's, the Roman Catholic church itself was a large tent that included various diverse approaches to Christianity. In a way, it is itself a protestant expression. How then to discern what is the arbiter of truth? Surely the Bible, rather than any one church. In which case I might find fellowship in a particular church/denomination, and find truth in the scripture. Lest we forget ANY organisation sins, just as we all do.
Colin Bain
Canada & Bermuda
I might have expected the 'full-on' response from Daryl Lach - but I wonder - did he read the book before commenting? If he had, he would have realised that it was written in 1904, so no – I wouldn’t expect it to be taking the world by storm today. That phrase was within the context of the Author's Announcement - in 1904. And just for the record, I wasn't 'promoting' the book - I merely referred to it as a counter-argument for Tom Quiner's acceptance of Catholicism, a record of Catholicism from a PRIEST'S point of view - someone with the inside info on life beyond the confessional – someone who challenges the spiritual foundations of Roman Catholicism with the perspective of an active participant.
Tom Quiner states ‘To understand the inerrant Truth found in the Bible, it is vital to have an infallible teaching authority led by the Holy Spirit. That authority is only found in the Catholic Church’.
The book gives the lie to that ‘authority’. And I would have thought that being in hock to the tune of 30 years gave Mr Fresenborg a unique insight for his descriptions of the stark evil realities of RC church life. And when he recognised spiritual truth he finally left the Catholic church.
That’s all.
A little more attention to detail by Mr Lach might avoid these confusions.
Dear Anonymous,
Why should I have read the book? I wouldn't waste my time. I just took it at face value as per what you were writing. Next time state that something was written in 1904, if it was.
Btw, have you ever heard of the Second(?) Ecumenical Council under Pope John the 23rd in the early 1960s? A lot has changed in Catholicism since then. In fact, I was recently at a Roman Catholic funeral and it sure sounded like the Gospel was read and preached every bit as much it would've been in TSA!
Daryl Lach
USA Central
I was also at a Roman Catholic funeral recently - and I can't describe it similarly. It was turgid and almost secular. And your hope at posting 2 is in vain - I AM a Salvationist. Shame you have to share fellowship with one such as I. Ain't life grand!
Post a Comment