Wednesday, March 18, 2015


Royal Commission into Institutional Responses to Child Sexual Abuse Case Study 5 Report and Findings
17 MARCH 2015

The Salvation Army (Australia Eastern Territory) has cooperated fully, openly and transparently with the Royal Commission into Institutional Responses to Child Sexual Abuse and acknowledges the findings released today regarding Case Study 5.

At present, we are studying these findings and recommendations handed down. After this material has been reviewed, we will be in a position to comment further and in greater detail.

Once again, The Salvation Army wishes to express its deepest sorrow to survivors and their families who have been traumatised and hurt as a result of our failures. To confirm, The Salvation Army no longer runs any children’s homes as outlined in Case Study 5.

We acknowledge that the need for some survivors to re-tell of their experiences through the Royal Commission has caused them and their families great pain and sadness. We regret that because of our past failings this has been necessary - we are grateful to them for having the courage to do so.

Their braveness in coming forward has meant that these past institutional failings will never be repeated and that children will never be placed in such situations again.

The Salvation Army encourages anyone who was abused in any way to contact our Centre for Restoration directly on (02) 9266 9781 or centreforrestoration@aue.salvationarmy.org.





The Salvation Army, Australia Eastern Territory is one of two  administrative territories that the Salvation Army is divided into within Australia and covers two states and one Australian territory on the East Coast of the country. Geographically it’s subdivided into seven divisions, all under different Divisional Commanders, each reporting directly to the territorial commander, currently Commissioner James Condon. Its headquarters is located in central Sydney. NSW.



The Salvation Army has taken significant steps to respond to allegations against its officers and staff.

Response to claims has changed over time to offer ‘support and justice’ The Salvation Army has developed its current approach to child sexual abuse claims over time. Major Farthing told us that when people first started to come forward with ‘complaints of abuse’ in the mid-1990s, The Salvation Army’s policy was to be compassionate but not admit wrongdoing: ‘We won’t say sorry and we won’t make a payment unless the person can prove in court that the offence took place.’

Major Farthing added, ‘As I understand, that was on legal advice.’ Major Farthing said that approach started to change from about 1995:
We got rid of the lawyers who were advising us that way, and the secretary of personnel at that stage said, ‘No, we’re not going to do that. We’re going to start engaging with people.’ So they began to meet with people, and they set up a process where we had an independent contact person who would go and meet with the person with a view to bringing about some degree of justice and healing, and they would offer counselling support.

Commissioner Condon gave evidence that The Salvation Army now adopts a ‘restorative justice approach to assist people who come to [it] with complaints of sexual abuse and other mistreatment’.

Elements of this approach include inviting ‘all who were harmed to get in touch’ with The Salvation Army, offering professional counselling, apologising to the person and providing an ‘ex-gratia’ payment.

Salvation Army has apologised in context of national apologies

One major element of The Salvation Army’s response has been public and national apologies. These have occurred in the context of apologies to those, known as the ‘Forgotten Australians’, who were placed in orphanages and similar institutions by state governments and religious organisations.

On 25 September 1999, after the Forde Inquiry, The Salvation Army (Eastern Territory) jointly signed an apology with the State of Queensland, the Anglican Church, the Catholic Church and others. The apology reads, in part:
We sincerely apologise to all those people who suffered in any way while resident in our facilities, and express deep sorrow and regret at the hurt and distress suffered by those who were victims of abuse.

That apology was given in the context of apologies for government-run institutions given by the Premier of New South Wales on 19 September 2009, and by the Prime Minister on16 November 2009 after the Forgotten Australians report by a Senate Committee.

Royal Commission into Institutional Responses to Child Sexual Abuse childabuseroyalcommission.gov.au


On 7 December 2010, The Salvation Army publicly apologised to ‘former residents of any of its children’s homes who experienced abuse of any sort during the period up until the early 1990s’.

At Old Parliament House in Canberra, General Clifton expressed The Salvation Army’s regret that some children ‘did not benefit from their experience and were not well cared for by our staff’. He went on: We acknowledge that at certain times in our history, the atmosphere in some homes was rigid, harsh, and authoritarian. Many children did not experience the gentleness of love that they needed. Some children suffered abuse and deprivation. As a result their stories are full of hurt, rejection, discouragement and a failure to realise potential.

As the International Leader of The Salvation Army, I express to all Australian care leavers, our deepest sorrow for these failures and hurts. The Salvation Army offers you our heartfelt apology. 

To you all, we say 'Sorry.'
That greater love was not given when you were so vulnerable – we are sorry.
For any harsh words, violent actions or abuse – we are sorry. These should never have happened.

For when you tried to speak out and you were not listened to or believed – we are sorry.

That the process of being placed in care meant for some that you lost family and extended family – we are sorry.

For those who did not find the support you needed as you grieved for your losses – we are sorry.

To our Indigenous care leavers, for the loss of culture and connection to your land – we are sorry.

For those who could not navigate the pain of their life experience and are no longer with us – we are deeply sorry.

To your families, your wives and husbands, your children, your partners, who have also suffered because the deprivations of childhood can impact on adulthood relationships – to you we say sorry.

The Salvation Army acknowledges that you were not to blame for what you experienced. We are now listening to your life stories.

General Clifton thanked Jim Luthy, President of the Care Leavers Australia Network (CLAN), for having the courage to write to him and initiate the idea that culminated in the gathering at Old Parliament House. He acknowledged CLAN’s support.673 Mr Luthy also spoke and, on behalf of many former residents of the boys’ and girls’ homes, expressed his strong criticism of The Salvation Army and the way the homes operated.

Report of Case Study No. 5


On 8 February 2014, the current General of The Salvation Army, Andre Cox, echoed the words of General’s Clifton’s apology in a letter to the Chair of the Royal Commission, Justice Peter McClellan.

And in his evidence to the Royal Commission, Commissioner Condon also expressed remorse:

Once again I want to express our unreserved apology to all who were harmed in any way at all. We are so sorry for every instance when children were sexually abused by our personnel, or while in our care. We are so very sorry for each instance where they felt unable to complain or for when they did, they were not believed. It is our firm resolve to do what is right by care leavers who were abused.676

9 comments:

Anonymous said...

Dear FSAOF, thank you for your update on this tragic SA history. You're non-prejudicial reporting provides us with a balanced report and one which demonstrates the SA's sincere wishes expressing remorse, regret and a promise to change.

Active officer Brisbane

Anonymous said...



By what I've read and heard about this case, I believe Commr. Condon has handled the affair in an excellent manner, restoring our confidence in how top SA leadership can effectively handle delicate matters.


DGC Norway

Unknown said...

I would like to be known as someone who could say that this is sincere and a first step. However, as one who has witnessed their family experience the devastating destruction of such horrific violence, I can tell you sincerely that this only seems as institutional rhetoric. Get out your checkbook boys. That will help convince me of your sincerity. Make restitution and let there be lots of zeros behind those numbers. don't make the courts tell you to do it. Do it on your own. These folks have suffered. They lost their lives as a result of the lack of leadership and righteousness that was in the mantle of Salvation Army leadership. The shame the institution should feel is only going to be recognized when restitution becomes material.

Anonymous said...

James Condon is as upright and honourable as they come. This reprehensible matter should have been settled years ago when Linda Bond was TC.

Oz active

Anonymous said...

One thing I know about Commr. James Condon is that he is a man of excellent character. Trustworthy and integrity are written across his heart. It's not anything to do with his salvation army position....it's about him as a man walking with his God. I am not a member of the Salvation Army but I'd trust this man. Those coming into contact with him are privileged.‬
‪


Australia

Anonymous said...

James Condon certainly presented very well at case study 5. He did his preparations well and appears to have had good legal advice. Perhaps he needed to because he knew intimately what would become revealed in case study 10. As one who has experienced James leadership over many years, I would disagree somewhat with others above. Ambition requires strategic plays. Don't forget that James was Chief to TC Linda Bond. Case study 5 was about historical matters. The report clearly condemns TSA coverup then. What will they say about the continuing coverup behaviours of contemporary leaders.
Will this comment be published - or covered up too?

Anonymous said...

What about those Officer-whistleblowers? They weren't made to feel they were "Doing the Most Good". Instead, Whistleblowing: BAD! (Frankenstein's voice)

Anonymous said...

Whatever the sympathetic comments above for the leading officers involved in this, they all appear to be 'career' officers content to sacrifice the victims in their bid to 'climb the greasy pole'. Bad enough in secular workplaces, but in a Christian organisation its reprehensible. How could they do it, and how could they sleep at night, knowing of the horrors that other officers were inflicting on the innocents?

Anonymous said...

There are many victims of sexual abuse committed by Salvation Army officers still to be heard from.
However, will they be heard, will they be treated with compassion, will Gods love be shown in the restitution process. Shame on those Salvation Army officers that dare take the life of another human through acts of sexual abuse.
More shame on those Salvation Army officers that knowingly stand next to a fellow Salvation Army officer guilty of sexual abuse and ignore his/her evil deed.