Proposed Church
Guidelines Would
Deny Membership to
Practicing LGBT
Population
8
April 2014
One
of the items on the agenda for the Executive Committee of the Seventh-day
Adventist Church this week during its biannual leadership meetings is “proposed
guidelines in responding to changing cultural attitudes regarding homosexual
and other alternative sexual practices.”
The
seven-page, 3,000-word document that accompanied the agenda for the meeting
includes a section on “The Moral and Religious Freedoms of the Church” that
states:
“The
Seventh-day Adventist Church will encourage all its congregations, employees,
ministry leaders, organizations, and entities to uphold church teachings and
faith-based practices in Church membership, employment, education, and marriage
ceremonies, including officiating at weddings. These teachings and faith-based
practices, built upon the Bible’s instructions about human sexuality, are
equally applicable to heterosexual and homosexual relationships. It is
inconsistent with the Church’s understanding of scriptural teaching to admit
into or maintain in membership persons practicing sexual behaviors incompatible
with biblical teachings. Neither is it acceptable for Adventist pastors or
churches to provide wedding services or facilities for same-sex couples.”
Within
the Adventist denomination, decisions about church membership are made by the
local congregation. Thus, the document being considered contains “guidelines,”
and describes its purpose as offering counsel to individuals, leaders, and
church institutions given “the growing divide between enactments of some civil
governments and the beliefs of the Seventh-day Adventist Church about
acceptable sexual behaviors.” Interestingly, unlike other documents on the
agenda, the guidelines document has no history of committee review.
In
March, the church held a leadership conference in South Africa where 350 church representatives spent
four days listening to presentations and discussing the implications for
the church and its institutions to alternative sexual practices. No
statement or guidelines were presented to the entire group at that time.
“Version
Date: April 4, 2014” is specified under the title of the guidelines document
given to the Executive Committee. Discussion by the Executive Committee could
change or require revisions in the completed guidelines. The Executive
Committee meets on Tuesday and Wednesday this week. Currently, the guidelines
are the last item on the agenda; however, the agenda is frequently revised.
Because the mission of
Spectrum Magazine is community through conversation, we invite participation of
all readers in a respectful manner. To comment on the Spectrum Magazine
website, one must register with a verifiable identity (email, twitter,
facebook) and agree to the following Spectrum Magazine commenters
covenant.

16 comments:
THE SEVENTH GAY ADVENTIST WEBSITE, Daneen Akers and Stephen Eyer
Dear friends,
Today was a very difficult day. I both wept and felt like I'd had the wind knocked out of me reading about a new guideline being proposed for vote tomorrow at the Seventh-day Adventist Church's Spring Council meeting which would instruct churches to deny membership to the vast majority of its LGBTI population.
Meant to Disfellowship LGBTI Members
While this proposed guideline says it applies also to heterosexual relationships that aren't in line with currently understood Biblical "instructions about human sexuality", it's quite clear that it's targeted to LGBTI people. I don't think anyone expects the church to start denying membership to divorced/remarried heterosexuals whose first marriages didn't end due to spousal infidelity, or to single moms, or to couples known to live together prior to marriage. This is clearly a targeted directive likely in response to the rapidly shifting attitudes around this intersection of faith and identity, even in the church. Tellingly, this is the only item up for vote that did not go through a committee review.
THE SEVENTH GAY ADVENTIST WEBSITE, Daneen Akers and Stephen Eyer
….
“The Seventh-day Adventist Church will encourage all its congregations, employees, ministry leaders, organizations, and entities to uphold church teachings and faith-based practices in Church membership, employment, education, and marriage ceremonies, including officiating at weddings. These teachings and faith-based practices, built upon the Bible’s instructions about human sexuality, are equally applicable to heterosexual and homosexual relationships. It is inconsistent with the Church’s understanding of scriptural teaching to admit into or maintain in membership persons practicing sexual behaviors incompatible with biblical teachings. Neither is it acceptable for Adventist pastors or churches to provide wedding services or facilities for same-sex couples.”
Kinship's Observations
Seventh-day Adventist Kinship International, the long-established support and advocacy organization for LGBTI Adventists, posted an insightful summary that included this observation:
"If this document passes tomorrow, the GC will have 'encouraged' local churches, church employees, teachers, ministers, institutions, and church-affiliated organizations to reject and disfellowship LGBTI people who now worship, serve, teach, sing, work, and grow in grace in Adventist congregations and organizations around the world. And local congregations and organizations will have to decide whether to comply with these 'guidelines' and kick out their LGBTI members, or continue to receive them as God sends them and learn from the Spirit of Acts 8 how to regard demographic differences in the Body of Christ."
Fear of Losing Control
On one hand, I can actually see this proposed new guideline as a sign of progress in the larger movement to stop obsessing about bedrooms and getting back to the work of loving all, listening to all of the voices, and being the hands and feet of God in the world. The institutional church is seeing its capacity to control information and control the narrative slipping away in a digital age when we all have access to each other and to a growing number of resources. An institution confident of its stance does not feel the need to issue symbolic directives that only further exclude and marginalize.
THE SEVENTH GAY ADVENTIST WEBSITE, Daneen Akers and Stephen Eyer
….
The basic assumptions around LGBT rights are rapidly shifting, even in the church. It's no longer the exception for a denomination to be examining its long-held assumptions, even their long-held hermeneutical frameworks.
That's now the norm. And the more people speak up and share, the more we are all realizing that LGBT people are not "out there" but part of our church family. Families don't always agree, and they sometimes don't handle disagreements well, but in healthy families with love as the organizing principal, we all gather at the table together to hold hands, be grateful, and break bread together. That is our sacred calling, and it's one more and more Christians, even Adventists, are taking seriously as they realize they've excluded part of our family. (Just on a pragmatic/retention level, research shows we are losing our young people in droves over this. See "How Evangelicals Won a War and Lost a Generation")
Largely Symbolic, but Still Hurtful
I also want to emphasize that membership remains a local church decision (probably one of the most intelligent organizational decisions made by church leaders). So this guideline that's proposed is largely symbolic. But symbols matter for a reason, and this would be deeply harmful. On a personal level, I wept today because I know just how harmful this gesture would be--and towards an already marginalized group in the church. Unions, conferences, and individual churches push back on all sorts of things (e.g. women's ordination), and I hope people on this growing newsletter list will make a point of talking to those in influential positions about how we can make sure we welcome all people, no matter if this guideline is voted up or down tomorrow.
THE SEVENTH GAY ADVENTIST WEBSITE, Daneen Akers and Stephen Eyer
….
Some Questions for Leaders
In both the Kinship blog and elsewhere, some fantastic questions were posed that I hope are taken seriously as this proposed guideline is discussed tomorrow:
▪ Is the Seventh-day Adventist Church a heterosexuals-only church? Guidelines and pronouncements like this that aren’t based on consultation with the church's LGBTI community suggest that “hetero-only” is what the General Conference wants the church to be.
▪ What kind of faith do ordinary Adventists believe we’re called into? Do you want local congregations that exclude LGBTI people and supportive relatives, friends, ministers, teachers, and care professionals? Or do you want us all to have space to grow in grace, wisdom, virtue, and mutual accountability?
▪ Whose voices aren't being heard? Why?
▪ Why single out one group of people for special disfellowship instructions? Can this really be what Jesus meant when He said that we'd be known by our love?
We'll be keeping this gathering in our thoughts and prayers. For updates tomorrow, a few places you can watch are Spectrum, the SDA Kinship Twitter feed (@SDAKinship), and the SGA Facebook page.
Thanks so much for all this community does to promote love and listening. You give me so much hope!
Love and gratitude,
Daneen
P.S. Thanks so much to the many who voiced their concerns about the recent summit in Cape Town. The great reporting from Dr. Lawrence Geraty was actually quite encouraging as a whole. (It's actually rather odd this proposed new guideline didn't come up there. Possibly the tone and trajectory of the summit was more inclusive and caring than even the organizers intended?) Do read all four reports on the Spectrum blog.
Here's part of his personal summary I found compelling:
▪ Although I came with some misgivings, I want to affirm my church for initiating a process by which this topic can be studied and shared. As one delegate said, “we now have a common language.” This has been a valuable beginning. Next time, however, it will be very important to include some representative voices such as those who appear on the video, Seventh-Gay Adventists. I share the points recently-retired Newbold College dean and professor, Michael Pearson, articulated:
THE SEVENTH GAY ADVENTIST WEBSITE, Daneen Akers and Stephen Eyer
….
We come to the truth about anything claiming to be that, not by lining up witnesses who agree with us – that is by the process of verification, which may produce a cozy and misguided consensus – but by inviting contributions to debate from those who disagree with us – which may be uncomfortable.
Thus I believe the Church should not simply allow gay people into its midst but welcome them, and so be obliged to face that which is unwholesome in ourselves. Maybe Jesus said we should ‘love our enemies’ primarily for our own sakes not theirs.
This conflict over gay people is very likely a proxy war. The real war is about authority, hermeneutics, belonging, power, ownership, membership, etc. This is merely a convenient battlefield on which some choose to fight the war because they feel very sure of the terrain.
In the meantime, here are a couple of links to voices that need to be heard: You love gay people? That's great, prove it; Morris Taylor's watercolor paintings of his son; and Herb Montgomery's reflections on standing up for LGBT people. No matter how painful, unbelievable, or bitter the accounts, they require us to listen. As followers of Jesus, we are committed to both growing in wisdom and protecting "the least of these."
▪ No specialist was able to present evidence as to the etiology of homosexuality — the closest to it is a combination of genes and environment. So it appears likely that a very few LBGTIs have chosen their homosexuality. We have not come to terms with the implications of this.
▪ As for me, Jesus has given me my task: “Neither do I condemn you, go and sin no more.” “He that is without sin, cast the first stone.” “To whom will I be neighbor?”
▪ While the church continues to study this topic, Jesus has given it its task, too: A loving, caring church needs to live up to its mandate. It has taken 40 years and more to deal with women's ordination and we are not done yet; we can ill afford 40 such years on the topic of helping LGBTIs to feel welcome
Well, well, wholesale approval of and support for the LGBT lifestyle. You wouldn't expect any different, though, from the source - Seventh-GAY Adventists, would you - or from this blog either, for that matter.
It seems to me that the 'go and sin no more' is the sticking-point for conservative Christians - the fact that LGBTs don't recognise their sexual ACTS as sin. Much is said about the 'exclusion' of LGBTs within the church, but there aren't many Christians who don't have sympathy with a person's orientation. It's the practice that is found to be abhorrent. And no matter how this plays out on the surface, you cannot change a person's conscience, or their interpretation of Scripture as they believe God has revealed it to them. The differences will always be there, and the divisions that 'acceptance' and full inclusion will cause the church will be catastrophic.
Dear well, well - Here's the positional statement of the SDA: "It is inconsistent with the Church’s understanding of scriptural teaching to admit into or maintain in membership persons practicing sexual behaviors incompatible with biblical teachings. Neither is it acceptable for Adventist pastors or churches to provide wedding services or facilities for same-sex couples.” How in the world does that translate as approval, acceptance, inclusivity? Your conclusion could not be more wrong!
And, while I don't agree with every article posted, I challenge you to point to one single statement made by the FSAOF or Sven personally that speaks to accepting anything other than a respectful and Christian acceptance of the LGBT community. There hasn't ever been any mention of their sexual practices nor insistence on celibacy - that is not a concern on which we make a judgment. Do you remember General Shaw Clifton's comments on this particular point?.
At the risk of offending you, please read this blog in the same spirit as is our intent, an open presentation and exchange on topics of interest to the church and those wondering what makes us tick. It's the only blog of its kind in the SA world and consequently, the very reason 200,000 persons have visited this blog site. And if you need SA support of our hundreds of articles, you may be surprized to know that in our corps we often use the blog posts in group discussions and from the pulpit.
And, if you'd taken the time to google the SDA's LGBT debate outcome, you'd find that the decision is very much in line with your preferred position.
Former officer and 6 year long FSAOF member and blog follower
To BDL US Central Territory
My comments (beginning Well, well) were a view on the five postings before mine, which didn't seem to me to be a conservative viewpoint at all, nor a reflection on the article itself. I do actually agree wholeheartedly with the SDA stance on LGBT, so maybe we're all victims of misunderstandings here.
I admit my view is ultra conservative, but I do have gay friends, just like most people on the planet, and we get along just fine, by recognising our differences on this subject.
Do I remember General Shaw Clifton's comments - no, I do not. And at the risk of offending many of the SA faithful, to whom he is held in veneration, I care not to heed him. He is, after all, just a man. By that I do not infer a homophobic bias - lest it should appear that way - I merely mean he has interpreted the Scriptures as he understands them - which isn't the way of everyone. In my opinion, TSA is just a small part of the Christian church - a fallible organisation where faith has, many times, been sacrificed (I have first-hand experience of this) on the altar of banding, songsters, uniform, positions etc, and is now constantly being watered down to suit the mood and culture of modern times. We spend too much time these days following the reasoning of alleged biblical 'scholars', instead of working out our own salvation between ourselves and the Lord. God will speak to us personally when we seek guidance - we don't have to rely on what others preach.
Before the hate mail starts rolling (that's an attempt at levity), I would reiterate that this is my own personal opinion, and one that I live by.
With your reference to the blog - I agree it's unique, but lately (this year) it's been lacking in 'diversity' in order to prove its 'diversity'. Don't you just love riddles!
USA Central and Well, well - "In case you missed the online updates, in brief, the SDA corporate church passed a new guideline that says it is "inconsistent" to allow the vast majority of LGBT people to either become or stay members of the church. The new guideline was passed without any committee review, no questions asked, only 19 minutes of presentation by the authors, and right before the adjournment of the meetings when only 80 of the 200 delegates were still present." This was the comment of an obviously biased SDA member and is shared for info purposes only.
I'm not 100% certain about the reference made to Shaw Clifton's remark(s) but assume it's his sharing of the publication of the A Christian Understanding of Human Sexuality, a document promoting the Methodist view in 1979. Rev. John Stott also referred to it in his Involvement, Volume II. Is he too 'just a man' like Clifton ? Veneration or not, Shaw Clifton was elected to the SA's highest office, although his prophetic pronouncements were made a quarter of a century earlier, long before most church leaders dared face the volatile LGBT issues.
USA Central mentioned that neither the blog nor I have ever made a public utterance about which side of the aisle the FSAOF or I stand. You didn't acknowledge the comment, and I suspect it's because he/she was spot on. We've never taken sides. Nonetheless I have been strongly attacked by persons on both sides of the debate for supporting their opponents point of view, and a good number who ask why I remain on the fence; just right it seems to me.
I've been forced to break up the series I was writing on the SA and the difficulty in reaching any cross-cultural or theological agreement. The conclusion consists of 2 articles, and a fair bit of blame on SA leadership. I welcome comments from you both, and an article if you care to put pen to paper. USA Central, your Commissioner sent a letter to all officers stating his official position and it mirrors the SDA position to a tee. I wonder why none of our often vocal gay and lesbian readers and FSAOF members haven't been more vocal and outspoken?
Blessings, Sven
Imho there will never be any theological agreement on this topic - that's why this series is so exhausting and frustrating. Black will never be white, and white will never be black. (In these PC times this is not a racist remark, lest anyone should have apoplexy) - it merely serves to illustrate a point. (The necessity for stating this shows how far down the lunatic path we have travelled already - can one say 'lunatic'? I could go on. It's all nonsense).There are, however, many shades of grey, depending on one's point of view, and it is within these shades of grey that many people dwell in comfort and ease. It's much easier to go with the groundswell of popular opinion and persuasive logic than to stick with what your conscience tells you to, and to endure the nasty comments of people who do not share your viewpoint.
I'm glad there are people like the USA Central Commissioner, who is not afraid to state his case - I pray TSA has many more like him within the ranks.
I won't be writing an article any time soon.
Anonymous said...
"Imho there will never be any theological agreement on this topic - that's why this series is so exhausting and frustrating. Black will never be white, and white will never be black."
I beg to differ and please take note - Some half million or more Salvationists believe that persons born with a homosexual orientation are sinful. Sadly, it's that black and white. I trust this not your view. We therefore, with all Salvationists who recognise the distinction between orientation and homosexual practices , have a shared responsibility to find room for them in our church family. A natural human hunger is a longing for identity and completeness. We, through Christ, ought to reflect and provide both.
The question is - how do we share that message? Our blog is but one small voice...
Anonymous said...
"Imho there will never be any theological agreement on this topic - that's why this series is so exhausting and frustrating. Black will never be white, and white will never be black."
I beg to differ and please take note - Some half million or more Salvationists believe that persons born with a homosexual orientation are sinful. Sadly, it's that black and white. I trust this not your view. We therefore, with all Salvationists who recognise the distinction between orientation and homosexual practices , have a shared responsibility to find room for them in our church family. A natural human hunger is a longing for identity and completeness. We, through Christ, ought to reflect and provide both.
The question is - how do we share that message? Our blog is but one small voice...
To Anonymous FSAOF (?!?)
Of course I don't think people 'born that way' are sinful. We are all born in sin. Clearly the Bible does not state anywhere that orientation is a sin, but it does state that homosexual practices are sinful, and this is where there will never be any agreement between the two groups. Some people will interpret scripture to suit their own persuasions, while others will hold fast to time-held truths which they hold in their souls. And therein lies the dichotomy - spiritual discipline.
We have strayed far from the perfect path that Jesus trod - we have become more accepting of worldly standards within our churches and less aware of the Christian disciplines we need to grow in faith, and unless we all (I include myself) centre our lives around Jesus, follow ALL His commands, and listen to His voice, we will continue in this mess of disunity of thought and practice.
AN APPEAL to the Soldiers, Local Officers, Officers and Leaders of THE SALVATION ARMY around the World.
Are you aware that the present administration of the Salvation Army here in India Eastern Territory is in a very pathetic state and engulfed in a deep Crisis? As we are fighting for our legal rights, democratic governance, transparency in Financial Administration, etc, our Territorial leaders unleashed a reign of terror.
Our Territory has lost much in terms of membership and Mission during the tenure of our TC Comr. Naomi Lalngaihawmi (2011-till date). The Territory is going down physically and spiritually.
During her tenure, many Local Officers have been dismissed without any reasonable cause or enquiry. Territorial leaders and Divisional leaders consider themselves as above every law, Orders and Regulations of The Salvation Army, Biblical Doctrines, Natural Justice and Laws of the Indian Government etc.
People who point at their wrongs are being intimidated that they will be dismissed from the Army. Persons like us who toiled in the Army and suffered ministering for this Territory are being treated without any respect by Commr. Naomi and her abusive officers. Hundreds of Soldiers had already left the Army due to their highhandedness and divide & rule policy during the past years. The perpetrators of this crisis rather got promotion to the utter surprise of many.
With the attitude that our Territory should not develop, Comm. Naomi has stopped the Ministry of Love & Compassion. Cases are being fought at Courts; the offerings of our soldiers are being spent at courts and police stations.
Our Territory is getting destroyed day by day. With indifference, Local officers, Divisional Commanders, Managers and Cabinet Secretaries are selfishly acting only to earn their promotions and self aggrandizement. They are no longer interested in the serving of suffering humanity, Church building, Spiritual Warfare and Evangelization.
Therefore, our dear Fellow Salvationists all across the Globe- We exhort you to help us protect and re-build our SALVATION ARMY and save our souls. Please bring our cause to the knowledge of the General for an early solution.
May GOD BLESS YOU, OUR TERRITORY and THE SALVATION ARMY
Yours in Christ,
A die-hard Salvationists in India Eastern Territory.
How brave to speak out about this. God bless you.
Post a Comment